Brad Arthur's selection of his son for chance to win premiership together is correct decision

By Michael Yatras / Roar Rookie

On completing his selections for his starting 17 to play in this weekend’s ‘Battle of the West’ Grand Final, Parramatta coach Brad Arthur has made one of the most high-pressure decisions he has ever had to make – selecting his son Jake.

Rightfully or wrongly, there will be a contingent of naysayers who expresses the belief that Jakob’s position on the interchange bench would be better suited to a player with increased versatility or physical presence that will guarantee them game time against an imposing Panthers outfit. There will also be the unavoidable sentiment from some quarters that nepotism has played a part in his decision-making process.

The short-sightedness of such individuals will not change, even though Brad’s proven recipe to success involves carrying a specialist half on the bench. The negativity that this publicity creates, at a time that will quite possibly be the peak of the professional careers of both father and son, is disappointing.

To combat the pessimism of the minority, it is important to highlight the potential for Sunday to be one of the most rewarding, joyful and personally special moments for Brad, Jake and the extended Arthur family. They have the potential to achieve what only an extraordinarily select few have the chance to do – winning an NRL grand final as a father and son combo.

As any parent involved in their children’s sporting landscape at any age will attest, very seldom does the motivation to be a part of the team revolve around providing an unwarranted leg up, rather than a sense of fulfillment and pleasure of being part of something that brings so much joy to the most treasured little people in their life. It is one thing to be on the sideline to witness that first try, goal or basket, however, it is a whole other feeling of exhilaration to be an active part of it.

Whether it is the World Cup final, or C Grade under 10’s netball, this feeling never gets old.

(Photo by Mark Kolbe/Getty Images)

However, as our kids get older their lives evolve. For some, study and work will become a priority, while others would rather socialise, or travel as opposed lacing the boots up on a Saturday afternoon or hitting the track early on Sunday morning. While the lives of our once little bundles of joy continue to be fulfilled by other pursuits, the exhilaration and feeling of shared accomplishment for parents will be lost forever. These emotions cannot be replaced.

So far in their father/son sporting journey, Brad Arthur has not had to say good-bye to this experience. Fortuitously, Jakob’s professional pursuits and source of fulfillment following childhood has aligned to coincide with a shared involvement in rugby league, a fact that has not alluded to him in reflecting on Ivan and Nathan Cleary writing their names in history as coach/player NRL premiers only last year.

“That was really cool seeing that, and it would be an unreal feeling if we can win a comp together, “ said Jakob.

“We watched that game as a family in Cairns. To be honest, we were thinking, ‘This could have been us’. That’s what we were hoping.”

CLICK HERE for a seven-day free trial to watch the NRL on KAYO

To describe the feeling as ‘unreal’ is to understate the achievement. Scrutiny on any coach leading into an NRL grand final will ultimately bring pressure, let alone one that has picked his son in front of others who on merit would not be out of place in the 17. To alleviate this pressure in his own mind, Brad Arthur could do a lot worse than think about the opportunity he has to achieve something with his son that very few will have the chance to fulfill.

The shared experience between father and son, in winning the biggest game on the NRL calendar cannot be replicated. This is something that as a game, community and as parents we should all celebrate.

The Crowd Says:

2022-09-28T23:07:03+00:00

The Bear

Guest


RCG and Junior are averaging over 50 minutes a game the last few weeks. So having another Prop/Second rower for Parra at this time is probably wasted unless something happens to those two. Brad Arthur is taking a gamble that nothing happens to those 2 but it has got the team to the Grand Final so you keep the gamble going.

2022-09-28T13:13:58+00:00

Big Mig

Roar Rookie


It would be poetic if Arthur junior that kicks the winning field goal and not Cleary junior.

2022-09-28T11:58:06+00:00

James

Roar Rookie


Of course he should play. He is as good a player as Jaemon Salmon and no-one criticises Ivan Cleary for selecting him. It is insurance in case of injury to a half. Brad Arthur is to be admired. I was born in the Nepean District Hospital near Penrith and spent most of my life supporting the Penny Panthers but I would love nothing more than seeing the much maligned Brad and Jacob Arthur celebrating Grand Final success to silence the creeps and cretins who attack on social media. Go the ...(gulp) Eels!!!!

2022-09-28T08:04:20+00:00

JOHN ALLAN

Guest


Jacob makes his bed, takes the garbage out & walks the family dog. What else does he need to do to be selected? Some people are hard markers. Ivan Cleary has no objection to his inclusion.

2022-09-28T07:41:48+00:00

Tom G

Roar Rookie


No problem with a coach selecting his son if he’s good enough.. poor old Jakab is the Eels Scott Fulton with even less talent

2022-09-28T05:44:06+00:00

Hondo

Roar Rookie


I don't see Jake Arthur as a starting half back going forward as I feel he's too tall already i.e., 6ft 2 and still growing and does not seem to have the elusiveness, the speed or step to be a good starting half back. In any case he will never be the starting half anyway for the Eels while Mitch Moses is at there. I see Jake's future more as a bench player in coming years as with his size and passing and kicking game, could with time, be able to cover almost every position in the back line and i think could also make a good fist of hooker, as he has the passing and kicking game if needed to play that position. In any case I honestly can't see Parra beating Penrith no matter who they put on their bench.

2022-09-28T05:12:31+00:00

JGK

Roar Guru


If they win without Jakob getting on the field or making any real contribution, it will still be the incorrect move.

2022-09-28T04:57:52+00:00

Chuck

Guest


If the Eels win it was the correct move, if they lose it will be nepotism at its finest. BA’s head will be on the chopping block or be re revered for eternity by the club and fans. So, we will have to wait for Sunday night for your question to be answered.

2022-09-28T04:42:33+00:00

Adam

Roar Guru


Nepotism always ends well...

2022-09-28T04:00:57+00:00

JGK

Roar Guru


The shared experience between father and son, in winning the biggest game on the NRL calendar cannot be replicated. Jakob's selection has pretty much guaranteed that the Cleary's will be replicating it this year.

2022-09-28T03:54:10+00:00

ALL ABOUT BALLS

Roar Rookie


Excellent article, spoken like a true parent.

Read more at The Roar