Roosters should derail plans to face Folau

By Joe Frost / Editor

Many years ago, a train broke down on the Sydney Harbour Bridge and there were calls for the premier’s head.

My initial thought was that it was a ridiculous overreaction – how the hell is it the fault of the guy who runs the entire state if one train didn’t work?

But then I started to think about the chain of command.

Why did the engineer bugger up? Were they negligent or, perhaps, was it that they were working within antiquated and illogical systems?

And if it was the latter – and this is the Morris Iemma government we’re talking about – then maybe we don’t call out the person unfortunate enough to be on the tools when the system inevitably broke down.

Maybe it’s the fault of the person who allowed this system to continue as if it wasn’t a problem, right up until it was.

There’s a chain of command that shows how this broken-down locomotive was in fact the fault of the state premier. Not necessarily because he implemented a bad plan, but because the standard you walk past is the standard you accept.

Which brings me to 2020, and as part of their preparations for the World Club Challenge, the Sydney Roosters plan to have an opposed session with the club where Trent Robinson cut his teeth, Catalans Dragons.

Yeah, the club that just signed Israel Folau.

Naturally, Robinson tried to blow off the fact a club that counts Oxford Street as part of its catchment area are going to have a hit-out against a bloke who has some wildly outdated opinions about homosexuality.

“An opposed session for two hours does not mean we are validating his views,” Robinson was quoted as saying in the Sydney Morning Herald.

“It was organised last December, before we knew that Izzy had signed with Catalans. In the end, let’s train.”

(Photo by RAYMOND ROIG/AFP via Getty Images)

Which, yeah, it’s not an unfair assessment – there are a whole lot more players than just Folau at the session who will be testing the reigning NRL premiers out.

But…

But if the standard you walk past is the one you accept, then what does it mean that the Chooks are pressing ahead with a session against the Dragons after the French club decided they’re cool with Folau’s unrepentant homophobia?

It’s the transfer of property – if the Roosters are cool with Catalans, and Catalans are cool with Folau, then the Roosters are cool with Folau.

I know some people will say that’s a stretch, but it’s really not that far – it’s literally one step removed.

Catalans have a history of not really giving a toss what anyone else thinks – they’re a French club in an English comp and while the Hundred Years’ War may be long over, the animosity between the two nations will never truly extinguish.

Plus Folau is still awesome at footy, so I kinda see where the frogs are coming from signing him.

But while they’ve pretended they can divorce Folau the footy player from Folau the bible thumper, well, they can’t.

He’s been completely unrepentant regarding his homophobic views, which is what separates him from just about every other misbehaving footy player in history.

Israel is not sorry for what he’s done.

In an attempt to cover for this, Dragons chairman Bernard Guasch said it was cool, because Folau would keep his opinions to himself this time around.

“We do not believe that those views should be publicly expressed, especially by a high-profile sports person,” Guasch said announcing the ex-Wallaby’s signing.

“We have a signed agreement with the RFL. Any transgression will trigger an immediate termination of Israel’s contract and a substantial fine for the club.”

So your guarantee that Folau won’t say anything homophobic is that he’ll get sacked and your organisation will lose money? Yeah, maybe you should have a chat with Rugby Australia about how that tends to work out.

(AAP Image/Daniel Munoz)

Ultimately, Folau’s views don’t preclude him from playing footy again, it was simply a case of finding an employer that would accept him.

Catalans were only too happy to accommodate him. And they can say they don’t agree with Folau’s views, but when in the same breath they explain that said views “are based upon his sincerely held religious belief” they give him a pretty substantial out.

Because who gives a shit why he’s homophobic?

Sports opinion delivered daily 

   

Bringing the train back to the station though, this was a chance for the Roosters to take a stand.

Sure, Folau isn’t the whole of the Catalans organisation, but by employing him, the Dragons have shown what they stand for. And by having an opposed session against Catalans – and, in all likelihood, Folau himself – the Roosters give this position legitimacy.

The Chooks can say it’s just an opposed session, it’s only for a couple of hours and it was all organised before Folau was part of the deal, but that’s three excuses fresh from the book of Copping Out.

When you see something wrong and have the power to fix it ­– and let’s not kid around, the back-to-back NRL premiers can totally call off a two-hour opposed session against the Frenchies – it’s incumbent upon you to do so.

Trent Robinson may say it’s just training, but then Morris Iemma said it was just a train.

A speeding locomotive known as Israel Folau is set to hijack Australian rugby league’s cameras and opinions this week. And it’s the Roosters’ fault for letting it happen.

The Crowd Says:

2020-02-23T10:18:47+00:00

EastsFootyFan

Roar Guru


@StevenG, That post literally made no sense. Anthems and damage to the NRL? Do you have evidence of this? What a load of nonsense.

2020-02-17T20:59:19+00:00

DP Schaefer

Roar Rookie


That last line was untrue and unnecessary. I had nothing to do with with that situation. By your logic, thousands upon thousands of Christians - including Jesus and some in my family - are dead because of people like you. You want to wear that?

2020-02-17T20:52:17+00:00

DP Schaefer

Roar Rookie


I'm quite happy to also discredit volumes of study in evolution if you like, by real world examples. Also discredit the claims that recent Victorian fires were caused by climate change (global warming) by real world facts. Just because a bunch of people with preconceived ideas agree on something doesn't make it right. You also throw the word 'bigot' around a lot for a person that demonstrates intolerance themselves.

2020-02-17T20:46:59+00:00

DP Schaefer

Roar Rookie


Hmmm I'm actually very tolerant, too much for my own good. Maybe you could suggest that to all the people intolerant of Folau.

2020-02-17T20:45:33+00:00

Mr Right

Roar Rookie


Your sexuality isn't a choice. What rock did you crawl out from under DP?

2020-02-17T18:46:36+00:00

mushi

Roar Guru


Jacko as I said, unless you have the details it's not really informed discussion. Why settle outside of reasons regarding merits of the case? Well if the rationale was to remove the negative news cycle or bifurcation of the supporter base I could see that as reasonable. Sometimes the court room victory is pyrrhic

2020-02-17T18:36:48+00:00

mushi

Roar Guru


It's not a principled stand though. It's vacuous click bait. He gave more life to the folau discussion by writing the article than the roosters ever could have.

2020-02-17T18:31:45+00:00

mushi

Roar Guru


Maybe he could solve your bigotry in at the same time.

2020-02-17T18:30:16+00:00

mushi

Roar Guru


also extrapolating limited anecdotal experience to apparently discredit volumes of peer reviewed study into sexuality isn't "real world " it's just where bigots start their training.

2020-02-17T18:26:02+00:00

mushi

Roar Guru


Way to reframe the position. The trite "people have choices" is a ridiculous repositioning. To suggest that this us some thin end of the wedge on free will compounds your ever present ignorance and dishonesty. I know many people who didn't choose. Including one who is no longer with us because of people like you.

2020-02-17T10:27:33+00:00

DP Schaefer

Roar Rookie


A reasonable and well worded question. Somehow my original response got lost so I tried again. I meant - Folau mentioned a variety of groups - so why did the media zero in on one group, unless they thought this was the only group of those mentioned that were deserving of judgement? I mean if I nominate a bunch of people - which includes various cultural groups - as deserving of some sanction and people think I'm only referring to a select few in that group, is the problem with me or actually them for highlighting a group that I didn't??

2020-02-17T10:17:02+00:00

DP Schaefer

Roar Rookie


That people have choices??? How about I know people who could have had a life in a particular pathway yet chose otherwise. Real life understanding is far from ignorant and dishonest.

2020-02-17T10:11:16+00:00

DP Schaefer

Roar Rookie


:laughing: :laughing: :laughing: :laughing: :laughing: :laughing: :laughing: I love it.. The God and creator of a universe needs to jump to your call and - with all the evidence around you , such as your existence - still needs to prove something to you... :thumbup:

2020-02-17T10:08:49+00:00

DP Schaefer

Roar Rookie


Of course it's a choice. One may have inclinations a certain way, but how you choose to act is a choice.

2020-02-17T09:59:21+00:00

DP Schaefer

Roar Rookie


Don't call me ignorant. Have you the courage to challenge your preconceived notions? I've done all the research I need. You despise religion.. yet how do you explain your existence?? Evolution? Don't start me burning that myth.. Hence my justifiable hesitation on believing 'scientists' at face value, I don't need twisted 'scientific' opinions, I have real life knowledge about choices. And I'm sure I'll be fine when all the dust settles.

2020-02-17T09:33:30+00:00

Gray-Hand

Roar Rookie


There were several reasons why RA settled. RA ultimately ended up settling because Folau’s lawyers were going to call recent and current wallabies and Waratahs as witnesses. They would have been questioned under oath as to their homophobic religious beliefs which would have put them in a horrible situation. RA didn’t want them to be put in that situation, so they settled.

2020-02-17T08:31:14+00:00

Steve

Guest


I'm a Bunnies supporter and even I think this article is over the top. It's a training session for crying out loud!

2020-02-17T08:18:13+00:00

Kiwi In East Perth

Guest


The media would make you think that the whole gay community is outraged. Several of my friends and colleagues are strong activists in the LGBTI community and most have never heard of Folau and similar to Margaret Court could care less of what a Sporting figure with Strong Christian Views has to say on their social media accounts.

2020-02-17T08:08:02+00:00

Brian Westlake

Roar Rookie


Why is it the same people keep liking your diatribe? Same church?

2020-02-17T08:05:57+00:00

Brian Westlake

Roar Rookie


Extremely Dishonest? Why?

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar