Racism and sport: A mirror of our society

By Gordon P Smith / Roar Guru

Although I live and breathe Aussie Rules, I am an American citizen, and have lived my entire life in the western United States. It’s also relevant to this article to point out that I am beige in colour, and my ancestry is mostly from the British Isles, many centuries ago.

I am old enough to remember the tail end of the 1960s in America, and how race relations between “the sons of former slaves and the sons of former slave-owners,” as Martin Luther King Jr put it, evolved from fire hoses and the National Guard in place to integrate Deep South elementary schools into what in some places is still an uneasy détente.

Most of the nation, however, reached the point where if its citizens weren’t colour blind per se, they were at least colour-tolerant for the most part.

In 2008, we elected a black President. The major topic of that campaign was not his colour but his inexperience. However, his eloquence and his message of cooperation between rival factions saw him win against two good candidates from the opposition party, John McCain in 2008 and Mitt Romney in 2012.

We patted ourselves on the back that America had finally overcome its racist past. Our most popular singer was Beyonce, a black woman. Our most popular entertainment figure was Oprah Winfrey, a black woman. Our most popular sports figure was LeBron James, a black man.

(Image: NBA)

Then Donald Trump happened.

More to the point, then the significant percentage of white people who’d been swallowing their resentment of their loss of apparent dominance and privilege in American society found a candidate who spoke their language: it’s the fault of all those darker-skinned people. Mexicans. Muslims. The Chinese.

They’re taking your jobs, they’re stealing money you should be getting, they’re ruining American trade, they want to force you to follow their laws instead of ours. And while most intelligent US voters recognised the racist code words for what they were, there were enough voters in key states who heard the call that still filled their hearts, that no one else had dared say out loud, that legitimised their racist feelings.

So Donald Trump was elected President of the United States over an already weak opponent who was saddled by foreign influences with a fictional scandal. (Observers noted how quickly the cries to “lock her up!” stopped after Election Day; there was nothing there to lock her up for.)

That scandal, the racism bubbling under the surface, and (ironically) just a hint of sexism produced the upset; the fact that voters were in some cases ashamed to admit they were voting for an unsavoury candidate explained the surprise to the pollsters.

It turns out we are a racist nation after all. We just hid it well for a few years. As an American, I feel the need to apologise to Australia and to every other country in the world for electing an incompetent racist who knows almost literally nothing about world relations and may blow the world up before he realises nuclear weapons aren’t toys. Believe me, a great many of us are trying to rectify the situation.

But if you’d been to sporting events in my country, especially in certain parts of my country, you would have figured that out for yourself long before last fall’s election.

It showed up again on Monday night, at a Major League baseball game when Baltimore outfielder Adam Jones (who is black) was the target of “racial epithets”, including many shouts of what we euphemistically like to call “the N-word”, as if making it sound cute makes it more acceptable.

Jones also had a bag of peanuts hurled at him while he approached the dugout after an inning in the outfield.

Indigenous athletes in Australia would immediately recognise the aftermaths as well: reports of something like 60 arrests in the ballpark after the incident, followed by lots of official statements like “we have zero tolerance for this sort of thing”, other athletes telling about similar experiences in the same location (Boston, in this case), and calls for fill-in-the-blank-solution-du-jour (education, in-park conversations about race relations, advertising, and invoking the name of integration pioneer Jackie Robinson one more time).

Ironically, the Boston Red Sox has an all-black outfield, at least on occasion, featuring Chris Young, Mookie Betts, and Jackie Bradley. Boston fans don’t seem to mind them. Maybe they’re the ‘good ones’.

While most issues of racial conflict in the US happen in the south-east, where slavery was concentrated before its de jure elimination in 1865, there are other pockets like Boston where racial tolerance has been curiously low over the decades.

The Boston Celtics, perennial champs of the NBA in the 1950s and 1960s, featured black stars like KC Jones, Sam Jones, and the legendary Bill Russell, yet the fans favoured “scrappy” players like John Havlicek or Tommy Heinsohn, good players who happened to share their heritage… players they “connected to”.

Russell famously refused to return to Boston after his retirement for decades because of the way he felt the city treated him.

When I read stories about Eddie Betts or Patrick Ryder being marginalised by idiot fans at an AFL game, I can’t help but reflect on the similar shortcomings of my own nation.

(AAP Image/Ben Macmahon)

For every “King Kong” comment by an Eddie McGuire, we had Howard Cosell exclaiming “Look at that monkey run!”

For every Allan McAlister saying (after Nicky Winmar’s shirt-raising declaration) that “Aboriginal players were welcome at the (Collingwood) club provided that they behave like white people,” there’s an Adolph Rupp, legendary coach of the Kentucky Wildcats men’s basketball team, declaring there wasn’t any team with black players on their roster that could beat his, implying that blacks weren’t smart enough.

And somehow, they weren’t smart enough to play quarterback in the NFL, either. My personal favourite tale along those lines was an idiot reporter asking Doug Williams, the first black man to quarterback a Super Bowl team, “How long have you been a black quarterback?” Williams’ quick-witted answer? “All my life.”

For every Adam Goodes who draws fire for his assertive stance in defence of his beliefs on race relations, we have a Colin Kaepernick who suffered the consequences of a league which doesn’t want to touch the controversy, mostly because, frankly, Kaepernick isn’t as talented a player as Goodes was.

And obviously it isn’t confined to our two countries – an English Premier League referee using epithets against Chelsea players in 2012, a protest by black players the same year against English captain John Terry for similar name-calling of another player. Head to Wikipedia and look up “Racism in association football”, and you’ll find samples from literally dozens of countries, seemingly every nation that plays the sport.

But sport is simply a mirror of society. The discrimination and hatred you see inside the stadium is only the tip of the iceberg of the sin-filled culture we live in. But it’s the tip of the iceberg that warns us to avoid the trouble that the rest of it causes.

When a target of racism has an identifiable face, as often happens in sport – especially when it’s a player as well-liked as Eddie Betts – it provides a target for our emotional response, a motivation to do something about the problem.

It’s much easier for us to care about Betts and Ryder than it is the thousands of faceless, nameless indigenous who undoubtedly deal with far worse hatred in Australia every day. It’s much easier for us to care about Adam Jones than it is the thousands of faceless, nameless blacks who I guarantee deal with far worse than some epithets at their jobs.

So, while you’re motivated, do something. The easiest thing is to simply set a good example. No preparation needed, no money required. Live the Golden Rule, and love your neighbour as you love yourself.

In this rapidly shrinking world, where an old man from Idaho in the US can scribble his thoughts in an Australian website, everyone is your neighbour.

The Crowd Says:

2017-06-20T03:12:54+00:00

Darren

Guest


Racism in every day life in Australia is common, from the lack of service at a shop counter in preference to a white Aussie. Asians & special needs customers experience it as well & I as a coloured male see it as just human nature.

2017-05-29T00:48:06+00:00

Perry Bridge

Guest


Sometimes you need to understand where you came from and the battles that have been fought to get to where you are. This indigenous round with the focus on 50 years since the 1967 referendum serves a very useful broader social purpose. And it mattered not whether a side had no indigenous players on the park on the day or the record.

2017-05-17T01:57:00+00:00

Rollo Tomasi Jr

Guest


"Soccer? Well, who really cares?" Only the overwhelming majority of the world's nation-states. Jog on...

2017-05-08T06:38:52+00:00

clipper

Guest


I don't have the figures, but isn't the number of indigenous players around the same in the NRL and AFL? Aren't there also a fair number of Italian and Greek players? Also, there is quite a bit of racism around European Football matches, again more noticeable as they get large crowds.

2017-05-08T00:25:02+00:00

paul cotton

Guest


brilliant comment rick.

2017-05-06T07:14:43+00:00

davSA

Guest


Appreciate your response Gordon... Having lived in South Africa through the height of Apartheid , the release of Mandela , the subsequent very difficult reconciliation process and now with the current government I do feel I am in a position to comment on this topic. I fought in the military defending the Apartheid system and also in subsequent years became a member of the End Conscription Campaign fighting against the same system . I am not certain which was more dangerous for me. Ja Nee ( Yes no ) that wonderful Afrikaans phrase which means all things or it means nothing . What I did experience over time was an understanding of my own processes through all this and came to the inescapable conclusion that my prejudices I had learnt as a child and one does learn them trapped me in my own Psyche......" No One is born to hate another , They must be taught to hate . They can also be taught to love because love comes more naturally to the human heart "...Nelson Mandela You are absolutely right , it begins with the individual and prejudice is a clear choice..... You are also right in that political leadership in any country has a major responsibility to lead by example .. People do follow. Trump is divisive . I lived through the Mandela era and actually felt the easing of tensions .. I also now live through the current leadership who are deliberately again reigniting prejudices as an attempt to appeal to the lowest common denominator in order to garner votes . I also feel that generalising is a cardinal sin .. in a sporting context for example when a Serena Williams plays to packed houses be it in Melbourne , London , Paris or New York that her skills and talent are warmly appreciated and applauded . But there is always that one person isn't there that has to utter a racist expletive . This is what the press reports widely and the wrong impression is created . This is not indicative of the feelings of the vast majority . One thing I have learnt through all this is that there are always good people out there that can be counted on to stand up and say no ... Not in my name. Again I quote the great man Mandela "Sport has the power to change the world , It has the power to inspire. It has the power to unite peole in a way that little else does. It speaks to youth in a language they understand . Sport can create hope where onece there was only despair . It is more powerful than government in breaking down racial barriers."

2017-05-06T03:55:01+00:00

Nick J

Guest


Rick, I think you make a good point; "I see a guy like myself..." That's one of the perspectives we want people to hold. I disagree with the earlier (and later) comment on Indigenous Round though with the assertion that it hurts long term. I understand some (many?) people view it as a wedge. I think this is a misunderstanding. Considering the difference between focus and exclusion is why I don't see a wedge or long term damage coming from the round. The round doesn't ask to exclude white people. It chooses to focus on the Indigenous for many reasons outlined within the discussions here. If we were excluding someone, then I'd agree that I see a wedge. I don't see a wedge if we are simply going to focus on something. As an aside, would the round be more of a wedge if we somehow oppressed the white players?

2017-05-06T03:30:25+00:00

Pope Paul VII

Guest


Thanks Brains. Typical Blainey.

2017-05-06T03:28:45+00:00

Pope Paul VII

Guest


Too true regarding the english penal system on the poor, unquestionably brutal. Colonialism was a whole different level though. The Irish population approximately 8 million in 1841, by the end of the decade it was 4 million. A minimum of 750,000 starving to death. The pop today is only 5.2 mil South and North. During WW2 about 4 million died in the Bengal famine. There are many more examples. I realise many european nations were as bad and worse.

2017-05-05T22:57:52+00:00

BrainsTrust

Guest


You can include in the discrimination against the Irish the lack of acknowledgement that AFL is really derived from the preferences of the Irish who played a game called caid for centuries. The Americans had dodgy historians that tried to make out baseball was invented in America, and in a similiar vein you have Geoffrey Blainey who did the same to deny the Irish their proper place in AFL history.

2017-05-05T22:57:13+00:00

Long Line

Guest


So if you're a white male Paul, why should any body listen to you regarding these matters? After all, you're all the same, as the cartoon seems allude to.

2017-05-05T22:26:41+00:00

Long Line

Guest


So, let me get this right. You say the NRL is not multicultural, then go on to list at least 3 cultures that play in the comp? With that kind of logic, you would make a great Trump supporter.

AUTHOR

2017-05-05T18:26:40+00:00

Gordon P Smith

Roar Guru


davSA, you're absolutely right, both about the fact that no single article could ever hope to address this topic in anything close to its entirety, and that its intent was indeed to invite more serious debate on the topic. I don't know The Solution. I do know that whatever it is, it only comes from individual people up, not from the top down, as much as we would love to regulate it out of existence. As a Christian first and foremost, I know that The Solution from MY perspective encompasses His two commands: Love God, and love everyone the way you (should) love yourself. If you're truly doing those two things, then you cannot be racist (or sexist or anything-else-ist)... but none of us can do that perfectly. I would love to hear more of your perspective on this, davSA - if there's any nation that has lived this problem more than others, you're there. (As an afterthought, the titles aren't mine; our editors work out the headers to make the front page work out cleanly. I don't want to throw them under the bus, though - I know my headline was any better, because I don't even remember what I put down as a suggestion!)

2017-05-05T11:42:13+00:00

J.T. Delacroix

Guest


What a load of rubbish. The NRL is not multicultural at all. It's about 8% indigenous, 35% Pacific Islander, & 57% bogan. Soccer? Well, who really cares?

2017-05-05T10:30:32+00:00

Agent11

Guest


May also have something to do with the AFL being dominated by white anglo players. Football and NRL are full of dark skinned players.

2017-05-05T10:18:35+00:00

davSA

Guest


Gordon , thank you for your article .. I am however going to be hopefully constructively critical. While I will not make any attempt to lessen your feelings on racism in society I do feel that you have covered a very broad range of issues which cannot possibly all be dealt with meaningfully from a single article . As a South African I have an understanding of just how complex this societal problem can in fact become. Would love rather to have heard your views on racism in sport ( as the header suggested) specifically which is of course a very topical issue globally . This may have invited more serious debate relative to experiences , instances and of course never ever forget possible solutions.

2017-05-05T09:16:46+00:00

Simoc

Guest


Excellent read Gordon. The problem is we have no progress. I had a hopelessly racist employee which he had no reason to be, apart from his parents. His son brought home an Indian friend in his first week at school and my employee did a complete u turn. Invited the childs parents over for dinner and changed his views on the world. So there is that hope as the classrooms are more mixed and the fear of the unknown becomes a lie.

2017-05-05T08:48:48+00:00

Slane

Guest


You must be forgetting about North America, IHP.

2017-05-05T07:41:09+00:00

Doc Disnick

Roar Guru


I'd agree with that Pope.

2017-05-05T07:24:42+00:00

Cat

Roar Guru


Spanish took some, English took some, Portuguese took some, Dutch took some, even the French took some.

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar