The Panthers are playing as well as they have in years and it could win them the premiership

By Jack Aubrey / Roar Guru

They did just enough to get the job done in matches against the Titans and Cowboys.

But on Saturday night the Panthers unleashed both barrels against the Sea Eagles to stamp themselves as genuine contenders for the premiership.

This is as well as the Panthers have played since 2014. A season where, despite a massive injury toll, Jamie Soward and Matt Moylan led them to an unlikely preliminary final, that they would narrowly lose. Surprise, surprise it is the same man at the helm in Ivan Cleary who arguably should never have been let go.

The Panthers are exhibiting all those same hallmarks that they did in 2014. Everybody is doing their job, and they have found the consistency that alluded them in Cleary Sr’s absence. In years gone by they have managed finals appearances and wins on some brilliance, and the ability to stage comebacks.

They have been incredibly entertaining to watch, but you never got the sense that they could go all the way.

This season is different. They have those traits you associate with the sides that are always there at the business end of the season. The traits you associate with the Roosters and Storm. They beat the teams below them. They compete every week. Everyone knows their role.

They win ugly, but they can also completely outclass their opponent as they did against Manly on the weekend. They have beaten the Storm, and the Roosters, pushed the Eels all the way, and only have that loss along with a draw that blemishes their record.

They have a hard nosed pack that also has some skill. They have enough depth there to loan Jack Hetherington to the Warriors. With what he has brought to them, it’s a wonder he couldn’t get a look in at the Panthers. They still have Kurt Capewell to come back too.

They bought a hooker to give them another dimension. Dylan Edwards works as hard as any player, and is fit as they come, even without him they remain dangerous. Caleb Aekins typifies their squad, he comes in and does his job. He isn’t Dylan Edwards but he is safe and consistent.

Dylan Edwards. (Photo by Matt King/Getty Images)

They have a backline that just hums. Steve Crichton is the star, but everyone else threatens. Charlie Staines has six tries in less than a game and a half. Brent Naden couldn’t get a look in after the resumption but since looks unstoppable.

Josh Mansour does the mountain of work he has always done, even if he isn’t the finisher he once was. They have Brian To’o and Dean Whare to come back, in what will be a major dilemma for Ivan Cleary. Trying to get the balance of experience in his backline just right.

They have a five-eighth with more try assists than anyone else in his team, but who barely rates a mention next to their number seven. Nathan Cleary has gone to another level this season. But it is no surprise to anyone who has watched him since his debut in 2016.

This kid has always had talent, and at times dragged his team into contention both in matches and over the course of a season. James Maloney was a wonderful acquisition for the Panthers but took the reins of the team away from Cleary.

With him gone, the team now belongs to Nathan and it shows. He has the hallmarks of all the champion players and playmakers of our game. It is not in the stats, but the onee percenters. Cleary recognises what the team needs every week, and his responsibility to deliver. It is as simple as a big tackle one week, a chase on a kick, an individual try. Against the Sea Eagles it was a 40/20, a try of his own, and a couple of assists.

The reason Brad Fittler has picked him in Origin because of his consistency. He doesn’t let anyone down. He is strong in defence and plays his role. Fitler has resisted the urge to pick some players in better form to remain loyal to a player he knows has what Origin takes.

Fittler is set to reap the benefits this series with Cleary more confident as a dominant playmaker without Maloney.

Nathan Cleary. (Photo by Jason McCawley/Getty Images)

Phil Gould stepping away from the Panthers has also done the Panthers some favours. This is the club that Gus built, and Panthers fans should be in no doubt about it. He saved the club from the brink of financial ruin, and while they haven’t won a premiership they have acquired the tools to do so since he came onboard in 2011.

He put the systems in place with junior development and management to facilitate the success the Panthers now enjoy. This is one of the youngest squads in the NRL, but it finds itself at the top of the table. Their player retention has also improved.

But it was time for Gus to go. Whatever happened with him and Ivan Cleary is immaterial. The Panthers have the coach they want, and one who Gould endorsed in the first place to lead this club to a premiership.

The spotlight became intense on Penrith with Gould at the Panthers, polarising as a figurehead and ever present in the media.

Every move, every failure was a reflection on him, and proof that his “five-year plan” wasn’t working. With his stepping aside, the Panthers have been free of the scrutiny Gould tends to attract from corners of the media.

The Panthers are better poised than ever to break a 17-year premiership drought. The Roosters have to come down eventually. The Storm are always tough to beat, but you sense that displaced from their home they can’t get to their best.

The Raiders are without their general in Josh Hodgson. The Knights and Rabbitohs are inconsistent at best.

It is their neighbours in the west, the Eels that can probably boast to be their nearest rivals. They have been waiting far longer, and are also at the right end of the ladder heading into the run home. They are close enough if talented enough, and if they keep playing at Bankwest they will keep the points coming.

They have a fanbase even more starved of success than the Panthers. Since their fairytale run of 2009, they have just one finals win. Their success is well overdue.

This season is like no other, and with changes so rapidly occurring in our day to day lives, who knows what the next 14 weeks of this competition will bring. The Panthers though looked poised to finally capitalise on years of hard work, and bring a trophy to the foot of the mountains.

If it’s not this year, it’s coming very soon to a club that has all the pieces of the puzzle.

The Crowd Says:

2020-08-05T23:23:01+00:00

Geoff from Bruce Stadium

Roar Rookie


At least they are having a crack Taree and that's all you can ask for. Really enjoying seeing the way this team plays for each other despite a big injury toll. Bateman was amazing against the Cowboys. And dragged players like Curtis Scott along with him. Such a shame that we are going to lose him.

2020-08-05T21:34:51+00:00

Taree Raider

Guest


Strap yourself in Geoff, it's going to be a hell of a rollercoaster ride. Bateman's back. There's still some depth, especially in the halves. If the Raiders keep having a red hot go each week I'm happy. Come the finals, experience is everything.

2020-08-04T23:41:07+00:00

Albo

Roar Rookie


Yep ! I must agree with you. At the start of the year, I would have picked Burton before Luai at 6. But Luai has sure proved me wrong and he is now a key component of this team. He controls the left edge well in both attack & defence, and he frees Cleary up do his thing on the right . And past regular fumblers like Sauce & Naden seem to have cut out those errors this season. I just think that Burton is a quality prospect who shouldn't be sitting in the sheds. I will hate to see him moved on because he can't get a run at Penrith ?

2020-08-04T22:28:15+00:00

souvalis

Roar Rookie


Initially I thought Burton should definitely been given the 6 jumper but Luai has been really really good. His slipperiness and linking up with his left side particularly man of the hour Chricton, has found this side an extra edge..wouldn’t dare change him. The coaching and selections have been first class..Naden is playing out of his skin even the Sauce hasn’t put anything significant down for a while and keeps on getting in there for a shuffle. Looking forward to seeing them take on Bateman, Papi and Whitehead this week..

2020-08-04T21:37:48+00:00

Matt

Guest


They’re not looking at anywhere near those crowds this year, surely. If the cap is 5,000 then why can’t the game be played where it rightfully should be played. ‘Rightfully’ the key word. The team earned that right.

AUTHOR

2020-08-04T11:19:40+00:00

Jack Aubrey

Roar Guru


Yeah one of those "NRL things", him not playing should be enough of a disadvantage in winning the medal without docking points too. But it will come for the young man soon enough in any case

2020-08-04T09:51:35+00:00

Big Daddy

Guest


On a side note re Penrith. The decision to dock Nathan Cleary 6 points on matches he hasn't played makes a mockery of this award .

AUTHOR

2020-08-04T09:49:41+00:00

Jack Aubrey

Roar Guru


The best teams can win anywhere. If you aren't the Bulldogs or Rabbitohs you don't get the luxury of playing at your home ground for the Grand Final, regardless of how dominant you are throughout the year. The Panthers would have played that Preliminary Final at ANZ regardless of the opposition, it was just unlucky it was one of the two regular tenants. The big games need to be played at big stadiums, and to lock 25k fans out of a match, just to appease one fanbase would be a ridiculous commercial decision, the NRL is a business after all.

AUTHOR

2020-08-04T09:44:13+00:00

Jack Aubrey

Roar Guru


I don't think Penrith have peaked. I think they need a loss sometime soon. They would have been beaten by plenty of other teams the way they played against the Cowboys and Titans, and I think maybe they need a bit of a reality check just to refocus and stop them reading their own press too much. The benefit of the youth that they possess is I think they can ride this wave for a while without coming down

AUTHOR

2020-08-04T09:38:21+00:00

Jack Aubrey

Roar Guru


The Storm and Roosters have equally as many question marks as the Eels and Panthers. I suppose what I mean with the Storm is that as the season wears on, outside of Victoria those pressures and time away from family and support may take a toll mentally. It is an unusual situation that they are handling at the moment, but as the weeks wear on, maybe we will start to see the impact. The Roosters and Storm have the big game experience, no doubt about it, and once finals roll around they will be the real test for the Panthers. Yes, they have just got it done a few times recently but they have also been sensational when it has counted, and as long as they can keep aiming up, they will keep winning.

2020-08-04T08:52:15+00:00

Matt

Guest


With all due respect, Jack, your argument that playing a Prelim at the opposition home ground was as fair as could be, is to be brutally honest, a bunch of crud.

2020-08-04T08:44:28+00:00

Big Daddy

Guest


Lot of pressure on them at the moment but also a lot of pressure on East's and Canberra who are 5 points adrift and cannot afford to lose many matches and either one could miss top 4. A loss by East's or Canberra has sharks and knights snapping at their heels so a lot of pressure on those 2.

2020-08-04T07:15:44+00:00

egbert

Guest


Re: Burton: yes, therein lies the problem, he'd walk into half a dozen other teams, I can't see him staying too long. With Tamou, here's a scenario I could handle: he leaves, maybe another on good money leaves (Mansour?), and with the freed up money Penrith go after Addo-Carr on his return to Sydney. I remember the Roosters' slump last year but were they really this sterile then?

2020-08-04T07:03:47+00:00

Muzz

Guest


They went next level against Manly. Ticked all the boxes. Scary good. Finals footy is a different proposition. Rooster, Storm, Raiders will be ready to take them down.

2020-08-04T06:43:20+00:00

Albo

Roar Rookie


I'd have Burton at right centre or fullback now. He should be playing somewhere in that team.

2020-08-04T06:40:15+00:00

Albo

Roar Rookie


It would have been a good multi, Crispy ! Wish I had have thought of it back in September . Chiefs into the Panthers .... what odds, I wonder back then ?

2020-08-04T06:29:14+00:00

Chris.P.Bacon

Guest


I can certainly see the 'Albo Double' getting up mate! ;) Of all the teams I've watched recently your boys have looked the most impressive and are playing some very attractive footy - it's been a pleasure watching them Albo! (....let's hope they take the foot off the pedal when they play the Dogs though!)

AUTHOR

2020-08-04T06:10:28+00:00

Jack Aubrey

Roar Guru


We should have, we had plenty of possession and territory right down to the final siren but couldn't get it done. The Rabbitohs would have been too strong on Grand Final day, although I do think we would have made a better account of ourselves than the Bulldogs. The Roosters did slump mid last year, they lost a big game to the Knights mid season and looked pretty busted. History shows they found a way back and without Origin to navigate this year if they can get personnel back at the right time they know what to do in big games. It is really hard to see why Burton would stay when he undoubtedly would get a run at other clubs, and is getting zero game time at the Panthers. Tamou will be offered something, and he seems like the kind of guy to stay.

AUTHOR

2020-08-04T06:02:20+00:00

Jack Aubrey

Roar Guru


I think Penrith are really challenging the notions of youth and experience as ingredients for success in our game. They have fielded one of, if not the youngest teams in the League on plenty of occasions in recent seasons. Their spine has less games combined than Cameron Smith. It shows what a good development system can do, their youngsters get to first grade and look ready to handle it while other clubs have to blood players who just aren't ready yet. They have experience where necessary but they aren't afraid to put faith in their youth.

AUTHOR

2020-08-04T05:50:40+00:00

Jack Aubrey

Roar Guru


I think any club that gets a home final in week one should be able to host it wherever they wish. Manly having a home semi at Allianz is just ridiculous for everyone involved. However when it comes to a preliminary final I think they do need to consider fans in terms of the venue. The Panthers had a week off, they got double the crowd that they could have fit into Penrith, and they were playing a busted dogs side coming off a golden point win. It was may have been the Bulldogs home ground but they Panthers were well represented in the stands that night, and just weren't good enough to progress.

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar