The Roar
The Roar

CUW

Roar Rookie

Joined September 2018

0

Views

0

Published

1.9k

Comments

Published

Comments

CUW hasn't published any posts yet

@ PIRU

Imm not SA supporter and i have no issue them losing

my issue is with the inconsistency of reffing and the cards

in Scotland match yellow given after few continuos fouls in side 25 yrad zone.

in England match it was after 17 penalties and few warnings a yellow came out

maybe there is a need for a Law to say four penalties inside 25 yard zone is automatic yellow

and worse – England fouled even after the yellow – with 99% cinfidence the ref will not give another yellow.

mind u – this is totally different from the way Gallagher is reffed – there are some refs who give yellow after yellow after yellw – much to the annoyance of coaches.

there was one match a couple of years ago when one team lost 3 players consecutively for fouls at mauls and foosides near 5yard line.

my point is – there shud be a way to stop teams engaging in foulplay knowingly – especailly when opponent is in attack zones.

it does not matter whether the team is all blacks bok or japan or uruguay.

UK View: England hailed for 'gloriously breathless outsmarting of South Africa' as Eddie makes Smith demand

England will love to take the ref along every test

gave them a win against France in that final and now against the boks.

17 penalties to 4 before a card is given – RUBBISH !!! 🤢

UK View: England hailed for 'gloriously breathless outsmarting of South Africa' as Eddie makes Smith demand

no he is not – he still doesnt know what a forward pass is 😂

the best english ref retired and went to usa – becoz the rugby world cant handle very good refs like JP Doyle.

currently Monsieur Raynol is far better than anyone – but again gets few matches becoz he is too good at application of the Laws.

'Is there any accountability?': Everything Rennie said as he savaged refs group over 'massive decisions'

all the refs this weekend were rubbish

it took the ref 17 penalties before giving a yellow against England !!!

some people talk about precedents – in that case how did the swinging arm to Ebens face didnot even get a yelow

and yet Siya gets a yellow for contesting a high ball.

worst one for me was when malins slapped the ball out of a saffa while laying on the ground – yet the touchie who was standing next to him saw nothing in it !!! ( 57 minute i thin when SA attacked on the left flank)

similar thing with Wales when they were off side at maul and sacked it – just next to the touchie.

funny how long it took the silly ref to penalize the jersey pull by aussy winger – i mean it was the only thing that happened around a 50 meter radius !!!

Raynol questioned the decision to give yellow to Beale – after that he did not say a word , perhaps he realized no point to argue with a mutt.

'Is there any accountability?': Everything Rennie said as he savaged refs group over 'massive decisions'

i think NZ try to play too much rugger – specially when they are up against the minnow teams.

italy are good – their teams have done well in the pro 14

hate to keep harping on the topic – but reffing is very confusing atm.

i thought this guy favored italy – where as the other guy favored england , and NZ guy favored boks.

rugger seriosly needs to have a look at the law book and make it more simple.

in italy match the ref gave a new defition to long position at rucks – basically u can lie prone on another player and grab the ball

in england match the ref gave a new definition to fair contest for a high kick – by carding the tongan who also went up for it , but not as high as May !!!

basically – if a non aligned fan watched the matches back to back , he will end up pulling out all the hair – coz there was no consitency or application of laws as we see them in other matches.

All Blacks break world records despite 'a lot to work on' after Italy romp, Ireland crush Japan

there are enuf 2nd rowers and 3 rowers in SA and around the world to stuff 3 teams

its just a matter of selections and strategy

im not sure if England have capped David Ribbans ( saints) for eg – he is a young 2nd row now qualified on residency

the Mamoth twins at Sale sharks – i forgot their names – they are really very big n strong rhinos. and also Rohan the center.

there are some big black guys who played flanker – like Bohli , Augustus , even Mohaje , Tutuska ( not sure of spelling )

there are lots of good players and big players – just got to see how good they may be

and some oldies like Marcel

'Bring back that wild waterboy': The Boks are 'sick' and maybe a return to Rassie is the only cure

SA are missing some imagination – Kolbe will have done wonders for them

i think the issue is their backs are very rigid guys – so used to Faf putting it up in the sky and chasing .

i dont think if u put in guys like Kolbe , Andre , Faassi i that backline – they wont do worse.

also those big twins in the pack – im sure they can do better then Orie and Mostert.

also not sure about those subs – Smith was a great 7S player but not sure he is a test class flanker , and have no idea who the bench 2nd rower is!

they will love to have snyman back – and maybe a proper flanker in the FLOW mould

MATCH REPORT: 'Box office' Thor hammers South Africa as Wallabies charge to famous victory

@ PETERK

what was the thinking behind Swinton subbing?

he was in the bin – came back 2nd half – played 5 minutes and was subbed

couldnt get it – i mean he could have stayed off and Samu could have come on when card time was elapsed.

or he could have played a lot more – coz he had a 20 minute break !!!

MATCH REPORT: 'Box office' Thor hammers South Africa as Wallabies charge to famous victory

@ HARRY JONES

why was Andre the giant not selected ? is it to do with quotas?

he was too good in Gallagher

also the other guys in England – like the entire Sale Sharks 😂 only Faf i see in the bok team

MATCH REPORT: 'Box office' Thor hammers South Africa as Wallabies charge to famous victory

he shud learn to go low

he is getting noticed as an upright tackler

he was lucky the head clash came after the tackle – else im sure they will have given a red.

quite a few English refs have given reds for head clashes in Gallagher last season

MATCH REPORT: 'Box office' Thor hammers South Africa as Wallabies charge to famous victory

i thought Quade was in aussy playing club rugger during super rugger season.

MATCH REPORT: 'Box office' Thor hammers South Africa as Wallabies charge to famous victory

i thought ur TMo said theres nothing in it

anyways it was funny how the 2 things panned out.

the aussy tmo was pushing a red for Swinton – at one point the ref was heard saying Luke is right its a shoulder charge ( or something to that effect )

then the Kerevi case ref was just going to let it go but the tmo kept pushing it till a yellow came.

am just wondering if theres been a change of heart from English refs for the new season.

a huge head hit on Bristol Bears player by Sarries player was let go by Barnes – he said its a rugby collision.

its an addition to the lexicon – rugby collision !

funny thing is rugby is a game of collisions – so then are we back to pre concussion era?

MATCH REPORT: 'Box office' Thor hammers South Africa as Wallabies charge to famous victory

@ HArry Jones

how does a double header affect the team playing second – after the ground being cut up?

in cricket it is always a problem for teams playing second on the same pitch – being marked and all

Will the Wallaby scrum survive scrutiny by beer-loving Frans Malherbe, the sweatiest prop in the game?

rugger shud also have an international panel independently reffing tests – like they do in cricket

the amount of things the touchies miss is mindboggling – specially when its like 5m away from their eyes

Will the Wallaby scrum survive scrutiny by beer-loving Frans Malherbe, the sweatiest prop in the game?

i think there were quite a few injury breaks and several tv reviews

argies did go down a lot – perhaps the exhaustion of big number of tackles

A rapid Wallabies turnaround, and other non-Cooper observations

but aussy will be concerned the saffas scored 3 maul trys – despite the good forwards play

wont be surprised if saffas just keep kicking to corner and maul till next week

A rapid Wallabies turnaround, and other non-Cooper observations

also he was helped by very good Carley

like when he looked at a knock on inside goal – by the the time Pearce came to TMO.

i think both teams got a bit of a shock – aussy more – of the north style of reffing

it will be interesting to see how they adjust in next match with Carley

A rapid Wallabies turnaround, and other non-Cooper observations

must be difficult to have hands in the ruck when ball is clear – i mean what are the hands doing there if no ball ? 😛

A rapid Wallabies turnaround, and other non-Cooper observations

@ Harry Jones

what is ur take on saffas not being able to get into try scoring position without a line out and maul?

ok – cheslin was missing but there must be others who can break a defence down

A rapid Wallabies turnaround, and other non-Cooper observations

maybe t he coach likes what Samu learn playing at arguably the best club team

A rapid Wallabies turnaround, and other non-Cooper observations

i think he reads the game better than the other winger or even the full back

perhaps the 7S rugger sense works better for him 😀

A rapid Wallabies turnaround, and other non-Cooper observations

thats a little harsh

he was always a good player but had to adjust to different coaches and playing patterns

not everyone is comfortable giving a free hand and saying go do what u like

A rapid Wallabies turnaround, and other non-Cooper observations

do u think its an issue?

i think NZ are doing the crusaders thingy – using two very good SHs alternatively – thus keeping them fresh and on edge.

im sure even if SR was NZ coach he will do the same. and maybe more.

rugger is a very attritional game – keep losing players and also players getting tired with overuse.

Retallick to captain All Blacks vs Pumas

why do u think BB did not get to be captain ??

im sure he captained NZ before all these guys ….

Retallick to captain All Blacks vs Pumas

start watching bit more football is all i can say – many times the foot up has been not even yellowed 😂

'Not guilty': Why Jordie Barrett was cleared for Koroibete face kick

close