Hindsight is a wonderful thing. Here is a look back at the 2002 AFL draft should have unfolded, which produced some brilliant players.
Pick 1 – Jobe Watson – St Kilda (Originally Brendon Goddard)
Watson has been a fantastic player for the Bombers over 15 years. He was originally taken with pick 40 under the father-son rule, playing 216 games and kicking 112 goals to date. He is a 2-time All-Australian, 3-time club best and fairest, one-time Yiooken Award winner, one-time Lou Richards Medallist and a one-time Archer-Hird Medallist.
He also won the 2012 Brownlow until he got it stripped from him last year by the AFL. Watson was captain of Essendon for six years.
Pick 2 – Brendon Goddard – North Melbourne (Originally Daniel Wells)
Goddard has been a great player for the Saints and Bombers, living up to the hype of being the No.1 pick. He has played 307 games to date – 205 for St Kilda and 102 for Essendon. During that time he has kicked 157 goals – 104 for St Kilda and 53 for Essendon.
He is a one-time club best and fairest, 2-time All-Australian, one-time Yiooken Award winner, and captained the Bombers for a season.
Pick 3 – Jarrad McVeigh – Brisbane (Originally Jared Brennan)
McVeigh has been a strong midfielder for the Swans across the last 14 years. He was originally selected with the fifth pick, playing 294 games and kicking 196 goals to date. He is a two-time club best and fairest, one-time All-Australian, one-time premiership player, and has captained the Swans for six seasons.
Pick 4 – Kade Simpson – Western Bulldogs (Originally Tim Walsh)
Simpson has been a reliable defender for the Blues throughout a 15-year career. He was originally drafted with pick 45, playing 282 games and kicking 131 goals to date. He is a one-time Jim Stynes Medallist, one-time club best and fairest, and 3-time International Rules series representative for Australia.
Pick 5 – Andrew Mackie – Sydney (Originally Jarrad McVeigh)
Mackie has been a solid defender in the Cats best 22 for the last 15 years. He was originally taken with pick seven, playing 273 games and kicking 99 goals to date. He is a 3-time premiership player and a one-time All-Australian.
Pick 6 – Daniel Wells – Port Adelaide (Originally Steven Salopek)
Wells has been a classy player for the Roos and Pies. He was originally drafted with the No.2 pick, playing 252 games to date – 243 for North Melbourne and nine for Collingwood. He has kicked 160 goals – 150 for North Melbourne and ten for Collingwood.
He is a two-time club best and fairest, one-time Archer-Hird Medallist, and the 2004 Goal of the Year winner.
Pick 7 – Nick Maxwell – Geelong (Originally Andrew Mackie)
Maxwell was a solid defender for the Pies until he retired after an 11-year career. He was originally taken with pick 15 in the rookie draft, playing 208 games and kicking 29 goals. He is a one-time All-Australian, one-time premiership player, and the Collingwood Football Club captain for five years.
Pick 8 – Will Minson – Hawthorn (Originally Luke Brennan)
Minson was a fantastic tap ruckman for the Dogs. He was originally selected with pick 20, playing 191 games and kicking 81 goals. He is a one-time All-Australian and a one-time VFL premiership player.
Pick 9 – Sean Dempster – North Melbourne (Originally Hamish McIntosh)
Dempster was a solid defender for the Swans and Saints. He was originally drafted with pick 34, playing 222 games – 54 for Sydney and 158 for St Kilda – and kicking 21 goals – eight for Sydney and 13 for St Kilda. He is a one-time All-Australian and a one-time premiership player.
Pick 10 – Brad Sewell – Essendon (Originally Jason Laycock)
Sewell was a strong player for the Hawks across 12 years. He was originally selected with pick seven in the rookie draft, playing 200 games and kicking 32 goals. He is a two-time premiership player and a one-time club best and fairest.
Liam
Guest
Found another guy who's more concerned about our great club than his own scrubby club. Carn the dons.
Conor
Roar Guru
I'll agree with Cat, it had standout players taken in the draft, but it does fall away fast, making it weak.
Cat
Roar Guru
Weak in the sense that it drops away very fast
JamesH
Roar Guru
Weak draft?!?!? That top 6 is elite. I wouldn't say it was a standout draft but definitely not weak.
JamesH
Roar Guru
Hairs: you're splitting them.
johno
Guest
Ooops ..... I guess I can't exchange Ricky Mott for Sandi .....
Keggas
Guest
was a very weak draft year so it is hard to be too critical of the article but Nick Maxwell doesn't deserve to be anywhere near the top ten
Conor
Roar Guru
johno, the players you are talking about are better than Will Minson, however they were drafted in 2001 as they all debuted in 2002
Mattyb
Guest
Wil Minson? sure he was an AA ruckman but I'm not sure there was much competition that season,won a VFL Premiership? not sure how high of an accolade that is under the circumstances. Shultz,Lonegan,Rivers,Malceski,Staker were all better players and I'm sure there's a few others. Would probably even have Wells at one or two but not Watson who was a father son anyway. looks like it wasn't a stand out draft,the dogs certainly made a meal of it with Minson being the only player who really even played much.
TomC
Roar Guru
I think those players went in the 2001 rookie draft. I'd humbly suggest that Joel Patfull - a dual B&F winner at the Lions - could slot in above some of the names in this top 10.
johno
Guest
I don't know, there was a bloke by the name of Aaron Sandilands taken in the rookie draft who was a bit better than Minson In fact I would rate Marty Mattner, Roger Hayden and Quinten Lynch form the rookie draft as better than Minson
Brian
Guest
I'd also have Malceski ahead of Dempster
dontknowmuchaboutfootball
Guest
...about 30 minutes before he would otherwise have received the phone call from AFL HQ asking him to give it back.
Ironmonger
Guest
Jobe Watson was not "stripped" of his Brownlow....he was wracked with guilt about his cheating ways and handed it back,
Paul D
Roar Guru
I think Tom Lonergan should be where Will Minson is.