It was entirely appropriate for Knights fans to boo our team

By perry cox / Roar Guru

I am particularly partial to a response by way of an article.

If someone has written something that I am not only opposed to, but passionately opposed to, I never feel that merely commenting on that article is enough.

No, no. I like to have my say.

So when Mary Konstantopoulos decided to let it be known that it is never OK to boo your team, not only did I want to say that position is wrong, but I wanted an exceptionally lengthy amount of writing to do so.

On Sunday, it was not only OK, but entirely appropriate and utterly necessary to boo at the 40 minutes of complete and utter anguish and disappointment that I had just sat through.

To say performance by the Knights’ players was awful sullies the good name of ‘awful’.

To be down 20-nil, at home, bearing in mind that it was actually only through the Tigers’ own incompetence that the score line was not even worse, was the most distraught I had been at halftime of a Knights game in Newcastle. Ever.

It was beyond disastrous.

Now, I won’t waste your own reading time with a list of words that might describe how bad it was. I’m actually not convinced that such a word to adequately describe the badness exists.

But I can tell you one thing, it was the first time I felt like giving up on Newcastle.

That’s how truly and utterly bad it was.

(AAP Image/Dean Lewins)

Three seems to be the magic number for the knights of late. The number of spoons we are about to win in a row. The number of wins in the last two seasons.

It’s entirely possible that three was the number of sets we had completed on Sunday.

But when you have sat through that for years, only to have your gut ripped out over and over, without any rhyme or reason, well, it finally wore thin. For a lot of us.

Now, I have been a paying member of the Knights for only four years, so I’ll admit, I’m perhaps not as passionate as some. But for those four years, I’ve seen some truly abominable performances, and I’ve always worn them with a grin, and managed to have a laugh.

I even managed to laugh off the 60-odd points to nil that I witnessed us suffer at the hands of Cronulla last year. Hey, at least they ended up winning the premiership.

Not Sunday.

Sunday truly broke me. In fact, the only thing that was missing on Sunday was the Benny Hill music, so utterly farcical was the play to watch.

So, fairly or not, after years of underperformance, myself and other patrons in Bay 53 in the Western Grandstand let fly with a torrent of abuse at the players that I honestly did not think we were capable of.

Why? I can’t speak for everyone else, but let me tell you why I did it.

I did it because I am tired that the people of Newcastle have to accept mediocrity.

I did it because I am tired of having to only accept, or be happy with, ‘effort’, as the performance isn’t there.

I did it because I am tired of our club paying for a halfback who doesn’t cut it anymore, because of young boys having to perform where men should be, because we are simply turning into a feeder club for other clubs in the NRL to poach our players.

I booed, and rightly or wrongly, at the players, because we, the people of Newcastle, deserve better than what we are being given at the moment.

And that anguish is not only directed at the players, but the entire Newcastle Knights club.

A couple sitting in front of me took exception with our antics, such that they decided to pass judgment, with lines of: “Gee, good fans you guys are.”

And that really got to me.

It got to me, as I let them know, because who else in sport in Australia can perform like buffoons, and still expect crowds of 20,000 to attend their game?

The people of Newcastle had not only been OK to boo, having attended performance after performance of such heartbreaking indifference and amateurishness. In fact, in a clear contradiction to the opinion of Ms Konstantopoulos, we had finally, very much, earned the right to boo, after a performance where we made the bottom of the ladder team look like premiership contenders.

This story may well have ended with the final whistle that brought an end to the torture on Sunday, but the next day, something quite curious occurred.

In the town of Newcastle, late Monday night, the local newspaper ran an online article, in print on Tuesday, where a high-profile Knights board member had the temerity to put the coach on notice that if performances did not improve, Nathan Brown was out.

Well, as a paying member of the Newcastle Knights, such board member antics have gone finally a step too far.

To even imply that the current state of this once great club lies at the feet of Brown is ignorant at absolute best, and deceptively manipulative at worst.

The current state of the club is more a testament to the absolutely atrocious state we were in when Brown got here.

Left with an ageing squad, a harsh reminder of a Nathan Tinkler reign that was more glitter than gold, and Wayne Bennett, a super-coach that was more ethanol fuel than premium, Brown was tasked with not only picking up the pieces, no, he was tasked with creating pieces to make a puzzle again.

(AAP Image/Dave Hunt)

But a particular board member has come out to publicly decry our coach?

It’s an extremely curious turn of events.

Some have said it was a call to arms by a board member who is one of the people, a show of support for a long-suffering fan-base. That’s a very positive spin.

There are those of us, however, who have taken a much more cynical view, in that a board member coming out, talking as if for the fans, and blaming the coach, is in fact deflecting attention away from the very clear failings of a board that, to date, has actually done very little by way of evidence to show an iota of care for its supporters.

Knights supporters are a lot of things, but we are not fools.

Yes, we are lauded for standing by the team through thick and thin, and recently I wrote about why the Knights are in fact the best club in Australia.

But we are only human. We have very real limits, and we will not be taken advantage of.

And board members in a club that is under the most intense of pressure would be mindful to stay out of the public eye, because if the rumours and murmurings are true, and the Knights are to be sold shortly, forget the coach, it will be the upper management the first in the firing line.

And that, for all those reasons, was why it was ok to boo. Such things do not occur in isolation. Not in Newcastle anyway.

It was more than simply 40 minutes of so much displeasure that I wanted that memory erasing thingy from Men in Black. It finally said to the club that we, the fans, wanted and deserved more than what we are being given.

It’s possible that I’ve never been prouder to be a Knights supporter than at that very moment.

It’s possible that it showed we still cared.

The Crowd Says:

2017-07-07T00:56:00+00:00

Fred

Guest


PS to those who say booing never achieves anything... About 6 weeks ago I recall the Panthers putting in an absolutely shocking 40 minutes, the home crowd gave them hell for such an embarrassing performance, and I dare say that's what fired them up to their remarkable come back win (was it against the Warriors?)

2017-07-07T00:53:45+00:00

Fred

Guest


Good article! Like someone above I'm a Tigers fan so can feel your frustration. I think both our teams will have a good year next year, with the right mix of blooded young players and good new signings. Hopefully a Tigers v Newcastle Grand Final!! I agree that the current coach is not to blame. If I had to blame a coach I'd blame Wayne Bennett before Brown (but blaming any coach is never the full story).

2017-07-06T20:22:09+00:00

The Barry

Roar Guru


You said before everything was fine except "throwing stuff and threats to injure". Now you wouldn't be able to resist flattening (isn't that a 'threat to injure' and therefore against your own 'rules'?) someone who wasn't doing either of the only two things you've said were not "all good" (ie he wasn't throwing stuff or making threats to injure)? Your inconsistency with your own moral code is astounding.

2017-07-06T13:04:09+00:00

Bugo

Guest


Would you? You go get 'em, tough guy bigj.

2017-07-05T12:11:16+00:00

Scott

Guest


As a supporter of the Giants, Seagulls, Chargers and Titans I am glad it is another club suffering at the moment but I can't recall ever booing. I've been disappointed to the point of not knowing whether I should go to the game or not with my key issue always being if the effort is there. If the players and team appear to be trying it will improve, if they don't care then the crowd will disappear. Imterestingly this year is the first time in years I've thought the Titans didn't care

2017-07-05T11:46:59+00:00

souvalis

Guest


Once the chairman is quoted as saying he's lost faith in the coach and the CEO writes letters of apology to the board for Sunday's performance,it's really hard seeing the coaches position as anything but untenable...he may try and quantify improvement by the margins of defeat,but really..can't remember a period of worse times..

AUTHOR

2017-07-05T10:42:10+00:00

perry cox

Roar Guru


You're not wrong about them living in the past mate. Antiquated in their methods and dealings. I often fear that they are just waiting for another Andrew Johns to appear. The word is that a leagues club will be buying the knight soon. Here's hoping it brings the change that we need!

AUTHOR

2017-07-05T10:41:16+00:00

perry cox

Roar Guru


Thanks Paul, I like to think I was booing judiciously. It was not exactly a well thought out plan, but it had thought behind it.

AUTHOR

2017-07-05T10:40:19+00:00

perry cox

Roar Guru


Thanks Nat, It's an article from the heart, and it may not be read this way, but I won't stop supporting them any time soon.

2017-07-05T03:46:39+00:00

BigJ

Roar Guru


I admire you restaint cause i just would of flattened that clown. You can boo all you like, there is a difference between letting your team to know its time to pull there fingers out and being outright abusive. I reserve the right to boo all i like, but it makes little difference pending on were you are in the stadium they probably won't hear you anyway. Especially if you at home infront of the tv.

2017-07-05T03:23:00+00:00

Nostradamus

Guest


I think the Knights are living in the past still. Its very hard to recruit players to a loosing team. They need to start trying to recruit players from the 20's that show potential at other clubs where their path might be blocked. Just relying on the local juniors does not work and hasn't worked for 20 years. Think the Tigers, Raiders, Knights. Then in the last 5 years the Rabbits, Cowboys, Panthers have started recruiting players which added to their Juniors now makes them more than competitive week in week out.

2017-07-05T02:23:59+00:00

Paul D

Roar Guru


I can assure you that there will always be muppets in the crowd determined to tell everyone that they've been supporting the club for something like 12 decades and have never lost faith ever and you're a terrible person to boo your players I don't have a problem with it, provided it's judiciously used. Don't boo every loss, but where's it is clearly unacceptable - sure, give it to them with both barrels. How else do you register your displeasure

2017-07-05T01:29:39+00:00

Nat

Roar Guru


Good on you for being a paid member and getting to the games Karlo. Your continued support will see through this dark period and you'll be cheering again for the Knights soon.

2017-07-05T01:25:05+00:00

KingCowboy

Guest


Booing your own team achieves nothing at all. I remember going to a Cowboys game many years ago and we were down 48-6 (I think) to the Knights at half time. A clown (A so called cowboys fan) next to us was yelling abuse at the cows and it is the closest I have ever come to getting into a blue at the footy. I go there to try and help the boys, not to bring them down. As my team they represent me and our region. If bad performances continue, changes will be made!

2017-07-05T01:17:43+00:00

Big Daddy

Guest


Board members are really good at shafting coaches. The Knight's need to take a long hard look at themselves particularly the board. They wouldn't be in their current situation because decisions made by current board and previous boards are killing this club. They have no leagues club , they are owned by the NRL , no on field performances to speak of. Of course the fans are entitled to Boo.

2017-07-05T00:57:03+00:00

Sava

Guest


Newcastle Was one of the original Rugby League Clubs,they still have a large area to gain up and coming players from.But for some reason they are neglecting these local products . The year they won the Comp the team consisted of nearly all local products(players) . I hope that West Newcastle League buy The Newcastle Club and get back to promoting Junior League right up the North-western line to the Qld border. Team spirit is a big plus in any team. Sava

2017-07-04T23:57:16+00:00

BigJ

Roar Guru


Damn right you can boo your team all you want, if they put in a poor performance they probably deserve it. There are limitations to it of course, no throwing stuff or threats to injure bar that it's all good.

2017-07-04T23:19:59+00:00

curaeus

Guest


As a Wests Tigers fan for the last 17 years I can sympathise with the way you feel. Both the Tigers and the Knights are rebuilding and can certainly look forward to much better times to come so hang in there.

2017-07-04T22:16:31+00:00

E-Meter

Guest


As a long suffering Eels member, I'll respectfully say the Knights have got a long way to go to match the abyss that Parra were in. Add in the fact that we're the only club that hasn't played finals in the last 9 seasons.

2017-07-04T21:33:30+00:00

jeff dustby

Guest


whats the point?

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar