Who will play the All Australian team?

By The Crowd / Roar Guru

The 2018 AFL All Australian team has just been announced, and what a star-studded team it is, featuring Lance Franklin, Alex Rance, Patrick Dangerfield, Dustin Martin and more.

But wouldn’t it be great if they had another team to show off their collective talent? If those talented players could represent Australia in a meaningful international competition?

But how? Professional Australian football is not played in any other country, so surely this is impossible, just a pipe dream. But rather than just put it straight into the too-hard basket, let’s think about how we could make it happen.

I believe that a ‘if we build it, they will come’ strategy would work. Of course it will take time and inevitably must start small, but from little things big things grow.

I believe if we put in place the right incentives, Australian Rules football can grow exponentially and organically around the globe.

I’m old enough to remember how the interest in the America’s Cup grew and grew as each challenger was defeated by the New York Yacht Club. It was 132 years before the first successful challenge was mounted by Alan Bond in 1983 with Australia II. Who would’ve thought that a yacht challenge could generate that much interest? Something similar could work for Australian Rules football.

I believe a similar format to the America’s Cup challenge series would make for a successful international Australian Rules competition. A significant and suitable cash prize and a perpetual ‘Australia’s Cup’ trophy would be necessary.

(Mark Brake/Getty Images)

If introduced, I envisage a similarly long, slow burn of international challengers to wrest the cup from Australia’s grasp. I concede that at the start it would be just a novelty interest, but over time I expect that would change.

How much would the AFL Commission and any interested sponsors, be prepared to invest to establish Australian football as a meaningful global game? Would it be $2 million per annum or $5 million per annum? This doesn’t seem that expensive when compared with the lucrative broadcast rights that the men’s AFL competition attracts.

The AFL challenge series would involve an annual, biennial or triennial tournament whereby the winner of an international knockout event would qualify to challenge for the ‘Australia’s Cup’ against that year’s AFL All Australian team. This could involve qualifying teams from different geographically aligned affiliated federations – for example, from the Americas, Europe, Asia, Africa, Oceania et cetera.

For example, if the AFL Commission invested a startup $20 million as prize money to the first international team to beat the Australian team and then topped this up with an additional $2 million for each unsuccessful challenge, the funds and the incentive and the interest would grow exponentially.

Under a scenario of topping up an initial $20 million in prize money by just $1 million per annum the total funds would be over $50 million by 2050 – assuming the All Australian team was still unbeaten of course. Heaven forbid the embarrassment and humiliation that would befall the first All Australian team to lose the international challenge.

The prize money funds would probably need to be held in trust, and with astute investment the interest would eventually cover the annual top-up. Of course there would be other costs, but they would be manageable.

(Brett Hemmings/AFL Media/Getty Images)

The challenger knockout series could be held in Australia in September – either annually, biennially, or triennially – and the successful challenger would compete against the All Australian team in early October. Imagine an Irish team featuring Zach Tuohy, Conor McKenna, Pearce Hanley, Mark O’Connor, Ciarán Byrne, Cillian McDaid and Colin O’Riorden, a US team led by Mason Cox or a Fijian team comprising with Nic Naitanui and Esava Ratugolea. I believe there would be interest.

Of course Australia should win easily at first – and maybe a half-time or points differential mercy rule could be included – but over time I think the competition would become more competitive.

I was envious of the FIFA World Cup held in Russia this year. What a spectacle that was with such worldwide interest. Wouldn’t it be great to see just a small portion of that international attention and focus on our own indigenous game? And then maybe people would start to appreciate and enjoy the beauty and skill of our game.

I’m biased, but I believe that Australian Rules football is the best spectator and participation sport on the planet. My objective means for assessing its relative appeal with other sports is to compare the level of interest and engagement on the spectators’ faces as the camera pans across the crowd.

In most AFL games the crowd engagement is clearly evident, whereas when the camera pans across the crowd at most other sports, the level of crowd engagement is generally much less. Ice hockey, netball and Gaelic football are other sports with quite good crowd engagement.

This may be a pipedream, but if we don’t dream and don’t take an initial step, then sure as eggs, nothing will eventuate.

I’d Appreciate any comments and possible improvements to my suggestion.

By Joseph Lee

The Crowd Says:

2018-08-31T14:41:41+00:00

Papa Joe

Roar Rookie


Fair enough - I concede your point. I went to many of the Asian Cup games in Australia a few years ago and a few Brisbane Roar games (when they on top) and the crowd engagement was very good. I shouldn't have included Football in that list. Baseball in Japan in another sport where the crowd engagement is extraordinary - and worth the admission just on its own.

2018-08-31T04:49:01+00:00

Phil

Roar Rookie


"In most AFL games the crowd engagement is clearly evident, whereas when the camera pans across the crowd at most other sports, the level of crowd engagement is generally much less. Ice hockey, netball and Gaelic football are other sports with quite good crowd engagement." Have you been to a football match anywhere in the world? You state that you were envious of the FIFA World Cup and maybe the crowds were part of the reason. Football crowds have some of the best crowd engagement. Yes there have been some issues with some football crowds but at the last 2 AFL games I have been to there were people ejected form the ground for their behavior. If you'd like to see a World Championship/Cup in the future then there needs to be a desire for spectators to watch AFL games from people outside of Australia. Look at how the parochial the AFL culture is in Melbourne. There are similar cultures for other sports in other parts of the world. That's the type of culture that you need to break into.

2018-08-31T03:57:17+00:00

Papa Joe

Roar Rookie


Hi Juan - I see my suggestion working in Ireland first. There is already a functioning Irish AFL competition - see http://arfli.com/ And also one in the USA by the way and I imagine in some other countries as well. Over time, I can see interested juniors playing their gaelic football on Saturdays and Aussie Rules on the Sunday (or vice versa). Much like many kids in Qld/NSW do (or did) with league and union. There is little money in Gaelic football, so more Irish kids will be tempted to try Aussie Rules - and with a strong financial carrot for a national Irish AFL team, I think it would expand. The current hybrid Oz/Irish comp is unsatisfactory to both in my view.

2018-08-31T02:07:56+00:00

Juan

Guest


I agree that it would be great to see Aussie rules played on the international stage, but I don't see how this could occur: "I believe if we put in place the right incentives, Australian Rules football can grow exponentially and organically around the globe." If there's no cricket oval available. The fact that so many countries don't have cricket ovals would surely limit the ability for an unmodified version of Aussie Rules to expand? I'm not saying we should try expanding a modified version, just saying that's a limitation you didn't mention. Wouldn't the simplest thing be to further develop the relationship with Ireland and Gaelic football? They are already in the best position to provide a legit international competitor to Australia. There's a way to go, sure, with them not being professional. But coming from a tech background myself, I feel like it makes sense to try a new product on a small scale, test it, improve it and only then, scale up, to more locations and people. So what's your plan for turning the international rules competition into a legit Aussie rules competition between Australia and an Irish Aussie rules team?

2018-08-31T01:10:29+00:00

Paul D

Roar Guru


Wouldn't happen. Would be like assembling a bunch of amateurs from rugby nations all over the world to play the All Blacks. They'd get annihilated the AA side is just a mythical outfit, a sort of side similar to those best all-time XI's in cricket, they never play games and never will. The sole purpose of it is to identify the best players within the 400 or so guys who played AFL each year in the games that were actually played. Not to take the field The international rules series is about all you get and all we will ever get I daresay

2018-08-30T23:30:24+00:00

JamesH

Roar Guru


I like your article as a thought experiment, but your analogy with sailing is flawed. People outside of the US still loved sailing before interest in the Americas Cup grew. It was still a competition sport around the world, having developed from a common mode of transportation. The Cup just raised its profile. On the other hand, most Americans and Europeans have no idea what Aussie Rules is. And even if they did, the AFL sure as hell wouldn't be willing to wait 132 years before another country had the means to knock Australia off its perch.

2018-08-30T21:29:15+00:00

Onside

Guest


The All Australian team must play with themselves

2018-08-30T18:52:45+00:00

max power

Guest


the best improvement you can make to your plan is to forget about it completely. there are probably 50 sports with legitimate world cups and australian football wont become one of them

2018-08-30T16:23:41+00:00

Gordon P Smith

Roar Guru


I love it. That's what the mixed rules cup with Ireland's Gaelic stars is supposed to be.

Read more at The Roar