Melbourne Storm's top ten players

By BigJ / Roar Guru

As we all know I love a good countdown list. With Matt Cleary beating me to the punch and doing a top 100 players list, it got me thinking that I should do a top ten players list for each team.

For this list it is going to be difficult but I have set myself some rules. Firstly, all current teams will have a list along with past teams (Jets, Magpies, Tigers, Steelers, and Bears). Teams such as the Crushers, Reds, Mariners, Seagulls, Chargers and the Rams will not get a list as they were around long enough.

One player per team, with so many players playing for multiple teams (Lazarus, Carroll, Inglis for example) I will choose the team where they had the most impact based on premierships won if any, most games played for a club and rep duties.

So Inglis would be picked for the Storm and not the Rabbioths.

So here is what I think are the top ten players to ever pull on a Melbourne Storm jersey.

10. Israel Folau
Only a two season player he still made a lasting impact for the club. In 2007 he won the premiership and the rookie of the year award. In 2008 he would play for Queensland and Origin and represent Australia. After this he went to the Broncos and then rugby union and has been missed ever since. We are still awaiting his comeback.

9. Stephen Kearney
The only Kiwi on the list, Stephen Kearney was a monumental part of the 1999 grand final and played 47 times for his home country of New Zealand.

He had 139 games with the Storm and after his retirement for playing he has stepped in to the coaching role, while not having any success at the Eels he has returned home to coach the New Zealand Warriors and hopefully lead them to ultimate victory to their first premiership.

8. Brett Kimmorley
Another original player for the Storm, Kimmorley was picked up by the Storm after the Super League war departing from the Hunter Mariners. As a huge part of the 1999 grand final team, Kimmorley lead the comeback for the Storm and was awarded the Clive Churchill Medal for his efforts in the game.

Although he only had 79 games for the Storm, he was one of their best in their early days and an example for future players. He would play 20 Tests for Australia and make ten Origins playing at halfback.

7. Ryan Hoffman
Hoffman started his career with the Storm in 2003 and was a part of their 2006, 07 and 09 grand finals. In 2011 he left for the Wigan Warriors for one season but returned to the Storm for the 2012 grand final.

He would score the Storm’s first try for the club and restore the club’s dominance in the comp. He was 244 games for the Storm and was a great part of the team. He has represented NSW 14 times and Australia 6, he is now playing for the New Zealand Warriors.

6. Greg Inglis
Inglis is one of the most successful centres-fullbacks in the modern game. Coming into the scene in 2005 he would win the Churchill medal in the 2007 grand final.

A multi-award winner for the club he has won the Dally M fullback of the year twice, 2009 rep player of the year and he made the Indigenous team of the century at centre. He has played 30 times for Queensland and was an instrumental part of their eight straight series wins and has represented Australia 38 times.

5. Matt Geyer
Geyer is one of foundational players for the Storm and the only man to play in their 1999, 2006, 2007 and 2008 grand finals.

A utility player that could really play anywhere in the back line, he was also pretty handy with his boot plotting the penalty goal in the 1999 grand final to steal it off the Dragons.

He was the first man from the club to reach 200 games. Geyer is considered club royalty.

4. Billy Slater
Billy ‘The Kid’ Slater, the fullback that you want on your side, for well over a decade Slater has been the Storm’s number one. With multiple Storm player of the year awards, Dally M Fullback of the year (2008, 2011) Dally M Medal in 2008 and Clive Churchill Medal in 2009, there is not much he has not achieve in his playing career. With only 22 games to go he is sure to make the 300 club and be only the third man form the club to do so.

He has represented Queensland 25 times and Australia 27. He is the best fullback of a generation – if not of all time.

3.Cooper Cronk
The best halfback that the Storm has ever seen just gets better with age. A new member of the 300 club, 2016 was his best season – he won the Dally M and the Golden Boot.

During their 2012 premiership win he was awarded the Clive Churchill Medal. Cronk has 31 Tests for Australia under his belt and 19 appearances for Queensland.

He is a very smooth and calculated player he is the perfect accompaniment to his hooker Cameron Smith.

2. Glenn Lazarus
Now I can just hear the Broncos and Raiders fans saying WTF? But hear me out, Lazarus became the most successful player of all time with what he did with the Storm.

Already a multiple time premiership player, Lazarus was recruited to lead the newly appointed Storm team in 1998, with no one really giving the team a hope of any success.

In only there second season Lazarus lead the team to the 1999 grand final and came back from a 14-0 deficit at half time to steal the title from the Dragons. Always leading from the front, Lazarus played 44 games for the Storm and 20 each for NSW and Australia.

He is the only player to ever win five titles with three clubs; a feat that I’m sure would never be repeated.

1. Cameron Smith
Seriously, was there going to be anyone else? There is no doubt that Smith is (if I may steal a saying from ex pro wrestler Brett ‘The Hitman’ Hart) the best there is, the best there was and the best there ever will be!

Smith has achieved more than any other man to pull on a Storm jersey. With 335 games for the Storm and counting, Smith has had a career than most could only dream of.

He has led his state to multiple State of Origin victories, playing 39 games for Queensland. He’s won a premiership and a world cup.

Without a doubt the Storm’s best.

Next up, the Broncos.

The Crowd Says:

AUTHOR

2017-03-06T00:01:15+00:00

BigJ

Roar Guru


Radiers, he would be the first pick, but with the Broncos you also have to consider, Webcke, Petero, Tallis and Thorn. but he is still top ten for all 3.

2017-03-05T20:27:55+00:00

The spectator

Guest


Just to put it into perspective, haha 3 teams top 10 and not any teams either, first forward picked every time. Big Lazzo.

2017-03-05T20:24:22+00:00

The spectator

Guest


???

AUTHOR

2017-03-05T04:43:40+00:00

BigJ

Roar Guru


I agree with that Barry but there were players that made better contributions at the broncos the Lazarus. Raiders definitely not he was and still is their best forward but i wanted to stick to my rules, but I appreciate the comment anyway

2017-03-05T03:12:13+00:00

The Barry

Roar Guru


I think Lazzo belongs in the Raiders or Broncs more so than the Storm. The Storm premiership was a great way to cap off his career but his contribution for Raiders or Broncs was better.

2017-03-05T00:27:15+00:00

The Barry

Roar Guru


Unfortunately big J when you make consistent errors it does take the readers attention away from the article and the points you're trying to make. That's particularly true of articles as opposed to general comments. So you probably have two choices - you can do nothing and keep blaming the readers or you can edit your articles after you've written them and improve their overall quality. It's your call...

2017-03-04T22:11:12+00:00

Joe

Roar Rookie


Yeah agree with your comments. Smith and Bellamy are the pillars of success for the Storm.

2017-03-04T10:19:45+00:00

Sammy

Guest


Your argument for Lazarus's inclusion in the Storm's Top 10 is based on his reputation rather than contribution.

AUTHOR

2017-03-04T08:43:22+00:00

BigJ

Roar Guru


hey Barry i think you have been replaced

AUTHOR

2017-03-04T07:37:27+00:00

BigJ

Roar Guru


i knew this was coming, but Im sticking with my choice. If you read my other comments you would know that i said six for raiders and nine for the broncos, but i wanted no double ups in the my lists. Plus he led the Storm to thier first history making grand final, so i went with that.

AUTHOR

2017-03-04T07:33:52+00:00

BigJ

Roar Guru


are you an english teacher or something, seriously mate, just enjoy the articles.

2017-03-04T07:19:29+00:00

Sammy

Guest


Glen Lazarus should NOT be on this - you should include him on the Canberra Raiders list where he played in 3 consecutive Grand Finals (1989, 90 & 91). You could even consider him for the Brisbane Broncos top 10, although he might struggle to make that list given that their history now spans 30 years. The most influential Melbourne Storm players from the 1998-04 era (pre Inglis, Smith, Cronk, Slater) that are not mentioned are: * Scott Hill * Tawera Nikau * Robbie Kearns * Matt King * Robbie Ross

2017-03-04T06:32:03+00:00

McTavish

Roar Rookie


Hi BigJ, good article but for a professional website you need to check spelling and grammar a bit more closely (or are the editors asleep on the job?) I counted at least 11 errors.

AUTHOR

2017-03-04T02:21:12+00:00

BigJ

Roar Guru


Hill and Nikau are 11 and 12 just missed out. With the one team rule i did not want to be bias or lazy in the list by just keeping name the same blokes, it makes me work harder for the list. As for Lazarus he wold be 6 for the raiders and nine for the Broncos if i was to put him in there.

AUTHOR

2017-03-04T02:18:48+00:00

BigJ

Roar Guru


i was going to put in Bai but Izzy's rookie of the year award got him over the line

2017-03-04T01:51:20+00:00

Magnus M. Østergaard

Roar Guru


I agree, Folau was a good player, but he only had 2 season with the Storm. Would think Marcus Bai or Scott Hill would be a worthy 10.

2017-03-04T01:28:18+00:00

The spectator

Guest


I remembee the accident and he wa hired as a coach or trainer but that was a long time ago now.

2017-03-04T01:18:55+00:00

Steve

Guest


I was in Huntly NZ last year, was chatting with a local about rugby league and he mentioned Tawera Nikua lives in the area. Often seen in the main street, yeah he was a tough player!

AUTHOR

2017-03-04T00:51:02+00:00

BigJ

Roar Guru


More like twenty, I'm really looking forward to it

2017-03-04T00:11:46+00:00

Albo

Guest


Yep ! No complaints from me about that list ! For me Cameron Smith is the best player of the modern era, and by a long margin. The Storm have benefited so much from having him at the helm for over a decade and a lot of average players have had good careers developed or resurrected thanks to playing under his on-field tutelage. Along with the top 10 Storm players, we should also note the one constant in most of their careers, their mighty coach in Craig Bellamy. The off field direction ( Bellamy) combined with the on-field direction ( Smith) have made the Storm a consistently great team for a long time.

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar