St Kilda Saints vs Geelong Cats: AFL live scores, blog

By Michael Horin / Roar Pro

Match result:

It was thrilling affair at Etihad for three quarters before the stronger team ran over the top, the Geelong Cats emerging as 38-point winners over St Kilda.

» Click here to read the full match report

Final score
St Kilda Saints 13.10.88
Geelong Cats 19.12.126

Match preview:

The St Kilda Saints and Geelong Cats are set to lock horns in an intriguing affair on Sunday in Round 5 of the 2017 AFL Season. Join The Roar for live scores and commentary from 3:20pm AEST.

Sitting pretty up the top of the ladder and coming off a thumping of ex-rivals Hawthorn, Geelong will be confident going into this matchup.

However, the Saints have been known to be giant slayers in recent years so this is anything but a certainty for the Cats.

To make things even more interesting the last two results between these two sides have been an upset win to the Saints last year and a thrilling draw in 2015.

While they haven’t played their best footy the Saints are in decent form and have an even record at 2-2.

Two promising wins against the Lions and the Pies should have the boys’ confidence up but admittedly they have been scrappy.

Overall, their structures and pressure have been sound but some basic skill errors have seen them too easily hurt on the turnover.

On the positive side, Dylan Roberton is in career best form while youngster Jade Gresham and superstar Nick Riewoldt (who plays like he’s the same age as Gresham) have been highlights.

Although losing David Armitage hurts, the return of Jack Steven should give Saints fans a bit more belief.

Geelong will likely face more pressure than they did last week but are still the strong favourites due to their impressive form.

Despite being unbeaten there’s a general feeling that the Cats still haven’t hit their peak. If they can bring their A-game that we have come to expect in recent years they could have this game wrapped up by half-time.

Mitch Duncan and Steven Motlop were in the votes last week and it’s the players of that caliber that need to lift to spark the team.

Zach Touhy, Brandan Parfitt and James Parsons (who has a few weeks off for doing what every non-Hawthorn supporter wants to do to Hodge) have all slotted in seamlessly to the Geelong lineup, continuing the club’s decade-long success in the recruiting department. It remains to be seen if club debutant Aaron Black can continue the trend.

Matchup to watch: Seb Ross has shut down Sam Mitchell and Adam Treloar this year and beating Patrick Dangerfield head to head last season was a big contribution to his side’s win. It will be interesting to see Ross v Danger Round 2 and how the Cats try to help out their superstar this week.

Prediction
Overall, while Geelong are rightfully favourites and will win comfortably if they play their best footy the Saints are always a danger matchup.

If St Kilda can start strong and play with the frantic pressure and speed they are capable of under the Etihad roof this could be a very tight game with an upset on the cards.

It’s tough to pick but it would be rough on the current ladder leaders to not back them to go 5-0.

Geelong by 32

Join The Roar for live scores and commentary from 3:20pm AEST.

The Crowd Says:

2017-04-23T09:07:43+00:00

Bobby

Guest


Geez that's an ugly word "elite"

2017-04-23T08:25:13+00:00

Cat

Roar Guru


Soft? He got smacked in the ear and late. That's a 50 every time. If you are gonna blog, try not doing your best BT impersonation and call its down the middle.

2017-04-23T08:23:26+00:00

Cat

Roar Guru


Don't matter how good a team looks for three quarters. It is a four Quarter game. Margin flattered the Saints, easily could have been more if the umpiring wasn't so bad. Riewoldt gets to run 18 steps and it's play on Parfitt runs 11 and gets pinged. Dozens of times Saints had prior and just dropped it. The rule is once prior has happened the ball must be hand balled or kicked. Ball can only come out in the tackle if there is no prior. Did Geelong get some questionable ones their way? Sure but not even close to the amount the Aints got.

AUTHOR

2017-04-23T08:21:28+00:00

Michael Horin

Roar Pro


Tuohy been great all year and Selwood was clearly best and most influential player on the field. Thought Duncan was excellent too for Geelong and Danger crucial in the final term.

AUTHOR

2017-04-23T08:20:41+00:00

Michael Horin

Roar Pro


Yep it was such an exciting game until the final quarter but that's exactly what the Cats do best, well done to Scott indeed. No worries, it was a pleasure to watch!

AUTHOR

2017-04-23T08:12:27+00:00

Michael Horin

Roar Pro


Yep two games that were elite for 3 quarters with the favourites running away in the end, still both great to watch!

AUTHOR

2017-04-23T08:09:06+00:00

Michael Horin

Roar Pro


» Click here to read the full match report

2017-04-23T08:03:23+00:00

hal

Guest


Tuohy was solid again. He has been a handy pick up. Selwood was great today. 43 disposals and 22 contested possessions. He willed himself to get us the win.

2017-04-23T07:58:54+00:00

Doc Disnick

Roar Guru


Never in doubt. Cats doing what all cats do best: toy with their prey. Much better control around the wings in the last quarter; whilst stifling the Saints offence. Great work Scott in the box. Thanks for the call Michael. GO CATS!

AUTHOR

2017-04-23T07:56:45+00:00

Michael Horin

Roar Pro


Selwood intercepts a kick in and handballs to Guthrie who finishes the Saints off in style. A great game but a boring last term. Saints – 13.10.88 Cats – 19.12.126 4th Q – 5 seconds left

2017-04-23T07:56:34+00:00

Doc Disnick

Roar Guru


Geelong just practising the old 7 point play at the end.

AUTHOR

2017-04-23T07:55:50+00:00

Michael Horin

Roar Pro


Umpires with their final say on the game giving away another soft 50m to Mitch Duncan.

AUTHOR

2017-04-23T07:54:34+00:00

Michael Horin

Roar Pro


Hawkins with a cherry on top after Aaron Black handballs to him on the goal line to finish the game off. Saints – 13.10.88 Cats – 18.11.119 4th Q – 1 min left

AUTHOR

2017-04-23T07:47:18+00:00

Michael Horin

Roar Pro


Hawkins buries the saints after dropping the mark, picking it up and kicking the goal. Game over, great effort from the Saints but not good enough. Saints – 13.9.87 Cats – 17.11.113 4th Q – 6 min left

2017-04-23T07:47:17+00:00

hal

Guest


Hawkins has had a dirty day but good to see him get one.

2017-04-23T07:46:13+00:00

hal

Guest


Good finish by Duncan. Horland Smith involved in that goal again with the clever handball. Montagna is very tired.

2017-04-23T07:45:35+00:00

XI

Roar Guru


Well that'll just about do it. Shame that neither potential Etihad upset went the fun/interesting way this weekend

AUTHOR

2017-04-23T07:45:31+00:00

Michael Horin

Roar Pro


Mitch Duncan kicks what is probably the sealer with a 40m snap straight through the medal and it's not a 20 point lead with just 7 minutes to play and the Saints seem to have been out classed. Saints – 13.9.87 Cats – 16.11.107 4th Q – 7 min left

AUTHOR

2017-04-23T07:44:33+00:00

Michael Horin

Roar Pro


NAKIA NO Cockatoo marks 20m out but thought it was touched, he plays on and misses the snap! The Cats have slowed the pace of this game right down and it's working for them. Saints need to lift the tempo and score the next goal.

AUTHOR

2017-04-23T07:41:37+00:00

Michael Horin

Roar Pro


Aaron Black somehow finds the ball in his hands in the goal square and he throws it on the boot while being tackled, Saints need the next one now. Saints – 13.9.87 Cats – 15.10.100 4th Q – 9 min left

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar