Why Rassie's right to pick the ressies

By Fresney / Roar Pro

As the warm-ups for the Rugby World Cup get underway, All Blacks coach Steve Hansen is, once again, executing the right approach by naming five debutantes to his B team, against the Pumas.

Sevu Reece starts at wing, with the other four to come off the bench.

To put this into perspective, essentially one-third of the side will, at some point during the 80 minutes, be first-time players. That’s a mind-blowing stat, speaking volumes about player depth, and giving Hansen the luxury to mold these players into contention for Japan.

I suspect two will make the squad: Reece and Luke Jacobson at flank.

Jacobson is a heck of a player and at 22 his future shines bright. Reece is also 22 years young.

And what of the Springbok selection in this department?

Coach Rassie Erasmus selected three debutantes – Rynhardt Elstadt is starting at flank and Herschel Jantjies at scrum-half, with Lizo Gqoboka coming off the bench.

Now let’s look just a little deeper. Gqoboka, a loosehead prop, is 29. OK, he only started playing rugby at 19, but why debut him at such a ripe age for World Cup evaluation when four years ago he was already shining?

Elstadt is also 29 and the same question is asked.

Jantjies? Well, Erasmus got that one right, in terms of giving him a start at the age of 23.

Yes, the coach only got the job in 2017, but he had ample opportunity to give these three playing time before the eve rugby’s biggest tournament. Let’s not also forget that prior to this, Erasmus was an assistant to Heyneke Meyer, so he had a say.

Sports opinion delivered daily 

   

Sotuh African coaches need to take a longer view of talent, of which there is plenty coming out of the country, and put class players under the national spotlight in their early twenties.

Those who rise to the top will have as much as a decade at their prime, versus maybe three for someone pushing 30.

That’s how you build a world-class squad. If you don’t believe me, just ask Steve Hansen.

The Crowd Says:

2019-07-20T09:35:37+00:00

Jill

Guest


Yes,jest ask Sir Steve Hanson...as his the best Coach...All the best to team All Blacks and coaching team...

2019-07-19T22:42:55+00:00

KiwiHaydn

Roar Rookie


Would be good to see the top 23 selections from each of the Tipping Panel before the RWC and reasons why. Would be a great series!

2019-07-19T14:30:56+00:00

AussieBokkie

Roar Rookie


Harry I’ve been keenly awaiting your analysis of the Bok squad and who your ideal matchday 23 is for the WC…please pen an article soon! In the meantime, who is your ideal centre-pairing? This seems the most problematic combination for us. If Steyn is ready to go then I’d personally like Steyn and Am. De Allende and Esterhuizen are just too one dimensional. I also think Rassie really missed a trick not giving Rohan Janse van Rensburg a go

2019-07-19T13:19:20+00:00

Harry Jones

Expert


Elstadt is almost always mentioned by top Saffa players as the hardest of the hard. Yster. Meyer was tied to Alberts, Coetzee didn't rate him, but Erasmus has always put him near the top, based on performance stats and power and ticker. But he couldn't select him for the last two seasons due to overseas cap rule. In the World Cup year, he can. He was one of the first players Rassie mentioned as a bolter last year. He will not die trying. Imagine him as a better, faster, slightly smarter J-Pot. Gqoboka was a later bloomer; doesn't have much mileage on him, and Rassie does need to get to 50-50.

2019-07-19T08:25:41+00:00

Olly

Roar Rookie


Only time will tell.

2019-07-19T03:12:44+00:00

Leading Authority

Roar Rookie


Both coaches are selecting to win the World Cup with SA planning another win in NZ before the big pool game in Japan to put doubt into the mind of their opponent. Age is not a consideration at this juncture. Just results.

Read more at The Roar