A grievance from the unrealistic attempt

By Peter Zitterschlager / Roar Guru

Unrealistic attempt here.

You know, I’ve got to be the most misunderstood aspect of Aussie rules.

I mean, the way umpires cruel me, you’d reckon they’d never seen a Buster Keaton film? That or half the stuff Gary Ablett did.

Yessiree, every time a player tries something a little lateral, the umps are all over me. They’ll blow their whistles with impunity, believing that even the most one-eyed fan isn’t going to raise an objection.

They’ll even shape smug expressions to make me feel preposterous – especially when I’m hatched by an ungainly tagger, who flew as though being catapulted, before plummeting capsized to the ground.

Yep, umpires have a real problem with conceptualising what I’m about. But if only they expanded their imaginations a little, you know? Or suspended their disbelief?

Hey, it works for moviegoers and Marvel studios, so why not the AFL?

I mean, every CGI film is chockers with superheroes pulling off unrealistic crap, so why not throw me a bone once in a while and embrace my stuff?

Doing so just once or twice a game would sure add some box-office-friendly green-screen effects to the spectacle, don’t you think?

(Photo by Daniel Kalisz/Getty Images)

It could even take the AFL from the ‘G to the cinema? And dare I say, Cannes!

Anyway, as frustrated as I am with the umps and the rules committee, my biggest beef is with the fans.

I mean, why aren’t the one-eyed ones up from their seats whenever I’m paid?

They do it for soft frees and umpiring howlers, but never me?

But yeah, you never hear a peep from the fans. Not a single boo.

Nothing from Joffa or Molly or Kenny Williams behind the goals.

Just once I’d like one of ‘em to holler, ‘unrealistic my arse!’ or, ‘we drafted that kid from Cirque du Soliel!’

But all you hear from ‘em is chuckles.

So yeah, it’s a tough gig being an unrealistic marking attempt. It’s little wonder I haven’t developed a complex.

But as much as a problem as it is for me, it’s more for the game.

Because right now, these rules only affect the specky … but they could one day metastasize and we’ll get unrealistic attempts to kick goals!

The Crowd Says:

2022-04-27T11:56:39+00:00

Doctor Rotcod

Roar Rookie


Does he know what is "unrealistic"?

2022-04-26T12:03:58+00:00

Chris M

Guest


An attempted mark is only found to be 'unrealistic' in hindsight. The player may have mistimed his attempt to mark by jumping too early or too late to even touch the ball or the player may have misjudged that the ball wasn't ever going to be within his reach at any time when he leapt. This futile attempt may have infringed on another player's ability to engage in the play or go back with the flight of the ball. It may have resulted in a free kick to the opposing player. If you are going to get a knee in the back of the head for being the sitting duck when someone attempts the unrealistic mark of the year, you would want to receive a free kick for the discomfort. Now if the player actually takes the mark of the year on the back of your head, the knee in the back of the head still sucks but you just have to suck it up because he took a specky. An attempt to kick a set shot at goal is also only unrealistic in hindsight if it falls short, but it usually only harms the attacking team attempting to increase its score. The only advantage to the attacking team when the attempt on goal falls short is when one of its players scores after the kick or the set shot routine is used to waste time at the end of a quarter or a game. Didn't Richmond's Jack Riewoldt tell the umpire during a shot on goal that he was going to kick a torp from outside 50 at the end of one of the quarters after the siren a few weeks ago? The umpire disbelievingly wished him good luck. The kick went through the big sticks. Only the beauty of hindsight helps us know what is realistic and what's not and sometimes we can be surprised.

2022-04-26T04:32:09+00:00

Papa Joe

Roar Rookie


Agree completely Peter. As one commentator said on the weekend "every goal of the year, started out as an unrealistic attempt".

AUTHOR

2022-04-26T04:23:28+00:00

Peter Zitterschlager

Roar Guru


Yes indeedy, Liam makes a hell of a case for expanding the parameters over what is realistic and what is not.

2022-04-26T02:23:37+00:00

Doctor Rotcod

Roar Rookie


Liam Ryan says hi. Hang time, four deep, vertical leap

2022-04-25T21:20:32+00:00

JudgeMental

Roar Rookie


Thank you :stoked: Wish I knew how to link the clip I was sent of Tom Hawkins accepting the Oscar.

Read more at The Roar