James Maloney has been denied a farewell premiership gift after his Catalans Dragons side went down to St Helens in the Super League grand final at Old Trafford on Sunday morning (AEST).
A two-time premiership winner with the Roosters (2013) and Sharks (2016) in the NRL, Maloney was hoping to win a third premiership medal and first outside of Australia, but his Dragons had to settle for a second-place finish in what was their first Super League Grand Final.
The French-based side had to play their entire season in England owing to COVID-19 travel restrictions, but nonetheless did well to finish the season as minor premiers and reach the Grand Final for the first time since entering the competition in 2006.
After last year’s Grand Final was played behind closed doors at KCOM Stadium in Hull, the decider was returned to Old Trafford, the home ground of EPL side Manchester United, with an attendance of 45,177 recorded.
The Dragons found St Helens a mountain too far to climb in the decider, losing 12-10 with former Wests Tigers centre Kevin Naiqama scoring two tries and winning the Harry Sunderland Trophy (the Super League’s equivalent of the Clive Churchill Medal) as best on ground.
He scored the only try of the first half as the Saints led 6-4 at half-time, with two penalty goals from Maloney keeping the Dragons in the hunt at the long interval.
Dragons forward Mike McMeeken scored ten minutes from the resumption to put his side in the lead, just before which Saints winger Tommy Makinson was sin-binned for a high shot on ex-Newcastle Knight Sione Mata’utia.
A second try to Naiqama followed by a conversion from Lachlan Coote saw the Saints reclaim the lead 12-10, which they would hold to the full-time siren.
Afterwards, Naiqama accepted his man-of-the-match award from former Leeds halfback Rob Burrow, who is currently battling motor neurone disease.
Kevin Naiqama was filled with emotion following St Helens’ Super League grand final win. (Photo by Lewis Storey/Getty Images)
While he will return to Australia for family reasons, he has indicated he is likely to retire but remains open to rejoining the NRL, where, apart from the Wests Tigers, he also represented the Newcastle Knights and Penrith Panthers.
Naiqama, Lachlan Coote, Tommy Makinson, Regan Grace, Jonny Lomax, Alex Walmsley, James Roby, Morgan Knowles, Louie McCarthy-Scarsbrook and Kyle Amor all backed up from their 2019 and 2020 premiership sides, each winning a third straight title with the Saints.
For Roby, it was his fifth premiership title with St Helens after also featuring in their 2006 and 2014 premiership sides, while Makinson, Amor, McCarthy-Scarsbrook, Walmsley and centre Mark Percival were also part of the latter side.
Percival could’ve also won a fourth premiership ring, but he missed most of last season due to a shoulder injury.
It was also Coote’s final game for St Helens before he switches to Hull ahead of the new Super League season, expected to start sometime in the middle of March next year.
By winning, the Saints became the joint-most successful side in Super League history with an eighth premiership, joining Leeds who also won that many with their most recent title coming in 2017.
They also joined the Rhinos as the only side in the competition’s history to win a hat-trick of titles, theirs coming between 2007-09.
In fact, since the Super League competition was formed in 1998, only four clubs – St Helens, Leeds (eight titles each), Wigan (five) and Bradford (three) – have won a premiership.
This contrasts with the National Rugby League, which has produced twelve different champions with only the Eels, Raiders, Titans and Warriors (of all active clubs) having not yet won a title since our competition was formed also in 1998.
Only the Titans have not yet contested an NRL Grand Final, coming closest in 2010 when they reached a preliminary final.
As for James Maloney, it was a heartbreaking end to a distinguished rugby league career which started at the Melbourne Storm in 2009 and saw him become one of the great journeymen, representing four clubs in the NRL and then the Dragons in the Super League.
MANCHESTER, ENGLAND – OCTOBER 09: James Maloney of Catalans Dragons is tackled by Agnatius Paasi and Louie McCarthy-Scarsbrook of St Helens during the Betfred Super League Grand Final match between Catalans Dragons and St Helens at Old Trafford on October 09, 2021 in Manchester, England. (Photo by Jan Kruger/Getty Images)
He joined the likes of Ivan Cleary, Brad Fittler, Matthew Bowen, Justin Hodges, Billy Slater and most recently Benji Marshall as those who came up agonizingly short of winning a title in their final game of rugby league as a professional player.
It was also his second Grand Final defeat as a player after being part of the New Zealand Warriors side that lost to the Manly-Warringah Sea Eagles in the NRL decider exactly a decade ago.
In between, as mentioned above, he was part of the Sydney Roosters side that triumphed under rookie coach Trent Robinson in 2013 while he also steered the Cronulla Sharks to their first title in 2016 before spending seasons 2018 and 2019 at the Penrith Panthers.
St Helens’ victory means that, as it stands, they will play NRL champions the Penrith Panthers in the World Club Challenge, but after this year’s edition (in which they would’ve faced the Melbourne Storm) failed to proceed, whether the 2022 edition does remains to be seen.
If the Panthers are sent overseas, this would mean, at best, a seven-day home quarantine upon their return to Australia, that’s provided all of their travelling party are fully vaccinated against COVID-19, or at worst two weeks in hotel quarantine, potentially impacting their pre-season.
Likewise, if the World Club Challenge is to be played in Australia, the Saints would have to quarantine for two weeks upon their entry into the country, and the match would either be played at one of BlueBet Stadium, the Panthers’ home ground, or even CommBank Stadium (formerly Bankwest Stadium) or Stadium Australia.
To finish off, congratulations to St Helens on becoming just the second side in Super League history to achieve a premiership hat-trick, and the joint-most successful side in the competition’s history; and commiserations to the Dragons, who did well to reach their first Grand Final despite having to play the majority of the season in Great Britain.
Cathar Treize
Roar Guru
you really are sick & only a loser has this much time to troll. New low level, a bloke dying of a disease & this is funny to you?
Kevin
Guest
I thought they ( dragons ) were stiff not to get the penalty try . As the foul stopped the try . Yellow was fair as it bounced of shoulder , but to suggest he doesn’t score if not for the tackle is wrong IMO .
Big T
Guest
Nat 45,000 is huge for RL over there. It's a great crowd
Nat
Roar Guru
Are you comparing RL to Football in Eng? At Old Trafford against Man Utd? 45k isn't enough, must be pretty sh.t hey? Keep up the good work.
Cathar Treize
Roar Guru
And what great projectionism from you because there are far more fans of other codes on RL threads attacking the sport on this site for example. You really do need to legitimise your attacks by lying as usual
Cathar Treize
Roar Guru
Word on the street from those there at the stadium is it was the correct figure. Since you're a union troll, it is very apt to ask you why the All Blacks struggled to half fill Eden Park?
Big T
Guest
Nat, Man Utd sell out each League game there. They wouldn't have had a crowd that low since the renovations to enlarge it decades ago
Nat
Roar Guru
It was hard to tell the way the crowd was seated. One end seemed far more loaded than the other and more up high than in the bottom tier. I wonder if it's the Old Trafford's Football members seats left empty? The same can happen at Suncorp.
Avatar
Roar Guru
Wrong - according to Wikipedia, its capacity is 74,140.
Cathar Treize
Roar Guru
Don't know, what was the excuse for a half empty Eden Park for the All Blacks or vast swathes of empty seats for the double header on the Gold Coast for the union internationals??
Tara
Guest
So old Trafford holds more then 90000,must of added some new stands since last weekend.
Avatar
Roar Guru
No idea, but apparently the UK has now completely opened up; i.e. no COVID-related restrictions whatsoever. The crowd of 45,177 is less than half of Old Trafford's total capacity.
Michael Carbone
Guest
Was the crowd Covid affected or was that infected?
Albo
Roar Rookie
I watched the match, and it was a pretty good contest. I thought St Helens was the better side overall and always looked likely to create more than the Catalan boys. But the Catalans were very brave and scrambled well in defence all night. Jimmy had a great game particularly in defence , but lacked the support around him to create much. In the end a couple of bits of class from Naiqama got the two tries to see St Helens home.
Redcap
Roar Guru
Hi Avatar, Oh well, there's still Toulouse tomorrow. By the way, Jimmy Maloney's not retiring just yet. He's playing with FC Lézignan in the Elite One comp next season. Sione Mataútia must be annoyed about copping a high tackle from one of his team mates ;)