How good are crowds, and how good is Darcy Moore

By Sports Bloke / Roar Pro

Welcome to my first Collingwood game review.

I am committing to this after each game, even if it’s while enduring rage and heartache. I will go off on tangents and you may even wonder if you are reading a game review.

Fortunately, my first is after a win against the Blues on Thursday night. I wanted to start last week but what I wrote down was what some would call a tantrum. But Round 2 was a game that warmed my heart.

How good are crowds? There is nothing quite like feeling raw emotion, the roar of goals and tackles, the boos after a questionable umpiring call, the shiver down your spine as chaos breaks into beautiful silence as tens of thousands of people collectively witness a moment of greatness, and just as that moment passes, the crowd lets out its most impressive noise, a symphony of minds all playing the same orchestra.

(Photo by Michael Dodge/AFL Media/Getty Images)

I don’t think there is an adequate English word that describes it, but if I were to try make one I guess, it would be unlonley.

Like many, I told myself last year that I loved the game, not the crowd. I watched and told myself I got the same out of a game.

I was lying to myself. The crowd matters. Thank God crowds are back. If you love your sport, do yourself a favour, get a ticket. The crowd must never die.

From a Pies point of view, it was great to see some intent from the word go. Collingwood’s back line is seriously good.

Darcy Moore can become the best back man in the AFL. If Moore plays more then 20 games this year, he will win Collingwood’s best and fairest. Finding somewhere to bet on it is on my to-do list.

Jeremy Howe is a marvel. I can watch the two of them take to the skies in defence like Goose and Maverick all night.

John Noble keeps getting better. Brayden Maynard is a bull. Isaac Quaynor seems to be a fitting addition. If Collingwood are at all good this year, it will be from that base and improvement in the team’s other lines.

Speaking of other lines, Jordan de Goey found a good mix, spending more time forward than Round 1. A day may come when he spends the majority of his time in the midfield but his ability to will a result in the forward line is something Collingwood don’t possess in another forward player. Collingwood need him there. I love his bursts in the middle but that’s what they should be.

Jack Crisp is Collingwood’s answer to losing Adam Treloar, and he is doing a fine job so far. He has done everything Treloar did in the middle but with a more defensive mind.

Instead of leaning more towards having a ping from 55 and ignoring leads, he leans more towards hard defensive running. It sounds perfect to me so far.

The Brown boys have ‘you know what’ in them. They are fantastic in the contest. As is Josh Daicos, whose development has been on a stunning path. When younger brother Nick comes in next year, Collingwood will be looking at four mainstays for the next decade.

Scott Pendlebury is the uncrowned king. He is robotically consistent. He has not lost a step. Some might say you can’t lose speed if you never had it. Pendlebury has never needed it. He continues to cast spells on his opponents, slowing down time as he glides around the field.

It wasn’t all great. Collingwood’s forward line is broken. Mason Cox is not getting better.

(Photo by Quinn Rooney/Getty Images)

Josh Thomas is absent and Will Hoskin-Elliott is good enough to produce eye-catching moments that keep him in the team to then play 90 per cent of game time with five touches.

Jamie Elliott, on the other hand, is a gun and the new rule could seriously suit his lead-up style. Here’s hoping that ankle isn’t too bad.

Oh, and one final thought: well done, AFL. That new rule looks to be a master stroke. It is opening up the game in a way no one would have thought it would. Genius.

The Crowd Says:

2021-04-05T04:49:44+00:00

Naughty's Headband

Roar Rookie


With my boys sitting on top of the ladder I will read it with relish!

AUTHOR

2021-04-05T00:25:58+00:00

Sports Bloke

Roar Pro


didn't have to wait long mate hahaha

AUTHOR

2021-03-31T08:01:53+00:00

Sports Bloke

Roar Pro


I did haha

AUTHOR

2021-03-31T08:00:54+00:00

Sports Bloke

Roar Pro


Thanks for the read mate. Love your point of view. Not wrong.

2021-03-28T15:06:56+00:00

John


Did you mean 'unlonely'?

2021-03-28T08:18:19+00:00

Maxy

Roar Rookie


Interested to read 80% of coaches surveyed would like to trade players NBA style,so I would trade Clurey and Marshall for Darcy Moore and future 2nd round pick

AUTHOR

2021-03-28T08:16:04+00:00

Sports Bloke

Roar Pro


Im definitely not kidding.

2021-03-28T05:39:57+00:00

Kevo

Roar Rookie


Crisp often does a crucial turnover per game. It is frustrating but he is a high possession player who takes a lot of risks and his intuitive plays often set up productive counter punches out of defence. I thought the writer summed up his importance, in regards to Treloar, on Thursday night quite well. Noble is getting plenty of the ball and creates good run, hopefully his disposal improves. He's still pretty new to this level of pressure. Adams, good as he is, often makes unforced errors. Even our 2 most elite midfielders Pendles and Sidey do the odd unforced turnover. DeGoey can be a bit blaise and unaware. Disposal is something the whole team needs to focus on imho. It can become infectious - both in a good way and a bad way. It usually has little to do with luck on the day, but doing the hard yards and dare I say it constantly drilling "the 1%ers" on the training track as a culture ala Richmond.

2021-03-28T04:26:41+00:00


It means being able to defend and contest when you dont have the ball (or are unable to score); the metaphor was suggested by the journalist who remarked that Collingwood did not break during the Carlton onslaught but were able to bend and absorb the pressure.

2021-03-28T01:32:40+00:00

Greg

Roar Rookie


Does anyone know what that means? Sounds like learned weasel words.

2021-03-27T20:58:08+00:00


Daicos seems to be gravitating to that role. Had some good moments when in the thick of things - has quick hands and body strength has improved.

2021-03-27T20:53:27+00:00


Buckley addeessed this in his post match comments. He said Collingwood was learning to bend when other teams had momentum.

2021-03-27T20:49:38+00:00


Cox has improved and is now finding ways to get more involved in the game. The big difference came from having DeGoey up forward which seemed to give Eliot a lease to be more attacking. As for Crisp and Noble I thought their ball use was poor - Crisp turned over two goals and one had Buckley almost smashing his phone (which was good to see after his paasiveness in the Coach's box last week). Noble repeatedly wasted possession. The one that impressed me was Quaynor. And you are spot on about Moore and Howe, they look dynamic and threatening. Teams will fear their ability to turn a forward entry into counterattack.

2021-03-27T14:48:58+00:00

JR

Guest


Are you kidding me ? Mason Cox is showing improvement

AUTHOR

2021-03-27T10:57:31+00:00

Sports Bloke

Roar Pro


Hahaha stay tuned. Can’t be far away.

2021-03-27T09:30:41+00:00

Naughty's Headband

Roar Rookie


Let’s hope so. A review of a Collingwood loss would be a pleasure to read!

AUTHOR

2021-03-27T08:32:26+00:00

Sports Bloke

Roar Pro


Haha read the start of the article again mate. Unashamedly had nothing good to say last week, but will try to post win or lose from here on out.

AUTHOR

2021-03-27T08:28:49+00:00

Sports Bloke

Roar Pro


Couldn’t agree more mate. He has inside mid written all over him. Thrives under pressure and body contact.

2021-03-27T07:25:51+00:00

Kevo

Roar Rookie


Agree Channon, the big difference between the 2 games from a Collingwood perspectiv was which team won first possession of the ball in each game.

2021-03-27T07:21:40+00:00

Kevo

Roar Rookie


I think it's more the momentum swings where Collingwood look a bit bi-polar. They kept momentum for most of the first half on Thursday. I know this impacts all teams but seems Pies have a big gap between playing well and then playing catch up. Often the momentum swings happen when Pies are full of running, looking great and then they make an unforced error and turn over, usually in the middle of the ground or near defensive goal. Pies in particular seem a confidence team. A team like Richmond are reasonably consistent in their body language, positive vibe, chemistry, synergy, digging deep in adversity, etc. Suppose it's easier when you're mostly winning. But young developing teams with their tails in the air can be exhilarating to watch and infectious with the positive vibe.

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar