I'm totally over the Haka

By Tim Gore / Expert

Sometimes I feel like if I ever see another Haka again it will be too soon.

Why?

No, it’s not because the All Blacks have been routinely slaughtering my Wallabies every year for the last decade and a half. With all of the smug and smarmy baiting our siblings across the ditch unleash upon us – I figure it is good for them to be decent at something.

I’m sick of the Haka because it has started to lose its aura, its significance, its poignancy – through what I feel is often inappropriate overuse.

Once upon a time it seemed to me that the Haka was performed only by the All Blacks before a rugby Test match.

It was a special part of the event.

It was exciting to watch and you could tell it was a great honour to be performing it. It was a battle cry that added real intensity and sense of occasion. In fact, my first memory of rugby union was my father dragging me to the telly and making me watch the Haka and explaining just how superb the All Blacks were at the sport.

The subsequent Haka I witnessed convinced me that these men in Black were surely great warriors to be respected and feared.

I must admit I loved it when Wallaby Phil Kearns blew kisses at the All Blacks while they were performing it.

It is arguable that our boys in gold deriding the Haka in such a manner is possibly our cultural equivalent. Plenty of our unruly World War I Diggers – who we have somehow managed to sanctify – would certainly have approved of such baiting.

As I suspect the Rats of Tobruk and the diggers at the Eureka Stockade would also have. However, the edict was then put out that the Haka was to be properly respected as the significant cultural performance that it is.

The Kiwis perform the Haka. (photo by Conor Molloy/Action Plus via Getty Images)

However, in recent years the Kiwis have gone Haka crazy and are in danger of disrespecting it more than any obnoxious opponents ever could.

Seeing four Kiwis perform an impromptu Haka in the aisle to honour their countryman Roger Tuivasa-Sheck winning the Dally M this season really got me thinking about this overuse.

Every time you turn around there seems to be another bunch of Kiwis performing the Haka. Things like sending someone off at a funeral, other New Zealand sporting teams performing it, and in honour of wins like Tuivasa-Sheck’s I guess are fine – and probably appropriate.

While I’d like it to be solely the possession of the New Zealand Rugby Team, why should it just belong to the All Blacks? Why shouldn’t any of their national sides be able to use it? Why shouldn’t it be used to honour deserving Kiwis too?

My worry is that it is also being used in less appropriate circumstances that are diluting this wonderful war cry and making it lose its lustre

Now there are even wedding Hakas. Sometimes I feel like we are getting to the point where we’ll be seeing spontaneous Hakas when someone posts a letter or receives their meal at a restaurant.

I personally think that there should be rules around who can perform one and when they can do it.

However, as an Aussie I have no idea who should make those rules and I have absolutely no say or stake in that happening.

All I know is that if Australia had a comparable cultural performance of such significance I’d certainly want it better looked after than I feel the Haka is currently being cared for.

And that’s the other thing that makes me sick of the Haka: I’m totally jealous of it.

Australia doesn’t have any equivalent that we can use to unify and represent us – like the Haka does for the Kiwis.

We’ve had banalities like “AUSSIE, AUSSIE, AUSSIE! OI! OI! OI” – a chant stolen from the Cornish (“Oggie” changed to “Aussie”) that mercifully died out, like the equally annoying vuvuzela craze.

For a while after Australia II’s Americas Cup triumph in 1983, Men at Work’s Down Under became a vague anthem, but it never really took. I guess the description of our nation as a place “Where beer does flow and men chunder” may have had some accuracy, but it is hardly “Ka Mate! Ka Mate! Ka ora! Ka ora!”

Nor did the efforts to get Waltzing Matilda – a cheerful little ditty about a disenfranchised itinerant suiciding after being busted stealing a sheep – as a regular pre game tradition really take hold.

Australia would love a Haka. (Photo by Brendon Thorne/Getty Images)

Then there is our national anthem: Advance Australia Fair. It was actually composed in 1878 by Scottish born Peter Dodds McCormick. It replaced God Save the Queen as our anthem over a century later in 1984.

It actually has three verses and occasionally a choir will attempt to sing them all before the crowd roars and the stadium sounds cut off their microphones, much to the chagrin of their uptight choir mistress.

Occasionally – think the 2006 football World Cup – our crowd will belt it out brilliantly to announce that we are there and loud.

But mostly it’s just an odd song.

As much as some got very upset about a schoolgirl refusing to stand for it recently, my experience is that lots of us don’t even know the words to the first verse, let alone the rest of them.

Back in 1992 I went to a Test match between the Kangaroos and the British Lions. Packed together in the mud and sweat of the wet area at the north east end of the old Lang Park we were regaled by an impromptu version of God Save the Queen” by the travelling Lions fans. Singing their anthem as one, they gave the event so much atmosphere.

Being the loudmouth rabble rouser I’ve always been, I tried to get all the drunken Queenslanders around me to sing our anthem in response. It quickly became apparent that most had no idea of the words. While lots laugh at the word “girt” featuring in our national song, the people from north of the Tweed who surrounded me that night didn’t have any idea at all of the words.

They did know Waltzing Matilda though, so we belted that out instead.

Then there is the Australian cricket team’s victory chant:

Under the Southern Cross I Stand
A sprig of wattle in my hand,
A native of my native land,
Australia you little* beauty

I mean, I love it, but can you see our sides yelling this out pre game at their opponents?

One of my very favourite moments of Australian sporting celebration was at the conclusion of an Allan Border Medal ceremony in the very early 2000s when the entire ACB contracted squad got up on stage and belted out Cold Chisel’s Khe Sahn with great enthusiasm and little skill.

It was magical.

However, a song named after a battle the Australians were not involved with at all, about a Vietnam vet returning to Australia and casual sex, drug use, post-traumatic stress disorder, itinerant work and alienation – all before going to Hong Kong to sleep with prostitutes – isn’t exactly the sort of anthem we should be putting before the world.

Jimmy Barnes performs during the 2018 AFL Grand Final match between the Collingwood Magpies and the West Coast Eagles (Photo by Quinn Rooney/Getty Images)

Or maybe it is?

Maybe a melange of all of these imperfect options might be created to represent who we are and unite us.

I guess if someone could do an effective mash up it might work? I’d personally like a bit of Highway to Hell or Long Way to the Top thrown in there as well. I’m sure Daryl Braithwaite’s Horses and John Farnham’s You’re the Voice would also have sponsors. The more straight laced amongst us might push for We Are Australian.

However, it is hard to see any one thing being able to be instituted for Australia as a nation that could compare with the majesty, power and symbolism of the Haka.

The Kiwis should both prize and protect that great tradition fiercely if they don’t want to ruin it.

The Crowd Says:

2019-08-25T00:44:07+00:00

StopGo

Guest


Get rid of the. Farta. Joke . Australia does not sing. "Red back on the toilet seat". It is not a singing competition. How the hell are these people allowed to sing this rubbish.

2018-11-19T08:57:47+00:00

piru

Roar Rookie


What is the level of hubris and arrogance allowed before you are subjected to a different set of rules? How does one measure this? Are you high?

2018-11-19T08:53:02+00:00

piru

Roar Rookie


Tim - seeing as no one seems to have addressed this NZ fits into NSW 3 times

2018-11-19T08:50:38+00:00

piru

Roar Rookie


Tell us the name of the Kiwi who hurt you Funbus

2018-11-19T06:27:40+00:00

OD

Roar Rookie


I'm outraged by your article Tim. Advance Australia Fair has 4 verses and a modified 5th verse which is generally sung with the first these days. The other 3 of them are rubbish admittedly but still.... Just saying, that's all!

2018-11-19T04:29:18+00:00

CUW

Roar Rookie


@ Jimmy it takes one to know one ... that is why countries rich in history and cultural heritage respect the Haka , by silence during its performance and applause at the end. Japan France Argentina any island nation that play rugger....

2018-11-19T04:23:47+00:00

taylorman

Roar Guru


Why are you embarrassed? Given you cant actually be embarrassed for someone else.

2018-11-19T04:21:36+00:00

taylorman

Roar Guru


Yes anon perhaps we should removes images of big, angry looking men frothing at the mouth running full tip into another just as angry man with a round piece of leather in his hand from the game as well? Oh wait...

2018-11-19T04:17:26+00:00

CUW

Roar Rookie


the TV company - who also decide on the timeslot and certain other arrangements. and then comes the world body - who have banned any interaction between the teams during the Haka or any other native performance. in fact they have stipulated that the two teams have to be at their 10m lines when this happens. famosly France in 2011 were fined for advancing the Haka at the RWC final. perhaps u shud start a petition to stop the haka at the start of the game - and see how far u can get with those who make the rules.

2018-11-19T04:14:57+00:00

taylorman

Roar Guru


Yes I believe the obligatory haka was due to the fact that it was likely the only interesting thing that was likely to happen all day. ????

2018-11-19T04:10:31+00:00

CUW

Roar Rookie


perhaps the heavy reliance on China is now showing its downside.

2018-11-19T04:06:31+00:00

CUW

Roar Rookie


he may not go - but his partner - " Shickerling ?' will for sure. there was another huge boy in the u20 team - wonder where he is playing....

2018-11-19T04:00:39+00:00

CUW

Roar Rookie


to this day there are countries that are suing GB to return their cultural artifacts and other valuable items. that is what english culture is all about - things stolen from cultures that had existed for over 10000 years and claiming as its own. there is a general reason why english are not liked all around the world - it is their pompousness, and behavior as if they are the gods gift to mankind. at one point in history england had a lot of power because of its navy and guns . so they went around and claimed other lands as their own , killing millions of natives in the process. they looted all those countries and fed off them. but once they had to give up those countries england became nothing. not a military power not an economic power and not even a sporting power. look at most of the sports in englnad - the star players come from the " COMMONWEALTH " :P

2018-11-19T03:52:21+00:00

CUW

Roar Rookie


@ moaman English culture is something stolen from other countries - aka the commonwealth. as Trevor Noah said - there is nothing common about it , or the only common thing is that british stole from the rest of the countries. best eg came up recently. When Meghan Markle wanted to wear an emerald tiara to her wedding the Queen stopped it and gave her something else. THE REASON ? the emerald tiara could not be verified as something the monarchy had ownership of. or in other words how it came into the royal family could not be ascertained. there are so many things like that - for eg the famos blue sapphire on the rig that was worn by Diana and later given to kate , which was taken from Sri lanka .

2018-11-19T03:00:28+00:00

piru

Roar Rookie


The old 'Maori killed and ate the Moriori' theory has been out of vogue for twenty odd years mate

2018-11-19T02:21:44+00:00

Bruce

Guest


Like the Taranaki did on the Moriori? 1810 should be a year of shame but it's celebrated as a mighty victory

2018-11-19T01:18:14+00:00

piru

Roar Rookie


If you went to a baseball game and were bored I'd contend that's largely your own doing

2018-11-19T01:17:29+00:00

piru

Roar Rookie


Perhaps write a letter to World Rugby asking that they rescind the rule of tying and gagging all players and fans during the pregame challenges (as I'm sure you don't mean JUST the haka, but all pregame performances from the likes of Fiji, Samoa etc - I mean if it were just the haka you have a problem with that would be weird).

2018-11-19T01:15:52+00:00

piru

Roar Rookie


Trying some new bait there anon? No nibbles so far,

2018-11-19T01:15:10+00:00

piru

Roar Rookie


Because it's a welcome - you don't welcome someone to your land after they've arrived, then sung some songs. You're trying so hard to pretend you don't understand FB but it's clear that you do

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar