Five thoughts From Day 2 of the 3rd Test

By Eddie Otto / Roar Guru

Australia mused their way back into the 3rd Test by dominating Day 2 against England on Friday. Here are my five main takeaways.

1. Australia fight back to take honours on day 2
Not for the first time in the series England let an opportunity slip through their grasp, as Australia finished Day 2 on an even keel at 3/203 in reply to the visitors 403.

Australian captain Steve Smith went to stumps on 92, closing in on another century, with Shaun Marsh surviving a testing closing period on 7.

Earlier in the day England squandered a position of real authority having lost their final six wickets for just 35 runs, when a score of 500 looked on the cards at one point.

Jonny Bairstow achieved his second Test match century with a magnificent 119, while Dawid Malan finished on 140, as the pair combined for a brilliant 237-run stand.

The wickets were shared once again amongst the Australian bowlers, with Mitchell Starc picking up 4/92 and Josh Hazlewood 3/91.

Both sides resume today knowing whoever can control Day 3 will go a long way towards winning the Test match.

England desperately need a first innings lead, whilst if Australia can bat all day, the momentum swing will be such that it wouldn’t surprise me if England crumble in their second innings when faced with a deficit and a crowd baying for blood.

2. Moeen’s meek demise a worry
Moeen Ali came into this Ashes series as one of the world premier all-rounders, however his struggles have played a large part in the tourists being on the edge of surrendering the Ashes in just three Tests.

This tour was always going to be one when Ali’s strong claim of being a genuine world class all-rounder was put to the test.

Australia has been a graveyard for overseas finger spin bowlers, and Ali’s frailties against the short ball were always likely to be worked over.

Although he did take 10 wickets in a match against an understrength South Africa, his bowling has been exposed since he managed just 10 wickets on a five-Test tour of India, at an average of 64.

In this series, Ali was been ineffective to the point of being irrelevant with the ball, with two wickets for 112 runs, and his last wicket of tailender Josh Hazlewood coming some 46 overs ago.

At least when Ali had struggled with the ball in the past, he could always rely on his cavalier batting. However, England inexplicably promoted him to No.6 this summer, which doesn’t suit the recklessness and freedom he likes to play with.

Ali now has just 102 runs at an average of 20, after starting the series relatively well. While Moeen fell to the short ball yesterday, it’s been his willingness to get on top of fellow off-spinner Nathan Lyon which has proved his downfall, being dismissed four times.

3. Unflappable Smith on his way to 22nd Test hundred
England thought they were on to something when they tried to get under Steve Smith’s skin with some not too subtle sledging tactics in Adelaide.

However, the boasts from the likes of Jimmy Anderson that the tactic had worked fell flat here in Perth, as Smith chiselled out an impressive 92 not out, after coming in under pressure with Australia 2/55.

It was only four years ago, in the corresponding game in Perth, when Smith announced himself with just his second Test century and first on home soil.

No one would have believed at that point that four years on Smith would be on track for his 22nd Test ton, with a batting average hovering over 60.

However, he looked a class above yesterday, striding to the wicket in a confident manner and immediately looking demonstrative and purposeful in his body language and stroke play.

Smith has an amazing first innings record, averaging 79 with the bat throughout his career.

(Photo by Mark Kolbe/Getty Images)

4. Broad struggling with bat and ball
Stuart Broad arrived in Australia as the pantomime villain, in a country where he had enjoyed plenty of success in key Ashes battles in the past.

However, the 2017/18 series is threatening to go by without a significant contribution from Broad who bowled weakly yesterday on a Perth surface offering encouragement to the seamers.

Broad has just five wickets, at an average of 43, just a day short of the halfway point of the series, and is desperately needed today if England are to remain alive in this Ashes series.

It is 19 Tests and almost two years since Broad took five wickets in an innings. While Broad’s lack of production with the ball is a concern, it’s his batting that truly is a sad tale and shows what a mental game cricket can be.

Three years ago Broad had his face smashed by a searing bouncer from Indian fast bowler Varun Aaron. Since that time, Broad has gone from an extremely useful No.8 batsman who had 20 half-centuries and a century, to a crease hopping bunny who wants no part of these Australian quicks.

5. It’s a big day for Mitchell Marsh
I said yesterday I could feel the Twitter knives sharpening for Mitchell Marsh even before he set foot on the crease for his first innings.

If Australia were to lose this game, one can sense the heat already coming the selectors’ way, and the mocking of Marsh if he was to fail with the bat.

Marsh had a largely forgettable first couple of days back in the Baggy Green, bowling nine innocuous and ineffective overs for 43 runs, and spilling a simple chance at first slip.

While the wicket was flat and outstanding for batting, Marsh looked like a man well short of a gallop with the ball after having shoulder surgery in the off-season.

The fact he wasn’t used until after the 70th over showed the need for an all-rounder was perhaps exaggerated, or over played, given the lack of faith shown in him by Smith when England were piling on the runs.

It’s probably a good thing Marsh says he doesn’t read any social media any more as they will have their fingers at the ready today. Regardless it’s good opportunity to produce with the bat on his home deck.

The Crowd Says:

AUTHOR

2017-12-17T20:47:58+00:00

Eddie Otto

Roar Guru


I thin Broad might be on the chopping block guys. Has been totally ineffectual. His batting also sets a poor example as a senior player. He might be saved by the Overton injury however I still would not be afraid to drop him.

2017-12-16T04:08:48+00:00

Chris Kettlewell

Roar Guru


Before the tour many were saying that Broad was likely to be the best English bowler for the Ashes and the question was whether any of the other bowlers could do any good also. But I really felt that Broad seemed to have dropped off over the last couple of years and may well struggle. He still has the odd period of decent bowling, but where Anderson has had the best couple of years of his career (albeit basically all played at home in England) and so, while not coming to conditions he likes, is clearly in good form, Broad seemed the opposite.

2017-12-16T02:37:47+00:00

Cadfael

Roar Guru


Another point you could have made was on the England captaincy. With a game they should have wanted to win, a 7-2 field was a poor way to go around it. I will sympathise with him in that he has been given a pop gun attack

2017-12-16T02:29:55+00:00

Cadfael

Roar Guru


Nine overs out of 115 bowled is not what one would expect from the fifth bowler. A poor miss at first slip (luckily it wasn't too costly with Stoneham out soon after). How he bats today ill probably decide if he is to remain. I do feel that if Hanscomb had to go, another specialist batsman should have been picked. I would have liked to see Jake Lehmann given a run.

2017-12-16T02:09:00+00:00

Rosso

Guest


Overton is a real talent for England , he can bat too

2017-12-16T01:20:36+00:00

peter chrisp

Guest


It will be interesting see how M&M will perform after getting yet another strange call up a dropped catch and his bowling had no impact at all we shall wait & see

2017-12-16T01:10:46+00:00

Chris Love

Roar Guru


Agree Rosso, I think Overton looks by far their best bowler on these decks. He’s in red hot form but Shaun Marsh always leaves me uneasy when coming in to bat. Will he get through this early period and pile them on again or will he offer up a nothing shot again before he hits 30? He’s so good to watch when he gets going but makes me nervous watching him get set. I thought Bancroft looked really good also before falling. It’s not too big a reach to smell a big score coming from him just around the corner. With the exception of the second innings in Brisbane we haven’t had much from our opening pair. This line up could be lethal right now with them firing.

2017-12-15T23:59:46+00:00

Rosso

Guest


Good article and I agree with all 5 points. Smith was just sublime and Khawaja provided great support with a good 50. Broad looks all over shop but their injured bowler overton looked good. Very interesting day 3 set up

Read more at The Roar