The Waratahs' stunning victory doesn't let Daryl Gibson off the hook

By David Lord / Expert

Kurtley Beale, Bernard Foley, Israel Folau and third-string halfback Mitch Short inspired a Waratahs comeback against the Rebels at Allianz Stadium yesterday that made Lazarus look like a hack.

Down 20-3 in the 39th minute despite 55 per cent possession and 55 per cent territory, the Waratahs looked a flat and beaten side against the unbeaten Rebels.

But in the next 41 minutes, the men in blue stormed home with six tries to one to keep the scoreboard busy, posting 48 points to seven.

The final score of 51-27 made everyone blink in disbelief.

If they were thoroughbreds, they would have been in the steward’s room for a serious chat.

And no doubt Waratahs coach Daryl Gibson will claim promoting benchman Bryce Hegarty to fullback and punting one of the world’s most entertaining 15s in Israel Folau to the wing was a master-stroke.

Wrong.

Gibson showed Folau no respect as he waxed lyrical pre-game about Hegarty being a footballer’s footballer with enormous game sense.

Really?

If Hegarty was such a boom boy, why was he on the bench for the first three games?

On my reckoning, Hegarty touched the ball five times yesterday, including a try.

In typical fashion Folau, because he’s such a superb talent and so humble with it, twice dodged post-match questions about the switch with “whatever is best for the team”.

And he said it with a smile having gone out of his way during the game to pat Hegarty on the back after his try.

Folau set up three of the six tries by reclaiming a towering punt on the full as only Folau can do.

Folau was again modest post-game, praising Foley and Beale for being right on the money.

(AAP Image/David Moir)

The Waratahs have a well-earned bye next weekend, where Gibson has time and space to correct his Hegarty-Folau brain explosion. In fact, the only space available for Hegarty is on the bench from whence he came.

Curtis Rona and two-try scorer Taqele Naiyaravoro are obvious first-choice wingers, feeding off inside-centre Kurtley Beale and fullback Folau.

And it would bring Beale and Folau closer together to strut their spectacular stuff as a mighty dangerous midfield pairing.

But none of that extraordinary comeback would have been possible if it hadn’t been for half-back Mitch Short playing out of his skin.

To think pre-season he was the third choice number nine after the injured Nick Phipps, and Jake Gordon, proved the old saying cometh the hour, cometh the man.

His service from set and broken play was right off the top shelf, and his support play netted him a try in the middle of the Waratahs five-try blitz in 20 minutes.

The second shock was Foley’s golden boot suffered its first miss of the season yesterday.

He converted all six tries, but landed three of four penalties, the miss slamming into the left upright.

But he’s landed 23 of 24 shots so far as a vital part of the Waratah scoring machinery, despite his mounting knockers.

(Photo Ashleigh Knight)

Both teams are to be congratulated for playing 80 minutes at a cracking pace, despite the record heat in Sydney.

How they managed up keep going in 38 degrees, the hottest March day for 78 years, was testimony to their fitness and courage.

Officials had an attack of brains, allowing a water break every 20 minutes.

As for the Rebels having their unbeaten run ended, veteran centre Tom English summed up his side’s shock loss with “You don’t become a bad team overnight”.

Top quote.

The Rebels will be around at the business end, especially with top footballers like Adam Coleman and the train-wrecking Amanaki Mafi up front, and Will Genia with Reece Hodge and John Maddocks out the back.

Keep an eye on Mafi, winner of last year’s Australian Super Rugby player of the year.

Tongan born, Mafi delivered the final pass in 2015 for Japan to beat the Boks 34-32 after the bell in arguably the biggest upset in Rugby World Cup history.

He’s a runaway train, and a devastating defender.

If Tonga doesn’t want him, Michael Cheika sure would at number eight.

The Crowd Says:

2018-03-20T12:50:42+00:00

Fox

Roar Guru


Yeah agreed pk- I just hope Gibson keeps Folau on the wing.

2018-03-20T05:28:05+00:00

Timbo (L)

Roar Guru


0 from 0 attempts. A result with no statistical significance either way. The Tahs had 83% possession, so there are no surprises. If you have a game plan where some players don't have to defend, you are going to get gobbled up by sides that can attack from everywhere, eg. NZ Sides, Ireland.

2018-03-20T03:45:27+00:00

Fox

Roar Guru


DL backed himself into a corner TM and now he has to continue to justify his argument after eating crow. But DL is one who can't eat crow with any dignity like his BS telling people to do their homework above when it is he who has no clue regarding Mafi at the Rebels

2018-03-20T01:43:39+00:00

jeff

Guest


But what Maki's eligibility David. Any apology coming. Obviously you find it difficult to acknowledge when you are wrong, But why after reading your columns for years am I surprised.

2018-03-19T20:21:56+00:00

Jeff

Guest


As I have previously said.Time to put this old dinosaur out of his misery.Do your homework indeed. And as yet no sign of an apology.

2018-03-19T18:22:39+00:00

bazza200

Roar Rookie


No he said they had some brains and gave the teams a water break was praising them actually

2018-03-19T14:43:00+00:00

Cheikmate

Guest


Alright, so how many of these so-called easy tries did he let past him while he was on? Any?

2018-03-19T13:23:27+00:00

cinque

Guest


Some arithmetic operators, like + & x, are commutative. 14 + 15 = 15 + 14. Others are not. 15 -14 does not give the same result as 14 -1 5. Clearly Folau is a better 15 than Maddox & a better 14 as well. But the relationship is not commutative. With Maddox, 15F ^ 14M > 15M ^ 14F, in my view. With Hegarty, suggest 15F ^ 14H < 15H ^ 14F. The evaluation may vary with opponents & venues. A coach's job is tough.

2018-03-19T12:06:47+00:00

Lano

Guest


David, another season, another man-crush; last it was Will Skelton, then Beale....Oivey!

2018-03-19T11:31:35+00:00

Timbo (L)

Roar Guru


I am assuming that that remark was made tongue in cheek. But just in case it isn't, The NRC teams proved that he is an easy mark - all you need to do is chip over or past and you are left with an open tryline,

2018-03-19T11:26:07+00:00

rebel

Guest


I follow them, I don't run them. No idea.

2018-03-19T11:18:40+00:00

soapit

Guest


dagg had that pace off the mark that could create numbers from nowhere.

2018-03-19T11:17:19+00:00

soapit

Guest


yeah ur right there are options to still use him that way. i agree with the problem tho i dont think it's so easy to exploit as you say, folau seems to get to most genuine bombs (ie giving it air for a contest not going long for territory, and yes the best fullbacks drop them. poor fullbacks drop a lot more and sometimes it becomes bad enough they simply cant continue to be picked at fullback anymore,

2018-03-19T11:11:59+00:00

soapit

Guest


yeah certainly seems to be talked about well, he was the one who played well for the barbarians last year as well wasnt he? anyway if we have someone playing well enough to allow folau to move to wing that'll be a good thing. i guess my point is its not all downside having him at 15 especially if you have decent wingers so i can understand why it might not happen at test level.

2018-03-19T10:15:08+00:00

Fionn

Guest


Soapit, I think that Cheika really likes DHP, but I would say that Jack Maddocks is a bolter to make the Wallabies' back 3. He's exceedingly impressive.

2018-03-19T10:01:58+00:00

soapit

Guest


perhaps, but when folau missed the spring tour and beale playedat 15 it was same old. id actually spoken up for beale saying he was better under the high ball recently but it all disappeared. previously there was no other potential fullback likely to force into the team on the other parts of their play. maybe dhp but he really does do a lot from 15 at test level and our wings werent bad enough to make shifting him a no brainer. apparently we do have some other options around now (dont watch much super rugby so cant say myself) but will they be getting picked in the xv? not as cut and dried what to do for the wallabies for mine.

2018-03-19T09:55:59+00:00

Jacko

Guest


Timbo does he need to defend? I would not run at him LOL

2018-03-19T09:54:08+00:00

Jacko

Guest


hunt back available now too. FB is Hunts best posi I think but he also plays 12 so a good bench option if nothing else

2018-03-19T09:50:35+00:00

Zane

Guest


Pay attention David Lord

2018-03-19T09:49:58+00:00

Jacko

Guest


Geez David a good winger is not locked into a corner of the pitch. A great winger roams aplenty

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar