Who should replace Tom Rogic for the Socceroos Asian Cup quarter-final?

By Pat Smith / Roar Guru

It’s been glossed over in the aftermath of the Socceroos’ penalty-shootout win over Uzbekistan, but Graham Arnold needs to find a Tom Rogic replacement for the Asian Cup quarter-final against the UAE.

After being lambasted for his display in the opening-round loss to Jordan, Rogic has been in fine form for Australia. In the three games since, the Celtic midfielder has two assists and a goal, and has looked far more the world-class player we all know he can be.

But the horrendous decision to show him a yellow card early in the match against Uzbekistan means he’ll be out for the must-win clash against the tournament hosts. So who should replace him?

Here are some options.

Massimo Luongo
Luongo was unreal in the last Asian Cup, finishing as the tournament’s MVP and scoring Australia’s first goal in the final.

Despite not playing a minute at last year’s World Cup, he’s been in excellent form of late, and would no doubt enjoy slotting into Rogic’s advanced role, further up the pitch from where he’s often been deployed in the green and gold. He’s the most likely replacement for Rogic.

(Photo by Zhizhao Wu/Getty Images)

Jackson Irvine
Having started against Uzbekistan in a holding midfield role, Jackson Irvine could be pushed up the field to cover for Rogic, with Luongo playing alongside skipper Mark Milligan in the heart of midfield.

Irvine has been used as an attacking midfielder for Australia in the past, and has displayed a good goalscoring touch in club football in the past. However, he and Milligan have been working well in tandem together, and it would be a risk to disrupt that engine-room combination for such an important clash.

(Photo by Simon Hofmann – FIFA/FIFA via Getty Images)

Chris Ikonomidis
Ikonomidis has been superb for Australia this tournament playing on the left wing. The Perth Glory man has an Asian Cup-best four assists, as well as a goal to his name, and has been vital in freshening up the attack after a poor first-up performance.

But with Mathew Leckie getting over his injury, Graham Arnold needs to find a place in the side for the Hertha Berlin winger. Moving Ikonomidis into a central role would do just that, although it would make the bench skinnier and give the midfield less defensive steel.

Sports opinion delivered daily 

   

Mustafa Amini
A left-field option, Amini doesn’t offer much of a goalscoring threat, but he has the technical capability to unlock opposition defences.

It would be a massive ask of the 25-year-old, who only has only earned five caps – and just one start – in his international career to date, but he played under Arnold as a youngster for the Mariners, and the UAE wouldn’t expect to see him lining up against him.

If picked, he could be an inspired selection. Or it could backfire spectacularly.

(Photo by Francois Nel/Getty Images)

So who should Arnie pick? For me, it’s got to be Luongo, with Ikonomidis staying on the bench, Leckie offering a super-sub option, Irvine remaining next to Milligan as a holding midfielder, and Amini ready to burst off the bench for a memorable cameo.

The Crowd Says:

2019-01-22T15:11:16+00:00

EJ

Roar Pro


or could change it to a 4-4-2 featuring Maclaren (or other striker) up top with mabil/leckie/ikonimidis, but Arnold should only change formation if he believes it will help the squad and if the squad is comfortable, when we had Ange I never liked how he changed our successful 4-3-3 in the Asian cup to a 3-4-3 during qualifying

2019-01-22T15:08:19+00:00

EJ

Roar Pro


in my view they could move ikonimidis in the midfield and move leckie on wing, ikonimidis and mabil have played well and don't deserve to be dropped yet after his performance Leckie deserves to be brought in, if its not ikonimidis moved into the midfield i will feel sorry for which ever winger does get dropped

2019-01-22T13:29:51+00:00

Sydneysideliner

Roar Rookie


Mabil for me. He's played that role for club, the Syria goal showed his ability to dribble and shoot outside the box and he seemed a bit too slow chasing some through balls and tracking back in defence (compared to Leckie). Plus if you're desperate for someone to stop passing out wide and just shoot , he's your guy!

2019-01-22T09:05:31+00:00

That A-League Fan

Roar Guru


Sorry, just no. Luongo is simply not good enough. He always plays in a deep role, and has been underachieving so far at the Asian Cup. Starting someone playing badly in an unpreffered position, just no. He wouldn't even make my starting xi. Anyway, Idk. Maybe worth changing formation.

2019-01-22T05:37:19+00:00

TheVolley

Guest


Loungo should start in that position and be given the freedom. He thrived in that mode in 2015. Also he has more experience over the other candidates.

2019-01-22T04:05:51+00:00

Midfielder

Roar Guru


Musty

Read more at The Roar