Rudan's perfect plan reminded us all that matches are won on the pitch, not in the stands

By Mike Tuckerman / Expert

Melbourne Victory’s return to AAMI Park earned rave reviews from fans on social media, but the problem for the Victorians was that it was Western Sydney who won the game.

Almost 26 years ago to the day, Sydney United travelled down to Lakeside and pulled off a 3-1 over a highly fancied South Melbourne in Round 2 of the old National Soccer League.

Tony Popovic started that game for the visitors – and almost scored with Sydney United’s first attack – while Mark Rudan came off the bench for Branko Culina’s side.

These days Popovic is one of the most highly regarded coaches in the A-League Men, while Rudan now goes by the first name ‘Marko’.

But it was the latter who masterminded a classic smash-and-grab raid at AAMI Park on Saturday night – and reminded a few of the Twitterati that football games are won on the pitch, not via elaborate tifos in the stands.

There’s no doubt that a Melbourne Victory side performing well produces desirable metrics for the A-League Men.

But logging on to Twitter on Saturday night was a reminder that people from Melbourne enjoy nothing more than talking about how much they love Melbourne.

The Victory fans were out in force, telling everyone that their fans are loudest, their walk-out song the most spine-tingling and their atmospheres simply the best at AAMI Park.

Unfortunately for them, Rudan was too busy orchestrating a backs-to-the-wall 1-0 win over Victory to notice, courtesy of the scrappiest goal from Tomislav Mrcela you’re ever likely to see.

Rudes is never going to win a popularity contest, but he remains one of the A-League Men’s most quietly effective coaches.

And more importantly, like his counterpart Popovic, he brings a level of personal intensity to the touchline the Wanderers arguably need.

And the A-Leagues need it too, because if there’s one club that can genuinely challenge Victory in terms of a passionate fan base, it’s Western Sydney.

But what this weekend, once again, reminded us of is that the easiest way to keep fans coming through the gates is simply by winning matches.

We focus far too much on attendance in the A-Leagues.

Mind you, that’s not good news for Brisbane Roar, who were as uninspired on the pitch as the fans were off it in Friday night’s diabolical 2-0 defeat to Melbourne City.

Credit to the visitors, who did little more than was required in what was the most routine of victories on the road.

Jamie Maclaren gave The Den a bit of stick after confidently slotting home a second-half penalty to make it 2-0 to the visitors, while a few fans had a crack at Paddy Kisnorbo on social media for not giving Marco Tilio more game time.

“I’m the coach of Melbourne City, I’m not the national team coach,” was Kisnorbo’s perfectly reasonable response when asked about only bringing Tilio on deep into stoppage time, after the visitors had been reduced to 10 men following Taras Gomulka’s red card.

Even with a man advantage the Roar rarely threatened in attack, and it’s going to be a long season for marquee signing Charlie Austin if they can’t find a way to provide him any service.

How the Roar could do with a player like Daniel Arzani, after the Socceroos hopeful turned on the magic in Macarthur’s 2-0 win over Adelaide United on Sunday afternoon.

The Reds were a touch unfortunate to have a handful of goals ruled out for various offences, but the Bulls were good value for their win in a game in which Arzani made all the difference.

Jason Cummings likewise enhanced his chances for World Cup selection with an expertly-taken goal in Central Coast Mariners’ entertaining 2-2 draw away at Wellington Phoenix, while Sydney FC’s 3-1 win over Western United was the ultimate Jekyll and Hyde performance.

But it’s Rudan who’ll be laughing at the end of an eventful round of action.

When all the focus was on the noise from the stands, the Wanderers coach simply set up his team to get the job done on the pitch.

The Crowd Says:

2022-10-17T09:17:21+00:00

Lionheart

Roar Rookie


he's been out for a fair while, or was (missed two seasons I think).

2022-10-17T08:45:51+00:00

Midfielder

Roar Guru


agree

2022-10-17T07:59:36+00:00

Brainstrust

Roar Rookie


Yeboah came back lazier thats quite common, his skills were not bad when he came back. Borrello looks like someone who did basically nothing for the last 5 years.

2022-10-17T06:56:06+00:00

Grem

Roar Rookie


There are a few managers in the A League I’d hate to get on the wrong side of and Rudan may well be top of the list. I thought the WSW v Victory game was fantastic – a real battle. I also loved Marko’s comments about how he was and wanted to bring the fans back. Let’s hope it happens. The Victory fans do have a great atmosphere and their singing of Stand By Me is great. For our game’s metrics I do hope Sydney, Victory and The Wanderers do well, but I want all teams to be strong and give their fans a reason to turn up each week. There were quite a few highlights this weekend – Cummings bicycle kick goal (should have been let go), Newcastle’s last minute victory with 10 men, Niewenhoff, Arzani, Lolley. Lots to keep looking forward to.

2022-10-17T04:56:45+00:00

Coastyboi

Guest


Marko? Goodbye Mark then. Hello accompanying pronouns & “proud” heritage backstory.

2022-10-17T04:14:00+00:00

Lionheart

Roar Rookie


play better, look good are different words. If someone's scoring off your crosses you look good too, surely. The previous former Roar p[layer Wanderers picked up overseas, Kwame Yeboah, I thought was also better before he left Roar than when he came home. There's a message there somewhere.

2022-10-17T04:02:57+00:00

Brainstrust

Roar Rookie


Borrello set up Maclaren not the other way around. Not sure how MacLaren being in the center makes a winger play better.

2022-10-17T03:45:41+00:00

Para+Ten ISUZU Subway support Australian Football

Roar Rookie


Fair point, he was given more space and room to make an impact in the second half but didn't make the most of it.

2022-10-17T03:36:28+00:00

Lionheart

Roar Rookie


Borrello and MacLaren were the perfect combo at Roar, I think they made each other look good. I recall when Borrello left for Germany, Roar academy staff watching closely as he was the first of their new breed to venture overseas, seeing it as a measure for themselves thus far (then).

2022-10-17T03:00:41+00:00

Midfielder

Roar Guru


Agree

2022-10-17T03:00:25+00:00

Midfielder

Roar Guru


WSW, MV, SFC, MC, & Cows IMO are the stand outs to date..... Nix, Mariners, Jerks, WU, AU next level... With the Roar & PG looking most likely to struggle this year...

2022-10-17T02:45:53+00:00

Brainstrust

Roar Rookie


I thought Cleur was a foreign player , is a good pick up, he did a good job against that Perth player Khellifi and a decent job against Nani. The question I have is what was Brandon Borrello doing in Germany for the last 5 years. He seems to still have the speed and strength, and his fitness is good probably better than he was at Roar. Skills wise he looks like he was in his first season at Roar, not the player he was the three seasons after at Roar. I was not expecting huge things of Borrello because when he did play for the Socceroos recently he looked awful. This business of going to Europe to develop, during the NSL because they weren't training full time, a player would go to Europe and there would be an improvement within a year. I dont remember players going to Europe and coming back worse skills wise, older and slower yes but not this.

2022-10-17T01:37:43+00:00

Para+Ten ISUZU Subway support Australian Football

Roar Rookie


That post-game interview by Ruden was what any fan would want to hear from his manager. Ruden is a manager clearly on a mission. On the game itself, Ruden won the game of tactics over his old friend Popa. Thoroughly enjoyed the game, it was a real arm wrestle, a game for the purist.

Read more at The Roar