The most un-Australian of all suggestions

By Ben Pobjie / Expert

I’ve seen a lot of un-Australian things in my time. Granny-muggers, dodgy tradesmen, Arts Council grants, illegal immigrants and Julia Gillard.

But I’m not sure I’ve ever seen anything more un-Australian than this article by Ben Quilty, who is apparently an “artist”; although I’m not sure when the destruction of Australian values was officially classified as an artform.

Apparently these days art has gone beyond pornography all the way into actual unpatriotic semi-treason.

Quilty’s thesis is basically this: elite Australian athletes benefit from their publicly-funded sporting educations, so they should amass a HECS debt in the same way as those Australians who benefit from other kinds of publicly-funded educations, and when they start to earn above a certain level, they will begin to repay that debt, as so many other Australians do after undergoing university educations to become doctors, nurses, lawyers, engineers, or, apparently, whiny painters.

In defence of this slice of radical insanity, Quilty spouts off some nonsense about our troops in Afghanistan and Stilnox and a horse suit, to distract from the base depravity of his argument.

So, Quilty, this is how it’s to be, is it? This is the brave new Oz you envision?

A country where innocent sportspeople are forced to pay for goods and services like common plumbers. Is this how we became a great nation? Is this how we came to dominate the world?

When analysing the 1989 Ashes victory, how many experts nominated “HECS debt” as a determinative factor in the triumph?

How often did Kieren Perkins thank his HECS debt for the contribution it made to his success in the pool?

I think we know the answer.

Yes, I realise that Mr Quilty, with his artistic temperament and Derwent-addled brain, will claim he has “logic” on his side.

It’s ‘logical,’ he’ll claim, that athletes pay their way in society just like everyone else, and don’t get a free ride simply because their gifts happen to lie in the physical arena.

Oh yes, he’s being terribly ‘logical.’

But what Mr Quilty doesn’t realise as he smears his filthy paint all over our national pride, is that we are talking about sport. And sport has nothing to do with ‘logic.’

Was it logical for Alfie Langer to fly back from England and lead Queensland to victory even though he was over fifty years old and rapidly shrinking?

Was it logical for Dean Jones to hit a hundred in the heat of Madras by vomiting on the Indian bowlers until they cried for mercy?

Was it logical for Matthew Mitcham to flip over in the air and land in water?

Of course not! There’s no earthly point to it at all, it’s a ridiculous pastime. But it’s through this lack of logic that we define who we are and gain pride in our heritage.

It’s through the senseless acts of futile physical courage that Australia has become a sporting powerhouse.

There’s no logic to Anthony Mundine: why should there be logic to our funding formula?

It comes down to a very simple fact: sportsmen and, to a certain extent, sportswomen, are better than us. There’s no point denying it: you know in your heart it’s true.

You know full well that you can’t measure up to Cathy Freeman in the Great Person stakes.

You know you’re a much lesser human being than Lleyton Hewitt.

You know that you probably don’t even have as many friends as Jai Taurima. Even if you don’t remember who Jai Taurima is, you know it.

It’s innate.

Yes, sportspeople hone their skills at our expense, and yes some of them get very rich and never pay any of it back.

But those rich sportspeople have expenses. Bills to pay. Nutritionists to hire. X-Boxes to buy. Vitamin supplements to acquire in a sinister manner.

Do we really want them to skimp on the essentials just to satisfy antiquated notions of ‘fairness’?

Remember how lucky we are to have these great guys and girls here.

If we don’t keep them happy, they’ll be off satisfying residency requirements for the Netherlands faster than you can say Hana Mandlikova.

It’s important we keep our athletes calm, content, and at a constant temperature of 36.8 degrees Celsius.

And we can only do that by pouring more and more money into their training with no selfish desire for a return on our investment.

So go ahead, Ben Quilty, do your artistic quibbling, demand what you like. Try to tear down our wonderful sporting culture with your petty penny-pinching.

We who sail the seas of reality will continue to ignore you and pay tribute to those gods who run and jump among us, happy to be helping them achieve their dreams with whatever they require.

We live to serve, and humble flabby drones that we are, we must be happy with this.

The Crowd Says:

2013-03-08T01:18:54+00:00

Tim Coghlan

Roar Rookie


HECS for atheletes sounds fair as long as it is limited to income earnt from sport. As for all this "un-australian" Macarthyism, if you don't like what goes on in this country, move on. If it happens in this country then it is Australian whether you like it or not.

2013-03-07T02:56:57+00:00

Rory

Guest


Reductio ad absurdum.

2013-03-04T21:25:47+00:00

Mushi

Guest


He could be... After all he said he thought. That should have been the give away

2013-03-04T04:41:54+00:00

BRIAN N

Guest


with te current financial presuresbeing applied to al axpayers this issue of AIS and assciated costs needs to be addressed immeditely. The AIS costs we can no longer afford. In the current inacial climate we need to focus on essential needs and AIS is not one of them. Lets close down and convert to Hospital or retirement villiage!

2013-03-04T04:29:46+00:00

teepee

Guest


Hmmm. Perhaps you could explain to me how a major in Nietzche sets someone up for a career? Some people study because they want a career. Some people study because they want to devote some of their life to learning. Some people study because they want to be the best in the world in a field, but find that it's beyond their abilities. And all of them will have a HELP debt. The HELP repayments don't kick in until a minimum yearly income is achieved, and are set at low initial percentages of gross income that scale up as income increases. I think that's a pretty fair system, be it based on sports or academia.

2013-03-03T14:47:39+00:00

Evan Askew

Guest


Lol, unless AndyMack is himself being satirical?

2013-03-01T13:48:19+00:00

Matt

Guest


Why does western sydney need a 40,000 seat stadium?

2013-03-01T10:29:50+00:00

dasilva

Guest


Yeah I remember that. I loved it when The Chaser wrote "Pat Rafter won the Bermudan of The Year Award" satirical piece in response to his award

2013-03-01T10:10:19+00:00

langou

Roar Guru


Simba, He wasn't simply writing the opposite of what he meant. It was a satirical look at Australian spoting culture and in particular the way Australians put sports stars on a pedestal.

2013-03-01T09:45:23+00:00

Bee Bee

Guest


They are punished by the fact that they stunk. Wasted years of their life doing something they stink at. But this article isn't about punishment. Its about paying back an investment in tax dollars borrowed to make you awesome. Now that your awesome its time to show gratitude and help the world's best treasurer (Mr Swann) get us back into the black.

2013-03-01T07:31:23+00:00

Timmuh

Roar Guru


Successful sports people pay us back through being able to bask in reflected glory. They deserve the HECS free success. Its those who get all this investment and then fail who should be paying back their debts. They took our money under false pretenses, or at least false hope, and deserve to be punished.

2013-03-01T06:15:32+00:00

me too

Guest


Make it retrospective! If the pampered prima donnas can't win a bloody gold medal, or win a tour de France, then it's payback time!

2013-03-01T05:32:03+00:00

dasilva

Guest


I'm not necessarily talking about superstars but more of average swimmers that train hard but don't win any medals. I'm not as certain about the necessity to pay back the trainings if they decided to pick up another career (this will go on top of HECS). If you make a certain amount of income in the fields of sports than yes I agree they should pay some % of the money back

2013-03-01T05:27:38+00:00

Jaiden Florimo

Roar Rookie


Im still trying to work out how to say Hana Mandli...

2013-03-01T05:23:32+00:00

Kev

Guest


Not necessarily. If you're really that successful the benefits could roll on long after you retire such as media work or the speaking circuit. I don't think the HECS vs AIS/sports funding argument is that solid to be honest. They are two different beasts. HECS is relatively easier to qualify for and once you get your foot into the door of a university the bare minimum required to keep a place in the course isn't exactly back breaking. To qualify for AIS funding you have to demonstrate high performance in your sport over a period of time and while I don't know with certainty, I dare say that there are higher minimum standards that you are required to maintain without putting your funding and placement at risk it so it's not like people of any standard can qualify for it.

2013-03-01T05:06:11+00:00

Gordo

Guest


I now understand that Simba was attempting to not seem stupid for missing the bleeding obvious point of the article. Unfortunately his execution was very poor.

2013-03-01T04:46:49+00:00

dasilva

Guest


I could agree with that. Perhaps taxation of the earning related to sports could be the answer If you get a uni degree, that degree is there for life. Train to be an elite athlete and the benefits only last until the mid 30's at best

2013-03-01T04:13:04+00:00

Australian Rules

Guest


Given I'm Australian, and that I obvioulsy rule, I feel better placed than most to comment here. so here it is... it's unAustralian not to appreciate the irony in this article.

2013-03-01T03:27:19+00:00

mushi

Roar Guru


Or he could have tried a verbal delivery on Alan Jones. Probably would have taken old Al two weeks to realise he was joking

2013-03-01T03:25:49+00:00

mushi

Roar Guru


Are you certain it was his execution and not your comprehension? I think most people got it from the simple blurb on the front page.

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar