The Rugby Championship Week 2: Up on blocks

By Brett McKay / Expert

The Rugby Championship is under way for 2019, and it’s crazy to comprehend, but after this weekend the competition will be beyond the halfway point.

And it means that this is really the only week where teams can tinker around with themselves – and no, that’s not a euphemism – before the 2019 title is decided.

So to varying degrees, all four teams have been in at the mechanics this week. Some teams are just getting new spark plugs; others are having a minor service. One is tossing up between a spit-and-polish detail or a full engine bay rebuild.

We’ll find out this morning which way they’ve gone.

LAST WEEK (and Overall): Digger, Harry, and Geoff 2; Nobes and myself 1.

For Week 2 of The Rugby Championship, I put this question to the guys:

QUESTION: What are the top priority improvements your respective team need to make ahead of this weekend?

Digger
Top improvement I believe will be in their handling and in no small part, decision making.

Some of the dropped ball and pushed passes were infuriating last weekend, and I would think a bit more composure while in possession will be a big step forward, especially against what shapes as a formidable South African side who have shown their counter attacking abilities.

Another big improvement would be winning in Wellington again, please. The All Blacks have dropped two of the last three and a second straight loss against the Boks in Wellington just won’t do.

And if someone would put their hand up at 6, that would also be pleasant.

TIPS: New Zealand, Argentina

SURE THING: We should expect a little bit more care around the rucks this week, both in when to commit and how to clean out, but then, maybe not. The Wellington crowd will be ever so slightly quieter this time around minus a certain parochial Saffa trying to get Faf’s attention.

Richie Mo’unga of the All Blacks (Photo by Anthony Au-Yeung/Getty Images)

Harry
Our rush-umbrella defence is still a crap shoot, with the umbrella sometimes getting stuck or opening the wrong way. We definitely have elite fitness: the line speed was off the charts. Even the big boys had legs.

Australia seemed to go into contact too high, suggesting dead legs. So, I’m looking to see better defensive organisation on first phase and in the reload.

Personally, as a huge Frans Steyn fan, he who seems perpetually untackleable, I’d like to see Frans-Am in the midfield, and with Kolbe and Leyds involved, so we have all real footballers behind Faf-Pollard.

The other thing is lineout throwing: if you can’t find Lood de Jager lifted by Elstadt and Etzebeth, you can’t throw.

TIPS: ALL BLACKS, PUMAS.

SURE THING: If Thomas Lavanini comes in lateral and at speed after the whistle and clocks a defenceless Hooper in the sternum right in front of the ref, Cheika will not protest a card.

Geoff
The compressed nature of this year’s Rugby Championship, plus the fact that all coaches are looking to change personnel and test the depth of their squads ahead of the World Cup, means that addressing changes from week to week is a very difficult proposition.

For the Wallabies, there are any number of improvements needed – the scrum, composure in finishing, competitiveness at the breakdown, discipline, and not seeking refuge in blaming the ref for their own failings, all spring to mind. But the thing I’ll be looking for this week is their ability to seize the initiative and play the game on their terms, not the opposition’s terms.

To do this, the Wallabies need more ball runners to run with more purpose, aggressive first-up tackles to be made, and intelligent kicking to put the Pumas under pressure. That’s not too much to ask is it?

As for the All Blacks, with a loss to the Boks at this venue last year, and higher stakes looming on the horizon, I think they’ll be happy with a win – any win. To do so, they’ll need to show far better discipline than they did last week, both off the ball and in retaining 50/50 possession.

TIPS: NEW ZEALAND, ARGENTINA

SURE THING: There is unfinished business. Lukhan Salakaia-Loto will miss several line out throws, his eyes not fixated on the ball, but instead scanning the crowd for a sight of ‘Baldy’, the Wallabies ‘fan’ who caused such a storm after the corresponding fixture last year.

Nobes
The two main things I would like for Los Pumas to improve are the percentage of missed tackles and that ball carriers can gain the advantage line. The opportunities created must become points on the scoreboard.

With respect to the next game Los Pumas, if they want to win, they cannot allow the Wallabies backs to play rugby.

They must slow down the game to allow time to reposition and be very attentive to the different variables in attack that the locals will present.

I think Mario Ledesma is going to do a couple of experiments to give the opportunity to players who have not seen much play time and that can backfire against him, since the Jaguares already have a very oiled system and newcomers can fail to understand it.

It was clear that Nicolas Sanchez against the All Blacks on many occasions did not know what to do with the ball, and ended up kicking without a predetermined destination.

Sanchez makes the Pumas tick – he will need to play better. (AFP PHOTO / MARTY MELVILLE)

The Wallabies on the other hand did not play well against the Springboks, but had opportunities in the first half they missed. They should win this match, but I can’t tip against Los Pumas.

On the other game, the All Blacks will have several of their players back and it will be an interesting match to see how the Erasmus experiment works. I go for the locals.

TIPS: ALL BLACKS, LOS PUMAS.

SURE THING: If the Wallabies lose, M. Cheika will blame the officials one more time and the press will eat him alive.

Australian coach Michael Cheika. (AAP Image/Darren England)

Brett
Nothing has changed my opinion first expressed on Tuesday that I wouldn’t mind the Wallabies this morning naming the same 23 as went down at Ellis Park to South Africa, and so a revamped approach based on the players selected is my priority.

But I could possibly make a few tweaks within that 23. I could probably live with Tom Banks and Dane Haylett-Petty, with the reasoning being Banks doesn’t lose nearly as much in his game playing on the wing as Haylett-Petty does. I loved that Banks was picked at fullback; but the greater good might push him to the wing.

I could potentially switch Jack Dempsey and Lukhan Salakaia-Loto, too, between the XV and the bench.

More than anything though, I want to see the in-form ball-carriers utilised for their ball-carrying.

Arnold, Rodda, Salakaia-Loto if he starts; Kuridrani. Tupou from the bench.

But beyond the obvious, I want to see the Wallabies take the game to Argentina and create second-phase opportunities through the offload and create some disruption in their defensive line.

If the Wallabies allow Los Pumas to simply slide in defence while they shovel the ball from sideline to sideline, that will be playing into the hands of the Argentineans and their broken-play game.

The Wallabies need to play harder and smarter.

TIPS: New Zealand, probably, at home, notwithstanding Diggers concerns about watching another Cake Tin loss. And Australia, out of sheer unadulterated, parochial, and irrational desperation.

SURE THING: Babies and bathwater everywhere when the Wallabies name their side this morning. Facepalms all round. Upwards of ten personnel and positional changes and exactly nil lessons learned from Johannesburg.

Who have you got, Roarers? Who gets your tip this weekend?

The Crowd Says:

2019-07-27T08:16:03+00:00

ThugbyFan

Roar Guru


Hi Nobrain, may the Puma vs WB match be entertaining. And btw ethanol is a clean fuel. I was never much chop "after a long period of abstinence ,..." :)

2019-07-27T04:00:14+00:00

ThugbyFan

Roar Guru


Well I proved one thing last week. Tipping from the heart is a mug's game. Zip from two was my return. Let's try this week! The All Black machine to score a decisive win to show the SB that they are the boss at RWC time. Forwards win matches and the SA pack is on fire atm and it's going to be a battle almighty in the piggies. I think the SB eight will just shade the AB pack in size, toughness, speed and nous but the defence of their outside backs will negate any advantage won in the forwards. I would say coach Hansen has put R.Mo'unga in at 5/8th to rip the SA rush defence and his chip kicks into space will send the SA backs into "Lady" ga-ga land. A massive WB improvement will get them over the line against a very tough Puma side. I am going to stick with my excuse last week that coach Cheika flogged his players too close to the SA match. That or someone put mogadons in their half time drinks as the mob that struggled around the park in the 2nd half was not the same mob that stretched the SA defence in the 1st half. Yes their tactics sucked at times, no-one seriously attacked rucks and the WB backs had no clue how to cancel out the rush umbrella defence of the SA but the WB were certainly in the race from their efforts in the 1st half. This week's team is a better side, though I still think T.Banks or H.Speight should be on a wing but the coach loves M.Koreibete and like K.Beale will forgive his "occasional" sin in defence. What I do want to see is more WB players contesting rucks. M.Cheika has now been the WB coach for 5 years and it STILL has not dawned on the goose that good teams have ruck monkeys throughout the side, they don't depend on just 1 or 2 players in traditional positions (mind you one trad role of an openside used to be ruck monkey and that has been tossed aside). Even wingers, 5/8ths and centres are expected to not only enter rucks but to be serious in pilfer, taking out opponents and slow down of the ball. I am not on my knees praying for the return of D.Pocock as the game has moved on. For starters he is too slow and injury prone. One individual, not matter how good he is, is not going to steal more than 3-4 rucks and is going to be belted into the next galaxy trying to slow down opposition rucks. Until the WB coach brings that into training and has a more rounded team, the WB will always struggle in the possession game. Sure Thing. Any yellow/red card against any angelic WB player and coach Mickey will declare the Christian version of j1had against the whole WR referee fraternity.

2019-07-27T01:09:54+00:00

Rugby Tragic

Roar Rookie


No such thing a an 'unimportant' test match between the All Blacks and the Springboks ... anyone who suggests that is lying. With which ever team who loses, that loss will be played down a little in public but in private, look out for the furniture..

2019-07-27T00:34:11+00:00

Machooka

Roar Guru


Jacko... I can smell burning! It's important when thinking not to over do it... it can fry the brain ;)

2019-07-27T00:25:33+00:00

Jacko

Guest


They could meet 3 times this year and this one is the least important...Or maybe the pool game is....But the least important is still important I think...

2019-07-27T00:19:30+00:00

Jacko

Guest


I think we now have a different Richie...We have moved on...

2019-07-26T22:34:30+00:00

Machooka

Roar Guru


Morning MrRobC... should be a couple of cracking games this arvo. Can't wait! Reckon your hunch about the Bok is on the money... Rassie will want to make a statement. And contrary to Shag's earlier 'statement', he will really, really wants a win in Diggerville. I think Shag's 'statement' was wind assisted... :)

2019-07-26T22:06:50+00:00

RobC

Roar Guru


Thanks gents! I think SB will do much better than expected. Pumas v good, their back row much better. Backs too, now I think about it too except Samu.

2019-07-26T08:45:22+00:00

Rugby Tragic

Roar Rookie


????

2019-07-26T07:57:18+00:00

Jibba Jabba

Roar Guru


Corne, Auusie has played poorly for bout 4 years.. let aloneback to back...

2019-07-26T06:25:46+00:00

Machooka

Roar Guru


'And then new Blues fullback Beauden Barrett over the ditch...' :) He's not biting, Brett... which is sooo tragic! Ooops... does he still have teeth??

2019-07-26T06:22:26+00:00

Broken Shoulder

Roar Rookie


I like to live dangerously...

AUTHOR

2019-07-26T06:15:47+00:00

Brett McKay

Expert


What about a forward in Brisbane swanning out in the back, RT?

AUTHOR

2019-07-26T06:15:05+00:00

Brett McKay

Expert


I reckon Broken Shoulder above has the right idea Chookman, I reckon Folau Fainga'a on the back of a Wallabies maul. And then new Blues fullback Beauden Barrett :lol: over the ditch...

AUTHOR

2019-07-26T06:13:02+00:00

Brett McKay

Expert


Vermeulen and not Marx, BS?

2019-07-26T01:31:34+00:00

Rugby Tragic

Roar Rookie


Two very interesting games for different reasons ... Much respect for Springboks ... but ... but ... but the AB's who according to Hansen is not concerned about results in the RC (he's lying!) will want to secure the mental edge over the Boks for their encounter 21st September. All Blacks by 8 Puma's will be relatively confident but will not find it easy at Suncorp ... I think they will prevail but Cheika will look on this game as a 'must win' I feel. I think the game will be close and think a Puma's win by 8, a similar margin to the earlier Wellington game. Sure thing .... MOTM in Wellington will be a back and MOTM in Brisbane will be a forward.

2019-07-26T01:06:01+00:00

Machooka

Roar Guru


My Wallaby by 13 (such an underrated lucky #)... and Kerevi to score da first try. The almighty ABs to draw with Harry's Bok... 'cause it put him on full tilt. Barely so! ;) First try scorer will be Faf as he has doesn't have a mullet... it's natural and care free.

2019-07-26T00:48:25+00:00

Broken Shoulder

Roar Rookie


Wallabies by 6, Kerevi first try scorer after bulldozing 3 Pumas AB's by 2 with Vermeulen scoring first off a rolling maul

2019-07-26T00:40:35+00:00

Paul D

Roar Rookie


Wallabies by 10, but Pumas to start off through Cordero Marx for the Boks, and the Boks by 3

AUTHOR

2019-07-26T00:23:15+00:00

Brett McKay

Expert


Righto, so let's make this interesting: Winning margin and first try-scorers in either Test this weekend? Have a sneaking suspicion it'll be less than a converted try in both games...

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar