So, how will this all work for Australian rugby?

By Brett McKay / Expert

So a review was conducted, and a new appointment was made. But the two aren’t necessarily related, and nor might that be the limit of changes.

Are we seeing a genuine attempt to improve the game nationally, or is it merely window-dressing; being seen to be making the changes seemingly demanded by an unfulfilled public?

It’s hard to say, really, and probably even unfair to make judgements so soon on what has clearly been established as long-term planning for the betterment of rugby in this country.

Scott Johnson’s appointment as Rugby Australia’s new Director of Rugby is an interesting one.

On one hand, the removal of Michael Cheika’s overwhelming autonomy and the inclusion of a rugby reporting line that should include a level of account that probably hasn’t existed before, should be a good thing.

But on the other hand, will Cheika’s release from the off-field distraction cited during Monday’s press conference actually free his on-field thinking? And how will he actually perform within these new and unprecedented confines?

There’s no question in my mind that Rugby Australia thought the newly-minted National High-Performance Plan was going to be the big-ticket item in the announcement. CEO Raelene Castle led off with this in significant detail, outlining the amount of dialogue, agreement and no doubt concession among the Super Rugby sides that had been achieved in bringing everyone onto the same page from a high-performance pathways perspective.

And in absolute fairness to her and Rugby Australia, this has been the sort of thing that has been both long discussed and long desired. The examples of New Zealand, Scotland and particularly Ireland were used with good reason, and undoubtedly the expectation will be that this re-aligned, for-the-national-interest way forward will deliver the same improvements that those countries have enjoyed over time.

The appointment of Johnson, with the brief to “lead the delivery of the new National High-Performance Plan” was to be the bow that tied it all together.

But as soon as Castle and the RA statement continued that Johnson in his new role, “…will oversee the Wallabies program,” their desired message was always going to be left behind. This ensured the narrative was no longer about the national good, but rather implementing a kind of change that is visible but nowhere near as expensive as sacking coaches.

Michael Cheika remains Australia coach (Photo by Dan Mullan/Getty Images)

The confirmation that Cheika’s assistant coaches had been granted a stay of execution only underlines this point.

Castle said on Monday that Cheika “has made recommendations on changes [to his coaching team] he’d like to make”, but that they’ll work through the process with Johnson. And that she expected that Johnson and Cheika would commence discussions on this and all other matters “immediately.”

In all reality, nothing will happen on this front until the New Year and when the discussions do commence, Johnson would be doing his role and the Wallabies review an immediate disservice if he didn’t move all members of Cheika’s team – not just the early sacrificial offerings of Stephen Larkham and Simon Raiwalui – into the crosshairs of scrutiny.

But Johnson’s delayed arrival in Australia until after Scotland’s Six Nations campaign is complete further complicates things in a way that only Australian rugby can.

Scotland were and are well within their rights to insist that their home season is not compromised, especially given their rise to a record-high seventh on the World Rugby rankings.

But to what degree can Cheika commence his 2019 planning? And how involved in that planning can his assistants be if their tenure is yet to be confirmed? And how will Johnson juggle the dual roadmaps of Scotland’s short-term and Australia’s long-term future?

Sports opinion delivered daily 

   

On that front, the most important, most immediate next step needs to be the appointment of the new independent selector to sit on the national panel with Johnson and Cheika in the same fashion Grant Fox operates over the ditch. And the biggest test of that appointment will be the true independence of said appointment.

Ideally, it needs to be someone like a Phil Mooney; someone still involved in the game to a decent degree, but with little or no connection to either Cheika or Johnson.

There is no question that there was and is a lot of good news coming out of these announcements. Clearly, a lot of thought has gone into them, and a whole lot more work behind the scenes again has gone into the alignment of all the national elite performance stakeholders.

And this all clearly contradicts Cameron Clyne’s absurd implications that all this has happened as a result of the end of season review, and from which he promised change by Christmas. I honestly thought that boneheaded performance last week couldn’t be topped, but yesterday’s follow up went awfully close.

Cameron Clyne needs to get on the front foot with SANZAAR. (AP Photo/Rick Rycroft)

With all this said and done, I’m open-minded about the impact Johnson’s appointment, the independent selector, and the national realignment can have.

As someone who has long-bemoaned the crippling self-interest within Australian rugby, moving toward a set-up that centralises all the elite performance pathways toward the national teams can only be a good thing. Centralised contracting is probably the only piece missing.

But like all good Australian rugby announcements, time is going to be required to know the full benefits.

And until then, all we have is hope and guesswork.

The Crowd Says:

2018-12-24T09:07:35+00:00

Jibba Jabba

Roar Guru


Do you seriously think cheika will actually listen to and work with Johnson.. ?

2018-12-24T08:48:44+00:00

Jibba Jabba

Roar Guru


On what planet does anyone think cheika will listen to - and work with Johnson.. it will be like two old boars in a pigpen..

2018-12-20T21:52:23+00:00

Train Without A Station

Roar Guru


Unless that revolution impacts your little part of the world. In which case it's wrong...

2018-12-20T07:59:06+00:00

johnnoo

Roar Pro


stop talking like RA are competant here and in the right what is scott johnson doing.. How you condone an appoitment of someone who the fans don't even know what he is doing.. You support this move by RA, you have no idea..

2018-12-20T05:32:53+00:00

Jock the sock

Guest


Sheek and Concerned supporter have categoricallly said that oz rugby was going to decline and gave reasons why and gradually gurus like Twas, Geoff and Brett . Who called him a pessimist saying the academies and NRC, q.c and RA policies will save us and stating every year why this will be the year we will the Bledisloe. Now the gurus state the selectors are now the answer, forgetting the total neglect of player pathways. The crossroads have passed and rugby is dead here as a major sport. REVOLUTION IS REQUIRED.

2018-12-20T03:17:52+00:00

Jock the sock

Guest


We need 23 selectors one for each position all answerable to Scott.

2018-12-20T01:01:34+00:00

CJ

Guest


Agreed. This is so obvious. Are they just trying to humiliate him for sufficiently long in some sort of passive/aggressive behaviour so he leaves in a fit of pique? Just got an email from a mate of mine who used to love the game. Says he now watches Aussie Rules. Talk about a false economy in keeping this coaching staff.

2018-12-19T20:57:20+00:00

Waxhead

Roar Rookie


@ Johnoo - again total speculation based on zero evidence from RA !! Johnson will start work late March and, for all we know, may end up with no power, no budget, no staff, no plan and an uncooperative coach.

2018-12-19T07:18:36+00:00

MitchO

Guest


With Kepu working together should mean him getting proper minutes at Loosehead before the world cup. Be good for AA to go up against Kepu playing loosehead in a real game not just at training. That way he can give AA some pointers and everyone wins.

2018-12-19T07:14:15+00:00

Garry

Guest


Derm, this is not a fix. WB supporters have given more than enough time to RA, and some like me, stopped watching the carnage some time ago. I feel we have the cattle playing in Australia to go all the way (RWC), but of course will not under these coaches. I'm angry that some of those players desreve a better chance to have RWC champions next to their names, but this is (for some) their last shot. I'm particularly angry with MC for not falling on his sword if money is not a concern to him. If you have more patience, credit it too you. But let me remind you to reflect on Bart Simpson and the electrified cupcake.

2018-12-19T06:07:11+00:00

johnnoo

Roar Pro


The stuff you talk about the wallaby team manager should be doing not Chieka..

2018-12-19T05:00:56+00:00

Hoy

Roar Guru


*91...

2018-12-19T05:00:36+00:00

Hoy

Roar Guru


Yeah, your right on France, forgot the 99 one...oddly. Also had it in my mind we beat England in 99 in the semis... you're right again.

2018-12-19T04:57:33+00:00

Hoy

Roar Guru


Fionn, 2007 is a funny one... I knew we were in trouble because of our scrum issues... that was the peak of penalty rugby, and we were duly punished for our rubbish scrum. BUT... as I said, once you hit quarters, it's win or out.

2018-12-19T04:46:49+00:00

Wombat

Guest


Pretty sure Scott Johnson was backs coach or attack coach several world cups ago. The Wallabies flopped out??!

2018-12-19T04:40:22+00:00

luis r sarri

Guest


The pair of C`s ( Castle & Chieka ) should retire NOW.

2018-12-19T03:40:27+00:00

ThugbyFan

Roar Guru


Well said Big Bird, young Mr. Cheika could place that on the last page of his Rugby Coaching cv; as I very much doubt that he will get another coaching gig anywhere on this planet. :)

2018-12-19T03:26:38+00:00

ThugbyFan

Roar Guru


My apologies, browsing past the Reds behind-the-times website I see that they have acquired two more 5/8th to their SR2019 squad. Teti Tala who has played behind H.Stewart in the NRC2017 and Matt McGahan who played for Auckland Blues in SR2015/2016 and in Japan since. It's a nice fit as the bloke could be a mentor or even a competitor to push H.Stewart. To be sure it plugs a gaping hole in the Red's roster.

2018-12-19T02:37:15+00:00

Train Without A Station

Roar Guru


No. Thorn’s approach is to base his team around only people who blindly follow him. He’s completely inflexible.

2018-12-19T02:04:37+00:00

Jock the sock

Guest


Cheika is just laughing. Business as usual.

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar