Warner set to be big winner with leadership ban overturned as BBL fights to remain relevant

By Paul Suttor / Expert

It’s always been looked down upon by many Australian cricket fans but the Big Bash League is in danger of fading into irrelevance.

Not quite as much as the domestic 50-over competition which is now played on suburban grounds in front of meagre amounts of fans (you couldn’t call them crowds) but the BBL is quickly approaching a moment of truth.

With the South Africans pulling out of January’s three-match ODI leg of their tour this summer to ensure their players are available for their own fledgling T20 league, Australia’s red-ball players will be able to bring some much-needed star power to the BBL after the SCG Test ends on January 8.

But the fast bowling triumvirate of Patrick Cummins, Josh Hazlewood and Mitchell Starc won’t want to be adding to their workload in the middle of a busy international schedule.

The likes of Travis Head, Marnus Labuschagne, Usman Khawaja, Cameron Green, Nathan Lyon and Alex Carey will be welcome additions to BBL franchises but probably won’t move the needle too much for a competition in desperate need to boost attendances and TV ratings.

After the controversial decision to ban Steve Smith from playing in the BBL following the COVID-enforced cancellation of the New Zealand ODI series, the Test vice-captain turning out for the Sydney Sixers would be enormous.

David Warner. (Photo by Matt King/Getty Images)

But the biggest name in the Test team who can make a difference for the BBL is David Warner, but he is still no guarantee of suiting up for the Sydney Thunder.

Warner is not often given credit for being a particularly deep thinker off the cricket field but the veteran opener is wisely saying and doing nothing publicly while Cricket Australia sweats it out.

At the very least Warner is set to be given a massive sign-on fee to ensure he spends his precious few spare weeks in a BBL uniform rather than take up a lucrative offer to play in the latest cash cow on the Twenty20 global circuit, the International League T20 in the United Arab Emirates. 

UAE’s start-up, which runs from January 6-February 12 in direct competition with the BBL and South Africa’s T20 competition, has tried to entice many of Australia’s centrally contracted players with huge offers.

Chris Lynn is the Brisbane Heat’s marquee man, but he’s underperforming. (Photo: Ian Hitchcock/Getty Images)

Anyone with a central contract would have to request a “no objection certificate” from CA but that doesn’t apply to the likes of power hitters Chris Lynn and IPL star Tim David.

Lynn, who parted ways with the Brisbane Heat a few months ago, was the only Australian announced earlier this week by UAE’s ILT20 among a list headlined by franchise globetrotters Alex Hales, Colin Munro, Moeen Ali and Andre Russell, and Sri Lankan all-rounder Wanindu Hasaranga.

The MI Emirates side, owned by the Mumbai Indians IPL franchise, announced on Friday that they had signed up Windies stars Dwayne Bravo, Nicholas Pooran and Andre Fletcher and, concerningly for New Zealand cricket, veteran seamer Trent Boult, who has opted out of his national contract.

The UAE tournament, a privately owned enterprise with six franchises funded in large part by Indian investors, did not have many other big names in its list of 33 recruits so perhaps it won’t cause the BBL too many headaches this time around.

For Warner, there is not just a financial incentive to stick solid with the BBL. There is a chance he may have his lifetime leadership ban removed by CA so he could be the Thunder’s skipper.

This will no doubt be a touchy subject if CA officials were to allow him to return to a captaincy role after the ball-tampering scandal at Cape Town in 2018.

Although he has been accused of being the catalyst for the sandpaper scheme which also landed Cameron Bancroft and Steve Smith in major strife, Warner has paid a heavy price for his actions.

There will probably be an outcry from non-cricket followers if he’s allowed to resume a leadership role, the type of people who love to be outraged for the sake of it.

Aaron Finch (Photo by Alex Davidson/Getty Images)

Despite uncertainty over opening partner Aaron Finch’s form in Australia’s white-ball teams, it’s highly unlikely the national selectors would hand Warner the captaincy as he is turning 36 in October and they’d be much more inclined to hand the reins to a younger option.

So there would be little harm in letting Warner call the shots at BBL level with the Thunder, particularly if it helps drive interest in the actual cricket being played on the field.

It was concerning recently that CA willingly played along with what could only be seen as a publicity stunt when Pavel Florin, the 43-year-old European Cricket League bowler nominated for the BBL Draft.

Clearly he was never going to be selected by a franchise but is the BBL that desperate for attention that it needs to sink to these depths? Apparently so.

The BBL has much bigger concerns as it fights not only for eyeballs in the Australian sporting market and to keep up with the other domestic leagues in Pakistan, England, the West Indies, Bangladesh and now South Africa to be the best tournament outside the IPL colossus which towers over all domestic rivals and is starting to do likewise to the international game.

CA needs to generate greater revenue, whether through private investment or other means, because professional cricketers will follow the money and if the salaries available in the BBL can’t compete with rival tournaments, you cannot blame them for taking their talents elsewhere.

The length of the BBL season, which will run from December 13 to February 4, is also a drawback for the international guns for hire who can earn more in less time at other locations. 

There are only 12 days in the 2022-23 draw where double-headers are being played. 

It would devalue the product’s asking price for the next TV rights deal if matches were played simultaneously but more double-headers and even three matches in one day on weekends should be factored into future schedules as much as possible to condense the season into fewer weeks.

Channel Seven has initiated legal action against CA to break its existing $450 million contract and claim damages because it claims the BBL is not up to the quality forecast when the deal was signed in 2019.

The BBL’s success, or lack of it, this summer will have far-reaching ramifications so throwing a few hundred thousand dollars at Warner to get him clearing pickets for the Thunder could be money well spent.

The Crowd Says:

2022-08-15T03:22:00+00:00

jameswm

Roar Guru


Nice line - "There will probably be an outcry from non-cricket followers if he’s allowed to resume a leadership role, the type of people who love to be outraged for the sake of it".

2022-08-14T08:22:12+00:00

Brainstrust

Roar Rookie


Warner skips the BBL for how many years, and they do this to bring him back in. What next instead of the power play they have the Bunnings special rub where they give the captain a go at the ball for 30 seconds with sandpaper once a game.

2022-08-14T07:38:16+00:00

Marty

Roar Rookie


Given CAs desperation to manufacture interest in this absolute stinker of a competition it wouldn’t surprise me in the slightest if they gave Warner the captaincy.

2022-08-14T06:40:15+00:00

Big Daddy

Roar Rookie


Candace must have had a word to the board .

2022-08-14T02:08:34+00:00

Marcus

Guest


Personally I think the ban was an ver reaction, so happy to see Warner lead again. CA is going to have real issues now. They should have locked the key players into long term deals, rather than the one year contracts they currently do. I have no problem with a non contracted player like Lynn doing as he pleases. But the likes of Warner who accept the $2m plus base should not be allowed to play elsewhere and should be made to play BBL. Again something that would have been better with 5 year contracts.

2022-08-13T14:01:36+00:00

Jeff

Roar Rookie


Haha. Yes. Had my share of poor quality feeds in Cape Town. As well as some good stuff. Love CT, but always looking over one's shoulder as a visitor. But have also hired a car and driven through the remoter parts of the Western Cape and one can certainly get some A-class quality meat-based meals away from the likes of CT, Stellenbosch/Franschhoek etc. South Africa is so much like Argentina - the meat diet is crazy! But oh so yummy!

2022-08-13T13:30:46+00:00

Just Nuisance

Roar Rookie


You tourists are so naive . Wanna decent steak , go hinter I tell you . I recommend Bakkies ( the Butcher , kid you not it’s real ) Botha’s spot in Pretoria. Real beef . :laughing: and for lamb it’s gotta be Karoo . The sheep feed on a herb exclusively found in that semi desert region . Won’t find that in a Capetown restaurant.

2022-08-13T13:25:14+00:00

Jeff

Roar Rookie


Like an uber-expensive, poor-quality cut of tenderloin at a Camps Bay restaurant :shocked:

2022-08-13T12:45:47+00:00

Just Nuisance

Roar Rookie


Oh and over reliance on metaphors ( mixed like a cheap cocktail ) is my thing . :happy:

2022-08-13T11:42:09+00:00

Jeff

Roar Rookie


Hello JN (my favourite SA contributor!) Look, personally I don't have strong views either way re Warner and his ban. It's more so CA's pin-ball approach to governance and management (in this case, CA is the ball and the pin-ball game is being played on a double-level pinball machine, where CA is susceptible to slipping down the sides without reliance on the side plungers to belt its ball back into play - phew! [Over-reliance on metaphors there with no real gain]). It's just that CA is all over the shop re strategy and consistency. It's a history that just keeps repeating. And from my perspective, I don't mind fiddling with the ball in order to add some variability to the match strategy; it adds an interesting dimension to the game; as has always been the case re shining the bejeebus out of the ball on pants. I don't like bottle tops and the like - and I guess sandpaper is bordering on the edge there - but the sandpaper undertaking, whilst worthwhile of a sanction, shouldn't have been a hanging offence. Just want CA to grow a set and stand for something, on a consistent basis. Now, if CA *is* to admit it overreacted, then it needs to come out and say so. And be very clear on why it's retracting its previous stance (actually probably pretty easy as they can refer to both previous Board and executive, which have since changed. Corporate management 101 - blame the previous exec, without actually blaming them, but provide sufficient distance to be seen as being a fresh start.).

2022-08-13T10:15:40+00:00

Just Nuisance

Roar Rookie


Hi Jeff , the big issue here is not whether Warner deserved sanction. He absolutely did . It’s whether the lifetime ban itself was not administered in the vortex of public emotion even I dare say hysteria at the time and was served not in the cold light of Lady Justice but pandering to popular opinion . Possibly a way out would be for CA to admit it overreacted and that the bans were probably not reflective of the severity of their actions . Ball tampering is not cool but certainly not on a par with say match fixing and the ICC guidelines for sanction of either appropriately reflect that . I don’t particularly like Dave Warner but sheer decency tells me his punishment is done .

2022-08-13T07:26:03+00:00

Jeff

Roar Rookie


Fascinating crossroads for CA this summer. CA really has only one shot in the locker re BBL, which is this coming summer. If they misfire, they are skrewed going forward. CA either fires true re locking in policy per Aus player retention and o/s player attraction (simply has to be $ influenced in the face of UAE and SAF), or, it goes down the path of recent seasons re waning interest in the comp; in which case its cause will be unretrievably lost in the face of spin-off IPL comps and CA's own reduced broadcast value for the next round of summers of cricket (primarily BBL-driven, though there is an Ashes and India Test series in there). -- As for Warner; well, a lifetime ban, is a lifetime ban. That's the starting point. From there, we then explore excuses of convenience. Failing to follow through/be consistent/stick to one's principles, is not at all far from what most expect from CA: they truly are an inept organisation - they have have no "centre". So, no surprise if, after 5 years, CA says the "lifetime" leadership ban *really* only meant a 5 year ban. Inconsistency, shooting from the hip, and mixed-messaging, is par for the course for CA. So no surprises re whatever they do.

2022-08-13T06:23:16+00:00

Andrew

Guest


I don't mind whether David Warner is gonna represent Sydney Thunder or not. All I want is he should be appointed as T20I captain for AUS . If it happens, then AUS can definitely win back-to-back WCs. Selectors have to announce preliminary squad. I hope McDermott, Head, David & Ellis are in selectors' mind!!

2022-08-12T23:42:39+00:00

Nudge

Roar Rookie


“There will probably be an outcry from non-cricket followers if he is allowed to resume a leadership role, the type of people that like to be enraged for the sake of it” Absolutely spot on, although I’m sure there will be some cricket followers that will be enraged for the same reasons. It was so long ago now and he’s paid a very heavy price, surely it’s time to move on

Read more at The Roar