Why the Eagles are the team to beat

By JFarrell / Roar Rookie

The Eagles are quietly building towards a dynasty as one of the competition’s top teams with a possibility of multiple premierships.

The West Coast Eagles last season participated in one of the great grand finals of all time, with Dom Sheed kicking the famous matchwinning goal.

This season has meandered along a similar path, with the Eagles still as dominant as last season. The slight slip-up came at the beginning of the season with a 44-point loss to the Brisbane Lions, who have turned into one of the top teams this season, but they quickly righted the ship with a 52-point win against the Giants at home and a 13-point win in the derby against Gold Coast.

West Coast have had a rather uneventful season, with only a few hiccups coming against the Power, Cats, Swans and Pies. The game against the Tigers at the MCG this weekend will be the most telling of all – it will give us a real understanding of exactly where the two most fancied teams stand.

(Will Russell/AFL Photos/via Getty Images )

The Eagles have the most well-balanced team in both defence and attack, with two of the most damaging key forwards and two of the most steadfast key defenders. They’re ranked fifth in points conceded and fourth in rebound from 50 differentials, with Shannon Hurn ranked fifth in the league for rebounds from 50 based on average.

In attack the Eagles are ranked third in points per game and fifth in goal assists per game, with Jack Darling fifth in the Coleman Medal race.

Their midfield, while not as flashy as that of Geelong or Collingwood, always provides a contest and creates opportunities to move the ball forward. With no dominant ruckman and Tom Hickey fighting a lone hand admirably, the Eagles still manage to sit fifth in clearances.

West Coast have one of the most dynamic forward lines in the league. It’s built around pressure and is always creating a contest. They are the top-ranked team in restricting rebounds from 50 and second in opponent clangers per game. Elliot Yeo is the top-ranked tackler in the AFL with 147 and Luke Shuey is not far behind in 11th with 114.

The Eagles play a fast brand of football regularly set up by the raking right boot of all Australian Shannon Hurn. Players like Jack Petruccelle, Willie Rioli and Liam Ryan have the ability to break lines and get out the back of defences if they are not aware.

Sports opinion delivered daily 

   

Jack Darling and Josh Kennedy have the potential to pry a game open and win it off their own boots.

Most defences comprise one tall defender along with what has become a hybrid player, such as Dylan Grimes or Jake Kolodjashnij. The eagles, however, have three key talls in Josh Kennedy, Jack Darling and Oscar Allen, with Tom Hickey rolling through occasionally when he needs a break in the ruck.

These three tall targets have the potential to create headaches for opposition teams and defensive coaches with match-ups. Coupled with the pace and X factor of Rioli, Pettrucelle and Ryan, they could be seen as among the most dangerous.

The only concern for the Eagles is Hickey in the ruck coming up against someone like Brodie Grundy in the finals.

Other teams like Geelong and Richmond, however, have ruckmen who are not dominant, and Hickey should be able to break to give his midfielders first use of the ball.

The criticism from previous seasons has been an inability to win at the MCG, but last year’s grand final disproves this as an issue. The Eagles have continued to prove this story wrong this season and have won every game at the G – they haven’t even got this strong a record at home.

This is a team full of players with finals experience. They’ve played finals every year since 2015 and have played in two grand finals.

When comparing the Eagles to teams around them, Geelong is now widely believed to have lost the spark they had earlier in the season and all backing appears to have them third in the pecking order. The Cats have floundered and have beaten only the Kangaroos convincingly in recent weeks – and that was at home, where they’re always tough to beat.

Brisbane, while playing electric football, simply lack the experience. The Lions are one or two seasons away from giving the competition a real shake and going the whole way.

So this round will be telling. Can the Eagles travel to the MCG and defeat a red-hot Tigers team in what could become a preview to the grand final?

The Crowd Says:

2019-08-15T07:56:30+00:00

EaglesMan

Roar Rookie


We do have weaknesses plenty so do the dogs and you’re overated midfield was smashed by West Coast last year and this year

2019-08-15T07:12:47+00:00

Doctor Rotcod

Roar Rookie


No deflection here. Eagles have weaknesses. Dogs have more. Believe it or not,so do all the top four. Where are the Dogs at the moment?

2019-08-15T04:34:20+00:00

IAP

Guest


Nahh, it's more fun pointing out the obvious to you blokes and watching you trying to deflect. You'd make great test batsmen with that defensive technique.

2019-08-14T22:54:33+00:00

EaglesMan

Roar Rookie


That is because IAP knows he flakey Dogs have not made finals since their flag. He has nothing else to write home about

2019-08-14T22:53:02+00:00

EaglesMan

Roar Rookie


IAP and yet we have a Norm Smith medalist in Shuey, All Australian in Gaff, Yeo and Sheed. We convincingly smacked your Dogs at Marvel by 50 points last year and flogged them again this year. What about your Dogs, if they are that good? Apparently the greatest midfield of all time Why did they loose to Carlton, Gold Coast, St Kilida and Melbourne. Go look at your own patch first.

2019-08-14T11:03:10+00:00

Doctor Rotcod

Roar Rookie


Do the words hyperbole and grandiloquence mean anything to you? I don't remember too much going the Eagles' way in their three finals last year in contrast to the Dogs in 2016 but then I don't battle with irrelevancy syndrome.

2019-08-14T06:19:48+00:00

IAP

Guest


Let's face it, West Coast need two home finals to win a premiership. They're home-track wonders who need the terrible, terrible umpiring bias they get at home to get across the line. Without the umpires they're a middling team with a mediocre midfield, except for Yeo; he's pretty much the greatest 2 players ever to strap on the boots. That's right, he's twice as good as the best player ever. He's pretty much the Bradman of footy.

2019-08-14T05:00:51+00:00

Doctor Rotcod

Roar Rookie


Just as well you're not playing Hawthorn in the finals then. Geelong vs the Eagles at the MCG makes for pretty reading. Watch out for those Lions.

2019-08-14T03:41:21+00:00

Yattuzzi

Roar Rookie


Just talking about the Gee. Played five lost one and won over Richmond and Collingwood. Hawks are always a worry for us. No surprise. Won’t be playing them.

2019-08-14T03:35:10+00:00

EaglesMan

Roar Rookie


And what about you? Lost to a below average Fremantle? Got beaten by the Hawks at the MCG

AUTHOR

2019-08-14T02:42:33+00:00

JFarrell

Roar Rookie


Richmond have previously held the MCG as a fortress, if they can find that again then they will be mighty tough to beat for the Eagles

2019-08-13T23:38:19+00:00

Seymorebutts

Guest


Agreed, Redden is an absolute gun, love his close in work, and we all would have seen how good he was sooner if not for some recruiting decisions which we dont need to go into. Hes a very good player as is Dom Sheed who is all class, Gaffy working away racking up possesions. I know the Pies and Tigers mids get plenty of media love but theres not much wrong with their Eagles equivalents when you think about it ;-)

2019-08-13T23:29:27+00:00

Seymorebutts

Guest


Exactly, they have a nice classy midfielder down there Matty Allen getting plenty of ball, nice left boot on him. So yes, they've got some talent running around in the WAFL, hoping to see some of these guys kick on next year ;-)

2019-08-13T19:46:23+00:00

Yattuzzi

Roar Rookie


Well this is an Eagles love in. You have had three whole games at the Gee. Below par Carlton, just over Hawks and the Pies. You will get soundly beaten by the Tigers at the MCG and give yourself an away final first week. Good luck with that.

2019-08-13T17:36:17+00:00

Jack A

Guest


Grant Thomas is also interviewed on the Sacked podcast, forgot to mention that but also worth hearing.

2019-08-13T13:17:11+00:00

Doctor Rotcod

Roar Rookie


Redden has all of a sudden developed a cranky side, maybe because he sees Yeo on the other side of the pack. It suits him. Other teams can't ignore him any more.He might be behind Shuey,Sheed and Yeo but that's still pretty good. I'd like to find out what proportion of the Eagles' tackles result in frees,either way. Although there's always the 360 degree spin tackle that has no result .

2019-08-13T13:15:40+00:00

bell31

Guest


that's exactly my line of thinking, but I think everything would need to go our way (eg, sneak into top 4, potentially avoid WC at home and win 1st qualifying final to give our injury list / returning players more recuperation time between games, etc)

2019-08-13T13:02:55+00:00

Doctor Rotcod

Roar Rookie


If any of them played for another side they'd all be in the AA. I can't see the selectors picking more than two. Barrass already plays as well as Rance.

2019-08-13T11:00:24+00:00

Jack A

Guest


I found this interview with Scott Watters interesting. I’m not sure how much is true but it’s worth a listen. I hope you guys pick the best coach and move back up the ladder - https://podcasts.apple.com/au/podcast/sacked/id1470557961?i=1000445730272

2019-08-13T10:55:09+00:00

Jack A

Guest


At least 3 WC backmen should make the AA 22 this year. Hurn, Gov, Sheppard. Each of them should be a lock. Barrass is a gun that can play Govs role just as well as Gov can - he did it when Gov was out. Those 3-4 players are as good as anyone in the game in their roles.

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar