It’s all about the destination for this All Blacks side, even if we're unsure how they got there

By Highlander / Roar Guru

The faculties are just about strong enough to remember being woken by the parents in the Kingswood station wagon having arrived at Nelson camping ground but personally having little idea as to how we actually got there, not dissimilar to the latter years’ Dunedin to Queenstown ride after a fine Highlanders home win.

And here too do the All Blacks find themselves. Their destination looked pretty good, albeit it has been via a series of pretty ugly detours in 2021/22 and without being sure that they were even on the right side of the road on occasion.

Saturday really was confluence of all that is good with New Zealand rugby, with a game plan that works, and more importantly, one the that looked like the players believed in and did so with some serious intensity.

A front row is now in, which if the radio journalists in New Zealand are correct, coach Ian Foster had to be ‘dragged kicking and screaming’ towards, and it is one that is taking a backwards step to no one.

A back row with clearly defined roles, that needs little tinkering or selection adjustment, a backline which has been released by the lightning in the hands and space awareness of Aaron Smith and Richie Mo’unga (the ‘total passes by outside backs’ stat has rocketed in the last three games) but most importantly, a discipline to stick to what was working, 10 minutes at the beginning of the replacements aside, right through until the end.

(Photo by Hannah Peters/Getty Images)

In the last five minutes we saw both backline Barretts have the opportunity to run the ball back from average Puma kicks, but both kicked the ball deep, looking for grass, and a final try was added for good measure. Sticking to the plan when the points are done and dusted is a really good sign.

The loose forwards in the last three games have been a revelation. Shannon Frizell has been the addition that fixes so many of the small things that made this side clunky over the last two years. His carries out of the defensive end, sheer speed of getting off the ground at lineout time, and a willingness to throw his body into everything sets a platform for those around him.

But it is the spread of the loose forward workload which has been the big change.

Rucks aside, Ardie Savea had 24 carrries and tackles on Saturday, a huge effort and still had enough gas to sneak over for a cheeky try towards the end. Compare that to the five involvements in the second Test against Ireland, or just 14 (four tackles) in the loss to France last year.

Sports opinion delivered daily 

   

There was no way either Jason Ryan or Joe Schmidt were going to countenance the waste of a loose forward used primarily for edge attack purposes which places too much pressure on his mates, let alone the two of them that Ian Foster has favoured for a year and a half.

Hardly surprising then that Sam Canes best two games of this year, Saturday and the win in the Republic, where that loose forward workload was evenly spread, and he can just concentrate on his own job. I was so hoping he would dummy and go for the try himself when he put Jordie Barrett in on Saturday, but as in all he does, the captain chose the selfless and best option.

During the week I noted that Foster gave an interview where there was some element of recognition of the failings of the All Black game plan while the results have been in free fall, and I hoped that he would back up this sparsely distributed interview with selections and a game plan that re-enforced what seemed to be his new way of thinking.

(Photo By Ramsey Cardy/Sportsfile via Getty Images)

Congrats to him for not only having the courage to select the same side that lost the week before, but to send them out with a variety of game plan that Argentina did not get to grips with from the opening minutes to the last.

Anyone who thinks that coaching doesn’t matter with players of this quality needs to seriously re-watch the last two Argentinian Tests. Same guys, vastly different approaches; massive result swing.

So many further things that could be highlighted here, but a couple stand out. A rush defence simply cannot hit something that does not provide a target and Richie Mo’unga handled that magnificently. His management of depth in the pocket is instinctive and precise, moving the ball either by hand or foot to the parts of the park that took the pressure off his side.

The tangential statistics of this use of time, such as team turnovers, plummet when the players outside him are given time and space. The re-discovery of Rieko Ioane’s running game as the ball is presented flat and out in front of him is a serious bonus.

Secondly, the kicking game at the Tron was exactly what was required; for territory, for manipulating the defence and as an attacking weapon. Who would have thought, eh, kick the ball 32 times and score seven tries.

If there was any doubt that the rugby philosophy under the Foster group, before the recent changes, was a thing of another age, then it was so proven in Hamilton.

Let hope that the flat attack, running rugby ‘cause it’s in our DNA’ is over, dead, expired, or whatever other number of descriptors were assigned to the famous Norwegian Blue.

I do not care how we got here, not if it was the Crusader influence of Jason Ryan, not if it was the attention to detail of Joe Schmidt, or feedback from the players after the turnaround win in Johannesburg that kept coach Foster in his job. I care not a jot.

On Saturday there was a structure that was far more like New Zealand rugby DNA than the fictional product that has been alluded to in the recent past. Aggressive and physical up front on both sides of the ball, and considered, patient and clinical out the backs when required.

Foster is renowned for his loyalty, both to players and to his rugby philosophy. Credit to him for not only changing the plan, but for sticking with the personnel best able to implement it. He had his reversion step last week, that one last time roll of the dice which may have given his philosophy a glimpse of hope, but which some big nasty blue and white forwards stomped all over.

What I do care about is we don’t go back.

Not in game plan, not in micro plans, not in selections. Not even against weaker opposition when running at all costs has little or no consequence.

If the All Blacks do strike injury trouble, then elevate the next young players in line and let Schmidt and Ryan get them up to speed, we can have absolute trust that both these men will get newbies up to Test level in the right way.

What was perhaps most pleasing about Saturday’s Test was that the man of the match discussions all involved players maligned by game plan or selection in the recent past and showed what they can do, given clear runway.

As for the approaching Bledisloe Cup: select the same side, micro game plan changes only and search for that consistency of intensity that raised its head on Saturday as the new All Black normal.

The Crowd Says:

2022-09-17T22:54:56+00:00

taylorman

Roar Guru


The weirdest thing about this season is it could be our worst season ever … yet our trophy cabinet could be just as full as before it started. A bit weird…

2022-09-09T18:29:39+00:00

Utiku Old Boy

Roar Rookie


Would rather play Sotutu at 8 for this game but if Akira is selected, he should be at 8 where he has played his best rugby for Blues, ABs and AKL. He does not have the graft, work-rate or game for 6. Sotutu neither really. Mikaele-Tu probably deserves a shot at 8 as well. Jacobson also has good game for 8 and none of these players are being developed because of the continued Cane-Ardie persistence. Blackadder, Frizzell, S Barrett, Vaii can all continue to develop as AB 6 even though the last 2 may be needed for lock depth in RWC run.

2022-09-06T14:49:32+00:00

Mo

Guest


Havilli is a 15 originally. J Barrett looked to have a good offload game at 12. I like the idea of at least trying umsgajensen

AUTHOR

2022-09-06T05:23:00+00:00

Highlander

Roar Guru


Of the top 10 turnover winners in the six nations last year - 1 was an open side flanker The laws have changed from the days when the tackler was the likely jackler

2022-09-06T04:26:23+00:00

Lara

Guest


Your comment “ I don’t care how we got here” shows you are a true gentleman. I had a boss who only cared about the results. He did not care how it was done, just get there. I can understand that, because I ran my own practice years later. However, l also wanted to know who were the drivers…..why, because I was looking into the future n give merit where merit is due.

2022-09-05T22:19:50+00:00

JD Kiwi

Roar Rookie


Cheers Don. Really the main thing is the decision making. Determining what the defensive line does is especially important, and so is making sure that the clear is right, and that the right pass is made when he's linking up. Just watch all his involvement in Jordie's try. For too long Foster has prioritised x factor when you also need those players who know what to do and execute their core roles. They hold the whole team together.

2022-09-05T18:02:27+00:00

ButThinkOfTheSnails

Roar Rookie


I wonder if this is a result of having had the new assistants more or less forced on him. The earlier models owed their jobs to Foster. Foster owes his job to Schmidt and Ryan (to an extent). Meaning Fosterball doesn’t have a free reign. I’m clutching at this straw, anyway.

2022-09-05T17:58:52+00:00

ButThinkOfTheSnails

Roar Rookie


As long as they don’t start high-fiving. It’s dangerous, the high five.

2022-09-05T17:56:23+00:00

ButThinkOfTheSnails

Roar Rookie


Now just to fix his passing to his outsides… still has a tendency still to pass high or at the shoulder/slightly behind. But as long as he runs like that, almost anything can be forgiven

2022-09-05T17:52:02+00:00

ButThinkOfTheSnails

Roar Rookie


Good comments Coker - i agree we should temper the Hallelujas with a little pepper… Regarding the lack of turnovers, it is a worry. My impression though (without a deep dive into the stats) is that the teams with higher/more effective turnover results are achieving it in part via numbers somewhat lower than 7 - and in particular 1, 2 and 3 (and particularly 2). Samisoni has been fantastic so far, but this is one area it would be great if he could work on. Perhaps it reflects a change in the open side role over the past few years, as well as Cane’s specific strengths and weaknesses.

2022-09-05T11:10:18+00:00

donmcdazzle

Roar Rookie


I completely agree on your work rate point. Last thing I want to see is Akira at 6 again… This isn’t a pop at you, and maybe I’m being harsh on Cane but is it too much to ask that your 7 does more than tackle and hit rucks? Breakdown threat, carrying, just anything else would be nice. I get he’s a hard worker and that’s great, but so was Reuben Thorne back in the day.

2022-09-05T10:58:49+00:00

Carlin

Roar Rookie


Variety in the kicking game got the Pumas thinking about their defensive pressure and needing cover the kicks, that opened a lot of space for the All Blacks on Saturday. The skill execution in the wet was excellent also. The other pleasing thing for me was the defence. We kept the Pumas tryless and we had the edge in the collison. Will be interesting to see what they do with Savea and Frizell being out for the Melbourne test. I would like to see Sotutu get a run and if the coaches feel Retalick is good to start, I would try Scott Barrett at 6. Sotutu has a wide range of skills and is a strong carrier. Barrett is a workhorse and his last outing at 6 was a good one. Will also allow for plenty of lineout options. Spot on as always mate. Thanks

2022-09-05T10:40:28+00:00

Nick

Roar Rookie


German = Marlboro...

2022-09-05T10:21:27+00:00

Tim J

Roar Rookie


Hopefully my anxiety pills can stay in the drawer now Digger.. :stoked:

2022-09-05T10:17:45+00:00

Tim J

Roar Rookie


Spot on Highlander, for a great article and for your honesty. I will give credit when it is due, and also was pleasantly pleased with Foster realising that this game plan is the one that brings the best out of the players. He seems to have learnt from the first game against Argentina, and it is not often for him to admit he has got something wrong. You can see how much Smith is more confident with Mounga as 10, Cane and Whitelock are back to their best as a result. Throw in Brodie and the team has more balance and genuine threats! Foster has the chance to win Kiwi fans over more as long as he uses the Pumas game as the template while progressing the team further.

2022-09-05T09:42:00+00:00

Colvin Brown

Roar Guru


Luckily for NZ rugby Ian Foster finally listened to the relentless advice he was getting from Roar contributors and took heed. He's not likely to deviate now he's seen it work. Let's hope anyway.

2022-09-05T09:27:09+00:00

Colvin Brown

Roar Guru


Excellent summary HL. Interesting to hear your info on Foster being brought kicking and screaming into the idea of a new front row. Isn't the scrum doing well now.

2022-09-05T09:20:28+00:00

Colvin Brown

Roar Guru


I'm not so sure about Frizzell at 8, SB. Frizzell's a 6 and there's a big difference between what's required of a 6 and what's required of an 8. I've been pretty frustrated with Frizzell's test career up till his last 3 games. This is the first time I've seen him given a game plan that suits his talents and bring his SR form to the test arena. Hitting the breakdown, big lineout play, strong one off running and heavy close in tackling. And he's fast and got an engine. It seems to me if they keep him in the game like the last 3 and a bit games, he could be developed into one of our greats. But he's a 6.

2022-09-05T09:06:12+00:00

Lara

Guest


Slowly we are seeing signs. It is a start, belated but a start. Great to see Jacobson getting a call up…..the signs are there.

AUTHOR

2022-09-05T08:34:07+00:00

Highlander

Roar Guru


Remember the golden rule set last year ( well by me) never start 2 of savea - ioane - sotutu together in the trio I’m sticking by that one

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar