Five talking points from Super Rugby Round 10

By Oliver Matthews / Expert

An interesting round of Super Rugby is almost at a close and there’s been a lot to talk about. So let’s dive in and get chatting.

Kerevi still knocking on door No.12
In this same article a few weeks ago I commented that Samu Kerevi was playing well at No.12 for the Reds and could start to make things complicated for the Wallabies and Kurtley Beale. Well, he hasn’t let up.

In a losing Reds side, he still managed to pick up two tries. Meanwhile, Beale had a very average game against a rampant Lions side.

Part of the value of Beale at No.12 is that he’s outside his Tahs teammate Bernard Foley at No.10. But that value is reduced if Foley and the Tahs aren’t performing. Yes, they are top of the Australian conference but their inability to score a single point in Sydney against the Lions is surprising and concerning.

Kerevi is just not as effective at No.13 and Michael Cheika is going to need a hard-hitting centre to keep the Saffer and Kiwi defences honest in the Rugby Championship.

Aussie teams starting to struggle
There had been some signs earlier in the season that the Aussie sides were going to be more competitive this year. The painful Force issue would mean that the remaining teams would be better RA told us and in the early rounds the Rebels and Reds were showing that even the arguably weaker Aussie sides had something about them.

But over the past few weeks, this theory has started to stumble. The Rebels and Reds strong early starts have turned into a string of losses and clashes against Kiwi sides and have led to the same result as last season.

This weekend the Reds, Rebels and Tahs have all lost and looked average while they did it. Currently, there are just three Aussie sides in the top ten and the Rebels are sliding down the ladder fast. With hard matchups against Kiwi sides around the corner, the Aussie sides really need to step up.

Chiefs dedication to the bonus point
The Chiefs beat the Reds pretty easily and had the game locked up early on. But what stood out was the way that they fought as if the game was on the line after the buzzer as they desperately hunted for the try that would give them the bonus point. And they got it.

That drive is impressive and the ability to keep calm, stay error-free and get that all important try is one of the things that separate the very best teams. In the competitive Kiwi conference, every bonus point is important and the Chiefs may well look back on the closing minutes in Brisbane and be very grateful that they didn’t just take the win and get back on the plane home.

Having the desire to score one more try is important for sure but plenty of teams have that – who doesn’t want to score more? But to then have the skill to make that happen under fatigue is impressive.

Are we all on the same page about the Sunwolves?
There was a 30 minute period in the Sunwolves match against the Crusaders on Saturday where they led the session 11-0 and overall the scoreline was closer than many expected. However, there was no doubt that they were going to lose.

Just like most if not all of their games – they are big underdogs and usually the result backs that up!

So what’s the point in them? There are those who keep saying that they are getting better and that it’ll take time for them to be truly competitive but that they will get competitive. But is this really the reason why they should stay in the comp?

In two and a half seasons they’ve won just three games from over 30 matches and are conceding an average of over 40 points per game.

(Photo by Matt Roberts/Getty Images for Sunwolves)

So let’s be honest – they might get better, but they will never threaten the big names for the title and arguably will never see finals rugby. But they do serve a financial and brand awareness purpose.

The Sunwolves are basically a marketing activity for SANZAAR and while that isn’t necessarily terrible we should at least make sure that we all agree what the Sunwolves are all about.

To be clear – not being a real threat to winning the title doesn’t mean that a team shouldn’t exist. But being whipping boys week in week out can only go on so long.

Umaga might want to update his LinkedIn
Yes, the Blues have been hit hard by injuries this year, but the stories are already starting about how the club might want to consider a change at the top. Since Tana Umaga took over in 2016, the Blues have not really gotten better.

Sure the 18 players on their injury list this season has made it hard for him to pick a stable team, but that excuse can’t go on much longer.

The Blues are in 13th place overall on the ladder and continue to struggle against their domestic rivals.

Missing finals again will surely lead to Umaga seeking other opportunities and while he’s currently doing a good job of praising his players’ efforts under difficult circumstances, its the results and the performances on the field that matter most – and those have been missing in action for too long.

The Crowd Says:

2018-04-23T07:53:33+00:00

cuw

Guest


in cricket in some countries - there is a traveling selector. he is one of the selection panel who decide on the tour squad. usually when overseas the selection panel will be coach captain and the traveling selector. this can be good or bad - even before the onfield performance comes into reckoning.

2018-04-23T02:56:22+00:00

Cadfael

Roar Guru


Ben Pobjie has one here on Izzy. There's also one on the Fox Sports ugby site/

2018-04-23T02:54:24+00:00

Cadfael

Roar Guru


Agree, that's why I feel a selection panel would be better for the SR sides and the Wallabies rather than coach ony selections.

2018-04-23T02:52:38+00:00

Cadfael

Roar Guru


A list of Asian Rugby: https://www.asiarugby.com/unions/

2018-04-22T22:05:38+00:00

Nobody

Guest


Great read, thanks for linking that

2018-04-22T21:46:16+00:00

Nobody

Guest


I think that's exactly what they'll say. Repeatedly replacing the coach is a losing strategy, so what the Blues need more than anything is a coach who will be there for the long term (five+ years). And Umaga is one of the few people popular enough to withstand the constant pressure of coaching a lesser team with unrealistic expectations on it. (Ironically the Blues would slot into the Aussie conference much better than the Sunwolves would, and it would take the heat off them too. Closer in ability level and geographical position. But no, I'm not quite insane enough to suggest that...)

2018-04-22T20:34:29+00:00

KFar

Guest


Didn't the ARU get rid of the national comp for a few years then brought it back?

2018-04-22T20:14:38+00:00

Cliff (Bishkek)

Guest


Not likely mate. Aus Rugby is broken and RA, Qld Management, NSW Management and all other administrations are doing nothing to correct the poor admin and management of some 15 to 25 years!!!

AUTHOR

2018-04-22T20:00:11+00:00

Oliver Matthews

Expert


Not really - my point is that Umaga is going to move/be moved on at the end of this season in my opinion because he hasn't gotten the Blues winning. The fact that previous coaches also weren't able to get the Blues performing better doesn't mean that the management at the Blues will say "well never mind Tana, no one else has been able to do better so you might as well keep the job mate".

2018-04-22T18:04:33+00:00

AM_Bokke

Guest


Japan qualified for the World Cup based on their performance at the last World Cup Man! Don't people know this!

2018-04-22T17:54:06+00:00

AM_Bokke

Guest


Yep.

2018-04-22T13:58:25+00:00

Malo

Guest


Flip a coin and give the super trophy to either the Crusaders or Hurricanes and save all the injuries and let Cheika retrain them and get them fit. The wallaby squad should be removed from the super squads and be retrained to get them ready for the internationals .

2018-04-22T13:41:22+00:00

ajg

Guest


After this weekend's result i have been left genuinely depressed by the state of the game. Perhaps the saddest thing besides the result is the fact that they happened in virtualy empty staidums it seems like a whole lot of other people are upset and pondering what is going on over on reddit is a really amazing analysis of why the game is going down hill https://www.reddit.com/r/rugbyunion/comments/8e25ty/whats_happening_to_australian_rugby/dxrue5v really recommend it as a read

2018-04-22T13:26:34+00:00

Matt

Guest


The Rebels and Force weren't much better when they started. The lions started poorly too, remember them having a winless season as well and now they are one of the top teams. And of course all the NZ teams have had bad periods, not to the Sunwolves level but still poor when you consider their resources.

2018-04-22T13:20:16+00:00

Marty

Guest


Bout time for another Izzy article don't you thin ROAR!!

2018-04-22T13:06:49+00:00

Bakkies

Guest


I would rather that than seeing the likes of Scott Sio and Richie Arnold (particularly in the Sunwolves match) have the ball ripped off them by backs.

2018-04-22T12:40:16+00:00

Rhys Bosley

Guest


Because when the 10 is buried under a ruck, somebody needs to make the kick. I think the problem with Samu’s passing is that he always tries to break the line first, but teams have learned to tackle him. He also seemed to get through the line more at 13, when he ran an angle, then pass out to his winger. It doesn’t seem to work as well with less space and time at 12. The more I think about it, I reckon he would be better at 13 with Perese or CFS on the wing and swapping with him in defence.

2018-04-22T12:14:28+00:00

Melburnian

Roar Pro


Don't disagree with you here but I would point out that Saracens' home ground has a capacity of 10,000 and they often fill it. If they play a game at Twickenham, its quite often 80,000. AAMI Park hold 32,000 but the best crowd the Rebels have had in five years was last month against the 'Canes. Many of the NZ home games seem poorly attended too. SR has a big problem in its appeal and I can see the SA teams drifting away into the NH competition over then next few years. We have to find a way to make Aussie Rugby in particular, much more competitive but whether that can happen in the time frames we have I'm not sure.

2018-04-22T12:12:57+00:00

StuM

Guest


God, what a thoroughly disillusioning weekend. Genuine question, if anyone knows the answer?: What does Michael Cheika do during his extremely long off-season - anything constructive regarding Rugby?

2018-04-22T12:06:36+00:00

Train without a station

Guest


How is it indicative of the problem? His opposite number ran 5 times, passed 6 times and offloaded once. He distributed the same number of times as Kerevi. Just without the running same running threat, as he ran for 20% as many meters as kerevi.

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar