If I was fined $20,000 for every stupid thing I’d done on the drink, I would be $4.76 million worse off.
Growing up in your early twenties in Canberra you’d go to the Private Bin and get right on it. It was a 24-hour booze barn and we drank like mad Irish fish.
Myself and three mates once stumbled out of there at 6am, got in a car and drove to Sydney. Drank stubbies all the way.
We laughed about it then. Shake heads now. Shiver up the spine stuff. Lucky to be alive. Luckier still we didn’t kill someone.
James Roberts has done a few stupid things on the drink – that we, the people, know of – and is at his fourth NRL club.
The most recent incidents have seen him fined $20,000 by Brisbane Broncos for bringing their brand into disrepute.
On separate occasions, reportedly, depending what you read, he got on the piss, was refused service by a bar maid, spat on a staff member, was choked to sleep by a bouncer, woke up in an ambulance, escaped it, and continued on on his not-so-merry way into the night.
Roberts was not arrested on either evening but was issued a fine for public nuisance. And the Broncos topped that up by $20,000.
Fair cop? It’s not about fair. It’s relative. If 22-year-old me had carried like on that, effectively nothing would have happened apart from said fine. Bouncer and ambos would shake their heads. They might ban me from the pub.
But I wouldn’t have been fined $20,000 by the Department of Defence for what was effectively stock-standard anti-social stupid drunk stuff by a 20-something dickhead.
But Roberts is judged differently. He’s a famous footy player and held to a different standard. He’s judged differently because he’s paid differently. (Click to Tweet)
And fact is he’s not a 22-year-old public servant. He’s a famous employee of a footy club. He’s on, what, four hundred grand?
And when you’re a famous footy player, the club and the governing body – the code – sees you as the living, breathing embodiment of their all-important brand. You’re an ambassador every time you walk out the house. You represent.
And branding is important. Because branding is money. And if you represent that, if you’re responsible for the brand – if you’re one of the fonts of the money and paid commensurately – then you’re an important person and expected to be responsible.
I’m not saying it’s right, necessarily, that Roberts cops a $20k fine and the “normal” dickhead doesn’t. That said it’d probably be good if all young men were fined $20,000 for being dickheads, we might have a nicer society.
Either way, it is what it is. And it’s because of television.
Advertisers and sponsors don’t want their brand associated with your brand if your brand’s representative – the famous footballer – gets on the television for being a dickhead.
Of course those Roosters fans lining up to decry the relative lenience of Roberts’ punishment – $20k, no suspension – to that of their man Mitchell Pearce – $125,000 and eight weeks out that effectively shafted the club’s entire season – have a pretty good point.
The big difference, it seems, in the NRL’s mind between the Pearce thing – which was a tasteless dumb gag – versus the Roberts thing – which sounds like an anti-social drunken rampage – was because the former’s antics were captured on video.
No video, it’s like it didn’t happen.
Roberts’ antic have only been outed in print. It’s a bad thing to read – “he spat on a bar maid” – but if you see it on video, it’s like he’s spat on you. The horror!
If we don’t see him doing it on the news or YouTube or wherever, we don’t feel like it’s actually happened.
And the NRL knows it. They know us, the people. Know what we’ll cop. And the advertisers know it. And the Broncos know it. And the lesson for you, 20-something tearaway footy player on the lash – is don’t get caught on tape.
Roberts hasn’t been outed on tape, at least not yet (though you’d think there’s security footage waiting to be sold somewhere). And thus the NRL, perhaps admitting to themselves that Pearce’s punishment was far too strong, have deemed that the Broncos punishment is OK. That twenty large is not to be sneezed at.
The NRL has the power to come over the top and add further punishments if they don’t feel the club has been strong enough. In this case they’ve given the Broncos a pass.
The money, the counselling, the programs, the community service, the “total plan for James’ development and wellbeing,” according to the club.. The sympathy for a troubled soul, the empathy of men for young ones.
But fair? Nothing to do with fair. It is what it is.
And Jimmy Roberts is lucky to still be playing footy. Lucky he’s very good at it, anyway.
soapit
Roar Guru
is it technically assault?
soapit
Roar Guru
i think most brisbane pubs would be pretty keen to stay in the broncos good books
The EYE-BALL Opinion
Roar Pro
Yes, but the question sill remains, did he think before he expressed the thought ... having expressed the thought does not mean he thought about it before he expressed it ... the comment "Being stupid isn’t a crime?" would suggest that he did not think about what he is saying ... stupidity leads to many crimes, some life taking ...
Matt Cleary
Expert
Thanks mate.
Con Scortis
Roar Guru
By definition if you have expressed a thought then you have thought, so "please think before you express a thought" doesn't make any sense.
Wilson
Guest
You mean like how the AFL work?
Don
Roar Rookie
You're a good man Muzz.
The EYE-BALL Opinion
Roar Pro
... and no beers after ...
Muzz
Guest
@ Mr Annoying Orange. No one talks to the Don like that. He's one of the more respected posters in this site. 2 laps of the oval and 20 push ups, son.
The EYE-BALL Opinion
Roar Pro
Of course being stupid can end up being a crime - just ask all those drunk drivers in jail for the damage they did whilst driving drunk. That is stupid right ... so being stupid whilst drunk is a crime waiting to happen - how many king hiy deaths have you read about? Please think before you express a thought.
The EYE-BALL Opinion
Roar Pro
You sound like a parent making excuses for your own kids bad behaviour ... actions have reactions and consequences. How responsible were you at 22 ... that was a long time ago for me - some 40 years and I can tell you bad behaviour is just bad behaviour ... if you know you have a problem with the drink, don't drink. Find some other way to let off steam that does not get you into trouble. As an athlete and having energy after training sessions to go out and party means you did not really put in during the training session - that's old school.
Geoff Parkes
Expert
Great piece Matt - and superb opening line!
Don
Roar Rookie
Slow down. I'd say if Roberts did it again he'd cop a hammering in the press too. Blake ferguson was convicted of indecent assault relating to an incident the night before he entered an origin camp. I'd expect with that in his rap sheet he would be prime junk news for further misdemeanors. Plus his photo with his mate on the roof drinking coolers when they were supposed to be training. Pearce has been hit with the double whammy of both incidents being on video. Perfect for the media mill and click generators. Can't beat vision. Ignore the context - just show the vision and then add your own narrative - its a beautiful thing for a media business. "Don't worry about the truth, just watch the vision again, isn't it great? He must be guilty of something surely? No? Being stupid isn't a crime? Well just watch that beautiful vision again. We'll come up with something. Just drunk in a private setting with a lack of bladder control and being mean to fluffy dogs? Is that it? By the way, lock up the cat and make sure no one films grandad this Christmas..."
Matt Cleary
Expert
Nah, but I was a computer dude in the Dept of Defence. Like most public servants. It's office johnnie stuff. You aren't representing the Dept when you're on the drink at the Bin, you're just a regular nong. And it's just how it is. Jimmy ... I had a yarn with Scott Gourley about players playing up in his "day" and he was like, yeah, we got up to more stuff, but we knew we could. These dudes today, on massive money, can put it all in jeopardy by doing stupid stuff on the piss. Most realise that. But you can't put heads on statues, is a saying I think possibly applies in this instance.
Matt Cleary
Expert
Oh, y'know, for a bit of perspective in this crazy old mixed up world of sports gibber-jabber.
Matt Cleary
Expert
Nah - I said it was "stock-standard anti-social stupid drunk stuff by a 20-something dickhead". Not that it was normal behaviour for a 23-year-old. And yeah I agree, there'd have to be footage of it. The pubs have just kept it mum. I'm also not sure he'll pay the fine but he has been fined, so ... it seems we are in complete agreement.
Bugs
Guest
What's the view like up there on your high horse? Yes, what he did was stupid and dumb and grotesque. But he's 22, with a STACK of disposable income, AND he's been told his whole life that he is special, mecurial, awesome etc. Easy to see why he would occasionally, or even frequently, behave like a dickhead. How many people do you know that aren't special, and don't earn $400k/yr and STILL behave in this way. Would we be any better in his position? He needs to be better, but really, he's a kid. It's all got to his head. Strong old heads - like Bennett - influencing him are just what he needs
Billyboy
Guest
It would be interesting this weekend if Pearce, Blake Ferguson, Josh Dugan went out, got on the juice refused to leave a pub if asked and just for the hell of it hocked a golly on some poor female nearby what would follow. I am thinking internet meltdown and a forest cut down to mill the extra paper required for all the outrage. I think the NRL might even go a bit harder. That would not mean the Bronco's are protected though, would it???????
northerner
Guest
Actually, I doubt that it has been put to bed. This particular incident yes; the underlying problem, not at all. The man needs help.
PNG Broncos fan88
Guest
Haha good to hear all your concern for the Broncos. JR apologized to his team mates and club, coach. They are all preparing for Melbourne tonite and the finals to come, this matter has been put to bed. Move on, all you righteous souls.