He has grudges, grievances and pets, but how does Eddie Jones still have his job as England coach?

By Harry Jones / Expert

Subtract the Italy cakewalks and what does Eddie have? Nine wins in his last 26 Six Nations Tests. Only Italy have fared worse.

Whilst Ireland and France are at the adult table, with Scotland sliding their chair up sheepishly, England — with the most money, depth, and analytics — is relegated to the little kiddie’s table with Wales and Italy.

Once again, England have lost the Calcutta Cup and a Grand Slam chance in the first round.

The man most responsible for that loss is Eddie.

He yanked Marcus Smith off, up only seven points, failed to bring Jamie George on in time to throw into a 5m lineout, prepared for that scenario by nominating Joe Marler as his lineout quarterback, didn’t allow Elliot Daly to do the one thing — kick from way out — he can do very well, and forgot Henry Slade has a left boot for corner kicks (he’s done it for Exeter all year) so George Ford scuffed a 9m boot that didn’t even make the 22.

On first phase play, after a solid scrum, not far from points, Daly had no support and the game was gone. All of Edinburgh sang. The Princess bestowed the Cup. Eddie made excuses.

Coaching, a good coach, would have changed every single one of those outcomes.

You pull a form flyhalf because the game is already won or he has a niggle. Eddie has now said he lacked GPS data at Murrayfield. Did Smith look spent to the naked eye? Come on, mate. He was the peppiest player on the pitch.

Eddie now says he has a 4-part dialectic to decide replacements. I thought they were “finishers,” mate?

I fell asleep listening to the four parts of his flow chart, but I caught “momentum” in there.

What momentum did Smith lack? He’d scored all 17 of England’s points. If he had good service, he’d have had a shot at seven more in the first half.

Eddie Jones. (Photo by David Rogers/Getty Images)

Just admit you got it wrong, and not only in retrospect. At the moment, every sane observer asked “Why?”

Finn Russell took it personally. You’re up seven in my house with plenty of time to go and you bring in the night watchman? A custodian won’t do it. Finn unleashed tricks and presto: 17-17. Now what? Would you rather have hot Smith or cold Ford on in a tied Test?

Has Ford ever taken over a Test? He’s a good flyhalf, but not a star at international level. Finn was in one of his moods. Backfire.

There were other players Eddie could’ve pulled if he was watching the same match I was: Ben Youngs’ service was slow and off target.

All that good ball wasted with wobbly, high passes from the basis.

Did he ever pop up in promising spots on attack like the Scottish backup 9 did in the first half try?

Why has Eddie never, ever identified a second scrumhalf for England? He canned Danny Care ages ago, but honestly, if Care and Smith were on the pitch at 80 minutes with an attacking scrum in the middle of the pitch and England down 17-20, one feels they’d have given a red hot go at the win.

The way Eddie has managed Ford, only sliding him into the squad when Owen Farrell was out, did not give the Leicester man confidence.

Speaking of players Eddie has given the runaround, what of Jamie George? When has that man ever failed his country? So why was Marler taking a throw after the starting hooker gave up a penalty try? What part of the 4-pronged algorithm dictated the joker make the most vital throw of the match?

Scenarios are rehearsed by coaches. If not, players panic.

Whether to kick (for 20-20 with time to go and even a miss resulting in possession back at halfway) for poles or the corner is a coaching choice. So is the identity of the kicker. Ford barely scared the 22 line with his feeble effort.

In that locale, Scotland could put two men in the air without worrying the lifting pods could not repel a maul.

Slade could’ve got inside ten metres, and it would have been touch and go for the Scots.

Eddie has lived off his honeymoon Grand Slam and a semifinal over the All Blacks, never had a proper reckoning, coached league and lacrosse and corporate execs and swordplay, but has never copped it straight on the chin.

The closest he’s come is after the World Cup final: he says he should’ve started Marler and Farrell. Really? That’s 20 points?

Marcus Smith in action for England during a Guinness Six Nations match between Scotland and England at BT Murrayfield, on February 05, 2022, in Edinburgh, Scotland. (Photo by Ross MacDonald/SNS Group via Getty Images)

Farrell and Marler were last seen waving g’bye to Cheslin Kolbe as he started the party.

Eddie is a liability to English rugby now. He has grudges. He has grievances. He has pets.

He was dragged into starting Smith but diminishes him. He is still Farrelized. He has no backup plan for nine, even though that deficit was one of the key reasons he lost the final.

The midfield has no answers. 13 is at 12 and a fullback at 13 and the wings are centers. Manu will be the answer, until he’s hurt.

Joe Launchbury would’ve been a far better look at wet Murrayfield than two error-prone locks who prefer six.

He seems to have a crush on Tom Curry, preferring him at 8 over Alex Dombrandt for two years, only to prevaricate between Curry, Dombrandt, and Sam Simmonds in the most important moments of the game.

Eddie is a game late and an apology shy.

Luke Cowan-Dickie said he was sorry to England. Eddie says he has no regrets and would do it all the same.

Is he daring RFU to fire him?

The Crowd Says:

2022-05-26T12:23:58+00:00

Dale

Roar Rookie


I think the inconvenient reality for 'The greatest rugby tournament on earth' is that for Jones and the RFU it's kind of a sandpit for the WC, at least this time around. Certainly not an overriding priority: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sandbagging

2022-02-15T23:47:47+00:00

Nicholas Bishop

Expert


Take a look at the teams he picked in Australia, they were all the same players 18 months down the line.

2022-02-15T11:41:06+00:00

FunBus

Roar Rookie


He'll be a big boy when he grows up...

AUTHOR

2022-02-15T11:35:33+00:00

Harry Jones

Expert


Alfie looks like he has anvils in his pockets

2022-02-15T11:32:20+00:00

FunBus

Roar Rookie


Damn...

2022-02-15T11:30:05+00:00

FunBus

Roar Rookie


My worry would be the scrum (where England can't afford to be under-powered). I don't think Lawes is a heavy scrumming lock. Particularly, as they've stopped trying to bulk him up and seem content with him at '6' (he's always had trouble putting on weight). I prefer it the other way around with Itoje '4' and Lawes '6'. You need a 'Lawes' type player at '6' if you play Launchbury at lock. For all Joe's huge qualities, he's not a dominant lineout jumper - good, but not dominant. This lad Chessum is exciting. Just turned 21, 6 feet 7, 118kgs (can probably add another 5 kgs by RWC). Good enough to play across the backrow, and excellent at lineout. At the very least the like for like for Lawes at '6', and potentially the answer to England's locking 'problem.' Despite the scrum issue, I think for some games you can go with Itoje and Lawes and have a 'carrying' 6. They did OK against the ABs in the RWC SF. You wouldn't risk it against the Boks, France or Ireland though. If this Barbeary kid continues to develop, he could be a great option there, and there's no reason you can't play Simmonds there with Dombrandt at 8. Lots and lots of options, which creates selection dilemmas, and brings us full circle back to the question of...

2022-02-15T11:14:41+00:00

FunBus

Roar Rookie


Radwan is very quick. I would say on a par with LRZ. May and Hogg just behind, and Daly bringing up the rear.

2022-02-15T11:11:10+00:00

FunBus

Roar Rookie


Do you mean Randall? He started against Italy.

2022-02-15T11:10:38+00:00

FunBus

Roar Rookie


Absolutely. Quirke - Smith would be my starting combination now and for the RWC.

2022-02-15T11:10:06+00:00

FunBus

Roar Rookie


The Japan game in 2018. At halftime, apparently, Care was lucky Eddie wasn't armed. The rumour is Danny chirped back.

AUTHOR

2022-02-15T11:06:23+00:00

Harry Jones

Expert


Haha! Andre the Giant has been capped a Bok already. Sorry! He is definitely pushing to be in the SA squad for France in 2023. Added skills in England.

AUTHOR

2022-02-15T11:05:18+00:00

Harry Jones

Expert


Do you think if Launchbury and Lawes could play lock, Itoje (being a defensive juggernaut) could play 6 and then in the second half, England has max flexibility on subs, because Lawes or Itoje can play 6, or they both play lock and bring on a carrier 6?

2022-02-15T10:50:48+00:00

FunBus

Roar Rookie


Google is your friend. Eddie has won 3 out of 6 six nations.

2022-02-15T10:46:40+00:00

FunBus

Roar Rookie


Very happy with Itoje at 6 if we had Etzebeth and de Jager at lock - but we don't.

2022-02-15T10:44:49+00:00

FunBus

Roar Rookie


I agree that Eddie didn't sort out his scrum half options for the 2019 RWC. But, they are sorted now (whether by luck or judgement is another matter). His 'understudy' nines have got over 18 months to get themselves up to speed - about 20 tests. Tight, but reasonable. I thought they were no more than 'OK' against Italy. We'll know a lot more about Eddie's England after the next 3 games. Particularly, as it looks like Launchbury, Lawes, Tuilagi and possibly Underhill might be back. A back-five of Itoje, Launchbury, Lawes, Curry, Dombrandt would do for me against Wales. Good to see Faf back running around for Sale yesterday. By the way, do you know if the Harlequins centre Esterhuizen has got any English grandparents? Asking for a friend. :happy:

2022-02-14T21:04:36+00:00

Spew_81

Roar Rookie


It was more me making a comparison to Mitchell's antics in RWC 2003; in regards to Jones' current behavior. But can you imagine the b/s they spouted when Mitchell and Jones had meetings :laughing:

2022-02-14T09:57:56+00:00

Ken Catchpole's Other Leg

Roar Guru


Don’t think that you could blame Mitchell for Eddie’s antics, which were modus operandi way before that association.

AUTHOR

2022-02-14T01:52:30+00:00

Harry Jones

Expert


And it was good to see Itoje play 6 again, as he did all of 2017, and probably always should’ve.

AUTHOR

2022-02-14T00:16:01+00:00

Harry Jones

Expert


Spicy defence of Eddie! Never has a coach done less with more. The lack of a nine backup bit EJ in 2019’s biggest match, and how many caps do his understudy nines have now? Which one is the backup? Good win over Italy, FB.

AUTHOR

2022-02-14T00:02:51+00:00

Harry Jones

Expert


Pragmatically, yes. This seems correct!

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar