A role for White, but not as Wallabies head coach

By Will Knight / Expert

Do your homework and you’d realise that employing a South African to coach the Wallabies won’t work.

Okay, that’s a lame link to the demise of Mickey Arthur as Australian cricket coach in 2013, the tipping point being when he asked the players to tell him how they could improve after being hammered in the first two Tests of the series in India.

It’s a saga worth recounting given Johannesburg-born Jake White has emerged as a potential replacement for Wallabies coach Michael Cheika, who will front the Rugby Australia board next month to fight for his job following a woeful year.

On that Test tour, four players — Shane Watson, James Pattinson, Mitchell Johnson and Usman Khawaja — were axed after failing to send through their homework to the boss.

For Arthur, who was also born and raised in Johannesburg, it was a quick and demeaning demise, especially as he explained later that there were a lot of other people involved in the decision and he had merely asked his players to come up with suggestions that could help him arrange for a more customised training session leading into the third Test in Mohali.

Sounds pretty innocent, right? An inclusive approach shouldn’t be simply regarded as a cry for help but can also have the potential to get players invested more heavily.

“So I went back to my room that night and didn’t sleep thinking… I am a South African coach and I was going to accuse the Australian people about their culture,” Arthur recalled last year.

“That’s not going to go down well. Eventually I made the decision and the rest is history.”

This insight is one of the reasons why – to me – a foreigner shouldn’t coach the Australian rugby team. Could you imagine if Justin Langer, a gritty West Australian, disciplined homework dissidents on that same tour?

The highly likely response from fans would’ve been highly favourable to Langer as he would’ve been taking a tough stance on team culture, camaraderie, respect. Arthur didn’t stand a chance.

Why? Predominantly because he’s not from Australia, that he doesn’t know how ‘Strayans tick.

What would he know about how to motivate Aussies?

A foreigner coaching another national team has a much shorter lifespan if things go pear-shaped.

Eddie Jones, a Sydney boy coaching England, found that out last year when the Poms were going through a rough trot and the knives were out.

Eddie Jones (Photo by David Rogers – RFU/The RFU Collection via Getty Images)

Robbie Deans, a rugged New Zealander with a brilliant provincial record and a solid Wallabies coaching record, got little sympathy when he took a ruthless approach with Matt Giteau and brushed him from Australia’s squad for the 2011 World Cup.

Maybe I’m more blinkered and prejudiced than I care to admit, but I much prefer an Aussie coaching the Wallabies. It’s a privileged position.

I want the coach to be someone who sung Advance Australia Fair at school, not learnt from a YouTube clip.

One needs to be careful when talking about national pride. Firm is my belief that sport should evoke a level of patriotism that never boils towards jingoism, the dangers of which are evident in Trump’s U-S-A.

Michael Cheika is in trouble (Photo by Dan Mullan/Getty Images)

It’s one of the great elements of international rugby, that national pride can be vented for a few hours, but opposition fans can share a handshake, a train, a hug and a laugh after the final whistle.

I’ve been lucky enough to experience while watching the Wallabies at venues such as Twickenham, Stade de France, Cardiff and the Olympic Stadium in Sydney.

Cheika should move on after a horrible few years. A passionate Australian he is, but he’s been unable to ignite the Wallabies even as they copped it from all directions this season.

But White isn’t the man for the head coaching job. His record is excellent, of course the standout being coach of South Africa’s 2007 World Cup-winning team. He’s had success at club level in Australia – with the Brumbies – as well as France and Japan.

Sports opinion delivered daily 

   

White sounds like a coaching nerd – a fastidious tactician who loves the technical aspects of rugby.

So what about bringing him in a Director of Rugby role, who can not only lend his expertise to the Wallabies, but also consult to coaching staff at the Australian Super Rugby teams and perhaps even the national junior teams?

It’s a role that Australian Scott Johnson has held with Scotland since the middle of 2013. In that time, he’s worked with Scotland head coach Gregor Townsend and helped them improve significantly – in 2017, they edged the Wallabies 24-19 in Sydney and then thumped them 53-24 at Murrayfield at the end of the year.

Johnson has spent the past 12 years overseas, so is a bit of an enigma to Australian rugby fans.

But he’s on the Rugby Australia radar, and having done a long apprenticeship that also includes stints in Wales, perhaps the 56-year-old is the man for the head coaching job at the Wallabies.

The All Blacks and Springboks have home-grown coaches. But you will tell me that the top three teams in Europe – Ireland (Joe Schmidt, NZ), England (Eddie Jones, Australia) and Wales (Warren Gatland, NZ) – all have foreigners as coaches.

Maybe I’m just small-minded and insular wanting an Aussie as Wallabies coach. Is that because I didn’t do enough homework when I was told to years ago?

The Crowd Says:

2018-12-04T10:24:01+00:00

Tony Mitchell

Guest


Well said

2018-12-02T05:21:54+00:00

Etepeus

Roar Rookie


Aren't Thorn and Wessels Australian citizens - I was lead to believe Australia is a multicultral immigrant nation.

2018-12-02T03:13:21+00:00

BigtreeSmallaxe

Guest


I didn't think I'd ever say this but I actually thought Phipps' passing was a big improvement on Genia's in the England test. I don't think I've ever seen Genia pass so poorly.

2018-12-01T21:12:50+00:00

Oblonsky‘s Other Pun

Roar Guru


That's not true, Double Agent. If you look at Germany's GDP growth figures very closely, they tick up when the Nazi party come into power and starting spending for the war effort (Autobahns and, much more importantly, the rearmament effort). They had to rearm in the years leading up to 1939. People weren't taking out loans to buy houses and renovate when the economy was in deflationary depression (people and firms generally do not take the risk of borrowing when in deflationary recession and certainly not in deflationary depression). Individuals and firms started borrowing privately once the employment rates started improving, once inflationary depression had ended and when the economy started growing. That was a direct result of German Government deficit spending to finance the war effort. The exact same thing happened in all the Western nations in the late 1930s and early 1940s. Economies returned to strong growth once central governments started running huge budget deficits to rearm (when the threat was invasion from an already-remilitarised Germany all the public debates about the danger of deficit spending disappeared and governments spent whatever was required to rearm, thereby boosting aggregate demand and income). I implore you to read into the history of deficit spending of developed nations from 1920s - present (with particular interest being 1920s-1945). Plenty of historians, economic historians and economists. None of this is commenting one way or another as to what current policies would be of most benefit to Australia or any other country, because there are obviously other issues that have to be considered, but I am just pointing out what actually happened historically.

2018-12-01T17:23:49+00:00

ojp

Guest


I went to my boys school assembly yesterday (public primary school in WA) and they belted out the national anthem... just a bit of sensationalism from Cookie there I reckon

2018-12-01T12:54:34+00:00

Double Agent

Guest


Agree with Hoy. We could use some fastidious tacticians.

2018-12-01T12:50:30+00:00

Double Agent

Guest


Germany's getting out of depression in the 1930s had nothing to do with spending on the war effort. What war? They were encouraged by low to zero interest loans to buy houses and renovate. At a time when official interest rates were off the dial.

2018-12-01T12:42:00+00:00

Crazy Horse

Roar Pro


But it took an Australian (Monash) and a Canadian (whose name I can't remember) to win it for them.

2018-12-01T12:25:00+00:00

Margaret Freemantle

Guest


It is a disgusting article!! Jake White commanded total respect, was the best coach in the Country by a long shot. he wanted to be the Wallabies Coach, but no, the ARU as it was then, in their wisdom(!!) wouldn’t have him probably for some of the crappy reasons in this article and because of their Tahs bias. RA has not changed, and until they do, we will not move forward

2018-12-01T12:15:50+00:00

Double Agent

Guest


Using a 9 in the defence role that Genia has been thrust into is a recipe for disaster. A 9 is selected primarily on their pass not on their speed. Expecting a 9 to compete in speed against the quickest players in world rugby is just asking for trouble.

2018-12-01T12:10:25+00:00

Margaret Freemantle

Guest


Agree completely- throw away the Tahs lucky dips

2018-12-01T07:33:06+00:00

Kelefua

Guest


^^what Fionn said x 2

2018-12-01T06:59:17+00:00

Just Nuisance

Roar Rookie


Yes Will I have often wondered about the aurthur saga . He got the job because he had the best CV in the world of cricket coaches . He was a fairly good cricketer , a successful provincial coach and took the Proteas to nr 1 in both odi and Test cricket. He did not have to prove himself either technically or culturally to the Aussie players or public. Aussie cricket shot itself in both feet . Aurthur now coaches Pakistan and is doing a great job . The cultural divide is far greater between him and the Pakistanis than it was ever between him and Australians. Jake white was incidentally also accused of being out of touch with this mystical Aussie culture while coaching ( successfully I might add ) The Brumbies. His biggest strength is truckloads of common sense. Something Aussie rugby can benefit from right now.

2018-12-01T03:51:02+00:00

Oblonsky‘s Other Pun

Roar Guru


Absolutely it has failed, mate. I wonder if Link takes satisfaction in seeing those that orchestrated his demise leading this mess? Your Rebels are looking pretty great for next year, mate! They'll have a better backline than the Wallabies.

2018-12-01T00:48:21+00:00

Bluesfan


Smith is out because he has said that he would never coach against the AB's. Either Joseph or Robertson would be a good pick-up.

2018-11-30T23:09:43+00:00

Sage

Roar Rookie


I think the difference is the use of the term "senior players" who became the coaches. I think the same senior players were the mutineers not necessarily all the players. It is then not so much a revolution than a coup. In my opinion. I have doubts on Nucifora as a coach too but I think he is a good manager.

2018-11-30T23:03:19+00:00

Sage

Roar Rookie


Americas 4% is based on government deficit spending so a self defeating example. 800 billion in 2018 or 17% increase to the deficit. I didn't like T. Abbotts knighthood to Phill the Greek at the time and a lurch to a more monarchy-ism style Australia. Abbotts Australia. That isn't virtue signalling it's just an opinion. I agree that Trump has created far more jingoism as do millions of Americans. That isn't an authors virtue signalling it is an opinion and one hard to argue against. Let's stick to rugby.

2018-11-30T22:57:12+00:00

TheTruthandNuttinbutTheTruth

Guest


Who is Sam Warburton?

2018-11-30T22:19:46+00:00

Sage

Roar Rookie


I'm interested in when this decision was made to stop singing the anthem in school due to it possibly offending someone . Please elaborate

2018-11-30T22:09:49+00:00

bringbackthebiff

Roar Rookie


Joe blow...you are someone who recognises facts when they slap you in the face. Coulnt agree more!

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar