The Roar’s AFL expert tips and predictions: Round 10

By Josh / Expert

Another tricky round of tipping last week, and it doesn’t get any easier in Round 10. This is the season that just keeps giving! Here we go with The Roar’s AFL expert tips.

The round kicks off tonight with Geelong in Geelong hosting Port Adelaide, who are coming in off the bye after playing in Shanghai the week before.

While the bye can sometimes trip clubs up, it’s also worth remembering that Geelong put in a huge physical effort last week and have a shortish break.

It’s a tough call but my gut is that Port can get it done – might be a close one, though.

On Friday night you’d expect Sydney at home can make short work of Hawthorn – the Swans are switched on, the Hawks are not.

The Bulldogs and the Saints to kick off Saturday is much harder to pick – the Saints have had two good wins over the Dogs in their last four meetings, and I reckon they can pull this one off.

Gold Coast are also set to be affected by the bye this week but I don’t think an extra week’s rest will do them any good trying to knock off Melbourne. Dees to win that one.

Richmond and Essendon in the annual dreamtime match is an intriguing contest. I’ve been burned by Richmond too many times now and I have a bad feeling that last week’s loss will be the one that breaks their confidence. Dons.

Six wins from seven matches for the Dockers, and now they get the chance to take a real scalp when travelling to play Adelaide. I suspect it’s the Crows who will come out on top though, and possibly by a tidy margin.

Can’t say I have a ton of confidence in Collingwood these days but I have even less in Brisbane – and with it being a homegame for the Magpies, they ought to get it done.

I’ve got my fingers crossed that North can get four wins from five matches against Carlton on Sunday, but there’s every chance the Blues catch the Roos off guard. Tipping North, though.

Finally, GWS have the chance to beat the only team they’ve never beaten in the AFL in the last game of the round – West Coast. But with the Eagles being at home, and the Giants’ injury list still growing, the Eagles should get a win.

Maddy Friend
Geelong, Sydney, Bulldogs, Melbourne, Richmond, Adelaide, Collingwood, North Melbourne, West Coast

Geelong faces another test this weekend against Port, but at the revamped Skilled Stadium, and with Port coming off a bye from the China trip, the Cats should be too good.

Who would have thought the Sydney versus Hawks match would pit two perennial finalists together in a 12th versus 17th clash?

Sydney seems to have its mojo back, and with Hawthorn’s injuries to key players, the Swans should get over the top of them.

St Kilda’s form has been up and down this season, and the Bulldogs will be too consistent for them.

Likewise, Melbourne should account for Gold Coast, another team coming off an international bye.

Richmond and Essendon could be the match of the round, with both teams in good form. Richmond will be keen to impress on the big stage, but the Bombers are playing well enough to spoil Tiger Time for another week.

Adelaide facing a resurgent Fremantle should be an interesting match, but Adelaide seems to be back playing good football, and should get the win at Adelaide Oval.

Collingwood should easily account for hapless Brisbane, while I expect North to beat Carlton, but in a closer match than it might appear on the surface.

West Coast versus GWS is an intriguing clash – the Eagles’ home form makes me lean towards them… just.

Cameron Rose
Port Adelaide, Sydney, St Kilda, Melbourne, Adelaide, Essendon, Collingwood, North Melbourne, West Coast

Port to overcome Geelong’s home ground advantage and their return to form. Sydney to continue on their winning way over Hawthorn.

St Kilda to upset the Dogs in what should be a cracker with plenty at stake. Melbourne and Adelaide pick themselves, and should be too good. Essendon to further Richmond’s misery.

Collingwood to beat Brisbane, and register consecutive wins for the first time this year. North should beat a plucky Carlton, while West Coast will be looking to win comfortably at home against GWS.

Round 10 Josh Elliott Maddy Friend Tim Lane Cam Rose The Crowd
GEE vs PA PA GEE GEE PA GEE
SYD vs HAW SYD SYD SYD SYD SYD
WB vs STK STK WB WB STK WB
MEL vs GCS MEL MEL MEL MEL MEL
RIC vs ESS ESS RIC RIC ESS ESS
ADE vs FRE ADE ADE ADE ADE ADE
COL vs BRI COL COL COL COL COL
CAR vs NM NM NM NM NM NM
WCE vs GWS WCE WCE WCE WCE WCE
Last week 3 5 6 4 4
Total 43 45 48 48 49

The Crowd Says:

2017-05-26T09:37:33+00:00

Don Freo

Guest


It's certainly the best Carlton team for at least 10 years. Their next challenge is to be able to sustain an AFL level effort for two quarters. They have been managing the one quarter most weeks.

2017-05-26T09:00:33+00:00

Bodhi.

Guest


Vic teams don't win in W.A...so what does that make them?

2017-05-26T08:30:05+00:00

Darren

Guest


Agree on Kreuzer Macca if he can break even that will be a big step forward against North. And no Thomas is a plus he always smashes us. Our much improved backline gives us a chance but likely we won't kick the 14-16 required goals.

2017-05-26T01:37:38+00:00

Leonard

Guest


Both crowd stats are correct; they were not forgotten, but deemed not spot on for this specific discussion. Point of fact there were twelve 45,000 H&A crowds at the old suburban / regional venues, and lots more 40,000s, and even two 50,000s at Moorabbin. This was back when footy-goers were more hardy and far less squeamish about matters such as what the dunnies were like. (Don't ask!!) And when today's Health & Safety attitudes weren't even a neurospasm in any bureaucrat's sub-conscious. Certainly have some strong memories of several Windy Hill 35,000 to 40,000 crowds in the early to mid-1960s. One more thing: I can't recall even one instance of soccer-style 'football hooliganism', even with club supporters mixed in the 'outer'.

2017-05-26T00:14:43+00:00

Cat

Roar Guru


You've forgotten the final against Freo - 32,458. These are also only 'modern day' records. The all-time KP record is 49,107 in 1952 against Carlton.

2017-05-26T00:11:57+00:00

Macca

Guest


Have to agree Leonard, how about we work on getting the Saturday afternoon game televised before we go after Thursday/Monday nights.

2017-05-26T00:00:29+00:00

Leonard

Guest


Yep, second-highest crowd after 25,539 in 2010-R4. Reckon it may have become only the second KP 30,000 against an Australia-wide^ club (GC has the sole one to date). Liked young Lewis Williams letter in today's Herald Sun: "Dear Mr McLachlan, "I don't think it's fair that there is Thursday night and Monday night footy. "I am ten and I'm not allowed to stay up. I'm a Geelong member and I don't think it's fair that I can't go to games. . . . "Footy is a family game and it's not fair that kids cant watch it. . ." And, AFL commissioners and your CEO McLachlan, if "kids can't watch it" in the 2010s, then when they're adults, they are less likely to be watching it in the 2020s, 2030s and the 2040s. After all, you all keep telling us (as if parroting mindless 'talking points') that maximising attendances ('bigger crowds' for those of us more familiar with everyday lingo) is one of your highest priorities. ^ I prefer this description to 'non-Victorian' (describing something by a negative is ugly, although it is sometimes a handy shorthand) or 'interstate' (all clubs are 'interstate' in some contexts). 'Australia-wide' seems the least worst - any other suggestions?

2017-05-25T23:12:25+00:00

Macca

Guest


"have no problems removing a brassiere" having Jeeves request the lady is nude before you enter the room doesn't count my Lord.

2017-05-25T22:44:15+00:00

Don Freo

Guest


Not "everyone". I take them seriously...as do their opposition. They are 3 solid teams.

2017-05-25T13:35:30+00:00

Cat

Roar Guru


2-7 now.

2017-05-25T13:34:52+00:00

Cat

Roar Guru


24,909 ... I was pretty close ;)

2017-05-25T13:03:30+00:00

Dalgety Carrington

Roar Guru


May have gone the big ass-u-me there Paul, my reference was about the shaky team formlines this year.

2017-05-25T12:23:21+00:00

West Crash

Guest


I tipped cats to win but never thought of a gift What was C Dickson doing....

2017-05-25T12:16:35+00:00

Sammy

Guest


It is likely to be wet and that will help freo more than a pacy adelaide side

2017-05-25T12:13:25+00:00

Sammy

Guest


I will tip geelong by 2 points..final score will be something like 81-79?

2017-05-25T11:12:53+00:00

Aaron

Guest


we almost always start slow--our only chance really in this one is if the crows spray their shots at goal.

2017-05-25T08:49:07+00:00

hal

Guest


Will you be watching the game at the Melbourne Club with your idiot second son?

2017-05-25T08:31:55+00:00

Jon boy

Guest


Ex S.A. Brennan Cox B.O.G. last week for Peel last week should make his Debut Against Crows

2017-05-25T08:01:20+00:00

Pope Paul VII

Guest


noice

2017-05-25T07:59:19+00:00

Lord Dunsborough of the MCC

Guest


Oh I say - I'll have you know I pushed my idiot second son Bernie out to compete this event, I've never closed my own car door in my life and have no problems removing a brassiere

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar