AFL Power Rankings 2019: Round 21

By Liam Salter / Roar Guru

What a weird weekend of football. I could be sad that Fremantle’s season is effectively over, I could be amused by the impressive efforts of Essendon, North or GWS put into losing, or I could be enthused at the prospect of continued uncertainty around finals positioning. A fortnight of 2019 footy remains for ten teams.


Last week: 1

I’m not seeing any genuine reason to bump them from number one. They perhaps had the hardest match up of the top four competitors – and were challenged by a super admirable Adelaide outfit.

They did enough though to secure the win – and head into the next two weeks in good form. Richmond next weekend a mammoth challenge, though – get through that, and Hawthorn at home should be another win.


Last week: 2

They were never going to lose Saturday’s clash, but what was in question was whether they’d garner the percentage they desired. A 91 point win means they did.

With perhaps the most difficult fixture of any team in the final fortnight – Geelong at home and Richmond away – Brisbane will be challenged like they haven’t in years. It’s bloody exciting.


Last week: 3

The fact that Richmond has to tackle two of their biggest competitors for a top two position – the Eagles and Brisbane – in the final fortnight is precisely the type of scheduling genius the league’s hierarchy would be pleased eventuated.

And they’re in good shape for those challenges, too, given they got through perhaps the weekend’s most regulation win with no qualms.


Last week: 4

Keeping an opposition to fourteen points is a remarkable achievement in the modern game, but the real challenge comes next week: travelling to Queensland to take on Brisbane.

I want to highlight a player whose name I’ve actually never typed in a Roar piece before; Quinton Narkle. The young man was sensational during Saturday’s win, and joined fellow young gun Gryan Miers, who also provided highlights in attack.


Last week: 5

If arch-rivals West Coast manage to defeat Richmond next weekend, and they hold strong against Adelaide too, then the Pies can still Steven Bradbury themselves back into the top four.

Neither is anywhere near certain, though – particularly the Pies’ game against Adelaide. In theory, I’d have them favourites, but Adelaide’s performance yesterday shows there is life in them next.


Last week: 6

Big yikes. Their lowest score ever, and that’s saying something given their two-win inaugural season in 2012.

Foreshadowed a strange weekend in terms of scoring, but the good news is – unlike Essendon and North – the Giants are certain for finals.

It’s how they go in finals, though, that is up in the air.


Last week: 8

Very strong win, and a very necessary win. They’ve picked a good fortnight to shake off their inconsistency and put together two strong, percentage-boosting victories in a row.

Cannot get complacent in the next two weeks – although they’ll start favourites against North and Freo, the tag ‘favourite’ can often mean nought for the Power.


Last week: 10

Sensational win – in the goddamn snow! The Hawks seem to be dominating the Giants of late, and Clarko coached a masterclass in the nation’s capital to return the Hawks to a – pretty dubious – finals contention.

It can happen, but it’ll take a remarkable effort (and rely on other clubs, which is always an uncomfortable position).


Last week: 11

It’s going to be remembered as a loss, but the effort that the Crows put into their hard fought clash over in WA is a demonstration of the pride that’s been sorely missing in the club’s last month.

The consensus of Adelaide’s fans appears to be that they’re impressed with the performance, but the club still is a long way from securing a finals position. Collingwood and the Bulldogs await.


Last week: 12

Twenty-one goals. In succession. Without their opposition doing much at all. Luke Beveridge’s men couldn’t have really had an easier night at the office.

The fact that they were reportedly still frustrated with letting the Bombers get three consolation goals shows how determined these blokes are. Finals likelier than they were last week, but far from confirmed.


Last week: 7

Complete, utter and indisputable garbage. Perhaps the season’s worst individual performance (too big a call?), Essendon did themselves no favours by conceding 21 consecutive goals.

Their horror fortnight hasn’t knocked them out of the eight – but the upcoming fortnight might. Neither Freo nor Collingwood have been stellar themselves of late, but both should be able to defeat the struggling Bombers.


Last week: 9

Scored fourteen points, and still only suffered the fourth heaviest loss of the weekend. There isn’t too much to say about the Kangas’ Saturday night effort. Not a good one.


Last week: 14

Bloody good to see Jack Steven back out there and kicking (literal) goals after his mental health absence, while Dan Hannebery’s game saw there was plenty to smile about for Saints fans.

The Saints had an excellent day, which for me only strengthens Brent Ratten’s bonafides as senior coach. Just sign him up, eh, Saints?


Last week: 13

[Redacted]. Okay, now that what I really wanted to say is out of the way, it really is a brutally disappointing loss for Freo, in a season that has seen plenty of brutally disappointing losses.

Their season is over, and the Dockers will be left to rue a peculiar string of losses to teams below them for blowing their finals chances four the fourth consecutive season.

They have the chance to be the spoiler for Essendon and Port now, though.


Last week: 15

News that Dusty had been removed from Richmond’s selected side brought back a minuscule amount of hope, but David Teague’s men were always heavy underdogs headed into this one. Nothing too surprising eventuated. Saints and Geelong in the next two weeks. Neither will be easy.


Last week: 16

I thought Sydney were not a half bad shout at recording an upset, given they were facing a notoriously inconsistent Port Adelaide, and their decent record in South Australia.

Alas, the Swans were unable to fire much of a shot, and were used as a step ladder for the Power to elevate themselves into the top eight.

They play Demons next Friday night. In hindsight, that isn’t too much of a premier time slot draw, eh?


Last week: 17

Not the world’s worst effort, but that’s precisely the problem with the Demons. They’ve shown up for a part of every game without winning. Like the team below them, I fully expect them to be eager for the off season – less than a fortnight away now.


Last week: 18

The gulf between the two Queenslander sides was epitomised by Saturday’s clash. The Suns kept up a strong-ish effort for the first term, but fell away badly after that. Just the two weeks until the clearly needed offseason for the young Suns.

The Crowd Says:

2019-08-14T08:41:04+00:00

Yattuzzi

Roar Rookie


The tigers fans will be insufferable. I didn’t say I was barracking for them.

2019-08-14T06:31:26+00:00

Gerry

Roar Rookie


Don’t you just love the humbleness of the Richmond fans. Haha. Looking forward to it I have a feeling win lose or draw it will be a positive for the Eagles somehow.

2019-08-14T06:27:59+00:00

Gerry

Roar Rookie


I hope you are wrong.

2019-08-13T22:03:44+00:00

EaglesMan

Roar Rookie


Just focus on beating Brisbane this week, that game will be no walk in the park

2019-08-13T22:01:24+00:00

EaglesMan

Roar Rookie


This is the same cats that lost to the Hawks at the MCG and that struggled to beat a second rate Fremantle? yeah we are all shaking in our boots

2019-08-13T11:50:02+00:00

Yattuzzi

Roar Rookie


Just quietly lamb, you did say nothing excuses when they played.

2019-08-13T11:45:32+00:00

Yattuzzi

Roar Rookie


Well I am backing them to do you this Sunday. It might mean you play your first final away from the fortress. Feel the fear or chill with Ben. I don’t think even Tiger’s fans would be confident against the Cats.

2019-08-13T11:24:17+00:00

EaglesMan

Roar Rookie


Yeah feeling fear good one you tell you’re self that. Richmond would wipe you off the park on current form

2019-08-13T11:19:40+00:00

Yattuzzi

Roar Rookie


I think you misspoke. The tigers are defined by the teams who have beaten/ smashed them.

2019-08-13T10:59:26+00:00

Peter Warrington

Guest


i.e/ the top 4 is defined by those the TIgers haven't beaten yet?

2019-08-13T10:30:00+00:00

Yattuzzi

Roar Rookie


As I said elsewhere, the winning margin or total goals is not important, it is the ratio. That is what shows up on the percentage. I am all for higher scores but the wind and rain didn’t help.

2019-08-13T10:25:59+00:00

Yattuzzi

Roar Rookie


Well actually Maxine is. Seriously good games coming up. I will be glued to the TV. Might go to the Richmond game.

2019-08-13T10:22:39+00:00

Yattuzzi

Roar Rookie


Sorry EM, trying to earn some money to keep the kids fed. Yes last years meltdown hurt. I saw it at the ground. This year is different, we are not falling into the finals. We are numero uno. We have thumped the Contenders. We have a far better record than the Eagles and the Lions at the Gee this year. The eagles will face the Cats or the Tigers at the Gee sooner or later. Feel the fear.

2019-08-13T10:15:18+00:00

Yattuzzi

Roar Rookie


Well Maxine, I have not revealed my sex. I seem to have slipped up calling the Eagles girls. I really meant they were particularly more attractive but not quite the optimum % muscle as the usual AFL men are. It was more descriptive of the players rather than derogatory towards women. I stand corrected and won’t belittle our sisters again.

2019-08-13T08:40:33+00:00

EaglesMan

Roar Rookie


I agree Richmond are playing better footy however you are not unbeatable saying that no one really is

2019-08-13T08:37:48+00:00

EaglesMan

Roar Rookie


I got no issue with that, but Yatuzzi bangs on about how good his Cats were because his team belted Richmond. You are that confident of beating us, look forward to it

2019-08-13T08:33:41+00:00

Maxine

Guest


Lambbob... I don't barrack for Essendon. My question wasn't directed to you. In any event,your response doesn't make any sense,and has nothing to do with the question I put forward. I'm already aware of your posting style,and politely request we ignore each other's comments from this point moving forward.

2019-08-13T08:03:12+00:00

Iambillbob

Roar Rookie


Maxine your on the wrong page u need too be worrying about the bombers pathetic performance by overrated players n coach

2019-08-13T08:00:40+00:00

Iambillbob

Roar Rookie


Eazy eagleman....Geelong played half of Richmond mate. By the way I did see the eagles get beaten by a Collingwood team that had some injury’s in Perth. Just remember eagleman you wouldn’t want too play the way you did on the weekend because you will not be up by 10 at the end it will 30 points down at the G...I a Richmond man I can 100% tell ya we will beat you this weekend

2019-08-13T07:49:06+00:00

PeteB

Roar Rookie


The cats must have been very ordinary too then if they only managed 9 goals.

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar