Stop the sooking and enjoy the weekend in Brisbane

By AJ Mithen / Expert

Prepare yourself for the festival of football!

The NRL’s inaugural Magic Round kicks off tomorrow and it’s going to be a good bit of fun for those in the stands and watching elsewhere.

Although it’s pretty much a shameless ripoff of the English Super League’s Magic Weekend, it’s still an innovation for Australian codes.

So far, it’s reported around 125,000 people will be getting along to a game in Brisbane over the weekend – including a bunch of interstate visitors – and that’s great. Anything that creates excitement over rugby league can’t be a bad thing.

But as is the nature of the game, there are a lot of folks around who aren’t too enamoured with the idea or its execution.

We’ve got the usual steady stream of rugby league sooking and disproportionate aggression about the NRL’s decision to move to Suncorp for the weekend.

I’ll grant those arguments bagging the ‘Magic Round’ name – a transparently corporate and highly unoriginal moniker – but when you start to complain about teams having to play away from home, that’s where you start to lose me.

Let me help you debunk the common sooks we’ve been hearing about this weekend’s event.

Some Manly fans – and others getting outraged on behalf of Manly – are complaining they don’t get to play Brisbane at Brookvale.

They’ve obviously forgotten that since 2016, the Sea Eagles have chosen to play their home games against the Broncos at Suncorp Stadium. They’ve won one from three in this time but in return have pocketed a decent amount of cash, which is the whole point.

Manly fans are disappointed their Eagles are flying north of Brookvale. (AAP Image/Dan Himbrechts)

One of the more common complaints is that fans of the Sydney teams are being robbed of the opportunity to get to a game.

This school of thought apparently ignores that this weekend their teams will be playing in front of crowds much larger than what they’d be getting at their home ground.

It’s also pretty safe to assume that these good people being robbed of a chance to attend a game are the same ones who won’t watch a game in Sydney because it’s too hard to switch trains, it’s too far to drive, the stadium isn’t perfect enough or there’s some other minimal issue stopping them from bothering to make the effort.

Then there’s the issue of the location.

When the Queensland capital was announced as the host city, doomsayers predicted the Suncorp Stadium surface wouldn’t be able to handle the booted traffic.

Well, the weather forecast is glorious and I’d still rather my team be playing on a slightly choppy Suncorp surface compared to chancing their limbs on the turf at the SCG, Kogarah or Brookvale.

If this event was being held in Sydney, there’d still be bugger-all people turning up.

Last year’s Round 3 double-header at Homebush attracted just 25,106 spectators, a dismal turn-out for two games featuring Cronulla, Manly, Souths and Parramatta.

Why not Perth? Why not Adelaide? Why not Melbourne?

Well to start with, the Queensland government and Brisbane City Council ponied up the cash for a three-year run. Brisbane City Council thinks they’ll trouser up to $60 million for their reported $5 million outlay.

As for Perth, they’re hosting the second State of Origin game in June, and the Adelaide Oval will have an Origin game played there in 2020. There’s plenty of rugby league to go around.

Perth’s Optus Stadium will the second Origin clash this season. (Grant Trouville NRL Photos).

So kick-off in Brisbane is the smart move to establish the weekend as a feature of the NRL calendar, with decent crowds, knowledgeable fans, and all the off-field entertainment and festivities one can manage.

Once other cities see what can be done with it and how it will attract interstate visitors, they’ll no doubt be keen to have a crack at getting Magic Round in their backyard.

Finally, we have the complaints that some folks just don’t get it. They don’t see the point of playing every game in one location, and that’s OK.

Because you know what? You don’t need to get anything.

It’s the NRL trying something different to create interest and buzz around their game. It’ll likely be a raging success which will set the scene for more into the future.

Aside from all that noise, there are some intriguing on-field stories to play out.

Can the dinged-up Raiders keep their league-best defence on track against the rampant Roosters?

Can Brisbane sneak an away win at home and keep their season on life support?

Will local fans realise Kodi Nikorima is playing for the Warriors?

Will the Eels beat Melbourne and vault over them into the top four?

Wests Tigers and Penrith face off again but, funnily enough, there’s been almost zero articles about Ivan Cleary, a bus or Phil Gould this time around.

If things go Newcastle’s way, the Knights could finish the weekend inside the top eight – a seemingly unfathomable outcome after their horrible start to the year. Their first step towards achieving that is to beat Canterbury.

Believe it or not, right now, every team is a live option to play finals. The gap between eighth and 16th is two wins and ten converted tries.

With 17 weeks left in the season, that’s nothing.

Sports opinion delivered daily 

   

The Crowd Says:

2019-05-10T05:06:15+00:00

Papi Smurf

Roar Rookie


Happy to be of service Nat. I just hope you will still be laughing by the conclusion of the second game tonight. I'm sure I will. Either way I win in any case. ;-) The reference re Suncorp stadium being 26% full was in reference to a 13,000 something crowd in a 52,500 capacity stadium.

2019-05-10T04:53:06+00:00

Nat

Roar Guru


OMG an insurance company is making it difficult to win $1m!! That would only happen in Qld! M0r0n

AUTHOR

2019-05-10T04:48:45+00:00

AJ Mithen

Expert


Further to this discussion: https://www.nrl.com/news/2019/05/10/magic-round-delivers-five-times-what-clubs-normally-bank/

2019-05-10T04:36:33+00:00

Nat

Roar Guru


That's hilarious. How many times can you get it wrong in just a few paragraphs? "The attendance was 13,643 which was only 26% of capacity!" BAHAHAHAHAHAHA " he Broncos fans couldn’t even come close to half filling their much vaunted Suncorp stadium to see their own team play!" HAHAHAHA OOOOOO HAHAHAHAH Stop Please!!! He doesn't know he's dumping on his own club. " Broncos could only get 27,638 to see the home team play the Sharks, that’s barely over 50% capacity." Wait what? Didn't that just contradict your last statement above? Brisbane's worst crowd is double what the bunnies can muster up for the big 'grudge match'. Do you really wonder what crowd Sydney would put on at ANZ? Well, put it this way, everyone that shows up gets 4 seats to themselves. Se ya ron blue balls - I'm off to the footy!!

2019-05-10T03:42:30+00:00

E-Meter

Roar Rookie


Why would it be on death's door by playing a whole round in Brisbane? Explain yourself man!

2019-05-10T03:41:09+00:00

E-Meter

Roar Rookie


Have you ever been to QLD?

2019-05-09T12:13:34+00:00

Adam

Guest


The NRL are playing all the rounds games in Brisbane? That's laughable, the sport isn't my cup of tea but the league must be on deaths door if that is where it is at.

2019-05-09T07:22:09+00:00

Emcie

Roar Guru


Would Parra be big enough for this kind of event? I'm sure the atmosphere would be amazing but it'd be topping out at an average broncos attendance

2019-05-09T07:07:05+00:00

Emcie

Roar Guru


Would it need to be massive? You'd only need to average low end broncos crowds per game to have a massive increase over the average nrl crowd numbers.

2019-05-09T06:45:12+00:00

Richard POWELL

Roar Rookie


What a w%nk Magic round is. Youi $1 million kick for cash - 50 metres, thru the goalposts then thru a basketball hoop/net. Not surprising no-one won it. Like the rest of Qld - B.S. one day, Up to sh%t the next.

2019-05-09T06:26:59+00:00

Papi Smurf

Roar Rookie


Cheers for the update but that won't be worth a thing to any of the teams if they lose players to injury because of too much wear and tear on the ground. I'll reserve my judgement until after the round is over but top marks to the QLD government for the initiative in taking care of their own.

2019-05-09T06:09:44+00:00

J

Guest


The NRL got $2.1 million from the QLD govt + all gate receipts. Each home team will get $270,000, which is massive compared to normal gate receipts. It’s a win for the NRL and a win for clubs. Figures are from the SMH.

2019-05-09T05:26:29+00:00

Bernie Pramberg

Guest


Geez....in the good old days we all sat through three games every weekend. Third, Reserve and First Grade at every ground, every round.

2019-05-09T03:25:04+00:00

William Dalton Davis

Roar Rookie


Kodi Nikorima’s homecoming after a whole week. Has he even gone to NZ yet?

2019-05-09T03:23:59+00:00

Rowdy

Roar Rookie


You’d have to split the Magic between those 2 cities. Even if it was Perth, with it’s greater population, it’d still not be successful. They’d be lucky to get 80k thru the gate. —- Perhaps share it with Melbourne, Adelaide and Perth on one of the less crowded AFL rounds. Those 3 cities attend sport to a greater degree than Brisbane or Sydney.

2019-05-08T23:58:47+00:00

Papi Smurf

Roar Rookie


"Magic Round" will be a dismal failure if they can't fill Suncorp stadium to capacity with between 4 and 6 teams playing over Friday and the weekend. If they pull no more than the recent poor crowds for Broncos games then Greenberg's "magic beans" will be more baked beans than magic ones! Still, I can't help but wonder how many they would get to ANZ stadium with a capacity of 83,500? The problem with Sydney is the transport infrastructure is rubbish and too congested which turns a lot of people off. I have travelled from Gosford to ANZ stadium and found the connections were fine if you could catch the train to the stadium instead of having to catch a bus for the last leg.

2019-05-08T23:50:10+00:00

Big Daddy

Guest


Yeah " that old chestnut". That aside I'm on your side it's a gimmick. Look at manly last year, played there in double header. Crowd was about 38k boosted their home and away stats so the NRL hopped on board and thought it was a good idea. Rugby league is strong in Brisbane so they thought they'd get on the back of that.

2019-05-08T23:49:48+00:00

Papi Smurf

Roar Rookie


"I think we both know you’ve been pantsed" Like I told Nat, you QLDers have VERY active imaginations to picture such things. Like I said before, I live a 7-hour return drive out of Sydney and don't get the opportunity to attend games. Sorry to disappoint you but the pants stay on mate. ;-)

2019-05-08T23:46:51+00:00

Papi Smurf

Roar Rookie


I responded to your thrown gauntlet yesterday with a checkmate move that the moderators have chosen not to post. I'll still claim checkmate... I live a 7-hour return drive out of Sydney and don't have the opportunity to attend games, Sherlock.

2019-05-08T23:13:50+00:00

Fix the scrums

Guest


Not so sure about teams giving up the home game advantage so often by playing away. Yes, a magic round has a certain appeal but let's see how they measure its success. The ratings and crowds would need to be massive. But it's a good promotion for Brisbane.

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar