Marcus Harris and Jake Lehmann stake early claims for Test selection

By David Holden / Roar Guru

Back in the golden years of Australian cricket, most Australian batsmen had to score plenty of runs for a number of seasons at Sheffield Shield level to make the Test team.

Names like Matt Hayden and Michael Hussey spring to mind. Players like Stuart Law and Martin Love would be locked into the Australian Test team today. Instead, they played one and five Tests for their country respectively.

Australian cricket, and the batting order specifically, is in a much different position today. Over the past few seasons, strong early Sheffield Shield form has led to Australian Test debuts. Matthew Renshaw and Pete Handscomb debuted against South Africa in November 2016 and Cameron Bancroft played his first Test in November 2017.

It will happen again this year. After the Test series defeat to Pakistan, coach Justin Langer told radio station SEN that Test spots were up for grabs. “It’s very open. Because we’re not performing,” Langer said, before adding “whether you’re an 18-year-old wonderboy or a 30-year-old run machine”.

With that in mind, we look at early season form and see if we can pick those batsmen who must now be firmly in selectors’ minds as we move into November. We also note there are three more Sheffield Shield rounds before the first test, so it is not too late for any hopefuls. However, they wouldn’t want to get too far behind.

Firstly, Will Pucovski has done the right thing, by taking an indefinite break from cricket, to deal with mental health issues. Pucovski is an undoubted talent, averaging 55.75 last Sheffield Shield season and, of course, the 243 run effort against Western Australia at the WACA this season.

However, at 20 years of age and with just six first class games under his belt, he has plenty of time to become a fixture in the Australian test team. With all the pressure that goes hand in hand with that position, Pucovski should be given all the time he needs.

Surprisingly, Pucovski’s double century is not the highest Shield score so far this season. Marcus Harris’ 250 not out against NSW is.

After six seasons playing for Western Australia, Harris left for Victoria in April 2016. The then Western Australian coach Langer described Harris’ batting efforts as “mediocre with flashes of brilliance”. Harris’ two seasons with Victoria have been much more consistent and he must be close to a Test call.

Going against him is that Matt Renshaw would have opened in Pakistan if not for concussion problems. Renshaw has only scored 0 and 3 in his only Shield appearance to date but he may be given first shot against India if he gets some scores in his remaining games.

Matt Renshaw. (AAP Image/Dave Hunt)

Jake Lehmann must also be very close to selection. After being tipped as an Ashes bolter last year, his scores this season of 61, 33no and 126 put him firmly in the frame. With the current Australian middle order positions all potentially open, another couple of strong performances would likely see Lehmann in the baggy green.

Plenty were rightfully calling for Shaun Marsh’s axing, from the Australian team, after his woeful series against Pakistan. Whilst those calls are not likely to ease, his 80 and 98 against Tasmania have given selectors a reason to pick him. With Langer a supporter, he may well keep his place for the first Test against India.

Of the others so far, Alex Doolan has scored 115 and 76 this season whilst Tom Cooper has scored 178. Cooper arguably only got his chance in the South Australian team due to Callum Ferguson’s injury whilst Doolan would need another few big scores to give him any chance of a recall. Kurtis Patterson has made 63 and 50 in the recent Shield game vs Victoria but his failure to go and post a big hundred will count against him.

The no 6 all-rounders position is also open after Mitchell Marsh’s series against Pakistan. After working on his batting and seemingly enjoying a break-out series against England, his away tests have been poor.

Mitchell and Shaun Marsh of Australia (Photo by Lee Warren/Gallo Images/Getty Images)

Of more concern though is that of his four dismissals in Pakistan, three were LBW. Marsh has worked hard on getting his pads outside the line but he fell back into bad habits in the UAE.

Of the contenders for no 6, Marcus Stoinis has put together 80 amidst a couple of failures. Glenn Maxwell hasn’t played Shield at all this season but is coming off a good season last year averaging over 50. As is the case with Stoinis, a successful one day series against South Africa could be enough for Maxwell to gain the no 6 spot.

With the first Test against India not starting until 6th December, there are another three Sheffield Shield rounds to stake claims. At this stage, Jake Lehmann is only a couple of good scores away from selection.

If Renshaw’s early season form continues to falter, another century or two from Harris will put plenty of pressure on the selectors. November promises to be a very interesting month of Sheffield Shield cricket.

The Crowd Says:

2018-11-03T12:00:37+00:00

Ronan O'Connell

Expert


To further underline this point about the major flaw in Lehmann's technique look at his horrendous shot to get out today at 0:09 in this video: https://www.cricket.com.au/video#videoId=5857136371001

2018-11-01T03:53:43+00:00

dan ced

Guest


This is why JLT runs are pointless.. with those tiny grounds, it's a joke tournament. Even BBL is on real grounds! People like Short and Lynn get hype but are clearly flat track bullies like Finch used to be. More traditional batsmen like Ferguson should be way above the sloggers or oddball technique brigade.. or even flashy youngsters, in the pecking order.

2018-10-30T13:47:50+00:00

Baggy_Green

Roar Pro


The word all-rounder in the context if Aussie test team makes me sick to the gut !!!!!! See the names you suggested for want of an AR - Stoinis , Maxi and Short .. MUST play with 6 proper batsmen

2018-10-30T13:41:02+00:00

Baggy_Green

Roar Pro


Too many of the half forward batsmen currently - Both Marshes , Maxwell , Lynn , Short - thats been a huge part of the "technique" flaw that Langer wants corrected ... Khawaja and Finch displayed good footwork in UAE and runs followed !!!

2018-10-30T13:36:40+00:00

Baggy_Green

Roar Pro


Agree with that Burgy - wrote an article on this - https://www.theroar.com.au/2018/09/24/its-time-for-australias-new-batsmen-to-shine/ The talent at U19 and U17 also looks good currently

2018-10-29T23:12:40+00:00

Ronan O'Connell

Expert


Another crucial point on the comparison between Harris and Lehmann - it is folly to compare their career first-class records because although they born only 13 days apart Harris started playing FC cricket 4 years before Lehmann. The much more relevant way to compare their first-class records is starting from the date Lehmann debuted in March 2015 and then this is what you get: Lehmann - 2,612 runs at 41 Harris - 2,310 runs at 47

2018-10-29T23:01:09+00:00

jameswm

Roar Guru


Must be genetic - you've just described Darren Lehmann's technique...

2018-10-29T22:59:54+00:00

jameswm

Roar Guru


You've never heard of a no d***head policy?

2018-10-29T20:00:30+00:00

Ronan O'Connell

Expert


To finish that point Harris has a much better technique than Lehmann IMO - his footwork and head position when playing balls outside off are far, far better. He really gets his foot to the pitch of the ball with his head following, whereas Lehmann's foot is planted on the line of the stumps with his head a long way from the pitch of the ball.

2018-10-29T19:54:42+00:00

Ronan O'Connell

Expert


Interesting article David. Harris has improved a ton in recent years but I'd still have him well behind Renshaw and Burns as Test opening options. As for Lehmann - so many Aussie fans complain about Head being a loose batsman yet Lehmann's style makes Head's technique look flawless by comparison! Lehmann is all eye and zero footwork. So often he plants his front foot straight down the pitch and then just reaches out to clatter balls outside off stump. Accurate Test seamers like Philander, Anderson and Abbas would pick him apart with his current technique. He's talented, no doubt, but his batting style does not look suited to Test cricket.

2018-10-29T14:20:25+00:00

Don Freo

Roar Rookie


Getting out for 50 will not get you a Test berth. He is also a very poor fieldsman. Even gloves don't help him.

2018-10-29T08:41:51+00:00

Andrew

Guest


Don't forget, need to consider what circumstances the batsmen scored these runs under i.e. a so so bowling attack on a flat Adelaide Oval wicket or against test level bowlers on Bellerive green top

2018-10-29T07:38:03+00:00

JOHN ALLAN

Guest


JL said recently that for batsmen to qualify runs were the only currency & they had to be good blokes??????

2018-10-29T06:30:44+00:00

Don Freo

Roar Rookie


Guffaw! Who do you think finds that clever? It's been said forever by dumb people. You identify well with them.

2018-10-29T06:29:36+00:00

Don Freo

Roar Rookie


And, of course, Pope goes out when Zampa returns. Even Zampa was 12th man in a few games for SA.

2018-10-29T06:28:16+00:00

Don Freo

Roar Rookie


Harris did not value his wicket in those days. Langer was very direct with his comments, clear that Harris was running away from the heat Langer put on him. Harris has matured big time since then. The problem with Harris is that, like Langer, he is a safe fielder but nothing special. A bit of hiding him in the outfield.

2018-10-29T06:22:31+00:00

Don Freo

Roar Rookie


Harris has been scoring Shield centuries since he was 18yo. He has been on the boil for some time...Shield finals, for instance.

2018-10-29T02:46:37+00:00

jameswm

Roar Guru


I forgot Labuschagne too DNP, 3, 28. If anything has gone backwards in the pecking order.

2018-10-29T02:42:35+00:00

jameswm

Roar Guru


I'm no expert, but I wonder if young sportsmen should be forced to have other interests - study, charity work, part time work. It's so much pressure to put on your sport, esp one like cricket where you can have a few bad days and there is so much pressure on you.

2018-10-29T02:40:54+00:00

jameswm

Roar Guru


Wade and SMarsh both doing well, headaches for everyone who doesn't want them in the team (like me). Good on them I guess.

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar