A hard chat with each NRL team’s most frustrating player

By Dutski / Roar Guru

Okay. Grab a seat everyone.

Look, you know why you’re here. You’ve been nominated the most frustrating player for each of your respective clubs. Now I know some of you are looking around wondering why there aren’t more fringe first-graders here, but you all fit the bill of being potentially really good players if someone could straighten out a few things.

Well, today’s that day. Now to keep it really clear I’m going to use your full names, not nicknames. I’m not a referee, am I?

Right. We’ll do this alphabetical order by club. Let’s see…

Broncos
Yes, that’s you Anthony Milford. No, don’t go looking for Darius Boyd, he’s retired. Listen up. Four simple words for you: Run. With. The. Ball. Not so hard, is it? Now I want you to write that 50 times, then you can go.

Raiders
Hello Curtis Scott. Here’s a pencil. Can you draw a picture of a defensive line for me please? Okay, let me see. And why have you drawn one player way out in front? That’s you isn’t it? Try again and keep at it until you get yourself in a straight line with everyone else. Then you can work up to doing it in real life.

Bulldogs
Next! Listen up Dallin Watene-Zelezniak…you are a winger. Not a fullback. Not a centre. A winger. See these numbers? 2 and 5. You wear one of them and that’s it. And here’s the number for AJ Brimson’s sprint coach. Call him.

Sharks
Matt Moylan. Oh Moylan, Moylan, Moylan. Being the most talented kid in under-16s has got you so far but news flash for you mate. It’s not the under-16s and you’re not the only talented kid now. You need to work much, much harder or you can stretch your hamstrings on the plane to England.

(Brett Hemmings/Getty Images)

Titans
Righto. Taylor, Ash. You here? Look I know you’re coming off a pretty good season but now that your team has punted the other likely candidates they had to send someone. Keep doing what you’re doing, let Jamal Fogarty run the show and throw it to AJ Brimson. Oh, and give Kevin Proctor this “Friends Not Food” t-shirt for me. Thanks.

Sea Eagles
Thanks for coming Dylan Walker, and I’m not making any cracks about you because you’ll probably punch my lights out. Yes, we will keep it short. Now that Kieran Foran is back you can just run up and down the field as a centre. Better for everyone. Oh, you gotta go? Lawyer’s appointment? Sure.

Storm
The Storm have sent their captain, I see. Please Mr Smith, Cameron, if it’s not too much trouble, could you make a decision on your future? Thank you.

Knights
Mitchell Pearce, you look a pretty good first-grade halfback when you have a pretty good five-eighth outside you. Now you need to be able to play like a pretty good halfback even when you don’t have a pretty good five-eighth outside you. Too tricky? Okay, I’ll simplify it. Don’t drop your bundle.

Warriors
The Warriors have sent a new kid I see. Kane Evans. Uniform fitting okay? Nice. Hey, you’re a big lump of a lad. Why don’t you try running really hard at the other team? No, I mean every time. Not just once a game. Good luck to you over the ditch.

Cowboys
Great that you could join in via Zoom. Means you could send more than one rep. Let’s work through it one at a time. Scott Drinkwater – try to limit yourself to one brain snap a game.

Coen Hess – I can see you right now sitting on the edge not engaging. Try doing something other than that.

And Justin O’Neill, I want you try visualising that it’s 2016 and you’re an Origin and Australian-level centre. Latch on to that feeling and who knows, maybe some of it is still in there somewhere.

Eels
The Eels have sent you, Mitch Moses? Fair enough. Here’s a simple strategy for you. Stop arguing with the refs and concentrate on your own game.

(Photo by Matt King/Getty Images)

Panthers
It’s the Panthers’ turn now. Hello Tyrone May. You didn’t pick yourself to play centre in the big games instead of Brent Naden, so in some ways that wasn’t your fault. Hang on, I’m trying to find something constructive to say. This is really hard.

I mean you aren’t really a half or a centre or a second-rower. Oh dear. Maybe you should just sit there and work on your elbow strapping.

Rabbitohs
Step this way Dane Gagai. No, you can stop singing Yippee-yi-yi, thank you. Although that is what we need to talk about. You see, if you pretended you were playing for Queensland each time you played for the Rabbitohs, then you’d be an Origin-quality player even when you weren’t playing Origin. Maybe just chant “Queenslander” in your head. Silently please.

Dragons
Dragons, Dragons, Dragons. Oh dear. How did you choose? I mean I’m not surprised to see you here Corey Norman, but Ben Hunt might have been in with a shot. Or a Sims brother if you have any left at the club. Anyway. What we have here is a mismatch of expectations.

You’re paid like a star but play like, well, not a star. So just pay back 3/4 of your salary and then people will start to expect the kind of game we know you’ll produce. Problem solved.

Roosters
Right, time for the Roosters. Hello Mr Jared Waerea-Hargreaves. Please look at this diagram. Notice the two parts labeled ‘head’ and ‘body’. Point to the bit you are supposed to hit when you tackle. No. Try again. Sigh. Okay. Try again. That’s right. The body. Not the head. Can you say that? Body, not head. Well done.

Tigers
Lastly, the Wests Tigers. Not surprised to see you here, Joseph Leilua. The problem is, Joey…or is it BJ? I don’t know. The problem we’re confronted with is that you’re capable of absolutely anything on the footy field. I want you to try and just do half of absolutely anything. The good half. Not the bits that involve decapitation or the like.

Right gentlemen. I hope you’ve listened hard and maybe if things go well, we won’t need to have this little chat again at the end of next season.

The Crowd Says:

2020-11-29T17:36:18+00:00

Mr Right

Roar Rookie


Loved your comment on Dane Gagai. One of my mates is a Manly fan & says exactly the same thing about Chris Close back in the 80s. He categorised him as a fringe first grader putting in so many half-hearted performances for the Sea Eagles. But put that Qld jersey on his back & played at 110%.

2020-11-29T00:30:16+00:00

Heyou

Roar Rookie


Right on the money, literally and figuratively! It’s a pity corporal punishment has been outlawed. We will have to settle for a good talking to, and... a few detentions could be in order. Suspension for the very naughty children and expulsion is always on the cards. I hope they had their listening ears on. I’m most concerned about Mr Norman. He was awarded that great big scholarship but sadly he has not performed as expected. You hit the nail in n the head there...he needs an attitude adjustment because it takes more than coffee dates, weird hairstyles and gym workouts to make the grade. Suspension is the next step. He would have been expelled already but no other institution wants him at this stage. Ahh well... the new headmaster might have his number and could sort him right out so it may be a case of another year ANOTHER chance. He is a nice kid from most accounts we don’t want to be TOO hard on him. Thank you for your entertaining article regarding your assessment of these students. Remediation is required toot sweet lol Great Sunday morning reading: A+

AUTHOR

2020-11-28T21:25:07+00:00

Dutski

Roar Guru


Yeah. He’s one of the likely candidates the Titans punted, leaving poor Ash to front the meeting.

2020-11-28T19:56:31+00:00

Watda

Guest


Good stuff.....Bryce Cartwright was unlucky not too make this list?? He timed his club switch too perfection...

2020-11-28T02:10:47+00:00

Matt

Guest


NAS has really improved. Maybe advanced notice of this article got out?

2020-11-27T18:48:59+00:00

The Sporacle

Roar Rookie


Yeah I would pick Tom, its a dream team, guys I want to see run around. Also got Bert and Joey in the halfs, I realise Bert's getting on a bit and his combo with the 8th might take a while. Seriously I think Tom brings a bit more in terms of structured attack and fully fit would balance out my backline a bit better. Lucky its a sports opinion site :thumbup:

2020-11-27T11:34:34+00:00

Tom

Guest


Jorge 'feet for hands' Taufua deserves a mention for Manly.

2020-11-27T11:00:51+00:00

Eelsalmighty

Roar Rookie


"I’d pick Tom T before Teddy for my dream team." At centre or winger, yeah, but at FB????? Why, are you the Manly supporter, and was your "dream team" too strong with Teddy?

2020-11-27T10:11:02+00:00

Geoff from Bruce Stadium

Roar Rookie


They've all obviously got ability or they never would have made it this far. But they have their frailties. At their best they are either brilliant or very good - but at their worst they can also be terrible. Its the lack of consistency that upsets people. Supporters are very hard markers. I'd hate to under the microscope every week like all of these poor bastards are. Then again they are paid very well. Guess you could put up with all the rubbishing if you are getting a fat pay check every week.

AUTHOR

2020-11-27T09:53:59+00:00

Dutski

Roar Guru


That’s the thing with all these players - they aren’t bad players at all. The potential is there and that’s why they frustrate the hell out of us fans. Except Tyrone May. I couldn’t find anything positive to say there. I tried and there weren’t really any other Panthers that stood out.

2020-11-27T09:40:58+00:00

Geoff from Bruce Stadium

Roar Rookie


Its going to be fascinating to see how Curtis Scott goes next year - could be a great redemption story or sad miserable end to his career at the Raiders - hope for his sake that he can get his sh&t together BJ Leilua is a tough one - at his best he is sublime but at his worst you never want to see him again. I really wanted him to go again at the Raiders in 2020 after he worked so hard to come back from a horrible neck injury - but obviously Ricky had had enough.

2020-11-27T09:36:12+00:00

Geoff from Bruce Stadium

Roar Rookie


Needs to give up the pies, pizzas and donuts as well

AUTHOR

2020-11-27T09:35:41+00:00

Dutski

Roar Guru


No mate - Roosters for me. The Cowboys were tough to split, that’s all

2020-11-27T09:34:39+00:00

Geoff from Bruce Stadium

Roar Rookie


Brenko Lee, Suliasi Vinivalu and Nelson Asofa-Solomona can provide the odd howler - much to the enjoyment of opposition supporters - but they need to get more consistent if they want to make this list

2020-11-27T09:23:01+00:00

Busty McCracken

Roar Rookie


Cracking article mate. Well done. Stab in the dark here but since cowboys got 3 nominations im gonna go out on a limb and label you a cows fan?

AUTHOR

2020-11-27T07:40:08+00:00

Dutski

Roar Guru


I did think of putting Mbye in there but... Joey, you know?

2020-11-27T07:38:51+00:00

jimmmy

Roar Rookie


So true it would be a tragedy if we never see the best years of Turbo. He's outstanding and a nice guy as well.

AUTHOR

2020-11-27T06:35:14+00:00

Dutski

Roar Guru


Cheers and apologies for the mess!

2020-11-27T06:26:50+00:00

jimmmy

Roar Rookie


I reckon that could work with Moose. Don't touch the ball. Keep it simple. I disagree though that he thinks he is Wally Lewis. I reckon he secretly watches replays of Paul Gallen. Must be a serious man crush because he sure plays like him.

2020-11-27T06:18:07+00:00

The Sporacle

Roar Rookie


Off topic, if everyone's fit and they stay fit for the season, I'd pick Tom T before Teddy for my dream team. Its a cruel thing, I want to see him fully fit the same way I wanted one fully fit season at the end from GI, it would be a shame if we never see him fully fit again, he could be referred to as being "Papworthesque". Any way "Do your stretches Tom, Jake get away from the buffet....."

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar