Where in the world should we play Ben Hunt?

By Adz Sportz / Roar Guru

Sporting history is made up of memorable and defining moments.

History was made in 2015 when the North Queensland Cowboys defeated the Brisbane Broncos in one of greatest rugby league grand finals ever played.

It was a game full of memorable and defining moments, but none more memorable than Ben Hunt dropping the kick-off in golden point extra time which led to a Johnathan Thurston field goal, securing a maiden premiership for the Cowboys.

Is it a moment that has defined the career of Hunt thus far?

It’s a moment that’s made him the most polarising figure in the NRL. Some leap to the playmakers defence during the tough times, while others criticise him for being unable to deliver on the big stage or when his team needs him the most.

Ben Hunt after the infamous drop. (AAP Image/Mick Tsikas)

Since the 2015 grand final, Hunt’s form over the past three seasons has been inconsistent at best.

He missed out on a big money contract with the Broncos, as they opted to invest millions on former halves partner Anthony Milford. He was dropped to reserve grade by his former coach Wayne Bennett midway through the 2017 season, only to return and earn an Origin debut for Queensland off the bench.

Then, perhaps to the surprise of many, he was offered a mega $6 million, five-year contract to play for the St George Illawarra Dragons.

With big money contracts, comes a huge amount of responsibility, pressure to succeed and produce the winning plays in those defining moments in big games.

Hunt’s 2018 season began with a lot of promise, producing a stellar performance over his former club in Round 1. He then went on to earn the vacant halfback jumper for Queensland for the State of Origin series opener.

Despite Hunt’s early season form with the Dragons, the memories of his 2015 grand final nightmare led to many questions on whether he’d be able to handle the big stage on the eve of Origin 1. He produced a reasonable performance but was unable to get Queensland over the line.

Those same questions lingered on the eve of Origin 2 with the series on the line for Queensland. Unfortunately for Hunt, he was unable to deliver during the key moments of the match and New South Wales claimed a rare series victory.

In perhaps the defining moment of the series, for New South Wales, Hunt kicked the ball dead on the third tackle, when the Blues were down to 12 men and on the ropes.

The ghosts of the 2015 grand final came back to haunt Hunt again, as he was crucified by the media and fans after Origin two and copped most of the blame for Queensland’s loss.

To make matters worse for Hunt, he was overlooked for the halfback role in Origin three, relegated to the bench as Queensland selectors opted to re-call Daly Cherry-Evans. This was a major blow for Hunt’s confidence and his form for the Dragons hasn’t been the same since.

[latest_videos_strip category=”league” name=”League”]

While many often critique Ben Hunt’s game and express their opinions on what he needs to do, and what not do to improve, there’s one question that often gets overlooked or ignored – is halfback Ben Hunt’s best position?

Players who are fortunate enough to don the number 7 jersey at NRL level is due to one of two factors, you’re either a naturally talented halfback like Johnathan Thurston, or you’re a manufactured halfback from sheer hard work and determination like Cooper Cronk.

Hunt spent the majority of his first four years playing first-grade as a bench utility for Brisbane, often used at dummy half. In 2017, he was switched from halfback to hooker at the backend of the season to cover the loss of Broncos regular number 9, Andrew McCullough, who suffered a season ending injury.

Hunt was sensational at hooker. He was solid in defence, potent in attack and helped guide the Broncos deep into the finals, which resulted in calls for Dragons coach Paul McGregor to play Hunt at hooker instead of halfback when he arrived at the club, as well as calls for Hunt to be handed the Maroons number 9 jersey when Cameron Smith retired from representative football just weeks before the Origin series began.

Fast forward to Origin 3 and as mentioned earlier, Hunt was relegated to bench utility. He was injected into the game in the 30th minute at dummy half and played so well that he kept starting hooker Andrew McCullough off the field until the 76th minute.

His first half try against the Roosters in Round 20, further proves his vision out of dummy half is as good as any hooker going around.

With the Dragons currently experiencing yet another late season fade out, those same questions remain as to whether Hunt can lead his side to a grand final, then whether he can step up in the grand final to deliver a premiership.

If he can’t, then the Dragons have a major dilemma, as it seems they’ve signed a naturally talented hooker to play as a manufactured halfback, who still has four years left to run on his $6 million contract.

For Ben Hunt, he needs to find the same formula to success as another manufactured halfback, Cooper Cronk, or succumb to the fact that he’s better suited at dummy half for himself and for whichever teams he’s playing for.

The Crowd Says:

2018-08-16T08:45:50+00:00

Kurt S

Roar Pro


Yes, at hooker he can decide when to run and when to take control. He seems to have a decent tempo when in hooker. Get Steve Walters or Cameron Smith or even Jason Hetherington into his ear about how to control the game and it might just be his making. Get his defense right and it might be a go. He doesn't seem to handle pressure in the big occasions when he is the play maker. and there is no shame in that. He is still solid and contributes. After the 2015 GF I really thought he was going to fade away out of top grade but to his credit he pushed on and improved. Working with Langer and Walters at the Brons in the past have given some glimpses, but he doesn't demand the ball and change the outcome of big games anywhere where he needs to. If Langer and Walters couldn't instill that in him whilst he was playing half, I'm not sure who can. This year's Origin 1 and 2 may have scarred him, though.

2018-08-16T08:41:50+00:00

Don

Roar Rookie


My issue is not with Hunt as a quality half. He is. But we are measuring his effectiveness in SOO and now behind a forward pack that is not having even half the impact of earlier this season. Plenty of very good halfbacks haven't performed at SOO level but been unreal in the NRL or NSWRL back in the day. Mitchell Pearce is the most recent example. The issue with Hunt is that he is knackered and is playing behind a pack that is even more knackered and now they have lost Widdop they are likely stuffed. He's not worth $1M a year but he'll get the job done as long as his pack does their job...

AUTHOR

2018-08-16T07:04:42+00:00

Adz Sportz

Roar Guru


I can understand both sides of the argument here. He did receive high praise from a lot of people for his performance in Origin 3 and again, he kept McCullough out of the game for pretty much the rest of the match. He didn't provide a try assist, but he provided another kicking option, 3 runs which is standard for a 50 minute stint and offered good service with his passing game. As far as his defence goes, his hit on Tariq Sims was a game changer if my memory serves me correct. Defending in the middle compared to defending on an edge presents different challenges. It's not just about making the tackle, its about defensive reads as well as executing their defensive structures and communication with the players defending next to you, which, by observation, he seems to struggle with defending on an edge. It's a bit different in the middle-third when you have forwards running straight at you, you just need to be sure of your tackling technique, and I've seen Hunt put on some big hits before eg Tariq in Origin 3. Defence is one aspect of his game that needs to improve regardless of what position he plays, but IMO I believe he offers more in attack playing at hooker, with his vision, his running game, his passing game and his kicking ability out of dummy half. And Nat, one of his 2 individual tries against the Roosters, was from dummy half. It was great vision and he showed great speed off the mark to score it. I don't think he'll be considered for the Origin halfback spot next year, regardless of how well he's playing. Morgan and DCE will be at the front of the line and Ash Taylor will also be considered depending on his form and development, however I do believe Hunt could very easily snatch the #9 jersey from McCullough for next years series.

AUTHOR

2018-08-16T06:41:29+00:00

Adz Sportz

Roar Guru


I'm not convinced that he's lived up to his price tag at all. While his form before the origin series was OK, he benefitted from playing off the back of the comps most dominate forward pack (which is why most of them got selected for origin) plus he was playing inside Widdop who was in great form. Now with their forwards looking tired and not producing what they were producing in the early rounds and with Widdop's form taking a hit, also him now being out injured, Hunt has looked all at sea. I think perhaps the Qld selectors were duped into believing the hype surrounding Hunt's form pre-origin.

AUTHOR

2018-08-16T06:32:28+00:00

Adz Sportz

Roar Guru


Many in the media as well as ex-players and commentators share your view. I also believe that's his best position.

2018-08-16T06:26:36+00:00

Emcie

Roar Guru


He's got the thrid highest missed tackles this year despite being positioned beside two of the best defensive players in the comp. He can pull off the odd good tackle but he's far from a reliable defender

2018-08-16T06:24:36+00:00

Emcie

Roar Guru


I'm sorry but Hunt was no where near being the Broncos best after McCullough got injured. He only scored points in one of the five games when he was coming off the bench to hooker in the regular season (with Thiaday was doing all the hard work early), and once in the finals he managed a total of 3 runs from dummy half in the first two games and pulled out 4 in the third game in which they ended up scoreless. I'm not sure that one win (and 1 try) from three finals games suggests he was a revelation. Even in Origin 3, what exactly did he create? Absolutely nothing. QLD were in complete control until Hunt came on, then NSW were all over them. He was far removed from the 2 trys that QLD created once he came on and a lot of attacking plays died once the ball got to him. I honestly don't understand where this number 9 hype is coming from.

2018-08-16T06:17:25+00:00

Nat

Roar Guru


He is avery good player but where the Saints saw $1m for him, I'll never know. If it's an investment in the future, he's 28 with 5yrs to run on the $1m contract. Good luck to him and the Saints on that call.

2018-08-16T06:14:03+00:00

Nat

Roar Guru


My qualm is not his attack, he pulled the Broncos out quite a few times but he needs confidence and even when they got dominated by the Roosters a few weeks back, when he decided to run - 2 individual tries. To move him to Hooker, what do you do with McInnes? Cam ave's more runs and meters, and made over 500 more tackles this yr with a 93% efficiency where Hunt is 75%. I think you lose more than you gain putting him in the middle.

2018-08-16T06:03:13+00:00

Nat

Roar Guru


That's fine but if you think he was the Broncos best player late last year I think we were watching different games. He ended up being their best option at hooker but he was 3rd choice behind McGuire and even Thaiday. In his 4 games at Hooker, he totaled less than 100m, 2 try assists and a single line break. Defensively, 15 missed tackles and a bucket of errors. It's fine to have opposing views but I've followed him his whole career and IMO you'll get more from him as a half than a hooker.

2018-08-16T05:30:56+00:00

jimmmy

Roar Rookie


That’s a really good spot for him Albo. It just doesn’t usually come with a seven figure salary.

2018-08-16T05:12:19+00:00

Zavjalova

Roar Rookie


Hunt can hold his own in defence. He actually has a pretty good tackling technique. If he stuck with being a hooker, he would have already developed his defensive game to handle the opposing forward pack.

AUTHOR

2018-08-16T04:21:15+00:00

Adz Sportz

Roar Guru


I think #14 will be his position when it comes to Origin from now on. I can't see him regaining the #7 jersey regardless of how well he's playing at club level. Morgan, DCE or even Ash Taylor will have leap frogged him for Origin 1 next year

AUTHOR

2018-08-16T04:18:20+00:00

Adz Sportz

Roar Guru


That obvious eh? Haha Hunt is a decent halfback don't get me wrong. But I wouldn't put him anywhere near the level of a JT or Cronk. I think the likes of Maloney, DCE and maybe Adam Reynolds have him covered. Cleary and Ash Taylor may have a lot less experience, but I also believe they are much more naturally talented than Hunt as a halfback. However, Hunt could give most hookers a run for their money if he was a permanent number 9.

2018-08-16T04:16:05+00:00

Albo

Guest


After a few sessions on the therapist's couch, I think Hunt could become a handy number 14. He could be called upon in times of need as a spine replacement for the 1,6,7, & 9. I am not convinced he is starting spine player let alone a $1m player.

AUTHOR

2018-08-16T04:14:07+00:00

Adz Sportz

Roar Guru


When he runs, from dummy half, he can create and finish as good as anyone. How many times did he do it last year for the Broncos when he was moved to hooker? Hunt offered a whole new dimension in attack for Queensland in Origin 3. He made over 100 metres kicking from the ruck, has that powerful running game, great passing game. He also made 21 tackles in 50 minutes. His struggles in defence as a half is largely due to defending on an edge and his inability to read the oppositions sweeping plays and structures. Defending in the middle is a lot easier for him in regards to reading plays, as he's predominately tackling forwards in the middle third, and he's proven to be strong for a little bloke so he can handle the forwards. But who am I to say... those rose coloured glasses are probably skewing my views lol

AUTHOR

2018-08-16T03:58:07+00:00

Adz Sportz

Roar Guru


Jimmmy, I wonder if he knows that his best position is hooker, but prefers to play halfback, trying his best to manufacture himself into a halfback, because that's were the money is. When he was offered the Dragons contract, I bet he thought he had won the lotto.

AUTHOR

2018-08-16T03:55:01+00:00

Adz Sportz

Roar Guru


Hi Matt, I feel from a Broncos fans perspective, you're probably right. His 2014-15 seasons he was excellent, but his form nosedived dramaically in the 2016-17 seasons in which his flaws as a half were exposed. The editers changed the title of this artice and it's a bit nonsensical, but it's a positional conversation haha

2018-08-16T03:43:08+00:00

Zavjalova

Roar Rookie


Disagree with everything you said. Hunt was clearly the Broncos best player after McCullough got injured last year. Just take a look at the difference in his state of origin 1 & 2 performances compared to his performance in game 3. A blind man could see that he's so much more dangerous at hooker than he is a halfback. He always has been and I've watched many ex-players on tele suggest exactly what this article says. Not saying he isn't a decent halfback. He struggles to manage a team. He can't manage a grand final team. He can't manage and origin team. His best position is hooker and he's be a bloody good one if he played there full time.

2018-08-16T03:32:35+00:00

Zavjalova

Roar Rookie


Yeah i agree with what's written in this article. Hunt has always been a better hooker than halfback. A blind man could see that!

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar