MICHAEL HAGAN: The gold and blueprint for Eels to break premiership drought

By Michael Hagan / Expert

I can’t remember a finals series where a couple of the bottom-ranked teams are coming in with the best momentum and form at the right time.

The sixth-placed Roosters have the best attack of any team in the last five weeks (average of 36.5) and the eighth-placed Raiders are running a close second at 32.5.

Meanwhile, in the top four the Sharks have the best defence in the last five weeks, averaging 11 per game, and the Eels are ranked second (14).

Panthers vs Eels

The Eels have also won their last three games and I like what I see in Parramatta having the building blocks to be a premiership-winning team.

Whether they finally break their long-running drought or not remains to be seen but they have everything in place to at least make the Grand Final while a Preliminary Final would be a pass mark and anything short of that would be a failure.

Any team that wins a premiership needs an element of luck, especially with injuries, but you also need cohesion, a clever halves combination, some X-factor, a strong engine room up front and momentum.

Looking at the Parra roster this year, they’ve used 27 players over the 24 matches but seven of those guys only filled in a few times here and there so they’ve had the luxury of keeping the same core team on the park more often than not.

Cohesion is important both off the field and at training but also when you’re out on the park and you know where each player likes to be, what their strengths are and how to cover up their weaknesses.

The Eels have made the semi-final stage in four of the past five years and many of the current members of the team have built up some battle scars from those playoff exits. They’d be sick and tired of coming up short and just like we saw with Souths (who lost a couple of prelim finals before they won) in 2014, the Cowboys in 2015 and the Sharks in 2016, droughts can be broken.

(Photo by Cameron Spencer/Getty Images)

There’ll be a Parramatta team at some point that does it, these guys will have that mindset of why can’t we be the ones.

I coached there for a couple of seasons 15 years ago and pressure to repeat the 1980s glory days era is always nagging away in the background at that club. It is a psychological road block to overcome but this team seems to have been able to put that to one side.

There’s been talk that their premiership window could be closing after this year because there’s a fair few players leaving in the off-season. I agree that most teams only have two or three years to compete for a title before things start to drop off and the Eels’ window won’t slam shut after this year but this is their best chance and it will slightly tighten next season.

A premiership team needs halves who complement each other and the Eels have got that with Mitchell Moses directing the side around the park and Dylan Brown putting the finishing touches on.

Moses’ kicking game is critical and he’s played four seasons now with Brown and they’ve developed a halves partnership that reminds me a bit of what Jarome Luai and Nathan Cleary had struck up at Penrith by last year when they went all the way to the title.

(Photo by Cameron Spencer/Getty Images)

I’ve been impressed with what I’ve seen, especially late in the season, how they set up in certain spots on the field and then sending it wide for Moses to give Brown, Clint Gutherson, Shaun Lane and Maika Sivo down the left edge. 

With Isaiah Papali’i on the right edge, they’ve got plenty of X-factor for those times in games, particularly in finals, when you desperately need to put points on the board. 

And another important factor for any team that has won a Grand Final for as long as I can remember is having two front-rowers who can churn through the hard yards up the middle. 

Junior Paulo and Reagan Campbell-Gillard are in career-best form and along with Reed Mahoney, they keep the middle tight in defence. Shifting Ryan Matterson to lock also seems to have brought the best out in him and I like that he can play long minutes.

Momentum is also on Parramatta’s side – they were dominant against Melbourne last week and they’re entering the finals as probably the form team of the NRL along with the Roosters.

Penrith could regret their decision to rest nearly their entire team last week against the Cowboys. It’s a pretty big gamble and they’ve got Nathan Cleary coming back in after his five-game suspension so their momentum is not the same as what it was coming into the finals this time last year.

Parra don’t seem to fear the Panthers, which some other teams tend to do.

Storm vs Raiders

Jahrome Hughes coming back means they have that three-way attacking strikeforce back together with Cameron Munster and Harry Grant.

I’d be tempted to move Munster back to five-eighth with Nick Meaney at fullback because I think when he’s in the halves with Hughes, they seem to have better cohesion.

(Photo by Mark Nolan/Getty Images)

In big games, you need Origin or international standard guys in those two positions and Canberra have found their mojo since Jack Wighton and Jamal Fogarty have been able to string a few games together in the halves.

They’ve won seven of their past eight and they’ve been quite successful in Melbourne the last couple of years so, with Joe Tapine and Josh Papalii, they have the physicality to match Nelson Asofa-Solomona and Jesse Bromwich up front.

Melbourne and the Raiders have developed a healthy rivalry and this game should go down to the wire, especially with two of the best (and most competitive coaches) in the NRL in Craig Bellamy and Ricky Stuart – one of whom will go home disappointed.

Sharks vs Cowboys

Cronulla getting the tick-off to play at Shark Park is a huge advantage and a good reward for finishing second. 

North Queensland are still a young team who have finished their season strongly with three wins from five games but are still learning how to prepare and handle the occasion against quality teams. Their recent form in Sydney for big games against the Rabbitohs and the Roosters wasn’t their best but it provided some good experience for the playoffs.

I think the Cowboys are learning around how to play at certain venues and how to handle the pressure. They need to learn a couple of lessons fairly quickly about adversity, in dealing with situations when things are going against them. But they are healthy and full of running at this time of year.

The Sharks have a few quality players to come back in and will be tough to beat on Saturday night.

(Photo by Mark Kolbe/Getty Images)

Roosters vs Rabbitohs

It will be much different to last week in terms of intensity with a few big guns coming back for each team.

The Roosters have been up for the past two months, winning eight straight, and Souths have the benefit of Cameron Murray, Damien Cook and Campbell Graham coming back.

The form of James Tedesco, who lines up against Latrell Mitchell, will have a huge bearing on the outcome along with the intense battle up front.

Having the best defence is so important at this time of year and the Roosters have made great strides in that area at the end of the season conceding less than 14 points per game.

In all four of the playoffs in week one I don’t think the favourites will have it all their own way and I am expecting a couple of upsets.

var request = new XMLHttpRequest();

request.open('POST', '/wp-admin/admin-ajax.php', true); request.setRequestHeader('Content-Type', 'application/x-www-form-urlencoded;'); request.onload = function () { if (this.status >= 200 && this.status

The Crowd Says:

2022-09-08T14:53:49+00:00

London Panther

Roar Rookie


Big call. Hope you are right. That GF would be epic!!

2022-09-08T14:52:36+00:00

London Panther

Roar Rookie


I’m not sure I would be reading that much into it Eelsallmighty, particularly given that when the decision was made to rest the players Ivan didn’t know who we was playing. I don’t think Ivan seems spooked; maybe a little wishful thinking there. What’s most interesting from my perspective about the resting is how different it has been to other years. Last year and the year before Ivan rested no one; this year it is the entire team. Should be a cracker of a game; I am actually quite confident.

2022-09-08T14:46:53+00:00

London Panther

Roar Rookie


And 80% of the 90% looking at the Eels. I’m not being jealous, you can see why the Eels are the bigger story. But I am not sure it is helpful to the Eels; they have performed better this year when they have been friendless. Hope it’s a cracking game and come tomorrow night we are talking about the awesome players and not the referee.

2022-09-08T04:25:28+00:00

Albo

Roar Rookie


No matter what happens on Friday night, I'm pretty confident the Panthers & Eels will meet again in October.

2022-09-08T02:36:11+00:00

jimmmy

Roar Rookie


Tipping is one thing, putting money on a team is another. Penrith are $1.40 favs and rightly so. The only 'knock ' on them is Cleary having no recent footy.

2022-09-08T00:30:27+00:00

Fitzy

Guest


Yep, it's critical they start well. Apparently they haven't lost a game when leading at half time and they panic big time when they find themselves trailing. It's a big game, but it's not critical they win. If they beat Penrith they'll likely meet the Roosters in the GF qualifier (ie. they have to beat the two best teams in the comp to get to the GF and Penrith for a 4th time in 2022 to win the GF). But if they lose to Penrith, they'll be on the opposite side of the draw to the Roosters.

2022-09-08T00:20:21+00:00

Tim J

Roar Rookie


It grates me when some take it too far GB, it is great that Danno spoke out.. :thumbup:

2022-09-08T00:15:36+00:00

Tim J

Roar Rookie


You are correct Danno, I like banter as most do. But it should be in a respectful way, thanks also as it will be a great game! It can go either way, I am genuinely nervous this one :thumbup: Also good luck to your Eels team, they are looking very good.

2022-09-07T23:34:49+00:00

JennyFromPenny

Guest


Taylan May did not have a conviction recorded. Suggest you retract your comment.

2022-09-07T23:14:55+00:00

Dwanye

Roar Rookie


Hi Fitzy. Your second paragraph, I had thought the same, Eels can start fast to me (maybe it just imagination) and Panthers starting slow due to time out. Great weekend ahead.

2022-09-07T22:33:41+00:00

Fitzy

Guest


Melb were dreadful last week against Parramatta. Countless errors on the 1st and 2nd tackles - dropped balls / bundled into touch etc. Penrith know Parramatta's weakness is their right side defence (which is why they can't beat Sths). Penrith just have to run numbers until Waqa Blake has to make a decision, which will invariably be the wrong one. Parramatta's best chance is if their week off means Penrith start slow, fall behind and panic trying to play catch up footy against a firing Parramatta.

2022-09-07T20:56:21+00:00

JennyFromPenny

Guest


You have me confused with someone else, sorry. I didn't even know zero tackle had a forum.

2022-09-07T17:52:18+00:00

Danno

Roar Rookie


Cheers Tim ,nothing wrong with friendly banter , but it was getting a bit too much from our friend over there, I know your a Penrith supporter, good luck on Friday but not too much luck

2022-09-07T11:40:49+00:00

JennyFromPenny

Guest


Yet none of the team remember losing to the Cowboys, sort from what they saw on TV. They only remember wiping the Cowboys 22-0. Compared to last year, the team half busted, Cleary 3/4 busted, it should be a warning to the other teams that we come into this year's finals close to fully fit. That we had the luxury to do that, same as you did before the Newcastle final last year, then you do it.

2022-09-07T11:37:11+00:00

Glory Bound

Roar Rookie


That line of defence doesn't work with an insanity plea, Tim. Narcissism is a psychological disorder. Follow the breadcrumbs (comments) and they all lead back to a very big mirror with a very small kitten trying to look like a Lion. :laughing:

2022-09-07T11:29:25+00:00

Glory Bound

Roar Rookie


VERY much! I'm way ahead of you there pal. I have been aware of it for ages. She wore ugg boots on Zero Tackle as well and changed her profile every year when she got punted... panther14, panthers15, panthers16, panthers17. She used to tag team with another wannabe that was Dragons supporter who was more concerned with correcting grammar and spelling mistakes than making a relevant contribution to the forum.

2022-09-07T11:09:50+00:00

Eelsalmighty

Roar Rookie


GB, have you found a new friend? Does JennyFromPenny remind you of someone?

2022-09-07T11:01:52+00:00

Eelsalmighty

Roar Rookie


I thought that was a great read, especially as it fits with my Parra bias narrative. I'd add, I think our biggest hurdles to going deep/deeper into the finals are: A. We often (more often than not, either way) don't play hard for the full 80min. If things don't go right early we can fold, and when things go well for the first 60/65 minutes we can become complacent. B. Our bench. Nothing against any player in particular, but collectively I think it's a weakness. Not weak, but a weakness, and this is finals footy. But back to the article, I found the most interesting comment was the one about the Panthers possibly regretting resting players last week. I have no doubt that (resting te players last week) will benefit them this week, but if they win this week it could become, and I'd argue will become a negative, but to what extent? A week off, week on, week off, then a prelim can't be your best prep. A week off when the opposition teams are having to go their hardest, especially late in the season is a huge bonus. I read into that Ivan's concerned about playing Parra this week, to the extent he is giving us a reasonable/realistic chance of the win. If I was BA I'd be highlighting that. We've got the Panthers spooked.

2022-09-07T10:57:55+00:00

Jenny

Guest


We is stuck with all the master baiters.

2022-09-07T10:48:50+00:00

Muzz

Guest


I don't think they're mentally tough enough to go all the way.

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar