A hometown villain amongst the Wallaby heroes

By Matt Porter / Roar Guru

‘Well done England, now a second continent hates you as well’.

That’s how the petulant headline on the back page of today’s Courier Mail screamed the wash-up of the whitewash.

Despite a much-improved Wallaby performance the ignominy was all theirs. Swept for the worst domestic result in 44 years – not quite the momentum Michael Cheika and his men were after eight months on from contesting the World Cup final.

More of the wash-up from Wallabies vs England
» Five talking points from the match
» England whitewashes the Wallabies
» Match report: Wallabies go down in points-fest
» DIY Player Ratings
» Roar Forum: Wallabies to-do list for the Rugby Championship
» How hard does a Wallabies forward hit?
» Re-live the match with our live blog
» WATCH: The full match highlights

And Eddie Jones’ England were good for each of their three wins, achieved with superior physicality, strategy, execution, endurance and grit.

Last night they added a fair bit of endeavour to the mix to complement the astonishing defensive display from the week before.

But there were heroes on both sides in an enthralling contest that kept the record Sydney Football Stadium crowd raucous from woe to go – or go to woe for the Wallaby fans.

For the visitors Billy Vunipola epitomised the power and passion of the England pack with a monstrous game. The big No.8 carried the ball no fewer than 15 times for close to 50m and made ten tackles.

Brother Mako at loosehead wasn’t too far behind in the physicality stakes with one barnstorming run to lay the platform for the opening try to Dan Cole plus an astonishing game-high 18 tackles.

Pivot George Ford put in another tactical masterclass while outside him Owen Farrell was deserved man of the match, keeping the scoreboard ticking over in England’s favour, banging over nine of his ten kicks for 23 points.

The Aussies played like a team the team they were – already on the wrong end of history and desperate to avoid the clean sweep. Sean McMahon more than justified Cheika’s faith in playing him out of position at No.8 with a game that bristled with aggression and intent. On a number of his 14 runs he scattered defenders despite giving away ten to 15kg on them.

McMahon hunted brilliantly in tandem with openside Michael Hooper who put in another rampant effort. Their terrorising of the world’s angriest fullback Mike Brown was a joy to watch.

James Slipper tackled himself to a standstill while his Queensland mate Rob Simmons should be dropped more often if it results in the sort of hard-shouldered running he produced before an injury to one of those shoulders restricted his involvement to just the first half.

The big rig of Will Skelton kept the English defenders honest until a lack of match fitness saw him fade with half an hour to go.

Matt Toomua did everything that was asked of him at inside centre – setting a rapid defensive line and making some telling hits while asking questions with his no-nonsense attack.

One of his three line breaks led to the lovely inside ball to set Israel Folau – who was again imperious – racing away for his try in the 59th minute. And Dane Haylett-Petty proved again why he is the Wallaby find of the season with another accomplished display.

He’s one of those Ben Smith-type players with an uncanny knack of creating things seemingly out of nothing. Also like Smith he has a ram-rod straight back, so straight it’s virtually concave – maybe that helps elude clutching defenders?

So there were heroes aplenty, but unfortunately for the Wallabies there was a villain in their midst and he cost them a game that was there for the winning.

That clutcher of defeat from victory was Nick Phipps. Before I go on can I just say that you cannot fault the Aussie halfback’s commitment and tenacity. Like in every game, last night he covered huge tracts of land and proved again he is one of the best defensive scramblers going around. But Test halfbacks need to be so much more than that.

Phipps is much criticised for his laboured pass and dwell time at the base of rucks and mauls.

That was in evidence again last night but the Wallabies were coping. The real collateral damage he inflicted came from some crucial errors and indiscipline at key times.

The most telling to the Wallabies’ chances came in consecutive blunders deep in the final quarter that led to England scoring the ten points that were the winning of the game.

The first came in the 67th minute with the Wallabies desperately hanging on to a 32-31 lead. Phipps attempted to dive pass a loose ball to Folau on his own 22.

Instead, he somehow rocketed the ball along the ground and watched helplessly, like the rest of us, as it cannoned off Folau’s boot into the grateful arms of the English who swept onto the attack that led directly to a try to replacement hooker Jamie George. Successful conversion, 38-32 to England.

Then, with time up but the Wallabies still within range of a converted try at 35-41, it was Phipps who snuffed out any sniff with a blatant offside at a ruck. A gleeful Farrell kicked the penalty that sealed Australia’s fate.

Just how costly that indiscretion was became apparent a minute later when Taqele Naiyaravoro scored the home side’s fifth – albeit unconverted – try.

Not to harp on, but it was a Phipps’ knock on in at the base of a ruck in the 37th minute that cost his team some serious momentum inside the English 22m heading into the break.

Previous to that he had raised the ire of ref Nigel Owens when he pleaded with him to yellow card one of the English. A petition that rightly received a sharp rebuke.

Assuming Cheika saw Phipps lurch from one calamity to the next, why didn’t he hook him and give Nick Frisby a go? Even for the last 10? It couldn’t have been any worse and might just have been better?

Wallaby fans can play along with the headline and hate England all they want, but it was one of their own that cost them the game.

The Crowd Says:

2016-06-28T03:48:27+00:00

Arvind H

Guest


Also at the game and agree with this, Phipps had a shocker and while one poor performance can be forgiven I just don't rate him at test level on what he's produced so far. Genia would have been a huge upgrade, but as we wasn't available not sure why Frisby was kept on ice? Jones has made some decisive early subs this series that have had an impact on the game and Cheika could learn from that. The player who I think the Wallabies missed the most in this series was Giteau for his kicking and decision making and providing an extra focal point to control attack. Our in play kicking was terrible and Gits has a great boot. It was a major difference between the two sides, Australia had terrible game management and the English rarely set a foot wrong.

2016-06-27T00:26:19+00:00

Old Bugger

Guest


Said the Pot, calling the Kettle black or, should it be white.....haha??

2016-06-27T00:13:00+00:00

Ruckin' Oaf

Guest


England 2003 / 2004 were the number one team in the world based on a very well executed 10 man game. And the All Blacks are masters at creating errors to feast upon.

2016-06-26T23:54:46+00:00

Hoy

Roar Guru


I am pretty sure the All Blacks have shown previously you can be number 1 in the world by a significant margin simply by feeding on opposition errors...

2016-06-26T17:55:09+00:00

Sir Eddie

Guest


Geez you Australians are a fickle bunch!!

2016-06-26T10:01:54+00:00

taylorman

Roar Guru


I'm not advocating 10 man rugby, far from it. I'm suggesting variation of the theme of 'all out attack' in a way that it caters for the current skilset. Currently oz can't play a fully attacking style reliably. They need to apply smarts but that does start with selection. Clearly Kerevi should have played this match. Based on the way it went, he could have made the difference, in hindsight of course.

2016-06-26T09:56:04+00:00

buster

Guest


That is worthy of consideration. From left field but I think he would be a natural.

2016-06-26T09:50:23+00:00

buster

Guest


Once again NZ rugby has shown us how it is done. Replacing 11 players in the last match of a 3 match series, and winning better than the first 15 selection in the two previous matches? Cheika is not the Messiah, and Waratah centric rugby will kill Australian Rugby.There, it had to be said.

2016-06-26T09:47:32+00:00

KTinHK

Roar Pro


Totally agree about Phipps. He had a shocker! Why wasn't Frisby given a run......??

2016-06-26T09:42:44+00:00

buster

Guest


Sorry, there is no defence, not at that level. His courage, and commitment are not questioned. Walking thru the ruck, pushing the other no 9? Does he even know the rules? The pass along the ground? Unforgivable, at that level. That close to the try line. We have this conversation after each game, lately. Not that his mate, Foley, was squeaky clean. That flick pass back to no one, which resulted in the first English try. WTF!.Giteau is coming back. Giteau and Toomea, along with Frisby, would be worth a try.

2016-06-26T08:51:13+00:00

Country boy

Guest


@Peter, test rugby is not the place for flashy rugby, you play to win. Period!

2016-06-26T06:48:30+00:00

Johnny Boy Jnr

Guest


I agree. Phipps is reminding me more and more of a Luke Burgess - all the courage and right intent but without the skills to back it up

2016-06-26T06:30:02+00:00

moaman

Roar Guru


"I’d suggest him for centre' What about halfback?

2016-06-26T06:15:57+00:00

wardad

Guest


Do the Wallabies practice their drills for clearing from their own 22 ? On a one point lead tossing it willy nilly to Folau ?

2016-06-26T06:09:52+00:00

Martin English

Roar Rookie


McMahon hunted brilliantly in tandem with openside Michael Hooper who put in another rampant effort. Their terrorising of the world’s angriest fullback Mike Brown was a joy to watch. Hooper is an excellent Rugby player. He is not a good loose forward. A typical example of his 'mastery of the position' was where he went missing on a 5 metre scrum, which let Vunipola score (around 45th minute). Given Hooper was packing on the blindside, he straight out went to sleep. I often saw him standing back from the breakdown waving his arms around (directing traffic or what ?). If he had a little more weight, I'd suggest him for centre, while selectors went looking for a real number 7.

2016-06-26T04:04:36+00:00

AndyS

Guest


What happened to all the folk who complained about the Wallabies play and contended that entertaining losses would be better all around than boring wins? That was certainly an entertaining loss...

2016-06-26T03:51:03+00:00

Ruckin' Oaf

Guest


"what has the NRC got to do with international rugby" Um they are both games of rugby. You know played by rugby players with a rugby ball on a rugby field. International rugby is not a different game to rugby. "have you learnt nothing in the past 10 years ?" I've picked up another degree but I doubt that's what you mean. However I don't really understand the rest of your comment or what your point is.

2016-06-26T03:42:35+00:00

Cadfael

Roar Guru


Kicking was a problem for both Foley and Toomua. Both couldn't find the line hen they needed to, England's last try came after another line kick failed to find the line. Apart from his kicking, Toomua had a good game. it showed we needed to have a 12 there not a second 13. With Toomua off to Pommieland who will be our 12. CLL just doesn't look the goods. Maybe Godwin or Hunt?

2016-06-26T03:25:56+00:00

Peter Hughes

Roar Rookie


Oaf - what has the NRC got to do with international rugby ?? have you learnt nothing in the past 10 years ? Yes you can play a limited feed on errors game but you can't be No 1 in the world that way - or even no 2. Wales have changed, England have changed. Argentina have changed because they had too. The top 5 nations don't make many mistakes & they just carve you up in attack ie ALL BLACKS.

2016-06-26T02:56:56+00:00

Andy

Guest


Agree on Phipps. He hasn't improved on these points in the last 4 years. Hence, I can't see him getting better anytime soon. Frisby has a higher ceiling imo. Need to get him involved. I don't think Phipps is a bad player he's just not international standard. Simple. And I doubt he ever will be. So let's try something different

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar