An all-time Test XI with a twist

By Two Slips and a Gully / Roar Rookie

With the conclusion of the first World Test Championship and a brief respite before the next Test series between India and England commences on August 4, I have put together an all-time Test XI with a slight twist.

For this XI only one player from each nation can be used.

This will create some interesting balancing acts and of course a number of players that arguably should be selected will miss out when one of their countrymen gets selected.

Openers

Sir Jack Hobbs (England)
Test batting average 56.94
Regarded by many as the greatest batsman of all time, Hobbs is the leading run scorer and century maker in first class cricket with 61,760 runs and 199 centuries. Hobbs played 61 Tests for England as an opening batsman with an average of nearly 57 and 15 centuries, which is all the more impressive when you consider that he played on uncovered English pitches.

Sunil Gavaskar (India)
Test batting average 51.12
The plucky Indian opener was the first player to crack the 10,000-run barrier in Test cricket. With a career average over 50, it was against fast bowling that Gavaskar really shone. A career average of 65 against the might of the West Indies highlights the tenacity and sublime technique that allowed him to be very successful.

(PA Images via Getty Images)

Middle order

Sir Donald Bradman (Australia)
Test batting average 99.94
Not much needs to be said here. The Australian goliath of cricket stands head and shoulders above everyone else with his career average. The Don’s exploits are the stuff of legend, scoring a hundred every 2.7 innings throughout his career. When it comes to run-scoring records modern players have been battling it out for second place.

Kumar Sangakkara (Sri Lanka)
Test batting average 57.40
Starting his prolific career as a wicketkeeper, Sangakkara and his picturesque technique amassed over 12,000 Test runs. However it is post-2006 when he demands the most attention, averaging 64 as a specialist batsman, which is right up there with the very best of all time. He had an enormous appetite for runs, going past the double-century mark 11 times during his 15-year career.

Sir Garfield Sobers (West Indies)
Test batting average 57.78, Test bowling average 34.03
He is the greatest all-rounder in history. Some would argue his proficiency with bat, ball and fielding means he would take the mantle as best cricketer in history. Sobers held the record for highest individual score of 365* from 1958 until Brian Lara eclipsed it in 1994.

(Photo by S&G/PA Images via Getty Images)

Going along with his prolific run-scoring, Sobers was also an incredibly skilled bowler in both fast-medium bowling and wrist spin. Also a tremendous fielder, he certainly personifies the moniker all-rounder.

Shakib Al Hasan (Bangladesh)
Test batting average 39.70, Test bowling average 29.20
Long regarded as one of the best all-rounders in the world, Shakib has been one of the more consistent performers for Bangladesh. With nearly 4000 runs and 210 wickets in his career, his solid batting and left-arm orthodox spin make him a valuable addition to any team.

Wicketkeeper

Andy Flower (Zimbabwe)
Test batting average 51.54
Easily the best batsman to come from Zimbabwe, Flower helped give his struggling nation relevance on the international stage. At the peak of his powers he held the number one ranking for Test batsmen. He is the only Zimbabwean to be included in the ICC’s top 100 all-time batting rankings. At 31 he is equal with Steve Waugh and is ahead of Indian legend Rahul Dravid.

Bowlers

Rashid Khan (Afghanistan)
Test bowling average 22.35
It is only a small sample size for the Afghan spin maestro but there is no doubting his quality with four five-wicket hauls in his five matches. His short-form career has a much larger sample size where Khan’s bowling average is under 20 in both the ODI and T20 formats.

(Photo by Mark Brake – CA/Cricket Australia/Getty Images )

Sir Richard Hadlee (New Zealand)
Test bowling average 22.29
One of the finest bowlers in history and New Zealand’s greatest cricket export, the Kiwi firebrand was one of the most damaging bowlers and finished his career as the all-time leading wicket taker. Hadlee was also a talented batsman with an average of 27 and two Test hundreds to his name. Considered one of the best bowlers with the new ball, he was dubbed the ‘Sultan of Swing’.

Wasim Akram (Pakistan)
Test bowling average 23.62
Widely regarded as the best left-arm bowler in history, Akram was one of the great proponents of swing and reverse-swing bowling. Some 414 wickets at an average of 23 has Akram at the pointy end of the very best bowlers to play. With a quick arm action and his ability to hide the ball, he could do damage with the new ball and the old one. That will make him an invaluable part of the attack.

Wasim Akram (left) and Waqar Younis were a all-time great bowling duo for Pakistan in Test cricket. (Photo by Neal Simpson/EMPICS via Getty Images)

Dale Steyn (South Africa)
Test bowling average 22.95
Unquestionably the best modern fast bowler, his career numbers stack up against anyone from any era. A bowler with a seemingly endless arsenal, he had pace and bounce, the ability to swing the ball, the ability to use the seam and most importantly he had a serious mean streak to help him find an extra gear when he needed it.

His ability to pick up wickets on subcontinent pitches where so many fast bowlers struggle was tremendous. The only thing that stopped him from adding to his impressive 439 wickets was that his body started to let him down.

This is a very balanced side, with numerous spin options in Khan, Shakib and even Sobers, plus fast bowlers who not only can take wickets in all conditions but also hold their own with the bat. There is an incredibly talented batting line-up who have excelled in various conditions.

The ‘one from every country’ criteria allows for many permutations of this side and the beautiful thing about cricket is that it has such a rich history with plenty of superstars that could make this side.

The Crowd Says:

AUTHOR

2021-07-10T13:59:54+00:00

Two Slips and a Gully

Roar Rookie


There are actually 12 test playing nations :stoked: :thumbup:

2021-07-08T10:28:09+00:00

Renato CARINI

Roar Rookie


Smith's numbers are impressive aren't they. The point you made about his scoring rate is really an indicator of 'class'. I remember during the last Ashes series, the commentators were emphasising the English line of attack which was eighteen inches outside off stump, for Smith. Almost every time they pitched on middle, or off, he would flick them through midwicket for four. Essentially, Smith was forcing England to employ a defensive, containment plan. Amazing in light of what was happening at the other end/ You know, this morning I crunched the numbers for the Aussie top order for the first innings of this 2019 series (the 4 Tests Smith played): Smith 527-4 Peers 332-20 Probably won't see that again in my lifetime.

2021-07-08T07:54:30+00:00

Once Upon a Time on the Roar

Roar Guru


I've had fewer scoring opportunities today ... only advanced to 196 but I plan to reach 200 after dinner break.

2021-07-08T07:34:24+00:00

Once Upon a Time on the Roar

Roar Guru


One recurring theme in the book is the superior scoring rate of Trumper over his batting peers within his own team. I forget where, but somewhere else on the roar someone pointed out that Steve Smith’s test match strike rate of 55 runs per 100 balls is only 2 higher than the average of the rest of his batting peers in the Australian team over the duration of his career. I didn’t think anything of it at the time, but I just realised this includes Warner with a strike rate of 72 over 86 tests, but with an average of 13 less, Clarke who played almost half the length of Smith’s career thus far, same strike rate as Smith, but average 12 less, and Labuschagne, same strike rate with average of 2 less but only played 18 tests so far and all 5 tons have come on home soil. So I would hazard a guess that if one takes out Warner, Clarke and Labuschagne than Smith’s strike rate of 55 would be comfortably ahead of all remaining peers in the Australian team who also obviously average nowhere near him.

2021-07-08T00:26:40+00:00

Renato CARINI

Roar Rookie


It's an interesting thought experiment, Bernie.

2021-07-07T23:58:59+00:00

Once Upon a Time on the Roar

Roar Guru


I think anyone who reckons that Bradman transposed to the 1980s would have averaged significantly more than 50 against the West Indies is kidding themselves.

2021-07-07T23:26:54+00:00

Renato CARINI

Roar Rookie


Not sure about that, Bernie. Grimmett was shy and did not really have the personality to be captain, nor the desire. Ray Robinson, a very respected Australian journalist, documented an incident which happened in the dressing room during the SA vs Victoria match in 1936: http://static.espncricinfo.com/db/ARCHIVE/1930S/1936-37/AUS_LOCAL/SS/VIC_SOA_SS_13-17NOV1936.html Bradman came in at 2 for 27, with the Victorian fast bowler McCormick in the middle of a very hostile spell, lots of short stuff etc.. The Don looked ill at ease and complained to the Vic captain (Ebling) that McCormick was bowling bodyline. Ebling did not agree (there was no bodyline field just lots of bouncers) and the game continued. Bradman saw the fast bowler off. Much latter, with Bradman 190-odd, McCormick was due to take the new ball after a long rest and everybody was agog to see the confrontation. Apparently, Bradman took a wild slog at part-timer Ross Gregory and was caught in the outfield. At the time, many thought that Don deliberately threw his hand in order to avoid a second encounter with McCormick. A few minutes later in the SA dressing room, Grimmett made the mistake of saying aloud what everyone had been thinking. Bradman never forgave him and Grimmett never played for Australia again. 'Grum' continued to dominate the shield and was so obviously Australia's best bowler (together with O'Reilly) but he had played his last Test.

2021-07-07T23:03:45+00:00

Once Upon a Time on the Roar

Roar Guru


Maybe that's why Bradman wanted Grimmett gone from the scene?

2021-07-07T20:45:11+00:00

Renato CARINI

Roar Rookie


Captaincy usually went to the most senior player and there was always someone more senior: Darling, Noble and then Hill In his last Test, Victor was only 34. He did captain NSW for his last 4 seasons and he also captained Australia in a tour match, in Noble's absence.

2021-07-07T20:36:49+00:00

Renato CARINI

Roar Rookie


Hahaha :cricket: :cricket: :cricket:

2021-07-07T12:50:40+00:00

Once Upon a Time on the Roar

Roar Guru


And a century on debut for two slips and a gully ...

2021-07-07T12:40:09+00:00

Once Upon a Time on the Roar

Roar Guru


Hey, just a random question sprung on a tangent to your incredible research of a unique batsman: why did he never captain Australia? Was the idea of the best batsman being captain not in operation yet?

2021-07-07T10:59:39+00:00

Renato CARINI

Roar Rookie


Gee, thanks Bernie. I thought you'd finished reading for the day. Don't neglect your beautiful wife now!

2021-07-07T09:49:38+00:00

Once Upon a Time on the Roar

Roar Guru


Yeah, you’re right, chapters 7 and 8 are phenomenal. You’ve really put a lot of thought into how to build this Trumper innings. I’m up to page 128 now. First 50, I laboured, second 50 was more fluent, and since reaching 100 the innings has really flowed. I’m ready to pin my ears back now and floor the accelerator.

2021-07-07T07:53:43+00:00

Once Upon a Time on the Roar

Roar Guru


I don’t precisely understand every single aspect of every single table but I always get the general gist. And I am understanding the main attributes that made him special.

2021-07-07T07:47:53+00:00

Renato CARINI

Roar Rookie


Nice. Chapters 5-8 are my favourites. Have you been able to follow my methodology, sometimes it can seem obscure? But you are smarter than most :happy:

2021-07-07T06:55:43+00:00

Once Upon a Time on the Roar

Roar Guru


Up to page 72.

2021-07-06T01:07:43+00:00

sheek

Roar Guru


I'm just so impressed you found 11 test cricket nations!

2021-07-06T00:50:03+00:00

JGK

Roar Guru


We're all home! Lockdown and all. But if you just want to leave it, beside the front door is fine!

2021-07-06T00:34:59+00:00

Renato CARINI

Roar Rookie


Hi JGK. I am heading over this afternoon as I have a delivery in Brookvale. Any particular place I should leave your book, around the back?

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar