The top ten swing-men in the AFL

By SportsFingers / Roar Pro

With the fast paced nature of elite football these days, dual position players are now extremely important for all teams striving to play in September.

These players are the men who can swing the match in their favour, men like Harry Taylor who can go and kick a much-needed goal and then stop the other team’s key forward from doing the same, absolutely priceless.

But what makes a great dual-position player?

If you look at all the best swingman in football they share one thing in common, they excel in both their positions, they are in fact good enough to play solely one position and manage a long and decorated career.

Here are my top ten dual-position players in the AFL:

10. Craig Bird – Sydney Swans (Midfield/forward)
Craig is a vital part of the Swans team with an elite kicking style, and the ability to shut down the best of the best, whether it is in a tagging midfield role or a more defensive forward.

Bird has that knack for shutting down opponents similar to his predecessor Brett Kirk.

9. Dustin Martin – Richmond (Midfield/forward)
Now one of the best young players in the league, Dustin can always find a way to get into space and either score a goal or deliver a beautiful kick to hit Riewoldt or Vickery on the chest.

Normally playing as a midfielder, his average of more than a goal a game for his career is well above average.

8. Tom Rockliff – Brisbane Lions (Midfield/forward)
Initially overlooked by recruiters as a junior, Tom has become an important part of the midfield mechanics at the Lions.

Averaging just under 25 disposals a match, Rockliff would be much further up the list if only he kicked straighter, with only 7.8 for the year.

7. Ash McGrath – Brisbane Lions (Defender/midfield)
Ash is one of few players who at over the age of thirty can still perform at an extremely high level.

When starting his football career, McGrath made his name as a handy small forward for the Lions before adding another string to his bow as a strong, rebounding defender.

Ash has recently played on the wing as well, making him what recruiters call a triple threat.

6. Charlie Dixon – Gold Coast Suns (Defender/midfield)
Although he’s only played six games this year because of injury, Charlie has shown what he’s made of kicking 11 goals while playing primarily in defence.

Once back from injury Dixon will be a force to be reckoned with, rounding off an already talented Suns team.

5. Cyril Rioli – Hawthorn (Midfield/forward)
Cyril is best known for his forward line magic but after recently becoming a major contributor in the midfield he could quite possibly be in the All-Australian team for a second year in a row.

With an amazing career goal tally of 153 from 113 matches, it would be hard to believe a player could achieve this while juggling midfield responsibilities.

4. Lachie Henderson – Carlton (Forward/defence)
Probably one of the most underrated players in the AFL, Henderson has shown that he can match it with the best at both ends of the field.

As part of the Brendan Fevola trade many were sceptical that he would ever come close to the heights of the power forward they were losing, but after a shaky start Lachie developed in defence before his transition back in as a part time key forward.

He showed again on Saturday his ability, kicking four goals even though he spent half the match in defence, his efforts earned him a wrap from fellow defender Michael Jamison, Michael said he believes that Henderson is Carlton’s most important player right now.

3. Dean Cox – West Coast Eagles (Ruck/forward)
As one of the best big men in the comp, his goal-kicking ability is a massive bonus for an already complete player.

Averaging a crazy 26.5 hit outs a game, a stat alone that would be enough to guarantee him a spot in the side for as long as he wanted, he also has a very handy 11 goals to go along.

2. Harry Taylor – Geelong (Defender/forward)
Many believe Harry is the best dual position player in the AFL with his ability to score a quick goal when his team is in need.

Along with this Taylor is one of the best fullbacks in the league shutting down players like the number on my list.

1. Jarryd Roughead – Hawthorn (Forward/ruck)
Jarryd Roughead is the best dual position player in the AFL, leading the Coleman medal and also putting in valuable work in the middle.

Ranked second in the AFL for marks inside fifty, there is little doubt this Hawks gun should be anywhere but number one.

Who would be in your top ten? Comment below.

The Crowd Says:

2013-07-19T21:19:53+00:00

Myles Stedman

Roar Guru


Not an Essendon fan ey? You're missing out Jake Carlisle, Michael Hurley, Brendon Goddard. Personally, Tom, I think you've missed the mark with your definition of a swingman. Most midfielders are competent shots on goal, hell, mostly anyone on the ground is. You shouldn't be playing AFL if you're not. Simple as that. What you'll most likely see these days is coaches naming midfielders on the flanks, simply to get them into the 18. They don't necessarily spend any game time there. These days, most forwards/defenders are defined as either the big key targets, or the crumbling/rebounding players. A midfielder who happens to kick a lot of goals (a la Craig Bird, Dustin Martin, Tom Rockliff) are not really players I'd call a traditional "swingman".

2013-07-18T05:06:01+00:00

Nash Mitchell

Roar Rookie


Justin Westhoff and Jake Carsile should have a spot there!

2013-07-18T01:34:14+00:00

Winston

Guest


We'll just have to disagree then. Obviously you like him and I dont.

2013-07-17T23:23:43+00:00

macca

Guest


I would say it's simply a good midfielder.

2013-07-17T23:13:37+00:00

Shmick

Guest


Correct, but that's not a "swing man", that's simply a multi-positional player.

2013-07-17T22:59:58+00:00

macca

Guest


Most Midfielders can. For example Martin has kicked 17 goals from 15 games, Marc Murphy & Jobe Watson have 14 from 14, Ben Cunnington has 12 from 13.

2013-07-17T22:59:29+00:00

macca

Guest


Most Midfielders can. For example Martin has kicked 17 goals from 15 games, Marc Murphy & Jobe Watson have 14 from 14, Ben Cunnington has 12 from 13.

2013-07-17T14:53:26+00:00

Billy

Guest


Carlisle best at Essendon by an absolute mile...

AUTHOR

2013-07-17T11:30:46+00:00

SportsFingers

Roar Pro


However players like Dustin Martin can play a designated forward role not just 'for a rest'.

AUTHOR

2013-07-17T11:28:32+00:00

SportsFingers

Roar Pro


I agree and if he was full health i would have him right up there.

2013-07-17T11:18:57+00:00

Connor

Roar Rookie


I had a feeling that was why. He was great last year though.

2013-07-17T11:13:55+00:00

Shmick

Guest


I agree with the above comment. Many midfielders rest in the forward line in particular. My understanding of a true "swing man" is exactly that: a player that can swing from key posts at each end of the ground. Adding midfielders takes away from what could be an interesting list.

AUTHOR

2013-07-17T11:07:54+00:00

SportsFingers

Roar Pro


Lots of people said this, but I didn't put him on the list due to the fact that he was injured indefinitely.

2013-07-17T10:37:28+00:00

Connor

Roar Rookie


LRT should be on that list. Excellent up forward or in defence.

2013-07-17T08:24:18+00:00

jacksoon

Guest


I always assumed swingmen only referred to defenders who go forward and vice versa. My top 3 are 3. Ben Reid 2. Harry Taylor 1. Jake Carlisle. Roughead and Cox and even paddy Ryder are good ruck/forward swingman. But cyril, a, has missed too many games to be all australian, and b, doesnt get many possessions. Cyril is known for his speed, pressure, tackling and skill, but not a 30+ midfielder. Midfielder/forwards are not swingmen.

2013-07-17T07:18:45+00:00

Kristian

Guest


To not have Jake Carlisle in the list is ridiculous.

2013-07-17T06:08:39+00:00

Benny

Guest


LRT Forward and back in plenty of games 2013 grand final!!! Bird assessment by Winston is wrong He is both a good midfielder and half forward..and a shutdown player

2013-07-17T05:15:44+00:00

cliffh

Guest


Err . . . Adam Goodes . . . AFL Rising Star winner in 1999 playing in a number of positions . . . 2000 kicked 40 goals playing at CHF . . . Brownlow winner 2003 playing in the Ruck . . . 2004 played CHB all season after injuring knee . . . Brownlow winner 2006 playing on the wing . . . 2008 kicked 8 goals against Fremantle playing at FF . . . 2009 All Australian playing midfield . . . 2011 All Australian playing as a forward (mostly) Does that make him a useful swing-man?

2013-07-17T04:28:32+00:00

Steve J

Roar Guru


I think you're using the wrong definition :)

2013-07-17T03:55:45+00:00

Dane Eldridge

Expert


The AFL's greatest ever swinger is undoubtedly Wayne Carey.

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar