It was because of momentum in the tackle - to be charged is ridiculous- the dragons player deliberately tried to trip Keary and should have been sent off
Yes it was. His knee was heavily strapped so he couldn’t resist twisting it. That type of dirty rubbish might be ok in the super league but it has no place in the NRL
I don't know about a deliberate twist. In normal speed, I'd give Hall the benefit of the doubt. A winger in the NRL who hasn't scored a try, that's going to take some beating. He'll be doing nudie runs all the way back to the U.K..
NO!!! it was just how the momentum of the tackle went. He went for a legs tackle & only managed to get Lomax by the one leg.
As far as I can ascertain Hall has never had a Judiciary appearance in his outstanding Super League career.
Didn't think it was intentional when I first saw it last night and after watching it again I still don't think it was. Didn't even seem like Hall realised what he had done until Lomax said something to him.
Probably not.
I don't think anyone goes out to deliberately injure another player. Things happen in games that are played at 90 miles an hour which can later look bad because they are slowed down and replayed over and over. Yes he did twist that knee but I doubt that he was conscious of what was happening and I certainly doubt that it was intentional.
Tony Blair
Guest
It was because of momentum in the tackle - to be charged is ridiculous- the dragons player deliberately tried to trip Keary and should have been sent off
Andrew
Roar Pro
Yes it was. His knee was heavily strapped so he couldn’t resist twisting it. That type of dirty rubbish might be ok in the super league but it has no place in the NRL
andrew
Roar Rookie
I don't know about a deliberate twist. In normal speed, I'd give Hall the benefit of the doubt. A winger in the NRL who hasn't scored a try, that's going to take some beating. He'll be doing nudie runs all the way back to the U.K..
Big Daddy
Guest
He'll probably get 6 weeks and the bloke with the trip will get a fine ( suspended).
Noosa Duck
Roar Rookie
NO!!! it was just how the momentum of the tackle went. He went for a legs tackle & only managed to get Lomax by the one leg. As far as I can ascertain Hall has never had a Judiciary appearance in his outstanding Super League career.
Parasite
Roar Rookie
Didn't see anything like what has been suggested.
Rob
Guest
Didn't think it was intentional when I first saw it last night and after watching it again I still don't think it was. Didn't even seem like Hall realised what he had done until Lomax said something to him.
Walter Black
Guest
Probably not. I don't think anyone goes out to deliberately injure another player. Things happen in games that are played at 90 miles an hour which can later look bad because they are slowed down and replayed over and over. Yes he did twist that knee but I doubt that he was conscious of what was happening and I certainly doubt that it was intentional.
Chuck
Guest
Of course it was intentional, he was trying to roll him over the touch line, by twisting his leg.