Why Queensland will win State of Origin Game 3

By Patrick Effeney / Editor

A whitewash looms for a refreshed New South Wales side. For Queensland, it’s a further chance to cement a unique and remarkable legacy that’s been building since Johnathan Thurston and Cameron Smith first pulled on the maroon jumper.

Game 2 was simply the opposite of Game 1. Both teams came to play, having been particularly guarded, even by Origin standards, in the series opener.

There were intercept tries, winger tries, a great chase from Tyson Frizell that will go down as one of the great ‘almost’ moments of Origin, halves playing games with opposition defences, and enough twists to make both teams believe anything was possible.

Origin football at its best, in stark contrast to the dire hitup-fest that was Game 1.

More Origin
» Laurie Daley’s survival guide: How many points can he lose by?
» Why NSW will win Game 3
» Final NSW Blues and Queensland Maroons line-ups
» Expert tips and predictions

Sadly for NSW, with Adam Reynolds’ early departure from the match, it was a case of two against one. Johnathan Thurston and Cooper Cronk were magnificent, and Cameron Smith earned man of the match plaudits for a masterful display of control from the base of the ruck.

What to take out of two deeply contrasting examples then, and how does is all apply to the final Origin of 2016?

I don’t see another 6-4 game at ANZ Stadium this time around. There was a bit of rain around Sydney over the weekend, but the last two days have been dry and sunny, with tomorrow dry but chilly. It could be down as low as nine degrees by the time the game kicks off, which could be a rude shock to Queenslanders travelling from their base on the Gold Coast (then again, NSW do train out of the similarly lovely Coffs Harbour).

So let’s ditch all this talk about wet-track, dry-track, and focus on what matters – who’s going to play better football tonight?

Queensland are a well-oiled machine. Arguably, they’ve weakened their team by including Nate Myles, who’s coming in on limited game time, but he is a seasoned performer and has the temperament required for Origin. He makes no mistakes, runs educated lines and will tackle as long as he’s on the field.

I don’t think he’ll spend long out there though. Josh McGuire will likely play more minutes from the bench than Myles does as a starter, and Jacob Lillyman will also see a lot of action.

If those three, along with Matt Scott, hold parity against what is a very good NSW forward pack, they’ll have earned their post-match XXXX.

Where the Maroons have the distinct advantage is around the edges, where Darius Boyd, Johnathan Thurston, Cooper Cronk and Cameron Smith have been terrific.

It’s not that these guys do anything particularly flashy, but the execution of all the plays is a level above what NSW are capable of producing right now – when you’ve played 20-odd games together at representative level, you’d expect them to execute better than James Maloney and Jack Bird.

The team that New South Wales have selected scares me. Laurie Daley has brought in players who will be prototypical rugby league examples in the future.

Jack Bird and James Tedesco don’t fit a traditional style of any position, which is perhaps why Bird’s been shopped around from the halves to the centres at club level. What they both do is run particularly well, are big for the position they play, and can break tackles through the ferocity of their play. Both are also good defenders, with Tedesco’s positioning in defence a step above the man he’s replacing, Matt Moylan. That immediately means fewer headaches for Laurie Daley when Cronk, Thurston and Smith have the ball in their hand close to the line.

But you can’t expect excellent players to gel within 80 minutes. As a Queensland fan, selections like these do make me worry about next year, but the focus for this match will be on who can deliver their outside backs the better quality ball. And nine times out of ten I believe the answer to that question to be Queensland.

Put Josh Dugan up against Greg Inglis, Michael Jennings up against Justin O’Neill, or compare the wingers, and I don’t see any upper hand for either team.

If NSW get a roll on in the forwards then they hold the distinct advantage, possessing big bodies who also can use footwork and deceptive pace to bully their Queensland opponents.

But at 1, 6, 7 and 9, Queensland are a dominant prospect.

For that reason, they will win Game 3 and take out a hard-fought, entertaining series in a whitewash.

The Crowd Says:

2016-07-13T06:24:40+00:00

Dave_S

Guest


Patrick, as you say: "Where the Maroons have the distinct advantage is around the edges ... Darius Boyd, Johnathan Thurston, Cooper Cronk and Cameron Smith" I said it in another post in response to a comments that Qld "want it more" etc - these games are so tight they usually come down to key position players doing the one-percenters the best. Has a rugby league team ever had a bunch of key position players capable of doing the one-percenters better than Boyd, JT, Smith and Cronk? Hard to think of one.

2016-07-13T05:55:49+00:00

Sid

Guest


Because NSW dont give a toss?

2016-07-13T03:41:54+00:00

Christov

Guest


Something for NSW to contemplate. Cameron Smith, 2003 debut, three origin series losses before 2006 success. Jonathan Thurston, 2005 debut, one origin series loss before 2006 success. Whoever NSW selects to be long-term players they better give them time in the position. Sure it didn't work out for Mitchell Pearce but you have to see a player of the future and stick with them. there are probably another few QLD players which started before the 2006 break through, you have to stick solid.

2016-07-13T03:34:48+00:00

jamesb

Guest


Moving forward, the worst case scenario for Origin is NSW getting smashed tonight with those new players that you've mentioned.

2016-07-13T03:17:37+00:00

Remo Shankar

Roar Pro


I think what we're experiencing here in NSW is a 'surface' level of disinterest. It's a way of protecting ourselves and not getting our hopes up. I reckon there's a lot of people in NSW who are hurting bad over all this and who will still be intently keeping an eye on the match tonight, hoping like hell that tonight the new breed (Tedesco, Moylan, Bird, Frizzel, Graham, Klemmer and Jackson) will give us real hope for the future. And if they get smashed tonight? I don't even want to think about it.

2016-07-13T02:31:39+00:00

JVGO

Guest


Seriously no one cares at this stage. Certainly no one in NSW. Any victory would be meaningless anyway. Maybe next year people will get interested but probably not. It will just be more of the same. There's only so much you can take of this stuff. An undeserved win would be more of a piss off than a loss actually, after so many narrow losses in games they should have won. What will the crowd be? 12,500? It has got to the stage that fans are actually avoiding watching the game.

2016-07-13T02:29:45+00:00

Maroon man

Guest


It will be a long time before I get sick of QLD winning....in fact, I never will.

2016-07-13T01:28:41+00:00

josh

Roar Rookie


Has Origin been cancelled nest year and replaced with just JT kicking conversions from different spots on the field.

2016-07-13T01:05:53+00:00

Griffo

Guest


Oh yeah.

2016-07-13T01:04:29+00:00

Griffo

Guest


"Queensland are out on their feet", or, "Look how bunched the maroons are behind the play the ball", are a couple of my Phil Gould favourites. As Rampaging Roy Slaven used to say of the great thinkers, "There's Confucius, Buddha, Edward de Bono and Gus Gould."

2016-07-12T23:59:16+00:00

Kaks

Roar Guru


Paddy, commendable effort writing as much as you did when all you really needed to do was write the names "Jonathon Thurston, Cooper Cronk & Cameron Smith" and everyone would have agreed with the article.

2016-07-12T23:44:25+00:00

jamesb

Guest


I love origin, but it has become just as dull as Ashes cricket in the nineties. The worst thing that can happen in a sporting contest is when one side dominates for a long long time, just like the kiwis in the Bledisloe. Imagine following the Wallabies and NSW over the last decade or so. Sure, you can appreciate Qld and NZ, but the end of the day, you want a contest. Another win for Qld tonight might be great for their legacy, but it'd be a terrible blow for origin in the short term. A Qld clean sweep and two games in Brisbane next year. Good luck to that person who is marketing it.

2016-07-12T23:04:42+00:00

Republican

Guest


This contest is as ground hog day as the Bledisloe Cup truth be told..........

2016-07-12T22:57:16+00:00

Tom Rock

Expert


I have been waiting for a Phil Gould 'the loser leaves the country' line for years. Hope he busts it out tonight. Makes as little sense now as it did then.

2016-07-12T22:33:11+00:00

elroncho

Guest


Qld will win, because at some point Phil Gould will claim " they're gone these Qlders" as he has done for every series for the last eleven years, sparking a Qld victory.

AUTHOR

2016-07-12T22:24:10+00:00

Patrick Effeney

Editor


We were going to swap it around, but Joe forgot. I'm glad he did.

2016-07-12T22:12:55+00:00

Oingo Boingo

Guest


Writing this article must have been like selling a bottle of water to man dying of thirst... I don't admire Joe Frosts assignment though.

2016-07-12T21:31:11+00:00

James

Guest


Yes, it will be a high voltage game..

Read more at The Roar