Can the NPL and A-League ever be friends?

By Stuart Thomas / Expert

The fascinating chasm between two of Australian football’s strongest sources of life was well and truly on display on Sunday afternoon when the New South Wales Premier League competition began with its opening round of fixtures.

Young men with dreams of a top-level professional football career and a host of cagey veterans still playing the game they love took to pitches across the state. The NPLs of Victoria, South Australia, Tasmania and Queensland are already well underway, with Canberra the final cab off the rank when the capital region begins play on 5 April.

The commencement of NPL action in New South Wales came on the back of week laced with A-League death-knelling. I read with interest the fears around the City Football Group’s potential domination of the A-League should the salary cap ever be jettisoned.

Rather curiously and contrastingly a second headline ran on Sunday after the Central Coast Mariners’ capitulation against the Phoenix and the subsequent sacking of Mike Mulvey. The two stories set up an interesting narrative.

On one hand the salary cap story conveyed the fear that a loosening of the club’s purse strings would hand immense power, influence and success to the wealthiest club in the land. The mere thought conjures images of silverware, prestige and glory. But at the same time the story emanating from the Central Coast of New South Wales evoked sombre notions of disaster, doom and decay.

I found it a fascinating contrast. One club with the potential to bring an unprecedented quality of player to the league and an ensuing boom in interest and exposure, the other a well and truly flogged horse with an unfortunate gathering of recycled players and a community sick to the gills of watching their non-competitive team.

There was no such death-knelling at Lily Homes Stadium on Sunday afternoon when fellow Roar contributor Paul Nicholls and I made the trek to Seven Hills to watch Blacktown City FC take on the newly promoted Mount Druitt Town Rangers FC.

To say it was warm would be an understatement, yet the packed grandstand defied the conditions and said a lot about the passion and soul of Australian football burning brightly at NPL level.

With more extensive coverage via live streaming and recent interest from A-League clubs in identifying and utilising the immense talent gracing NPL pitches, the competition is enjoying a newfound level of enthusiasm and interest.

The wonderful crowd on Sunday merely cemented that thought. With a community feel and an old-world charm that have been the cornerstones of many fans’ emotional attachments to the FFA Cup competition, Blacktown City FC hosted an afternoon of not only high-quality football but also a slick match day and social event.

The homes side’s under-20s, 18s and junior players were all professionally kitted out in official club merchandise and in full voice when the NPL 1 boys took to the pitch. The rusted-on supporters of a club that has its roots as far back as 1953 took up their usual positions at the back of the grandstand, craftily avoiding the heat of the intense afternoon sun as it lowered towards the horizon and the canteen did a roaring trade as patrons sought a cooling afternoon refreshment.

The state NPLs are growing in quality (Tony Feder/Getty Images)

The game was gripping, hard-fought and at times controversial, with the referee’s assistants under intense pressure throughout – so pleasing it is to witness a close offside ruling without copious replays to further confuse and infuriate fans.

In the end it was a lone first-half goal to Blacktown City that separated the two teams. Mani Gonzalez was put into space on the right and his shot across the goalkeeper thundered off the bar before collecting the knee of Mount Druitt defender Nick Trimble and dribbling into the back of Carlos Saliadarre’s goal.

Blacktown looked more likely in the first half but the new kids on the block were dangerous on the quick break and Satoh Hiten, Fabricio Fernandez and Lord Darkoh kept the home side’s defence on watch for the entire contest.

Former A-League Jet Devante Clut was influential for the home side, James Demetriou threatened when he took to the pitch in the second half and stalwarts Matt Lewis and Grant Lynch were as stoic and professional as expected.

Former A-League striker Joey Gibbs struggled to get into the game and coach Mark Crittenden will reflect on the match with some satisfaction but also a knowledge that clean-cut chances were few and far between.

After a fourth-place finish in 2018 Crittenden will be looking for more fluency when Blacktown face Sydney United 58 next Sunday at the same venue.

Sports opinion delivered daily 

   

With the perennial challenge of an A-League competition entering the late-season funk where eliminated teams and their supporters lose much motivation, the NPL is now in full swing across the nation.

It appears that more and more people are realising this fact and heading out to local grounds to watch an ever-improving standard of football. The second tier looks very strong and, as I have written previously, the non-existent link between it and the fully professional game in Australia still hampers football’s development.

Some call it old soccer and new football, others see professionalism as the clear distinction. Whatever the best phrase is to describe the chasm in Australia football is immaterial. What matters more is the melding of the NPL and A-League competitions for the benefit of the game.

There are more than enough people attending, it just feels that sometimes we are watching two entirely different games.

The Crowd Says:

AUTHOR

2019-03-15T08:41:14+00:00

Stuart Thomas

Expert


From our perspective down here in hippie-ville, there are three certain things in life. 1. Death 2. Jobs 3. Right wing nut job politicians from up north.

2019-03-12T12:43:56+00:00

Mister Football

Roar Guru


Whoever wrote that article clearly doesn't know their Victorian geography.

2019-03-12T09:59:39+00:00

Nick Symonds

Guest


The Age is reporting it's a deal for a minimum of 7 matches but they can't work out which dates they will be until they know the fixtures for AFL, AFLW and BBL in addition to the Women's Twenty20 World Cup next year. It also briefly mentions playing matches in Wyndham. - "Western United's remaining home matches are likely to be held in and around western Victoria. This could see games held in Ballarat and Wyndham and other suitable venues in the region." - https://www.theage.com.au/sport/soccer/western-united-secure-deal-at-kardinia-park-20190311-p513cy.html

2019-03-12T09:37:07+00:00

Mister Football

Roar Guru


Has been mentioned. I'm guessing Ballarat is even further away from Tarneit than Geelong is.

2019-03-12T09:12:42+00:00

The Ball Bobbled

Roar Rookie


This comment has been deleted for breaching The Roar's comments policy.

2019-03-12T08:47:49+00:00

AR

Guest


Victory CEO “shocked” and “concerned” by A-League TV audiences Melbourne Victory CEO Trent Jacobs admits he was “shocked” by the poor TV ratings from their Australia Day clash against Sydney FC, 1116 SEN reported last week. The Big Blue encounter on Saturday night attracted just 31,000 Fox Sports viewers and Jacobs believes the poor numbers can be put down to a couple of reasons. “I was a bit shocked if I’m honest and it hasn’t been consistent with our games throughout the year,” Jacobs told SEN’s Gerard Whateley. Jacobs says FFA and A-League chiefs are working together to try and arrest the league-wide ratings slide. “Year-on-year they’re down now,” he added.

2019-03-12T07:20:30+00:00

Jordan Klingsporn

Roar Guru


Ballarat?

2019-03-12T07:17:54+00:00

Jordan Klingsporn

Roar Guru


Yes but there were other things in it as well.

2019-03-12T07:17:45+00:00

Mister Football

Roar Guru


They'll have to find a venue for five more home games.

2019-03-12T07:15:24+00:00

Mister Football

Roar Guru


What have I said that's out of keeping with the article linked above? I'm not sure if you read it, but the article itself is talking about declining ratings, and it's referring to a report from this Gemba that the value of A-League licenses has fallen by 36% (and you'd have to think that declining ratings are part of that equation: lower ratings, lower sponsorship revenue, lower future earnings).

2019-03-12T07:08:23+00:00

Jordan Klingsporn

Roar Guru


I find it interesting to hear that the Victory still want to play 1 game there next season.

2019-03-12T07:07:46+00:00

Jordan Klingsporn

Roar Guru


Dang it. Since you came back from suspension (Assumedly) you've been on your best behaviour but now......

2019-03-12T04:46:33+00:00

Waz

Roar Rookie


Time you were banned again. Pest.

2019-03-12T04:44:34+00:00

Waz

Roar Rookie


Where ...?

2019-03-12T04:43:26+00:00

Waz

Roar Rookie


I was actually thinking more in terms of clubs not players. The gap for clubs is huge, some of them play on a public park, most are amateur, some semi-pro. But the gap is huge and needs at least one intermediary competition.

2019-03-12T04:24:40+00:00

Nick Symonds

Guest


NEWS: Western United lock in deal with Kardinia Park - The Western United Football Club will be bringing A-League home games to Geelong for the next two years. The newly formed club has made a deal with Kardinia Park to call the stadium home for around eight home games, starting in October. - https://www.bay939.com.au/news/sport/103016-western-united-lock-in-deal-with-kardinia-park

2019-03-12T03:41:59+00:00

apaway

Roar Guru


I'm sure I've heard that somewhere else...

2019-03-12T03:38:28+00:00

apaway

Roar Guru


There sure is. And he's a really good player.

2019-03-12T03:33:08+00:00

Mister Football

Roar Guru


The A-League's TV ratings may have fallen off a cliff over the last two seasons, but surely Gemba factored into their modelling that everyone is now streaming?

2019-03-12T03:28:21+00:00

Nick Symonds

Guest


NEWS: Value of A-League falling, say clubs - In a strongly worded letter sent to FFA chairman Chris Nikou last week, which has been seen by The Australian, Australian Professional Football Clubs Association chairman Paul Lederer made it clear that the organisation, which represents all 10 A-League clubs, is tired of the stalling tactics. - Details of the letter include: • Disagreement over the figure FFA should receive from the Fox Sports broadcast rights; • Rebuttal of a report delivered by sports management consultants the Gemba Group, commissioned by FFA, which APFCA claims is out of date; • Suggestion that a subsequent Gemba report, commissioned by the clubs, forecast the commercial value of the A-League in 2018-2019 had declined by 36 per cent; • Laid the blame squarely at the feet of the FFA for “the failure of the administration to operate the League at best practice levels”. - “By the time the current broadcast agreement expires in four years time there will be no product that the owner of the League will be able to convince either Fox Sports or anyone else to invest in.” - Paul Lederer - In terms of the Gemba report commissioned by FFA, Lederer said it was done on the 2015-16 A-League season and that the clubs had “obtained an up to date report from Gemba as to whether the opinion and data that it provided to the FFA Board, in 2016 had remained constant, had improved or had worsened”. “It is my singularly unpleasant duty to tell you that since you commissioned the modelling of the A-League report by Gemba, it has now provided its opinion that the forecast commercial value of the A-League in 2018-2019 has declined by 36 per cent. “That is a catastrophic outcome for the game in Australia. The opinion of Gemba is that since the delivery of its report to FFA, reach figures have declined at an accelerated rate that has deviated significantly from what was previously projected. Furthermore since that report, Gemba has determined that the A-League has lost significant ground to benchmark leagues in Australia. Gemba has therefore adjusted IP to reflect more realistic benchmark rates.” - https://www.theaustralian.com.au/sport/football/value-of-aleague-falling-say-clubs/news-story/641522c692ebdb53e34eaf6766c3acf0

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar