BRETT GEEVES: Is it just coincidence that Roos are biggest dog's breakfast in Aus sport since Sandpapergate?

By Brett Geeves / Expert

Football clubs, executives, nepotism, and conflicts of interest all walk hand in hand on their way to holy matrimony. It’s just how they roll. It’s like a Neighbours storyline.

But hey, it’s the modern world. Four entities entering the sacred agreement of marriage is the next step to America truly blowing itself up.

You’ve heard Luke Darcy call a Western Bulldogs game? Eddie McGuire? Conflicts “everywhere”. And of course, you’d remember former AFL Chairman, Mike Fitzpatrick, holding an enormous stake in the consortium that owned ANZ Stadium, that one in Sydney with the horrendous sand bunker of a surface, yet hosted marquee fixtures, denying the Swans access to their own home patch for their most important games of the year.

Side dollars are important for all of us. Consortiums as a side offering are for the freemasons and other secret societies that we public school kids would sell our souls for.

The North Melbourne Football Club, as it stands, is not just the king of wishful thinking – thanks Go South, um, I mean West, geez, the last thing North need right now is Eddie McGuire’s agenda to push North Melbourne deep south into two head territory – but it is currently holding the title of kings of all things conflicting interest and wild acts of silo leadership.

The recent leaks to the media of its coterie group leader, Adrian Kinderis, a Kangaroos benefactor, and member of the Shinboners Club, calling for CEO Ben Amarfio and President Sonja Hood to immediately resign, is a level of juicy you rarely see in the modern day.

Leaked information at this level screams bad culture.

You know what else screams bad culture – your list manager, recruitment manager and national recruitment officer all resigning on the same day, which happened to be one week before the mid-season draft.

Yikes.

Oh, and more conflicting interest, it was reported by Sam Edmund that Football Director, Anthony Stevens, went rogue and appointed Geoff Walsh to review the football department, without approval from the CEO, and to top it off, Geoff Walsh is a director on the board of the Coaches Association, the very entity responsible for protecting coaches from this type of invasion and disrespect.

And what happened to Paul Roos as the consultant? He started in the coaching box, helped with post-match reviews, and is now consulting from somewhere in California?

Are these people for real!!??

But it was a quote from Leigh Mathews that had me thinking about North Melbourne’s leaders and whether we should actually be surprised by the level of misery we are seeing play out across all aspects of their business.

“When I look at the North Melbourne hierarchy from chairman down – it looks a bit to me like the blind leading the blind,” Matthews told Sportsday.

“You’ve got the chairman of the board, who’s only been around the board and the footy world a little bit at that level, never at club level in other words, never at an executive level.

“Ben Amarfio, who’s been there for a year or two, but didn’t come out of a football background.

“Who’s got credibility to be making decisions on a way a football club, particularly a football department of a football club, should be run?

You might remember that in 2018 Amarfio was one of the first executive leaders to be dismissed from Cricket Australia as a result of the Longstaff Review, which took a deep dive into the culture of cricket in the country in the aftermath of the sandpaper gate scandal.

David Noble, Senior Coach of the Kangaroos and CEO, Ben Amarfio share a laugh during a North Melbourne Kangaroos AFL Media Opportunity at Arden Street. (Photo by Darrian Traynor/Getty Images)

I’ll throw to Joe Aston, Financial Review, who wrote brilliantly of CA’s culture in 2018, with a particular focus on Ben Amarfio’s struggles with culture and managing conflicts of interest.

“Then there’s another CA executive, Ben Amarfio, who earned the moniker “Johnny Rivers” in 2016 when he was busted moonlighting as a Secret Agent Man for sports commentator James Brayshaw. That’s right, the executive managing cricket’s $120 million per year broadcast partnerships was approaching broadcasters “pitching the services of a mate”

“The broadcasters were appalled and unsurprised. This kind of behaviour from Amarfio was already fabled. Most mornings, in full view of his speechless colleagues at Jolimont, he had his secretary cook and serve him a hot breakfast in his glass-encased office. “Where’s the Worcestershire sauce?!” he famously thundered. What else would you expect from Eddie McGuire’s former sales director at Triple M’s Hot Breakfast?”

You should read the full piece. It is a masterclass in research, humour and delivery.

That’s right, such was the strength of friendship between Ben Amarfio and the former chairman of the North Melbourne Football Club, James Brayshaw, Amarfio was willing to leap all professional boundaries to help his mate find his next gig.  

I know what you are thinking.

Was the job-hunting favour returned by the former chairman when North Melbourne appointed Amarfio as CEO?

Nice coincidence, hey.

But perhaps more important is the fact that after years of poor performance and a whole host of cultural in-fighting, the North Melbourne recruitment panel responsible for recruiting the new CEO, clearly didn’t read any Joe Aston, or Peter Lalor, or Gideon Haigh, in the aftermath of the Cricket Australia executive staff cleanout.

Even AAP got in on the act of nailing Ben Amarfio to the wall.

“AAP understands the exit of Amarfio, CA’s general manager of broadcasting, digital media and commercial, was more messy. 

“Head of security Sean Carroll, a former Victorian police detective who oversees CA’s anti-corruption program and ensures players are safe while on tour around the world, was summoned to help evict Amarfio. 

“The scene unfolded in front of shocked staff.”

AAP continues…

“Much of The Ethics Centre’s report focused on Australia’s men’s team but it also highlighted a corporate culture that “privileges combativeness over collaboration”, noting “a lack of emotional maturity … is also seen among CA staff”.

Is it just coincidence that North Melbourne are in this mess?

I’ll let you decide.

var request = new XMLHttpRequest();

request.open('POST', '/wp-admin/admin-ajax.php', true); request.setRequestHeader('Content-Type', 'application/x-www-form-urlencoded;'); request.onload = function () { if (this.status >= 200 && this.status

The Crowd Says:

2022-07-08T08:32:01+00:00

Charlie Keegan

Roar Guru


I mean attributing anything to one man at norf is reductive they’re just experiencing the problem of nearly a decade of mismanagement

2022-07-08T08:31:07+00:00

Charlie Keegan

Roar Guru


Blue writing under your name means you do it for love of the game, red means you’re paid or at least that’s how I think it works haha

2022-07-08T08:30:13+00:00

Charlie Keegan

Roar Guru


Launceston Llamas

2022-07-08T07:03:16+00:00

Tony Harper

Editor


Glad you like his work. He does get paid to write for The Roar. All of our editors and experts do. Thanks for your support!

2022-07-08T00:54:22+00:00

Pumping Dougie

Roar Guru


Wouldn't they need to be renamed South?

2022-07-07T23:54:48+00:00

RT

Roar Rookie


As Hutchy said, Caro is the star of FC. She's always been one of Richmond's biggest critics when they were down and recently with some of their off field stuff so your comment surprises me. Look at McGuire if you want to find anyone on FC who can't be objective about their team. Regardless I understand your point, but I don't think getting rid of any of those presenters will be a ratings bonanza (and FC would go backwards big time). The only one I would like to avoid is Carey, but it's hard to escape him when he is part of the Channel 7 broadcast. I am not going to miss the footy because of him. Most people would choose love over their mate, don't kid yourself otherwise. It clearly wasn't just a fling, which would be a different story.

2022-07-07T23:39:27+00:00

G money

Roar Rookie


Fair, but I'm sure glad you're not my mate

2022-07-07T23:27:39+00:00

Pumping Dougie

Roar Guru


My point about Caro was purely that she is unpopular and grates on many viewers. I rarely watch Footy Classified any more, because her approach is to constantly criticise and present speculation as fact, without regard for the people she is dissing. Sometimes she is correct, sometimes she's not. She's totally one-eyed and incapable of objectivity when it comes to discussing Richmond. Regarding Lyon, sure, Billy was split from his wife - but Billy and Lyon were extremely close, yet Lyon made a decision to date Billy's ex, despite knowing Billy was still emotionally strongly attached and knowing it would disintegrate their mateship. If they were just colleagues, I'd have no issue. But this tells you what sort of selfish, uncaring 'mate' Garry is and how much he values his mates, to explore a relationship with the love of Billy's life, knowing the impact it would have. The point I'm making on all three (Lyon, Caro and Carey) is they are highly unpopular with a sizeable section of the public, which reduces the audiences and therefore reduces the potential revenue from these shows. So on a commercial basis, their employers would reap better financial rewards if they found alternative presenters.

2022-07-07T23:16:23+00:00

Ado Potato

Roar Rookie


:laughing:

2022-07-07T23:12:20+00:00

Ado Potato

Roar Rookie


Why isn't BG writing for the ABC or The Age (and being paid)? Beyond his blokey, story telling humour is an insightful, analytical mind and a gift for language.

2022-07-07T22:39:43+00:00

RT

Roar Rookie


I'm not condoning anything, but it's none of our business and no one else would lose their job over something like that, except maybe a parishiner. Everyone involved was single. I am not privy to their personal circumstances (how things ended etc) and don't want to be, but you are saying that Brownless's ex is only allowed to fall in love with he approves of.

2022-07-07T22:04:16+00:00

G money

Roar Rookie


You obviously aren't a good friend if you condone that lol

2022-07-07T22:00:56+00:00

RT

Roar Rookie


Grow up

2022-07-07T20:48:19+00:00

G money

Roar Rookie


That's shocking if true!!

2022-07-07T20:47:36+00:00

G money

Roar Rookie


He broke a sacred code.

2022-07-07T13:42:36+00:00

Rusty

Guest


And didn’t I read some 70 resignations at my NMFC since Amarfio in charge? He has to go.

2022-07-07T10:01:31+00:00

RT

Roar Rookie


I think it's unwarranted because it's their personal lives, Billy's ex wasn't his property and they were, I recall separated or divorced at the time; not that I would be too happy if it happened to me, but if I had a colleague who did that, he wouldn't be sacked. That aside, it's a good point that there will be a proportion of the population that will switch off. I'm not sure what Caro had to do with this, but Lyon's behaviour is nothing like Carey's domestic violence.

2022-07-07T04:13:29+00:00

Pumping Dougie

Roar Guru


I think a sizeable portion of the public are put-off by Lyon's personality and past actions (same with Carey, Caroline Wilson and previously Hutcho before he turned his performances around). Lyon is an excellent football show host and presenter, but his past disregard for his friendship with a best mate that he was thick as thieves with, and Carey's similar past action and violence toward women, personally puts me off their shows. For example I'll still watch On the Couch, because it is a great show (Jonathan Brown and Nick Riewoldt are brilliant analysts and likeable people), but I don't listen to Lyon and Watson on SEN Radio in the mornings any more. I understand you will think this is an unwarranted reaction, but the commercial reality is that a portion of the public will think the same way as me and act accordingly with their preferences; so some of these shows are losing audiences because of the presenters they persist with (which presumably means they are compromising their revenue making ability).

2022-07-07T00:20:59+00:00

RT

Roar Rookie


Garry Lyon should have lost his job for that? Seriously?

2022-07-06T23:00:56+00:00

Charlie Keegan

Roar Guru


They could condition a support package on north moving to Tassie let the fans deal with jt

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar