You're not really coaching Penrith until you're feuding with Phil Gould

By Dane Eldridge / Expert

Phil Gould’s strategy to remedy the Panthers has been unique, with his five-year plan now in to its eighth year of hiring as many personal enemies as possible.

Whether it’s Ivan Cleary, Anthony Griffin, Wayne Bennett or his college hair colourist, Gould seems drawn to working alongside people with whom he can’t stand to be in the same room with.

Based on his current rate of collaborating with these Paul Simons to his Art Garfunkel, we should see Penrith pay out contracts to Phil Rothfield, Satan or his mother-in-law before the turn of the century.

The supremo’s turbulent reign at Penrith has brought an edict where a football operation can only be run provided it does not impede any dramatic internal feuding, and to a lesser extent, the dodgy tapes.

The latest fracture to emerge from under his watch has been tension with Ivan Cleary. The head coach is under fire for flagrantly encroaching on Gould’s remit by being head coach.

(Photo: Renee McKay/Getty Images)

The Panthers boss has since denied the rift, claiming he and Cleary have been friends for 24 years, and everything was fine last time they spoke in 1998.

Cleary was re-hired by the Panthers in the offseason, with the board unable to deny his tailor-made experience for the role as someone who has been sacked by Gould in the past.

Not only could he bring astute coaching and son Nathan’s signature, but he would be still stewing for being labelled ‘tire’ by someone with bags under his eyes like suitcases.

While this was playing out, Gould was working behind the scenes on his own replacement after ruling out interim coach Cameron Ciraldo because he was too easy to work with.

This resulted in the Channel Nine doyen sounding out Wayne Bennett for the role, who as one of his most despised enemies was considered perfect for the job.

So how does Gould always continually find himself working alongside people he’d probably swerve towards in the street?

Many would consider hiring your enemies as a bold strategy for improving a rugby league club, but I suppose anything is better than perishing, or worse, Brian Smith.

The tactic has hardly burdened Gould, who has undoubtedly been the catalyst for immeasurable improvement at Penrith when you consider everything except the failed finals campaigns and DUIs.

Under his watch, the club has shored up juniors, built a Centre of Excellence, and compiled a star-studded list that has boosted fan sentiment from dispirited ennui to unfulfilled frustration.

This has been achieved by clearing the roster of stalwarts and deadwood that underperform, and shrewdly replacing them with elite stars that underperform.

Gould’s internal warring has not harmed his reputation elsewhere either, with Cronulla recently making overtures for his services even though John Morris is a really nice bloke.

(Photo by Matt King/Getty Images)

So is the former Blues coach ever destined for a harmonious workplace? Or should he just cut his losses and join the Liberal Party or Oasis?

When you consider naked hatred as one of the game’s great bedrocks, Gould’s working day will probably remain as seven hours of phoning prank pizza orders to the adjacent cubicle.

Because let’s be honest – Gould’s current beefs are hardly Robinson Crusoe in rugby league.

The game has seen plenty of other functional discordant relationships, such as Gould vs Andrew Johns, Gould vs Ricky Stuart, Gould vs Bill Harrigan, Gould vs the NRL, and Gould vs Ray Warren.

Anything less is destabilising.

So in light of this, let’s hope morale remains afloat at Penrith with these continued spats.

The Crowd Says:

2019-04-09T02:17:32+00:00

Robert Szemeti

Roar Rookie


geez you guys are jibberers, i'm not a fan of gus, especially with his commentary, but he has done more for rugby league than most people have, especially in penrith and the country areas west of, especially in regards to pathways, so much so parramattas board are now trying to emulate it. if every team would engage in junior pathways, instead of just stripping other teams of their juniors, (i'm looking at the roosters here) rugby league would be so much better off. hate him all you want, you need gus, more than you need a politis or a rusty or a penn family, no wonder the whispers of cronulla trying to poach him were going around. and the whole explansion/relocation rubbish that greenburg is task with won't happen, gus outted that on 100% footy the very next week, with danny wielder saying it's not a priority....really, its a diversion from the off field dramas, and it's more of a what if to see how us all water cooler talkers react to it all, and give us the options of the what if? to push our clubs elsewhere. So if we do? manly are gone for sure if there is a criteria, roosters should go, and that's the only reason there is no and never will be a criteria. so sydney clubs will remain safe, until they fold on their own, or they themselves move elsewhere to Adelaide or South Island NZ, where there is not a strong RL presence, coz you cannot expect a brisbane or perth to open their arms open for a failed NSW team. Gus may be hard to watch, and opinionated and rub most people the wrong way, but he is in the know too, well maybe not about the s.e.cks tapes, but RL stuff he's smart, and if he thinks Ivan needed a rest, or a sacking fair enough, if he'd rather have him back rather than lose Nathan, well done, coz the tigers were circling, and if griffin needed to go coz he lost the playing group, thru rubbish gameplays and terrible tip sheets, 2 birds one stone, i give him credit for that stunt last year, plus almost bennet coaching too, i saw them getting chummy at the immortals event, i knew something was up, the old fox

2019-04-08T12:17:28+00:00

Rowdy

Roar Rookie


Very funny. As an AFL fan I'd love to see him work with Malthouse. 2 blokes who are waiting to happen to each other. The Coen Bros couldn't dream it up.

2019-04-08T08:29:42+00:00

mach4

Roar Rookie


Does Phil still try to sing "The Gambler" Kenny Rogers? lol

2019-04-08T04:30:44+00:00

Fred

Guest


Don't you think he cooked up the whole fued thing to take heat of the Cleary V Tigers story? Ivan has never really been a fan of that sort of thing, and one of the things Gus admires most about Bennet is the way he plays with the media.

2019-04-08T02:02:18+00:00

Superspud

Roar Rookie


Very tight with Freddy and importantly Nick Politis. That is why there was no chance of Cleary being Cronks replacement at the Roosters.

2019-04-08T00:48:49+00:00

kk

Roar Pro


Hi Dane, I love the Jack Gibson quote " There is nothing in a contract that says a football coach has to be sane or a good loser." Jack also preferred a maximum three year stint at any club. Gus has had access to the very best minds in the business yet seemingly prefers to remain friendless except for the effervescent James Bracey and the great Jimmy Maloney. Maybe it would pay Gus to head to head to Belmore and take both James with him. I have to ask, could Gus do any better than Dean? I doubt it.

2019-04-08T00:03:24+00:00

Paul

Roar Guru


"Keep your friends close and your enemies closer". From one Godfather to another.

2019-04-07T22:16:17+00:00

Superspud

Roar Rookie


I remember the way it ended at the Roosters. He recruited Stuart and the war started pretty soon. I think Ricky said that the worst thing he done in terms of the relationship with Gould was winning a premiership.

Read more at The Roar