The 'A to Z' of the Australian attack will struggle against India

By Anindya Dutta / Roar Guru

What is clear from cricket conversations on various forums, including this one, is that the Aussie public is largely indifferent to the ODI series that will start this weekend between Australia and India.

The focus is understandably on the Ashes, and this series is seen as a distraction and merely a reason for Cricket Australia to pick up some extra cash.

For entirely different reasons the interest in India is low as well. From a fan perspective there is clearly cricket fatigue after a very long domestic season that never ended, merely morphing into an ‘away’ season that gave the opportunity to Virat Kohli and boys to win a few more matches against some largely ordinary opposition.

Nonetheless, come this weekend, when two teams glued together at the number two spot in world ODI rankings face up, at stake will be the bragging rights of the number one position in ODI cricket.

Whoever wins this series will leapfrog South Africa to the title of top dog in limited overs cricket as long as the margin of victory is 4-1. A 3-2 margin will leave the victor in second place and relegate the loser to third. With this peak in sight and two extremely combative captains Steve Smith and Virat Kohli in charge, one can be sure that no quarters will be asked and none will be given.

Given how important to the two teams (and to the two cricket boards) this series is in that context, it is interesting to evaluate the composition of the teams which has been a matter of some debate in recent days on social media and on more serious cricket forums.

It is clear that Indian team management decided to use the quality opposition that they will face to give much-needed top-level exposure to the up-and-coming talent in the country.

The 2019 world cup is not that far away, so it is indeed time to find the right balance in the team. The fact that players like Yuvraj Singh and Suresh Raina are not a part of the equation is hardly surprising, and it is a tribute to MS Dhoni’s supreme fitness and continued importance to the team that he continues to be first-choice wicketkeeper even leading up to 2019.

(Image: AP Photo/Rui Vieira)

India’s batting talent on display can be the envy of many other teams and the bench strength at the moment is remarkable. Shikhar Dhawan at 32 and Rohit Sharma at 30 are the oldest members of the batting outfit and are the most explosive opening pair in the world at present in this format. With Virat Kohli, Ajinkya Rahane and KL Rahul in the top to middle order, the batting is solid.

It is the bowling that is an interesting study.

Mohammed Shami, Umesh Yadav, Bhuvaneshwar Kumar and Jasprit Bumrah are fighting for the two likely spots in the pace department. All four are bowling extremely well, and India has never in her cricketing history had a plethora of riches in the pace department as she does today.

Hardik Pandya is one of the most exciting young talents in world cricket today in the limited overs format. He is an explosive batsman and he just needs to learn how to best use the 140 kilometres per hour speed at which he consistently bowls to be the effective fifth bowler in Indian conditions.

India made a statement by dropping Ravi Ashwin and Ravi Jadeja, the top two bowlers in the world in Test cricket, from the limited overs side. It is ostensibly to give them rest, but the real reason is to throw the youngsters into the pan and see how they come out.

Axar Patel has a lot of experience in the shortest format of the game and is learning quickly how to handle the ODI format. With an average well below Jadeja’s and an economy rate which is superior, one is hard pressed to question the picking of this 23-year-old.

One of Axar’s likely bowling partners at the other end is exciting leg break bowler Yuzvendra Chahal. As is often the case with spinners, Chahal got his break fairly late in life at the age of 26 last year.

A few months later, playing a T20 against England, he put in a magical bowling spell, picking up six for 25 against England, the third best bowling figures ever achieved in the shortest format of the game. On the hard unresponsive pitches one can expect over the next two weeks, how Chahal does will be crucial.

(Image: AP Photo/Gautam Singh)

Chahal will, however, be fighting for a place in the XI with one of the most exciting wrist spinners in the world today: India’s Chinaman bowler, Kuldeep Yadav. Yadav made an immediate impact when he debuted in the Test match against Australia in Dharamsala earlier this year and has followed it up with a strong start to his ODI career with an average a shade above 20.

Overall India looks a well-balanced side and will be difficult to run through at home.

In this context Australia’s team composition is a bit curious. It seems to have been picked with the constraint of the Ashes series in mind on the one hand and based on IPL experience on the other.

The top order is clearly formidable. Any ODI batting side that boasts David Warner and Steve Smith at the top deserves to be treated with a lot of respect. Aaron Finch on his day is devastating, and Indians know well from long IPL experience exactly what their much loved Glenn ‘Maxie’ Maxwell can do to even the best bowling on a good day. Travis Head adds stability.

Beyond that, the batting looks a bit iffy against a strong Indian bowling line-up in the event at least two of the above don’t fire every match.

The real worry, unlike for India, will be the Aussie bowling outfit.

Pat Cummins will have to spearhead the attack and be careful not to injure himself before the Ashes. That, one can be sure, will be playing on his mind as he steams in to bowl at Shikhar Dhawan.

(Image: AP Photo/Aijaz Rahi)

Nathan Coulter-Nile has valuable IPL experience and has done well in the 16 ODIs he has played to date. He is a good pick. Hilton Cartwright has never played an ODI and India is an interesting place to start your career.

James Faulkner is someone the Indians sorted out a long time ago and his inclusion in the team will have been met with salivating faces across the home grounds. Kane Richardson’s move from domestic to international cricket has not been easy and the hosts won’t make it easier.

The spin duo of Ashton Agar and Adam Zampa are going to have the toughest short tour of their lives starting this weekend. At 23 years of age Agar has played two ODIs to date, taking two wickets, the last one two years ago.

His senior partner Adam Zampa has at the age of 25 played 24 ODIs with an average just a shade below 30. Having played the IPL without notable success and knowing how better leg spinners have fared in India in the past, it is safe to predict that he will have a challenging tour. To pick up a humorous line from Kersi Meher-Homji’s article here a few days ago on Nathan Lyon’s exclusion from the team, it seems likely that the ‘A to Z’ of Aussie bowling will struggle in the days to come.

The Aussie team will fight as they always do and Kohli and men will know not to take them for granted, but the most likely outcome of the series when the presentation ceremony is held at Nagpur on 1 October will be a 4-1 victory for India.

The Crowd Says:

AUTHOR

2017-12-22T22:17:28+00:00

Anindya Dutta

Roar Guru


For those who missed it The Roar’s review of my new book ‘Spell-binding Spells’ : http://www.theroar.com.au/2017/12/21/fascinating-book-crickets-finest-bowling-spells-inspired-roar/

AUTHOR

2017-09-17T11:07:17+00:00

Anindya Dutta

Roar Guru


I hope Brasstax you are watching him bat. He is clean and brutal. A fantastic talent.

2017-09-15T10:01:39+00:00

Savage

Roar Rookie


Ronan and Brasstax i believe you both are right.Agree with him being talented and brutual against spinners but i also think he is overrated.if you purely judge him by stats,he's probably been best AR in limited overs cricket since 2016.Despite his stats,i'm still not sure about his batting against Quicks(140+ bowlers),his finishing ability(saw him fail to finish matches in ipl and odi's twice or thrice) and his bowling is very erratic at times.I believe this series is Perfect opportunity for him to silence his doubters as not only he will have to face bowlers like cummins,coulter nile but also he would bowl against likes of warner,maxwell,smith.After this series,we'll know exactly whether he is really that good or was it just some beginner's luck.

2017-09-15T07:51:40+00:00

Ronan O'Connell

Expert


I can't agree Brasstax. Pandya is an immensely talented player - one of the cleanest strikers of the ball in the world. He has a unique ability to clear the rope from ball one. He's particularly brutal against spinners.

2017-09-15T07:47:08+00:00

Ronan O'Connell

Expert


You're right though Anindya that this is the biggest challenge of Zampa's career so far, a massive challenge for he and Agar bowling against a destructive Indian batting lineup.

AUTHOR

2017-09-15T05:47:26+00:00

Anindya Dutta

Roar Guru


Lets wait and see. He is a clean powerful hitter and will mature as they all do. I am hopeful he will in time be a very valuable all rounder.

AUTHOR

2017-09-15T05:46:11+00:00

Anindya Dutta

Roar Guru


I don't think we shall have any turning tracks. Would be surprising if there were. Should be high scoring matches.

AUTHOR

2017-09-15T05:42:44+00:00

Anindya Dutta

Roar Guru


Thank you Kersi. Looking forward to your piece. Sounds promising that it will be as quirky as your best!

AUTHOR

2017-09-15T05:41:55+00:00

Anindya Dutta

Roar Guru


Thanks so much Gordon! Appreciate the kind words. I am sure Kohli's ears will be busy with nothing else. :)

2017-09-15T05:33:08+00:00

AGordon

Guest


Anindya Thoroughly enjoyed your article and I think you probably have it right. India, in India, will be very hard to beat against what is a made up first XI for Australia. At the end of the day though, both sides are treating this as a series of little importance in the grand scheme of things. India will try a number of players, assuming they are winning games, and Australia will use a second string attack that should give more experience to guys like Zampa, Coulter-Nile, etc. Both sides will give it their best on the field but as you suggest, the public are either "cricketed out", in India's case or looking forward to the Ashes in Australia's case. It'll be interesting to see how Kohli goes after his Test disaster against the Aussies earlier in the year. No doubt he'll be reminded of that throughout the series!

2017-09-15T05:06:10+00:00

Swampy

Guest


They should play this series with bats from the Bradman era and remove the ropes from the already small fields. Need to clear the 3m barrier fence to get a six. See what the totals are then....

2017-09-15T04:03:23+00:00

Rellum

Roar Guru


No one used to care about rankings till a few years ago. Even now it feels like a gimmick used by CA to justify tours and series. Given the disparity between who plays who how often it really has little meaning. Thankfully they are finally looking at bringing in a league style structure after the next world cup.

2017-09-15T03:44:53+00:00

Kersi Meher-Homji

Guest


Enjoyed your balanced preview of the Oz-Ind ODI series. Thank you for acknowledging my "A to Z of spinners quirk" and titling the story A to Z of Oz attack. This has inspired me to do a story titled "Initially speaking". Will be sharing it with you and CW readers tomorrow. You have been Warned (neither Shane nor David)!

2017-09-15T02:45:03+00:00

Ouch

Guest


If you win the World Cup, you are top dog. I don't see any point in the rankings unless, like the rugby, they are used to determine the draw for the following world cup. If they aren't used for this then all they are good for is boasting if your team happens to be No. 1 and perhaps giving an indication of how a team will perform in the next WC. The years between WC's are used as preparation for the next one. It wouldn't bother me in the slightest if Oz are never ranked 1 in ODI's. As long as they put in at the World Cup is all that matters. Everyone remembers the WC winner. In 3 months, not many will remember the victor of this upcoming series.

AUTHOR

2017-09-15T02:35:25+00:00

Anindya Dutta

Roar Guru


Very true. And the competitor and proud man that he is, I am sure its at the top of his mind. He is good enough. Its a mental issue to overcome and we know thats not always obvious or easy.

AUTHOR

2017-09-15T02:28:39+00:00

Anindya Dutta

Roar Guru


Indeed Tanmoy. Things can change and I do hope it will be an entertaining series.

2017-09-15T02:28:15+00:00

Paul D

Roar Guru


I think everyone is looking to see if Kohli has learnt anything from his slow motion trainwreck of a series in 2014. Could do worse than see how Dravid batted in 2011. He was so far above everyone else around him he was practically walking on water

AUTHOR

2017-09-15T02:27:48+00:00

Anindya Dutta

Roar Guru


Australia are deserving world champions and will continue being addressed as such until 2019 when (and if) they are dethroned. That does not mean the rankings between world cups have no meaning if Australia's name does not appear at the No. 1 spot. Being the best in the world is not about waking up once every 4 years and performing well in a tournament, and cant be so for any one team. Its a dynamic process which is why we have a ranking system in the interim.

AUTHOR

2017-09-15T02:25:12+00:00

Anindya Dutta

Roar Guru


I agree. India will hopefully shut up critics in England 2018. Nothing seems enough so not sure if a new spin will emerge after that were India to do well. Lets wait and see.

2017-09-15T02:04:23+00:00

Paul D

Roar Guru


Yeah, agreed there. Even if India win they will just say flat tracks, particularly if this series is the predicted run glut everyone thinks it will be. India would go a long way to earning more credibility as a test nation if they put in a good performance in England in 2018. Their last two tours in 2011 and 2014 have been unmitigated disasters, 2011 was the most one-sided series of all time and they copped an absolute flogging in 2014 as well, after a promising start and a win at Lords.

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar