Jarome Luai is Penrith's most important piece of the puzzle tonight

By Scott Pryde / Expert

If you’re looking for the most improved player in the NRL this year, the Panthers’ home qualifying final against the Roosters this evening will be must-watch television.

The minor premiers, who have won 15 straight to close the season and are closing in on the longest winning streak in NRL history, have been phenomenal right across the paddock this year.

There has barely been a bad moment. The only other teams who have won 15 straight this century are the Storm in 2012 and Sharks in 2016, and we all know how they ended: premierships.

Of course, the Bulldogs also did it (and made it to 18) in 2002, but that didn’t finish quite so well.

So when you start throwing numbers around like that, it’s clear to see why Penrith are building something special.

In fact, the only glaring weakness in their squad would appear to be a lack of big-game and finals experience, although that is somewhat thrown out by Nathan Cleary’s Origin run, Apisai Koroisau’s finals experience and other forwards like James Fisher-Harris, who has played representative footy.

(Photo by Mark Kolbe/Getty Images)

While all those players will potentially be a deciding factor in tonight’s qualifying final against the Roosters, it’s Jarome Luai who will look to continue his stellar season and buy his team a week off.

When looking for differences between the nearly-but-not-good-enough Panthers of 2019 and the minor premiers of 2020, there are two key determining factors.

One is Koroisau joining the pack of Penrith juniors to provide a shining light at hooker, and the other is the impact of Luai. It’s his game, replacing the departed James Maloney, which has inspired Penrith to new heights.

Sports opinion delivered daily 

   

Statistics don’t always tell the whole story, but they do tell a large chunk of it here. Luai has been absolutely everywhere for the Panthers.

While his fitness to play all 20 games without a break is something to be marvelled at, he has seven tries and 21 assists to be right at the top of the charts for try involvements, while he has 13 forced drop outs, 17 line break assists, 14 offloads and, for a half, a ridiculous average of 67 metres per game.

There are games this year when you look at his stat line and wonder if he was playing in the forwards. His 183 metres against the Sea Eagles in Round 12 takes the cake, but in half of all games he has cracked triple figures running the ball.

These are stats that just aren’t an everyday occurrence. Heck, they aren’t an every season occurrence anywhere in the competition. Luai has been special, but he has been able to sit in the background behind his more fancied teammates and simply do the job for the mountain men.

(Photo by Mark Kolbe/Getty Images)

His kicking game hasn’t been bad either, but it’s the ball running, passing and offloading that has allowed Nathan Cleary to soak up all the applause and credit as a very real likelihood of taking out the Dally M Medal when that is awarded in a few weeks prior to grand final day.

That is the part of the story Luai’s stats won’t tell. The control he plays with is beyond his years, and has improved players around him.

Sure, credit needs to go to coach Ivan Cleary, and the forwards who have all aimed up, but with Luai running the ball and constantly demanding defence, it has created time and space for Cleary to work with Koroisau and Dylan Edwards, who has also improved out of sight and could be a candidate for that award alongside Luai.

Compare that to the 2019 version of the Panthers, where Maloney and Cleary struggled enormously to work as a combination, and it stagnated the Panthers’ attack from start to finish, and it’s like chalk and cheese.

Interestingly, Luai’s style of footy could suit playing the Roosters even more than some other sides. His running and ability to break a game open when working with Koroisau and the forward pack could be pivotal in a game that may well be low-scoring given the defensive work of their opposition that is normally on display.

When they arrive at the foot of the mountains this evening, though, the Roosters will have an Everest-sized challenge on their plate.

(Photo by Cameron Spencer/Getty Images)

Not just Luai, but their forwards will have to aim up, their kicking game must be spectacular, and the combination of Freddy Lussick and Lachlan Lam will have to be better than it has been at any point this season.

The battle of the hookers looks as if it will be the single biggest difference between the two sides.

That is until you remember the Roosters had their doors blown out last week, conceding more points in a single game than any other team this season. Ironically, their demolition of the Broncos way back when sits second on that list.

Plenty has been made of that performance, and while the Roosters aren’t a mentally weak side, recovering from a performance like that takes any side time, no matter how good.

Qualifying finals are sometimes viewed as not important in comparison to elimination finals, but this year, that couldn’t be any further from the truth.

No bye rounds, fatigue and injuries are gripping the competition. The winner of this year’s grand final will win a qualifying final and secure a week off.

Having to play next week will simply be a recipe for a preliminary final knockout.

Don’t be surprised if, come the end of this evening’s game, Jarome Luai is a huge part of the reason why Penrith’s odds for the premiership are cut in half before the side can put their feet up next week and watch the teams they might face in Week 3 bash each other up for 80 minutes.

The finals are finally here.

The Crowd Says:

2020-10-02T08:20:06+00:00

Joey

Guest


Ben, they have re-written the history books for the last 7 weeks. Every win beyond 8 has been a club record, never been done before. There’s no historical reference for what they are doing, if you are trying to find the answer somewhere in the past. All you can do is look on and watch what kind of record they will finish with, ultimately a possibility if the greatest finish in 113 years.

2020-10-02T06:42:38+00:00

Ben Roberts

Roar Rookie


Yeah not saying it can’t happen, just saying they will have to make history (if they win tonight) to win the prem, just as the roosters will need to

2020-10-02T06:34:21+00:00

JOHN ALLAN

Guest


I backed Intergaze that day. I also followed the money trail and backed Fine Cotton aka Bold Personality at my local TAB. Could not understand why correct weight took so long after Gus Philpott steered it home.

2020-10-02T04:36:39+00:00

Albo

Roar Rookie


You never boo a champion. Although I did back Intergaze to beat the huge crowd favourite Octagonal in his last ever race, the Queen Elizabeth Stakes at Randwick back in 1997. I think I was the only one cheering at the time , but I didn't care if I spoilt that party . Winners are grinners and Intergaze was also my personal favourite horse at that time. :happy:

2020-10-02T04:07:18+00:00

egbert

Guest


As Phil Gould keeps saying, all those young guys have won everything going as they have come through. I'm not entirely sure that's relevant or applicable, but we'll see...

2020-10-02T04:05:58+00:00

egbert

Guest


Ah yes of course, thanks.

2020-10-02T04:05:36+00:00

Joey

Guest


Storm had a similar run to Penrith in 2011. Won 11 straight, rested players last two rounds. Lost both those games. Won the first final and straight into the prelim. Lost the prelim to the Warriors. Would show that most of the team was only playing their 2nd game in 5 weeks. Resting players is not always a great strategy. Panthers mostly chose not to this year. Mostly because Cleary coaches the Warriors that year and made notes after the prelim win.

2020-10-02T04:01:01+00:00

Joey

Guest


Tetevano has won a premiership too with the Roosters. Total of 57 finals games from the Panthers starting 17. Up against Roosters hooker with 4 games of NRL, and halfback with zero finals.

2020-10-02T03:56:52+00:00

DP Schaefer

Roar Rookie


No heads will drop. I'm no chook fan but I don't see them tossing the towel like last week, especially if J-Moz is on the field.

2020-10-02T03:47:39+00:00

jimmmy

Roar Rookie


I agree. There is enough experience in that Panthers side. Hopefully the younger guys don't get overawed. Chrighton, Naden and the FB need big games in D. I don't have any worries about Martin or Kickau or the pack in general. Best of luck.

2020-10-02T03:07:05+00:00

egbert

Guest


Penrith may well fall short this year but the whole lack of experience thing is a bit overblown, as suggested in this piece Have played GFs: Tamou, Koroisau Origin: Cleary, Mansour, Tamou, Test: Tamou, Mansour, Fisher-Harris, Luai, Kikau, Tetevano Capewell was around the Sharks squad that won in 2016 Not a patch on the Roosters, but could be worse.

2020-10-02T02:25:22+00:00

Mango Jack

Roar Guru


Just friendly banter, Joey. I'll be cheering for the panthers tonight, even from enemy territory (Bondi).

2020-10-02T02:08:44+00:00

Joey

Guest


Melted by the moon maybe ?? The nay- sayers are struggling. Did we cheer on Winx and Black Caviar, or did we boo them every race hoping they would lose?

2020-10-02T01:27:06+00:00

Gods Country

Guest


Great stats Ben . It’s almost as though they need a loss not far from the finals to ground them . The Panthers are gone I reckon, the “we win every time” mentality will be very influential I think .

2020-10-02T01:00:48+00:00

Ben Roberts

Roar Rookie


Melbourne’s 15 game win streak stretched into 2013, it was only 8 in 2012. Interestingly, Melbourne wining 10 straight in 2017 to win the title is one of the longest streaks I can find that stretch to grand final day. Going back to 1998, no team has come close to winning 18 straight to win the GF, and considering that the 4 teams since 1908 with streaks of 16+ all either had a loss before the final or had the streak stretch into the next year, it’s clear that the Panthers will have their own “no team has conceded 50 and won the premiership stat” if they win tonight. In fact, the most amount of consecutive wins to end a season is 13 (Souths in 1925, but there was no final series). Most amount of consecutive wins to win a GF is 12 (Souths in 1955 and Easts in 1935). Consecutive wins to win the GF in NRL Era: 2019 Roosters- 3 2018 Roosters- 4 2017 Storm- 10 2016 Sharks- 3 2015 Cowboys- 3 2014 Souths- 3 2013 Roosters- 4 2012 Storm- 8 2011 Manly- 3 2010 Dragons- 5 2009 Storm- 5 2008 Manly- 6 2007 Storm- 8 2006 Broncos- 3 2005 Tigers- 4 2004 Bulldogs- 3 2003 Panthers- 7 2002 Roosters- 9 2001 Knights- 5 2000 Broncos- 3 1999 Storm- 3 1998 Broncos- 3

2020-10-02T00:56:46+00:00

JOHN ALLAN

Guest


May be a low scoring arm wrestle and a battle of the two sides defence. Roosters to win 1 NIL with a Keary field goal in extra time. Would bring back memories of a similar score line years ago with Kenny Wilson doing likewise for Newtown. I recall a game finishing NIL ALL years ago as well, Am I correct or is old age setting in? Or perhaps both! The game has thankfully changed from the era of Warren Ryan inspired boreathons like the 4-2 GF.

2020-10-02T00:42:50+00:00

Adam

Roar Guru


I couldn't believe it either. I didn't realise it was for such a low amount

2020-10-02T00:38:36+00:00

Nat

Roar Rookie


Yep, he could support the young fellas in so many ways. I can't believe we let him go for $100k last time. 20/20 hindsight I guess.

2020-10-02T00:35:09+00:00

Big Daddy

Guest


I'm more concerned about referee appointments this weekend. Same old , same old. Chiddy and Maxwell get 2 matches each in the bunker and Cechin can't even get a run as linesman and poor old Badge has had enough and is hanging the whistle up.

2020-10-02T00:31:01+00:00

Stormy

Roar Rookie


Love it, Barry, & so true - sadly.

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar