ANALYSIS: England are running on empty when it comes to steel-edged confidence and street snarl

By Mick Cleary / Expert

The back-heeled conversion by Barbarians lock George Kruis that went viral might as well have been a collective kick in the nuts for England such was the deflating psychological impact it had.

The team sank to its metaphorical knees as it conceded eight tries in a record 52-21 defeat prior to departure for Australia where, rumour has it, the locals are not slow to rub Pom noses in all sorts of nasty things should the opportunity arise.

Of course this was England’s second-string team with senior players still on Premiership duty.

But, let’s be straight. This was also France’s back-up side in Barbarian colours.

Kruis, in fact, was the only player in the Barbarians line-up to have won a match at Twickenham before. The conversion indignity matters because Kruis would not have even considered such flagrant mickey-taking (there are stronger terms) if the likes of a Martin Johnson or Lawrence Dallaglio had been in opposition ranks.

England’s Twickenham fortress was reduced to match-stick status.

England, in short, are running almost on empty when it comes to steel-edged confidence and street snarl.

Sure, their ranks have been massively bolstered for the first Test against Australia at the Optus Stadium in Perth by hard-nut acts such as Owen Farrell, Ellis Genge and Courtney Lawes.

But nothing is for certain anymore with this England squad following two pitifully feeble Six Nations campaigns.

In its own right, the Kruis coup de grace was no more than a bit of Sunday afternoon fun. In the context, though, of this flaky generation it was somehow the perfect symbol of an under-fire Eddie Jones regime.

Australia’s larrikin outcast is well used to copping flak. It’s been that way ever since he came onto the coaching scene in the late ’90s.

(Photo by Richard Heathcote/Getty Images)

He takes the hits and dishes them back out as he did so tellingly and entertainingly when first back on home soil with England in 2016.

His one-time Randwick mucker, Michael Cheika, didn’t stand a chance. It was 3-0 off the field and 3-0 on the field.

It is different this time. Very different.

There are no voices-off, no verbal skirmishes with Wallabies coach Dave Rennie, a down-to-earth Kiwi with issues of his own to resolve.

England are not coming off the back of a Grand Slam as they were in 2016. The Jones star dust has faded. He can talk the talk still but it doesn’t carry the same clout and he doesn’t have the same easy charisma.

Jones has been here before, his credentials questioned, his contractual arrangement with the RFU in need of the vote of confidence that came his way post another underwhelming Six Nations with losses to Scotland, Ireland and France.

Jones and England are in need of a massive pick-me-up ahead of the 12-month countdown to the 2023 Rugby World Cup in France. It is entirely possible that they will get one over the next three weekends given that the Wallabies themselves are in a state of the unknown.

(Photo by Ian Hitchcock/Getty Images)

Jones has been round the houses a few times, scrabbling and scheming with a World Cup on the horizon. He was very much on his backside four years ago in South Africa following five successive Test defeats (six losses if you include a pre-tour Baa-Baas fixture).

The first two Tests against the Springboks had been lost and it took an act of last-ditch creative genius from recalled Danny Cipriani to get them out of trouble for victory in the third Test in Cape Town.

A year later in Japan and England smashed Australia 40-16 in Oita and destroyed the All Blacks a week later in the World Cup semi-final.

There are such things then as rapid turnarounds in fortune. England cricket has just done likewise with a 3-0 clean sweep of Test champions New Zealand. That, though, involved a mindset revolution with the Baz and Ben (McCullum and Stokes) show proving to be a box office hit.

Jones, meanwhile, has only the same old voice and the same old tricks to play. England have a long way to climb.

And yet the Wallabies do not induce any fear. They are promising rather than proven. Their forward pack contains only one world-class operator in Michael Hooper.

(Photo by Daniel Pockett/Getty Images)

The days of an Australia eight stacking muscle in the form of a Phil Kearns or John Eales or Simon Poidevin are long gone.

They are a durable lot, though, Aussie forwards, aware of their place in the grand scheme of things.

A few of us once gathered around tighthead Al Baxter in London to grill him on how his Wallabies mates were going to be able to withstand the might of the England pack.

It could have been a tense exchange given that we were intent on questioning Australian manhood. Baxter was charm personified, never ducking a question, never shirking responsibility.

“This is great,” he said by way of explanation for his honesty and openness.

“A real novelty. Nobody ever wants to talk about scrummaging back home in Australia.”

Well, Rennie does. And mauling. And lineouts.

The Wallabies’ coach knows his team has to stack up in the forwards or they will be on the back foot at best, doomed to defeat (their ninth in a row against England) at worst.

Hence the bugle alert to so many Brumbies (seven in starting line-up, 12 in match-day 23).

Dan McKellar’s coaching expertise is also forward-directed. And he knows what he’ll get from the fairytale (very much a Grimms version) debut of the huge lump that is 33-year-old Cadeyrn Neville.

(Photo by Kai Schwoerer/Getty Images)

It’s shoulder to the wheel for Neville and front-rowers such as Allan Alaalatoa (in the potentially seminal absence of Taniela Tupou) and fellow debutant, one-time London Irish hooker, Dave Porecki.

Only if these boys do some sort of business against England’s eight will Quade Cooper and his pals get to show what they can do.

And, to be fair, the Wallabies’ back line carries more muscular threat than England’s, Joe Cokanasiga notwithstanding. England look vulnerable to midfield wallop.

Jones is well aware of the importance of results. Hence the recall of 35-year-old scrumhalf Danny Care. So, too, that of Billy Vunipola.

Likewise also the preference for Courtney Lawes as captain over Owen Farrell. Jones wants Farrell to be spitting feathers (as he is at being reduced to the ranks) and is desperate for him to focus on being the world-class player that he can be.

England are up against it. Jones’ credibility is on the line – again. There is a lot riding on this series.

Jones galvanised his team in Australia six years ago and they also got out of jail in South Africa in 2018 to tee up a terrific run to the World Cup final.

It will be fascinating to see if he can goad his players to significant heights yet again.

If he can, then it will make Houdini seem no more than a race-track hustler. Eddie’s great escape act? That’s the name of the game in Perth.

The Crowd Says:

2022-07-02T22:13:42+00:00

Fred Clark

Guest


Machooka. There you are! You used to chat with me in the SMH comments years ago. Glad to see your comments again. Fred from Dulwich Hill

2022-07-01T22:57:32+00:00

Double Agent

Guest


I've got one too Crow!! The Sleeping Machine. But like a dead Zombie that suddenly opens one eye he comes alive at walk times,breakfast time,lunch time and dinner time!! :laughing:

2022-07-01T22:49:56+00:00

Double Agent

Guest


"England can always win – more than enough ugly forwards to do a job on any team" Brilliant!!! :thumbup:

2022-07-01T22:39:28+00:00

Machooka

Roar Guru


'He won't give the bloody kicking tee away!' How can he? He's got no arms ffs! :silly:

2022-07-01T22:36:35+00:00

Machooka

Roar Guru


Mario Milano... and Killer Karl Kox :happy: Let alone 8 dwarfs in a caged ring at the old Sydney Stadium circa 69-71?? :shocked:

2022-07-01T22:31:43+00:00

Machooka

Roar Guru


Thanks Mick... as I sit I'm rubbing my hands together in anticipation!

2022-07-01T14:36:07+00:00

The Crow Flies Backwards

Roar Rookie


Mate, great memories! I have 2 adopted greyhounds as pets. Beautiful dogs. They are happy just to crash out

2022-07-01T13:33:25+00:00

Craig

Guest


WB’s scrum will be under the pump all day Will it though? Last time we played them we had a LH playing TH and a club journeyman called up to bolster our front row, and sure, Oz lost the game handsomely but I don't recall the scrum under any particular pressure.

2022-07-01T13:26:40+00:00

Derek Murray

Roar Rookie


This is a rational view of some hyperbole elsewhere. Billy V is in great form and is a worry. Itoje had a quiet game in the big final and may not be at his very best which is, admittedly, world-class. The front row are strong and 2/3 of this version gave Ireland all they asked for. Genge made life difficult for Furlongh twice (England and Leinster). Curry has been way off his best form but Lawes is consistently excellent. Care and Smith carve up good club sides but Danny isn't a top-class defender and both are small. Farrell has been terrific since coming back for Sarries but offers no running threat whatsoever. Marchant is a solid player, nothing more. Nowell works hard but Cokanasiga does not. Steward already looks destined for big things. Remarkably our bench is more experienced and better across the board. I'm nervous but cautiously optimistic. If we don't get steamrolled and are in it with 20 to go, we'll win it

2022-07-01T13:16:39+00:00

Derek Murray

Roar Rookie


Speak for yourself. I've forgotten more about everything than anybody

2022-07-01T13:04:15+00:00

Broken Shoulder

Roar Rookie


I lived in Shoreditch for 2 years and my dad is a Geordie so we all have our demons.

2022-07-01T12:56:27+00:00

Derek Murray

Roar Rookie


Imagine how I feel. Left Sydney's northern beaches for London. Can a man make worse life decisions?

2022-07-01T12:09:58+00:00

Waspie

Roar Rookie


I'm torn as an England supporter as what to take from two very poor 6Ns efforts. Was it a development period or was it a team and coach that appeared to have lost their way? The 2020 6Ns was rather impacted by Covid, but England went into it, without Manu (no surprise) but looked to play like it was still 2019. They won the 6Ns but little new. Autumn Cup 2020, France and Ireland especially, looked to experiment, England played their best side, only just beating an experimental France team, who looked to experiment further on their Australia tour. 2021 6Ns and it seemed like England hadn't registered the WR guidance on the breakdown and were comprehensively beaten at ruck time by Scotland at home and Wales and Ireland away - but bizarrely looked great vs France in their only decent performance. Finally some new players started to filter through....but 2022 6Ns, we couldn't decide what we were trying to do. Especially iro 8 and 9 and 12. Again dull picks, with England suggesting there was some sort of plan...if you squinted...lots...Performances might have papered over some cracks - but the most worrying game for me was vs Wales. Winning but looking so ineffective with the ball. So here we are - the biggest need is to win some games. England can always win - more than enough ugly forwards to do a job on any team - but it's a long way from being the bluntest team in the 6Ns to a team demonstrating a coherency needed to threaten a world cup win. Even with a great draw!

2022-07-01T12:07:26+00:00

Frank from Geebung

Roar Rookie


Thank goodness for the Roar. Not much coverage elsewhere.

2022-07-01T11:47:31+00:00

Broken Shoulder

Roar Rookie


Terrific to get your views from the other side of the pond, Mick. Eddie is always unpredictable so who knows which English team we will get. And with that, I say, go visit The Ministry of Silly Walks and take a hike.

2022-07-01T11:26:43+00:00

Nicholas Bishop

Expert


Good memory. You still at the Telegraph Mick?

2022-07-01T10:48:29+00:00

Just Nuisance

Roar Rookie


Fascinating rugby coming up . Can Aussies put the Jones curse to rest . Won’t lack motivation.. yes England low on confidence but high , very high on desperation . England know one good winning performance can put right so many negatives recent past . Yes just one solid 80 minutes . NZ tackle an Irish team that no longer will approach them with awe .. NZ look ripe for the pickings .. a disrupted preparation , uncertain selections and gameplans , the familiar supreme confidence strangely lacking .. Irish up against history but surely , surely they must fancy their chances . Boks just have to pitch up to beat Wales apparently . Champagne bottles already on ice .. yet .. nothing last few years between these two teams suggests that is going to be the case . If Wales can match the set piece , pressurize the nr 9 and 10 channel and with ball in hand go wide and do it fast .. But history also against them . Wales however have nothing to lose . Can play bold , brave rugby .. Not expected to win anyway .. Boks do not have that luxury . Argentina and Scotland a coin toss .. who wants it more ..? Could be some very interesting discussions here on Monday .

2022-07-01T10:35:21+00:00

SDHoneymonster

Guest


... people do realise Farrell has played against and tackled Kerevi before, right? That he has never finished on the winning side against England? He's an excellent player, but England have nullified him before. And the idea that Farrell - a man so hyper-aggressively, so combatively Northern it's almost painful - is going to panic at the thought of Kerevi coming at him is laughable.

2022-07-01T10:24:14+00:00

A.J. Woodgate

Roar Rookie


Yes England have had two sub-par six nations but that speaks to the standard in that competition recently. Gone are the days of the Tri-Nations being a quasi annual world cup. This year both France and Ireland beat NZ comprehensively (yes long season for NZ) with NZ looking completely at a loss in both tests. In the six nations England got a red against Ireland in the 2nd min and were trailing just 15-18 in the 72nd minute. They were also decent against France. How many times have the Wallabies had a poor trinations or rugby championship and gone north and won 3/4 tests. This England team is pretty dangerous. Not unbeatable but certainly not a soft team that will roll over

AUTHOR

2022-07-01T09:52:09+00:00

Mick Cleary

Expert


True Farrell has had to cede the captain's armband. He won't give the bloody kicking tee away !

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar