Does Tim Cahill deserve a farewell Socceroos friendly?

By Mike Tuckerman / Expert

There’s no denying the fact that Tim Cahill is a Socceroos legend, but does he deserve a final farewell against Lebanon at ANZ Stadium on November 20?

How many more goals would Cahill have scored for the Socceroos if he hadn’t been forced to delay making his debut until the age of 24, after once turning out for Samoa as a 14-year-old in a meaningless friendly?

That friendly ended up costing Cahill years in the green-and-gold, and it wasn’t until the late Sydney Morning Herald journalist Mike Cockerill took up the cause and started publicising Cahill’s case that FIFA eventually relaxed its rules around national allegiance.

And it’s a testament to Cockerill’s journalism that years after taking up the cudgels for Cahill, he turned around and wrote a prescient column claiming that Cahill was risking his legacy with his dalliance with the A-League.

You were one of a kind, Mike, and you are sadly missed.

But will Cahill be? Or has a frustrating 2018 World Cup campaign in Russia – where the erstwhile Millwall striker was handed just 37 minutes of action by interim coach Bert van Marwijk in the final pool game – taken some of the shine off a glittering Socceroos career?

There’s a misconception in some quarters that Cahill loaded up on goals early on in his Socceroos career against inferior opponents from Oceania.

But a quick fact-check suggests that was hardly the case, with Cahill scoring a brace in his second Socceroos appearance against Tahiti and a hat-trick against Fiji in the OFC Nations Cup, and another goal against the Solomon Islands in a 2006 World Cup qualifier.

And the calibre of opponent for his next international goals – Norway, the Netherlands and, famously, Japan – prove that Cahill was a decisive figure from early on in his international career.

In fact, Cahill had a knack for consistently scoring in the biggest games of all – and not just at the World Cup.

He scored in three consecutive Asian Cups, including a double in Brisbane that took Australia into the semi-finals on home soil in 2015.

He scored a vital winner against Oman in Melbourne in 2011 in Asian Cup qualifying that helped the Socceroos narrowly top a group they struggled to emerge from.

And he scored an incredible 20 goals in World Cup qualification – including two in the 2018 continental playoff against Syria at ANZ Stadium last October.

In fact, his 11 goals in 2018 World Cup qualification gave him the same total as Belgian striker Romelu Lukaku and Danish playmaker Christian Eriksen.

Yet his ill-fated stint at Melbourne City and the incessant references to his legacy have tarnished Cahill’s reputation for some.

Then there was his dogged pursuit of a place in van Marwijk’s squad. For all the goals, did he truly deserve to be there?

At the end of the day, it doesn’t really matter. History shows that he did indeed travel to Russia, where he failed to become the first Australian player to score in four consecutive World Cups.

But doesn’t the fact that he was good enough to put himself in that position deserve our acknowledgement?

Couldn’t we simply applaud Cahill onto the pitch for the final ten minutes against Lebanon, instead of cutting him down like every other tall poppy who does something notable?

Bastian Schweinsteiger played a testimonial for Bayern Munich in midweek that saw 75,000 fans turn out to watch the former German international and World Cup winner play one half for his current side Chicago Fire and the other half for Bayern.

I doubt there were too many fans inside the Allianz Arena sniggering at Schweinsteiger’s contribution to the German game.

The fact is that Football Federation Australia have finally listened to fans by taking the Socceroos back to Brisbane for a friendly against South Korea on November 17.

They should do one other thing, and give Cahill a brief cameo against Lebanon in Sydney so that he can get the hometown farewell he honestly deserves.

The Crowd Says:

2018-09-04T13:48:35+00:00

Cousin Claudio

Roar Guru


One of our best ever Socceroos and leading goalscorer. Of course he does deserve the recognition. ANZ stadium will be sold out and a nice little earner for the FFA or whoever is left in charge by then.

2018-09-04T00:05:56+00:00

parkhacker

Roar Rookie


No, I am a Tim Cahill fan but he had his last farewell game in Russia. We should leave it as that perhaps he could make a final appearance at an Asian cup match like do a lap in a convertible sports car and wave to the crowd.Also he could make a final speech to his legion of fans.This could be arranged at the half time break.

2018-09-02T11:02:01+00:00

chris

Guest


...at least football has its tab back on the main page. Roar what were you thinking? Oh thats right...you're all AFL and Rugby fans

2018-09-01T00:02:15+00:00

Pdro

Guest


No way

2018-08-31T07:44:32+00:00

Football is Life

Roar Rookie


Honestly if something was not done for Tim it would go down in Australian history as a dead set crime, a national travesty!

2018-08-31T07:12:44+00:00

Bri Blackwell

Guest


Why pose the question if you are going to answer it in the positive? The headline is written as clickbait. It should have said something along the lines of 'why Tim Cahill deserves a big sendoff' etc. Otherwise, an interesting and accurate article.

2018-08-31T05:04:27+00:00

RF

Guest


It is unfortunate that FFA is now in negotiations with Cahill's "management". Sums up everything I dislike about Cahill as a footballer. Framing it as if he is doing Australian football a favour and, as it always is with Cahill, in the end it comes down to money. One thing I most surely will not miss about him is the serial use of spurious altruism being used to cover up otherwise naked self interest.

2018-08-31T04:32:47+00:00

Brian

Guest


Sorry but Arnold has 2 games in charge before the Asian Cup. He can hardly afford to waste one on a testimonial. After the Asian Cup sure, but before am not sure

2018-08-31T02:50:55+00:00

AGO74

Guest


Yes he deserves the opportunity for a friendly farewell. It’s up to him whether he accepts. For mine he was worth taking to Russia for his leadership alone - he was playing in a position which we desperately lacked quality in power lus he head runs on the board as recently as the Syria match so it’s not like he was taking it from somebody else who deserved it more.

2018-08-31T01:55:47+00:00

aubgraham

Roar Rookie


I disagree that Cahill deserves a farewell Socceroos game before the Asian Cup. To be a proper farewell I believe Cahill would need to start and play until the 60th minute of the game. Basically it would use up a friendly that would otherwise be used as a warmup for the Asian Cup defense. Since there are only two friendlies organised with FIFA international match windows between now and our Asian Cup defense this would constitute 50% of those games. With a new coach, I don't think this is an appropriate use of these games. I do believe Cahill deserves a farewell match immediately after the Asian Cup. However, what form this farewell match takes is a different discussion.

2018-08-31T01:32:47+00:00

Fadida

Guest


Agree, the format is truly horrendous

2018-08-30T23:43:59+00:00

Redondo

Roar Rookie


It’s not age Mid, just poor design. Disorienting navigation, it sacrifices content in favour of colour, and it fills comments section with white space. All up, I spend too much time scrolling up and down to find stuff and then more time laboriously scrolling to read stuff. It’s awful. Did anyone design this or is it a package? If it was designed I doubt it was based on actual usage patterns. And I can’t work out how to get alerts for new posts - has that disappeared now? MQ/Grobbelaar has disappeared too - was that part of the design brief?

2018-08-30T23:29:50+00:00

mattq

Roar Rookie


not just you mid. this new website format is confusing! I can't tell which articles are new and which are being commented on. I mean I kinda can but it is a backwards step from the old format.

2018-08-30T23:10:49+00:00

Midfielder

Roar Guru


I think he does. Don't like the new format... must be getting old...

2018-08-30T22:47:12+00:00

Stevo

Roar Rookie


Geez Mike, that’s two articles that have been NAIL.HEAD. Agree, need to publicly recognise outstanding contributions and this certainly deserves that recognition.

2018-08-30T22:16:20+00:00

Fadida

Guest


I'd love to see it. He'd probably score too!

2018-08-30T21:49:59+00:00

Kaks

Roar Guru


He deserves something, that's for sure. That forehead has done more for this country than anyone ever has!

Read more at The Roar