Marcus Bontempelli will end the year as the AFL's best player

By Ryan Buckland / Expert

He’s just three seasons into what will be a long AFL career, but the Western Bulldogs’ Marcus Bontempelli is ready to take the mantle of the game’s best player.

It feels like Bontempelli has been a feature of the AFL’s tapestry for a decade, such has been the fervour his first 63 games have whipped up among football aficionados.

The Dogs’ No.4 draft pick from 2013 debuted as the great white hope of a team mired in the middle phase of rebuild.

His was an auspicious debut year, playing the final 14 games of the season after a Round 7 injury, averaging 17 disposals, 3.5 tackles, eight contested possessions and 2.5 clearances in a team that won just four games.

History shows the AFL Rising Star voting panel erred in awarding Brisbane’s Lewis Taylor the title, even if Bontempelli lost by a single vote, despite playing eight fewer games.

Bontempelli has never really looked back, playing 47 of the subsequent 49 games, being part of a premiership team, winning his club’s best and fairest count in the premiership year, and generally earning the kind of universal praise and respect reserved for the top half a per cent of players in the game.

He is the cover star of the AFL’s upcoming AFL Live video game, winning around 70 per cent of the fan vote in an 18-man race.

His 2016 season was excellent, if a bit slow starting by way of impact, due to a hip injury he carried into the year. His third year, 20-vote performance in last year’s Brownlow medal, was better than all but one medal winner of the past ten years. No, really.

The Bulldogs superstar plays something of a unique role for a superstar: when his game is stripped down, it becomes clear Bontempelli is effectively a utility.

That is normally a characterisation reserved for the bottom four or so players in a team’s best 22, but for Bontempelli, it is a marker of how good he is at a range of football skills.

In his 68 game career, Bontempelli has had:

Bontempelli has demonstrated flexibility that might be unprecedented in the AFL – at least in the modern era.

This is partly due to the scheme of Dogs coach Luke Beveridge, which requires most of his players to be useful across the ground.

Plenty of players can play inside or outside midfield, can take marks forward or backward of centre, switch from tag to attack, but none can claim to do multiple things at a very high level.

He combines the poise, steadiness and decision making of Scott Pendlebury – although the Collingwood captain is still the AFL’s “lord of bullet time” as Jay Croucher likes to say – with the frame and skills of a key position player.

One of his plays of the year came against Collingwood, when Bontempelli broke free of a stoppage, sucked in five Pies as he galloped forward, allowing Lin Jong to get space before the maestro hit him with a perfect release handpass.

Inside forward 50, Bontempelli is as comfortable dealing with a groundball as a high marking opportunity.

His highlight videos are chock full of scores created by knock ons and other light-touch wizardry.

He creates just as many scoring opportunities for his teammates as he snaffles for himself in these situations.

Around the ground, Bontempelli has the gait of a baby giraffe, but the momentum of an African elephant. He’s nearly untackleable when he breaks into a run, his powerful, long strides difficult for all but the best stoppers to contain.

In a meta-game that prioritises the quick lateral or backwards handball, Bontempelli runs in straight lines through opponents. It’s a ‘see ball, win ball’ mentality that coaches everywhere spend entire seasons drumming into their players’ heads; Bontempelli knows no other way.

Patrick Dangerfield is unique for his combination of straight line pace and long kicking, which makes him a metres-gained machine.

Nat Fyfe combines savant-like ball-winning abilities on the ground with an aerial prowess rarely seen in a midfielder.

Scott Pendlebury never makes a bad decision. Ever.

Josh P Kennedy uses his leverage to extract possessions when it shouldn’t be possible.

Lance Franklin is the league’s best small forward, in a key forward’s body.

Dustin Martin is the football equivalent of Hugh Jackman’s Wolverine.

Jedi Knight Alex Rance could stop a freight train if they allowed them on a football field.

I have no reason to believe Sam Mitchell is not an amoeba that has taken the form of a human, such is his ability to contort his body to make footballs do things they aren’t supposed to.

At his peak, Gary Ablett Jr could accumulate possession between the arcs at a rate that seems impossible. Now he might become the best small forward in the game – we will see.

These players that sit at the upper echelons of the league today – the top one per cent – are what I have grown to call game changers. They are rare players who can swing a contest through their own actions.

Bontempelli could already be in this class of player, but if he’s not then 2017 is the year.

How? With a central role in the Western Bulldogs’ title defence, which looks more like it is on track than most pundits will have you believe.

As the Dogs continue to evolve under Beveridge, it is reasonable to expect Bontempelli to continue to create more of the team’s offence out of stoppages and congestion, and to spend time as a threatening option inside 50.

There’s a universe in which Bontempelli kicks 1.5 goals a game and averages close to 30 touches a game. There’s also a universe in which he kicks two a game with 20 touches. In either case, the Dogs attacking sets will flow through him.

It could end with a finish near the pointy end in this year’s Brownlow medal count. If you ask me, regardless of his position in the Brownlow, 2017 will end with Marcus Bontempelli considered the best player in the game.

The Crowd Says:

2017-03-12T21:03:21+00:00

MNEAL18

Roar Rookie


I agree that Bontempelli will be an absolute champion of the game but if Fyfe gets back to his form of early 2015 no one can match him for the mantle of number 1 player in the game. He is every bit as good as Bontempelli with midfield craft, maybe not as silky. I would rate Fyfe a better mark, especially contested. That is what sets him apart. We may have forgotten how good Fyfe was/is due to his injuries since his early 2015 form

2017-03-04T13:13:21+00:00

mattyb

Guest


Hey PD,how you been mate? I really think you need to be including Macrae in that group of players. Had a hand in nearly every one of our goals. Morris was also brilliant. I've watched the game many times and my votes have changed often.

2017-03-04T06:21:23+00:00

Brendon the 1st

Guest


I reckon Heeney from Sydney will ne right up there with.the bont in 2018, similar footballers. Heeney might be a bit more skillful, he's a one on one machine

2017-03-04T00:32:52+00:00

Bobby

Guest


Cat you are the king of being passive aggressive. I'm embarrassed to have you as a fellow cats fan

2017-03-03T21:05:44+00:00

Bobby

Guest


Danger was 20% better than every other player last year. If bont finishes as the best, it would have to be due to Danger slowing down

2017-03-03T15:05:30+00:00

Freo As

Guest


No. No he won't.

2017-03-03T10:47:09+00:00

Pumping Dougie

Guest


I agree. Late in the game I thought it would be between him, Boyd, Wood and Picken for the Norm Smith (JJ was too wasteful). Bont was sublime throughout the game.

2017-03-03T09:00:42+00:00

Cat

Roar Guru


So if I have this right coaches are happy if their players go third up and players go third up on their own because they think it helps yet some administrator decided they know better because a ruckman might possibly, maybe, someday might get hurt for which we have zero verifiable cases to back it up with and some paywalled statistic that had never before been seen? Yeah definitely sounds like a legit rule change #sarcasm #eyeroll #dontbeleiveit #stupid

2017-03-03T08:16:53+00:00

Philthy

Roar Rookie


If you are comparing Bontempelli to Judd, well Judd is quoted as saying he reached his physical peak at about 23. If Bont is comparable to Judd, this gives the Bont about 2-3 years of development left. His very high percentage effective disposal rate will make him almost unstoppable if he can attract more of the ball as a consequence of any additional development. In the GF last year, he went missing for patches of the game. Something that he needs to address and something that does not seem to afflict Fyfe. When he did get the ball in the GF his effective use percentage makes him a candidate for Norm Smith except for the quiet periods. All in all, there is probably no better candidate to become the competition's premier player, but it's far from certain that this will happen.

2017-03-03T05:23:56+00:00

DB

Guest


Joel Selwood got 16 votes in his 3rd year

2017-03-03T05:21:06+00:00

Josh

Expert


Absolutely - he was ace in the granny too, I would've given the Norm to JPK or Picken, but Bont third behind them.

2017-03-03T05:20:15+00:00

Josh

Expert


Haha pretend you didn't hear it AD.

2017-03-03T05:19:53+00:00

Josh

Expert


Any of Browny's goals in the eliminator. Phwoar

2017-03-03T05:16:07+00:00

Another Paul

Guest


When I said 'aggressive' I wasn't saying you shouldn't be having a discussion with Cam all I was saying is that he answered your comment above and since then it seems like you have jumped on all his comments with an aggressive/pointed question. The 'pointed' here is referring to your logic trap. I wasn't accusing you of asking a direct question rather a question that you already have an opinion on but have chosen not to give making it difficult for others to have a discussion. It's rude because you are basically making someone argue against themselves. If you had simply put what you have explained here, along with your question to Cam above, then I would interpret that as being more of a friendly discussion. That's all, Now in answer to how the Bont is being used, Cam gave one answer below. I also think that it's partly due to how he plays, he likes to read the game from a distance and if he sees an opportunity he takes it and I think Beveridge gives him the license to do that, the Bont isn't thinking I shouldn't go 3rd man because I need more clearances he is just making a judgement call moment by moment.

2017-03-03T05:05:45+00:00

Pumping Dougie

Roar Guru


Aye Cam.

2017-03-03T04:59:57+00:00

Slane

Guest


Come on Cam, don't tell me you've ever gone to the footy specifically because you couldn't wait to see a genuine, true-blue, one-on-one ruck contest. I'd have thought that generally the ruckmen would be the least skillful player on the ground.

2017-03-03T04:57:51+00:00

Another Paul

Guest


haha, okay fair enough

2017-03-03T04:54:54+00:00

I hate pies

Guest


That's a pretty good goal; quite similar really. Did it win goal of the year? It should have, just like Bonts.

2017-03-03T04:54:35+00:00

Slane

Guest


I'm with you on this one PD. In my experience the person most likely to injure a ruckmen is a ruckmen. I don't see how they deserve special treatment over anybody else.

2017-03-03T04:47:40+00:00

Steve J

Roar Guru


18 votes from 19 games in 2013 for Fyfe (not 22 games - 3 games were finals) .. that's 0.94 votes per game (better than Bonts 0.91 average in 2016)... so Bont would probably hope for a "dip" in form like Fyfe's 4th year :) In games where he didn't poll his worst effort was a 19 possession, 5 clearances, 5 inside 50's, 2 goal effort against GWS in a 113 point win ... where somehow Nick Suban got the 3 votes. He got 27 or more disposals in 6 games where he didn't get a vote Also copped the mandatory final round rest game from Ross in round 23

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar