High-five for Gibson by end of April or it's Tah Tah

By Will Knight / Expert

As the cricket season winds down, Daryl Gibson will need to have picked up a Michelle Pfeiffer to have any chance of staying on as the Waratahs’ coach.

Five-fa; five wins from their first eight games – that’s the strike rate the genial Kiwi requires to have any hope of opening his bosses’ doors for a chat about a contract extension.

It will take a substantial turnaround.

The Tahs have been underwhelming at best and dismal at times under Gibson. They’ve been mauled. They’ve been mocked. They’ve been made to look ordinary. The Horrotahs label returned.

With Gibson in charge for the last two seasons, the Tahs have finished 16th and 10th to miss the finals – an emphatic slump after winning the title in 2014 and making the semis a year later.

In the final year of his contract, Gibson has only the first couple of months of the competition to prove he’s worth sticking with. The Tahs’ big cheeses will want to get his future sorted by mid-season. Every organisation seeks certainty so planning can proceed.

So by week ten – when the Tahs have their second bye in the last week of April – we will get a very clear picture of whether Gibson is a chance of staying in Sydney.

That’s eight games of the new 16-match season. Five wins would be par. More than that, he’s naturally got bargaining power in the boardroom. Less than five, and he’s as good as gone. In fact, less than five and he might not even see out the season.

Much is expected from the Sydneysiders. Their fans are fickle and their rivals love nothing more than laying the boot into the underperforming city slickers.

But it’s got its rewards; get on a winning streak and the Tahs can create a buzz fairly quickly.

Mindful that his job is on the line, Gibson has already talked about hitting the ground running. The Waratahs copped it publicly from Wallabies coach Michael Cheika for not being fit enough when they got into camp for last year’s June Tests.

Gibson has subsequently admitted they got it wrong and conditioning would be addressed leading into 2018. You could assume the Tahs have been flogged over the last six weeks.

(AAP Image/Craig Golding)

The upside for Gibson is that the Waratahs don’t face any New Zealand teams over that opening eight-game block (they have a run of four games against Kiwi teams – the Blues, Crusaders, Highlanders and Chiefs – from week 11).

They are at home to the Stormers first-up on February 24 – only five weeks away. Then there’s a tricky road trip to take on the Sharks in Durban and the long haul to battle the Jaguares in Buenos Aires. The Melbourne Rebels are next back in Sydney. Gibson would be eyeing a three-from-four start – the South African leg being the toughest clash.

Following a week five bye, there’s the Brumbies in Canberra, followed by another sizeable trek – this time to meet the Sunwolves in Tokyo. The eight-game package finishes with home games against Queensland and the Lions.

There shouldn’t be a slip-up against the Sunwolves and the Reds’ backline looks flimsy. Snaring one win out of the other two seems difficult but not insurmountable.

It’s naturally speculative in January, but the Tahs have a pretty nice early draw in which six early wins looks very achievable. That seems pretty optimistic given the woes of the past two seasons and the moderate changes to the squad.

Much will depend on the return of Kurtley Beale in the midfield. Rob Simmons, Curtis Rona, Tom Staniforth and Alex Newsome are among the new faces. Rob Horne, Dean Mumm, Will Skelton and David Horwitz are the big losses.

But the Tahs still have the strongest roster among the Australian teams.

The biggest concern is in the front five. Sekope Kepu is top-notch, Tolu Latu a weapon when fit and Tom Robertson is solid. Reds outcast Simmons comes in – essentially to replace the retired Mumm – and his second-row partner is likely to be a battle between the inexperienced duo of Staniforth and Ryan McCauley.

Ned Hanigan might be used as a lock, but Gibson noted at the end of last season that he believes his best position is at No.8.

Hanigan should start in the second-row – if at all – as Jed Holloway at No.8 gives more punch as a ball-runner. This season is a big one for Jack Dempsey, who was a beast for the Wallabies in their Bledisloe win over the All Blacks.

Can he maintain that aggro consistently over a full Super Rugby season? Michael Hooper – a class act in so many facets – completes a formidable back-row.

Will Nick Phipps hold onto his halfback starting spot? Jake Gordon is putting a heap of pressure on him after taking the No.9 jersey from him a few times last year.

Bernard Foley seems to have lost a bit of spark in his running game but he’s still a top-shelf all-around package at five-eighth. Beale is Gibson’s main man to get the backline humming.

His combination with Israel Folau is critical, as those two love linking up all over the park. He will also take heat off Foley with his slick kicking and passing game.

(AAP Image/Paul Miller)

The Tahs only snared their outside centre a few months ago when Western Force utility Rona signed. He’ll offer a powerful presence and will be itching to be fed by Foley and Beale. More Wallabies caps await for Rona if he lights it up for the Waratahs.

The reliable Cam Clark is a favourite of Gibson’s on the wing. Who gets the gig on the other side is an intriguing question. Is Taqele Naiyaravoro in shape and ready to rip in? Or as he did at the end of last season, will Gibson go for Bryce Hegarty as a backfield winger who hangs who helps out Folau at fullback?

Folau is a freak. He’s well rested after missing the Wallabies’ end-of-season Japan and European tour. Some still want to see him at No.13, but that ship has sailed – at least at the Tahs.

That’s a fifteen with a plenty to like. Perhaps there’s not a heap of squad depth putting pressure on starting spots which is usually a hallmark among top-level teams in all sports. But the core is strong.

So it’s all about a fast start for Gibson, although even if the Waratahs are flying, his bosses might want to see how they are matched against the benchmark New Zealand teams. Nonetheless, the first eight games shape his future.

He will hope to have the Tahs humming for their last trial on February 15 against the Rebels at Brookvale Oval as building momentum is crucial. Get in a hole – especially on the big trip away to Durban and Buenos Aires – and it will get gloomy quickly.

A fellow Kiwi – Simon Cron – has come on as an assistant coach and has been tasked with firing up a forward pack that looks like it could do with a bit more grunt up front.

Perhaps Gibson doesn’t even want to stay in Sydney. But if he wants to stay in coaching he’ll still need to get his side rolling, and early. After all, he’s had a top-notch squad to work with. Improving his record is vital.

The Crowd Says:

2018-01-23T05:21:09+00:00

Bad Doctor

Guest


Bloody 'eck.... How quickly we write off the Reds. For mine - new coach, untried players - top of Aussie ladder. Bets anybody......???

2018-01-22T04:05:24+00:00

John R

Roar Guru


Yeah I was pretty impressed with him in the NRC as well (and his sweet mullet). It's obviously a big step up to Super Rugby, but would be great to see him get some decent minutes.

2018-01-22T03:47:28+00:00

Fionn

Guest


John R, I really like the thought of Jack Maddocks at 10.

2018-01-22T03:29:56+00:00

John R

Roar Guru


They should at least get a look at Horwitz at ten. He won the Ken Catchpole medal playing at ten, so he's got experience. Jack Debreczini is back too, but he's been a bit underwhelming at ten. Maybe Wessel's can unlock his potential there though.

2018-01-22T00:50:40+00:00

jeznez

Roar Guru


Yeah, only four key issues! But at least they will apparently be much fitter this season! Despite them being very much a second half team last yea, so seemingly not as big an issue them. I guess we need to add another item to the list. Based on last year they need to start much more strongly in matches this season

2018-01-22T00:47:07+00:00

jeznez

Roar Guru


With Lance injured and if as you say Hodge is down for 13 then Horwitz will likely be at 10 or at least the back up 10.

2018-01-21T22:52:12+00:00

Jimmyjam

Roar Rookie


I agree 100% buck stops with Gibson. He needs to move on sooner rather than later.

2018-01-21T22:21:23+00:00

John R

Roar Guru


Word is that Hodge is likely to start the season at 13, which I presume would put Meakes at 12. Not sure what the plans for Horwitz are.

2018-01-21T21:14:04+00:00

Train Without A Station

Roar Guru


No. He's just not saying anything about club rugby. He's talking about Wallaby bias to the Waratahs. He's talking about Super Rugby. You're just so keen to defend club rugby that you try and defend them when they aren't even being talked about.

2018-01-21T20:29:39+00:00

Fionn

Guest


I agree, jez, in attack they should be top notch. That said, I am concerned about their ball carrying in the forwards, their ability to compete at the breakdown, their kicking and their defence.

2018-01-21T18:58:06+00:00

P2R2

Roar Rookie


...a top notch SQUAD to work with....that's an oxymoron sorry....Tahs will blow out again and Gibson will move on....

2018-01-21T08:25:07+00:00

jeznez

Roar Guru


This is part of the coaches remit though - the fact the pack has so many issues and in a season the entire Force side came available for recruitment and all they picked up were Simmons, Rona, Vui and some development players has to land squarely at the feet of the coach. A major reason so many of the Force players went to the Rebels was Wessels. That they have a logjam of locks down there while the Tahs have Simmons, Staniforth, Power and McCauley indicates that either the offers, the program or both are on the nose with players. Squad management is the head coaches number one responsibility (given they hire specialists to perform the detailed coaching as assistants). There is no point saying poor Gibson doesn't have the cattle - he is responsible for attracting and hiring the players. For setting a vision and getting players to buy into it. Particularly given selection for the Tahs seems to bring with it preferential opportunity to make the Wallabies - it speaks volumes that he cannot attract a better squad with that additional carrot.

2018-01-21T06:46:11+00:00

Redsfan1

Guest


That's why I've given up on 'Australian' rugby. Kiwi coaches and nearly all the players are Kiwis or from the Pacific Islands. Any decent Australian player goes straight to Europe.

2018-01-20T20:44:15+00:00

Jimmyjam

Roar Rookie


Unfortunately for the tahs (and Gibson) there are only 2 remaining forwards from the 2014 winning squad and it really shows when comparing the teams why the recent tahs have performed so poorly! Talk about a drop in quality!! 2014 2017 Kepu Kepu / Lolohea TPN Latu /Roach Robinson Robertson Douglas Mumm Potgeiter (Skelton) Skelton Dennis (Hoiles) Hanigan (Holloway) Hooper Hooper Palu Wells (Dempsey out for most of season) With that pack and considering their poor fitness levels, in hindsight I'm surprised they won any games at all last year!

2018-01-20T20:06:04+00:00

concerned supporter

Guest


In his state of hatred of the NSW Waratahs,he may not be aware of Sydney Club Rugby. TWAS,what % of Wallabies since Super Rugby commenced,1996,came from 1/ NSW 2/Queensland. 3/ Other States ? Not Waratahs, Reds etc, but from State Club Rugby. For example Reece Hodge is a Manly player, Jonno Lance is a Brisbane player. Be interested to find out, do you have the records?

2018-01-20T11:04:41+00:00

Train Without A Station

Guest


Does he actually say anything about club rugby?

2018-01-20T10:57:31+00:00

Johnno

Guest


The last two years DGibson hasn't had a good squad. eg retirements/players going overseas/injuries, Chieka had a better roster.

2018-01-20T10:36:14+00:00

jeznez

Roar Guru


Yeah - more NSW lads playing for other states need to be given a shot! Not just the ones that stay in NSW!

2018-01-20T10:34:50+00:00

jeznez

Roar Guru


Agree fully - if he is in shape then he is the first winger picked, probably with Clark on the other wing, Kellaway if Clark can't find his feet.

2018-01-20T09:25:34+00:00

Concerned Supporter

Guest


Do you actually think that the Sydney Club Competition is not immensely stronger than Canberra Melbourne & Perth? Brisbane is closer,maybe some Queenslanders may comment

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar